First time here& I would definitely come back. Service was great, everyone was so friendly & above & beyond. Our waitress, Veronica was so nice & took the time to talk to us& was nice/ friendly. On the house, we got bruschetta, they were ok. As an appetizer we had stuffed avocado with crab, which was good but too salty! I had the paella& it was so good, idk how I finished it because it was a nice portion & it was so good! I couldn't walk! My husband had the seafood trio? He liked it. The drinks were good, strong. The prices were a bit on the high price, $$$ but portion, service & taste make up for it. Thanks for a good time. read more

See all

Very happy with my experience at Seafood Grill. The staff graciously let us switch our tables a couple of times because of bees bothering us outside. They offer a nice variety of Mexican and Italian dishes. I also enjoyed the bruschetta they start every table off with. The food was very tasty especially the burrito which was uniquely pressed like a panini. The food is also very affordable here, which is refreshing. Would recommended this spot to others and come back myself! read more

Seafood Grill on the Bay - Grilled Chicken Crudaiola - Seafood Near Me - Freeport, New York

See all

Great food! Great music! Why Seafood Grill? - Great for all occasions - Mexican and Italian menu with lots of options - Huge portions ($ well spent) - Two Bars (inside and outside) ( many drink options) - Very clean establishment (main dinning area and restrooms) - Friendly staff - Valet parking - On the water (indoor and outdoor seating) read more

See all

Hate to say It but I have been back multiple times and It hasn't been the same. My latest experience was that I ordered chicken tacos and I received raw chicken. I notified the waiter and he had asked if I would like something else instead I said no thank you I gave them back my side of rice and my chicken tacos that I ordered. When the bill came he proceeded to charge me for the side of rice and guacamole that I asked for that I did not eat because I did not feel comfortable eating anything after receiving raw chicken. He ended up taking it off the bill but I feel more should have been done. It's a shame I really loved this place when they open but it's been downhill for the last year read more

See all

Always a pleasure having dinner there. Portions are big and the drinks are great. Friendly staff and nice views from the outdoor seating

This place is beautifully decorated inside and out. We opted to sit out back because the weather was perfect. The view back there is amazing! My only complaint is sitting back there just be prepared to get eaten alive by then knat looking bugs that bite like mosquitoes! Sitting by water has it's pros and cons lol. Bae started off with their spicy margarita i got the Pina colada. Pina colada was delicious but couldn't taste the liquor so def ask for a shot or two but that spicy margarita omg was the star off the show! The food was amazing we all ordered different things and needless to say you could hear a pin drop lol. We also ordered tres leches cake which was so good! I love the mile and if your ever in the neighborhood check this place out! read more

My husband and I wanted to try a new place. Definitely would not recommend going here. The food was not good at all. My husband had the tongue tacos and we were surprised it was only 2 tacos and a super small salad on the side. I got the paella and it was the worst I've ever had. Barely any seafood just a whole bunch of rice. The place is pricey and charges 18% gratuity automatically! The drinks were good but they will give you the worst hangover. Not going back. Trust me, you're not missing out on anything! read more

Awful experience . Drive on by. Poor service. Bad food. Loud and dirty. Plenty of other restaurants nearby .

We wanted to eat at otto's and fortunate for us, they were closed. I definitely will be coming back to this place. The oysters were so fresh and big we ordered a second order. I ordered the linguini pescatore which was amazing. All six of us ordered different entre's and they were all winners. My father ordered the three musketeers and the filet mignon was perfect. My kids are usually horrible eaters. They ordered fried seafood, red snapper and salmon. It was all fresh and cooked perfectly. The waiter service was excellent. We had brayan as our waiter who was very professional and great. The mohittos were great. All I can say is this place is FLAWLESS. read more

Seafood Grill on the Bay - Seafood Near Me - Freeport, New York

See all

Shady AF billing. they double added 18% gratuity on the bill, then charge tax on the gratuity. and when confronted on it, they were pushy and not willing to change. Also food is mediocre at best. Nice location, but spend your money elsewhere. if you do go, DOUBLE CHECK THE BILL read more

We enjoyed a delightful lunch with a sweet view of the boats on the canal. Good food. The mussels were terrific. The baked clams could have done with a few minutes more under the broiler and some more topping but the sauce was worth asking for a take-out container! My lunch partner totally enjoyed the paella. Service was attentive although by the time we received an order of garlic bread, we had finished lunch. Strange that when making a reservation, I had requested outdoor seating and was told there "couldn't be any guarantee" of an outside table. When we arrived for our noon reservation, we were the first and ONLY patrons in a restaurant that could easily serve 60 people. Perhaps the owner could give the reservation staff authority to reserve the outside tables when, obviously, there was no competition. I would definitely return. read more

See all

Stopped in on a Monday night. Very nice place next to the canals before the main strip. Dining room was nicely decorated, large screen TVs on each end, large windows. We ordered an appetizer, calamari, and a Fraser salad and there was time before the entrees arrived to digest a little. I don't like when the food is served too quickly. They served warm Italian bread after the appetizer before the entree as well. My hubby had the paella and I ordered the walnut crusted sea bass. Both were very good. I had some to take home but my hubby left the plate bare. Juan was our server and was very pleasant. Dessert was beautiful as well as tasty, cheesecake and flan. Will go again, would recommend. Although casual it has an upscale look read more

Seafood Grill on the Bay - Cheesecake for dessert - Seafood Near Me - Freeport, New York

We had a wonderful time celebrating our daughter's and new son in law's wedding. The service was on point, letting everything moving smoothly. They even helped set up with the decorations! The food was so delicious and plentiful! It was a beautiful day! Thank you read more

A little gem of a place. The food was excellent. The atmosphere and service was excellent. There is an outdoor bar and seating area. We had a nice waterfront view. We usually go to Rachel's Waterside Grill, but they were closed on Tuesday. I was surprised at how really nice this place was. There is a service charge, but we asked and that was the tip. I recommend trying this cute little place. read more

See all

We were waiting for this place to open and came with 4 people. Inside has been updates a little bit. It's hot a nice atmosphere. The owner introduced herself. Her name is Marilyn. She's very gracious and sweet. We started out with chicken quesadillas. It was a nice size stuffed with chicken and cheese. The seance was spicy and really good. The guacamole was delicious. Their burritos are huge and jam packed with food. I loved the ground beef. The paella had lots of seafood; my husband enjoyed. The chicken francaise was delicious as well. Next time I'd like to try their salmon. It sounds so good. This is a new business and I hope they make it. read more

I wanted to order take-out on a quiet Wednesday night. I asked the woman with the glasses at the front desk for a menu since this was my first time there. She disappeared for 10-15 minutes to find one. There were no other staff around. While getting bitten by mosquitoes in the open doorway, I contemplated leaving and wish I had. A group of teenagers on bicycles came in. They waited with me for the woman to come back. When she finally did and handed me a menu, she took their drink orders for a total of $9 while I stood there. I was ready to order and waited patiently. She disappeared again and as the teenagers and I were waiting several more minutes, a group of people showed up for dinner and looked around for the hostess. We're all standing there waiting. Frustrated, I left. A total waste of my time. They missed out on the $100 worth of food I was going to order. The greeting at the front of the restaurant is very important. Not only did I encounter a hostess who was hiding behind the desk when I first entered, but she showed zero interest in helping me place an order. She disappeared for a long time and had no sense of urgency. read more

Only reason I gave them 3 stars is because they told us we could do happy hour at the bar only. And didn't allow us to order drinks at the bar and carry them to the table which was legit 5 feet away. Even though we asked about it before we sat down they only told us this after sitting and looking through the menu. The manger (I think) was very loud and rudely said we could not take advantage of the happy hour deal unless we sat at the bar. They didn't even have open bar seating for us... The Oysters and baked Clams were delicious. The chicken fajita was decent. Took some time for the food to come out. Nice spot but honestly the manager running back and forth yelling into her headset ruined the vibe for us. read more

See all

Hey, great family restaurant great service. The food was amazing and good drinks Nice ambience definitely coming back again. read more

Seafood Grill on the Bay - The three musketeers The three musketeers - Seafood Near Me - Freeport, New York

This establishment used to be Tony Cubans, it changed to this place before I tried it. I some reviews and I figured I would give it a try. The street view is nondescript when you first walk it there is a bar on the left and then you enter the dining room on the right. This establishment has outdoor seating in the back which was a wonderful surprise. It was very welcoming and perfect for a summer evening. They had love music and people were dancing and having a wonderful time. The music was not overwhelmingly loud which was nice. I am a vegetarian so what I can eat is somewhat limited. They had a number of dishes that were offered with meat and the waiter said they could make it just vegetable for me which was great to hear. We started with the guacamole with chips, it was standard the guac was nicely flavored. For entrees I ordered a vegetable quesadilla and my husband had the blackened salmon. While we were waiting for our entrees the owner came by to introduce herself and check on the service. I like to see the owners engaging with patrons. My quesadilla was good, and very big I could only eat half and brought the other half home. I believe it was filled with squash broccoli carrots tomatoes and a few other vegs. My husband liked his salmon and it was prepared well. We will definitely be back before the end of the summer to try other items on the menu. read more

See all

No pics sorry in advance ‍ We went to Seafood Grill on the Bay in Freeport on Saturday night. After calling 6 other restaurants, it was literally the only place that would accept a reservation to guarantee outdoor seating and allow dogs in the outdoor area. Afterwards, I looked them up on Yelp and was admittedly a *little* frightened we were going to get more of a red lobster experience than a nice on the water dining experience but to my absolute delight we were beyond satisfied with the experience! The indoor dining is nice and is clean, floor to ceiling windows so you stil get water views. The outdoor patio was gorgeous. Bistro lights, water views, center bar, umbrellas / coverings at most tables. Our waitress was very sweet and efficient. Food came out fast, was hot and delicious. We ordered: Apps: *calamari *mozzarella sticks Dinner: *Chicken fajitas *Three musketeers (lobster, filet mignon, tilapia and vegetables (side of fries) *Blackened salmon with roasted potatoes and vegetables Everyone at the table loved their mixed drinks as well (strawberry margaritas and some cinnamon toast drink) Overall a really great experience and I would definitely go there again read more

Yes, would recommend this place, the music can be loud, Fun place for birthday celebrations with friends and and family. Photographer on-site makes it a memorable event instead of just a dinner. read more

Outstanding food, service & drinks with a beautiful water side patio. Allen prepared an amazing flambéed grilled seafood appetizer with squid, Octopus & shrimp that was a huge crowd pleaser! It's a quiet little local spot with free parking and no wait. If your in Freeport it's worth a trip!! read more

Absolutely Amazing! I came here to celebrate my aunt birthday and we had such a great time I booked a reservation for another birthday. The food was top notch and the drink presentation and taste were spot on. A MAJOR SHOUT OUT TO ALLEN (the chef/manager). He made our experience so memorable. The ambiance was fire. It's by the water and they play music. If I could give them more stars I would.. definitely visit them!!! read more

Went for my wife's Birthday first the service was great very attentive. The drinks were kicking (definitely hangover type) !!! Food was good wife got the 3 Musketeers with lobster, steak & tilapia. Would definitely go back in the summer to enjoy the outside seating and music. read more

If you're not Spanish don't go there. They never came to take even a drink order. The waitress gave us our menu and said something in Spanish to her coworker and started laughing and staring at our table. After 20 minutes of waiting we got up and left and she turned to us and said thank you...what? read more

Let me tell you this Seafood on the bay was definitely and enjoyable experience. From the moment we walked in the restaurant. Everything was excellent. The Service and the food. I definitely will be coming back. read more

Seafood Grill on the Bay - Seafood Near Me - Freeport, New York

So... the location and ambience was great and we had a good feeling with the Dj playing and energy high but boy were we wrong. We initially had a reservation for 830 and even called several times to confirm. We arrived at 815 but were told that it was made for 7 after we called and confirmed with them. We, then even had to proceed to wait another 30 minutes before we got sat. When we sat, we had noticed a dirty cup and asked for a new cup, we did not get this extra cup for 20 minutes. We then proceeded to ask for water 3 times to 3 different people. It was mind boggling because I saw AT LEAST 7 front of house employees for at most 10 tables. We placed an order for drinks and food. The drinks came moderately fast but it was only a bottle of beer. We ordered some appetizers and entrees and for 1 hour and 15 minutes we had not seen any of it except for some complimentary bread. We had got so tired of asking our server where the food was and being told that it was coming but eventually we all finally decided to leave. I would never justify leaving but with such a lack of action and promise we had decided to leave after paying for whatever we had consumed. The only reason why I will give this place 2 stars and not one is because the Dj was playing some good music and our server seemed compassionate. Returning from mandatory closing could be a reason for what ever happened but I really do hope they can provide better service in the future. As I said the ambiance is really nice and along the water. read more

Seafood Grill on the Bay - Good ambiance - Seafood Near Me - Freeport, New York

Had a good time here. Armando the manager is amazing. Really friendly great people person awesome vibes. The view is also breathtaking. Right on the water out door bar live music. Everything is nice. U might Gs for to wait a bit on the food if it's packed but everything else is great. read more

Seafood Grill on the Bay - Outdoor bar! - Seafood Near Me - Freeport, New York

I passed this place all the time and finally went there. The food was good staff was friendly and it was a very nice ambiance Im sure it's even more beautiful when you can sit outside. Great for a date night! read more

So one thing I will say is that this place has a lot going on culturally . You walk in and there's Cuban art, Mexican and Seafood, and salsa playing outside. And I'm not mad at it! The outside ambiance is beautiful, right on the water with a pretty lit up bar and a couple of people dancing salsa. The paella was awesome but I wasn't a big fan of the ceviche. It was mostly tomatoes . Also, the bar staff needs a little more training because they made my moms "white Russian" straight up taste like milk and we tried to get it revised and still tasted the same. With a couple of improvements this place can easily be 5 star read more

See all

The place, the food, the music, the vibe.. it's all good! Great service thus far.. this place has not let us down! We already have our next visit set for a family visit. It is definitely one of our go to spots! Their Coconut Mojitos are on point too. read more

See all

I really enjoyed this restaurant. We sat outside which is very nice. We started off with the nachos supreme. It was great. I had the Grilled Chicken Grudaiola which was Grilled chicken breast with diced tomatoes, red onions, fresh mozzarella, and arugula. It was great and a nice portion. For dessert I had the Oreo ice cream cake. It was delicious. The service was great. I would highly recommend eating here. read more

Aside from the long wait to be served the food was amazing and our waitress was very friendly. The Tres Leches cake for dessert was the best ever. Sangria was not watered down the portions were generous. Would surely revisit read more

See all

Great service! Love the Italian Mexican fusion. The seasoning is good Must Get: Ceviche shrimp read more

Seafood Grill on the Bay - Linguine with Grilled Shrimp - Seafood Near Me - Freeport, New York

Not quite on Woodcleft Ave but ranks up there with the best of the Nautical Mile. Food's great, good portions, strong drinks, great view of the water and reasonably priced. Repeat worthy! read more

This is not a real seafood restaurant. I had crab cakes and Calamar, sauce was chips salsa Crabcakes were actually discussing and was not lump crab!!!! Was not fresh and had absolutely no flavor to it. read more

Ate here Saturday evening 8/3. We've been coming to this restaurant's location for quite some time all the way back to when it was owned and run by the same people who own PitStop in Merrick. Glad to see it has reopened with new owners. We had guacamole and a Capri salad. Both were excellent. Our main courses were whole red snapper and paella. Both were a great choice. The paella included half a small lobster and the meat was very sweet. Service was good and we plan to come back at a happy hour and try the tacos. Took one star off because the coffee was weak and not hot (I had it black) A minor issue that should not deter you from giving this new establishment a try. read more

We planned a week in advance for a party of 18 for my mother birthday. Suprising to say it was handled very well. Great selection of food, fitting everyone's particular palate aside from seafood. Table seating was great, out side and by the water with calming views and live music (Saturday night). We didn't take long for our food to arive although i assume the portions would be slightly bigger. Blacked Salmon was cooked great and dessert was a great assortment of choices. My mother had a great time , certainly one to remember. Highly recommend this place for your events. read more

Seafood Grill on the Bay - Outside - Seafood Near Me - Freeport, New York

The food is OK too pricey. The service leaves a lot to be desired the ambience. Nothing to write home about. If you visit this establishment to eat, make sure you look at your check very well because gratuities are included which they do not tell you about. Also look at the receipt that you sign and the one they give you. They both have different taxes attached to them another thing that they do not bring to your attention very sneaky, I will not be going back not trustworthy read more

We went on a Saturday night and we're seated promptly the staff and servers are very nice and attentive live dj when we went, the white sangria is excellent strong and sweet the red sangria was ok we had shrimp fajitas chicken burrito and some apps the food was mediocre not much flavor portions are good prices are too high for the menu honestly it was a nice night out clean restaurant nice location but honestly we probably won't return read more