If you're ever in Fort Walton Beach and craving authentic Italian with a cozy, picture-perfect vibe, Sebastiano's Pizzeria Italiano is a must-visit From the moment you walk in, it's giving warm, homestyle charm with the kind of atmosphere that makes you want to snap a few photos before you even take a bite. But trust me... the food steals the spotlight. We started with the garlic stuffed mozzarella knots and WOW. Soft, buttery, cheesy perfection with just the right amount of garlic. And the marinara sauce? Rich, flavorful, and honestly worth dipping everything into Every dish tastes like it came straight from someone's Italian grandmother's kitchen. Fresh, comforting, and made with love. And don't even think about leaving without dessert. The salted caramel cheesecake is next-level indulgent. Creamy, sweet, with that perfect salty finish that keeps you going back for "just one more bite" Whether you're there for a date night, girls' night, or just treating yourself, this place delivers on food, vibes, and experience. read more

Sebastiano's Pizza - Love this cheese - Pizza Near Me - Fort Walton Beach, Florida

See all

This place is amazing! The sweet lady at the front ensured that we had an amazing experience since we were looking for a new pizzeria! This place made us feel at home! We can't thank everyone enough and can't wait to come back! We have found our new pizzeria! The food was amazing! The ambiance is so family friendly! read more

Sebastiano's Pizza - Pepperoni pizza, cheese pizza, Cheese Bread - Pizza Near Me - Fort Walton Beach, Florida

Since my first review a year ago I have visited Sebastiano's several times. I have not been disappointed, EVER! The pizza and calzones are consistently delicious, perfectly cooked and priced fairly for the quality you get. I love their food so much I opted for a Retirement Pizza lunch at my office. There weren't any leftovers when it was done. The only downside is I live in Niceville, so this gives me an excuse to get to FWB once in a while. read more

Great pizza. Family owned and run. Staff were very friendly. Small dining room, so we got carry out. Food was fresh from the oven and traveled well. Pizza is a great NY style. Prices are good for the quality of the pizza. read more

Pizza was really good and staff was so nice. Would definitely come back! If you want some good pizza this is your go to place!

Excellent pizza. This is our go-to place for pizza. The staff is awesome and they have the best home made desserts! Amazing! The inside is quaint and comfy. read more

Very friendly! Pizza was nice and thin NY Style and really really great! Garlic rolls slap! read more

I'd leave more stars if I could. This is an amazing new "family-owned" pizzeria. I had pizza from one of their previous locations in South Florida and was so excited to see they were in Fort Walton, and we happened to be around the area. I love the crispiness of the entire pie, not just the crust, and the fact that I could eat it without it being greasy. We got the white pizza, and it was spectacular. Make sure to come in and support this family's fantastic new spot! We will be back next time and every time we're in the area. read more

See all

Best pizza in Fort Walton! We got the large pepperoni and crumbled Italian sausage pizza. The flavor was delicious and the pizza itself was perfect for a family of three. The service was amazing and the environment was super cute. I would definitely come back again. read more

The pizza was huge and really tasty.i got the BYO Cheese with sausage, Caprese and Mozz Knots, everything was really good and arrived hot and full of flavor the cheese had great cheese pull and had perfect amount of toppings on it. The caprese mozz was great and tomato was awesome too. Worth a try. read more

See all

If NASA ever needs to fuel astronauts for a trip to Mars, they should skip the space food and just send them to this place. The Meat Lovers Calzone was absolutely out of this world--like, Houston-we-have-no-problems kind of good. Everything tasted fresh, like it had just been handcrafted by a team of Italian grandmothers. The cheese bread? Let's just say it's so dangerously addictive you'll consider weighing yourself just to figure out how many pounds of it you'd need to consume to be satisfied (spoiler: it's never enough). The pizza also passed the toughest test known to mankind: approval from a kid. When the boy gives it two thumbs up, you know you've struck gold. Portions are no joke either--massive, generous, and perfect for creating next-day leftovers (or for the walk of shame when you try to convince yourself you'll "save some for later" and then don't). Verdict: Come hungry, leave happy, and maybe bring stretchy pants. read more

Sebastiano's Pizza - Meal Lovers Calzone. - Pizza Near Me - Fort Walton Beach, Florida

Food 10/10 Tip option is FRAUD. Selected 10% Got charged 33% Got a premium pie with free cheese pizza, added pepperoni. Pizza: $31.00 Tax: $2.17 = $33.17 I selected 10% tip. Unsure if the 10% is on pizza or grand total. It charged me $10.56 = 31-34% tip. Im quite sure there wasnt an option for tipping that much and I selected wrong by accident. (Now if the $10.56 was listed below the 10%, I dont remember as I was chatting with the lady at the register.) Owner came out and told me it would only take a sec to fix. Showed me it on the screen and said it will show up tomorrow to my CC. *SO easy to fix = SO easy to FRAUD!!! Love Love LOVE the pizza. However this tip "oopsie" is pure fraud. read more

Food was great. I ordered the BYO Stromboli with sausage, sliced meatballs and fresh mushrooms. It was amazing. It was our first time eating there. My husband got the grilled chicken, jalapeño pizza. When they brought out his pizza the cook explained that there was an issue with my order and it would be longer. I told them I don't mind at all and I thanked them for telling me the issue and that I value quality. It was worth the wait! Evidently, the owner/chef remade my Stromboli! It was so dense with high quality and delicious "toppings". I highly recommend the Stromboli as it is made with cheese, garlic-oil and your choice of toppings/ingredients. The pizza comes in one size and that's 16". It didn't fit the pizza box - it was a lil too big! Worth the $$ highly recommend for local Italian! read more

***New game in town! *** Treat yourself to pizza from Sebastiano's. Long time fans of Lost but Sebastiano's may have won us over! This thin but not-too-thin crust is delectable! We tried the Greek with a few extra toppings....out of this world! Tasty sauce, chunks of garlic and loaded with flavor! The veggie pizza was just as good with an abundance of fresh vegetables and baked to perfection! Be sure to grab a salad... Fresh, crunchy lettuce, and crisp toppings with a delicious dressing! Super friendly staff and hands-down one of, if not THE best pizza in Fort Walton Beach! Give it a go! read more

Got a stuffed meaty, a Caesar salad and some dessert too and everything was excellent. The stuffed pie was probably big enough to feed 6 people, portions are outrageous and we love that in this economy. Everything was delectable, will be back! read more

Very good struboli, and full of what ever you want in it, also owners are very nice and friendly. Owners have previously owned a restaurant in the keys. read more

Really good, New York style pizza. The delivery was fast and the pizza was hot. I know it's a preference thing but I really wish it had a little more sauce. Overall it was a good pizza. read more

Do NOT miss this place for a great pizza! Crispy crust, with just the right amount of chew! We chose the white pizza (our fav) with banana peppers on 1/2 and ground meatballs on the other 1/2. It was so good! read more

Sebastiano's Pizza - White pizza! Added banana peppers and ground meatballs on each half. - Pizza Near Me - Fort Walton Beach, Florida

Was looking for a place to eat and pizza was not high on the list because Ft Walton is not known for pizza. Well, this place changes my mind! I couldn't believe how good the pizza was and best of all, true thin crust with nice flavor like back home, Jersey. They only offer one size, 16 inch but worth it because of its thinnest which may allow you to eat one more slice than normal. Try this spot if you miss northeast pizza. read more

New to the area and trying a different pizzeria each week. This is up there with the best so far.

The pizza here is the best in town! Love the fresh ingredients and the desserts are home made. Great place!

Very good pizza. Available by the slice with a salad. Nice quick lunch. Also have carried out a whole large pizza. There can be a wait on the weekends. But it was worth it. Small place for eat-in. Owners/workers are friendly. read more

Best pizza we've had in a long time sooo good. Thin light crispy good fold great undercarriage. read more

Sebastiano's Pizza - Tuscany pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Walton Beach, Florida

See all

Pizza was great, nice crispy crust throughout. Not cheap, but still worth it. Would prefer fountain soda rather than having to buy individual cans or having to buy bottled water. read more

Great pizza. Thin crust. Great sauce and toppings. Garlic knots also delicious. Simple surroundings. Drinks in the can from the fridge case. Very friendly service. Off the main hwy - worth the short in - town trek. Reasonable pricing. Great pizza, great people. read more

Usually if I want NY pizza in town I go to Wiley's but they were closed because of new year and I went here instead- the pizza was almost as good but I spend 3x more than I ever would usually. The bang for my buck doesn't really make sense to me here. read more

Outstanding pizza with quality ingredients and plenty of them my new favorite pizza place in town!

We were in Fort Walton and found Sebastiano's online so we went to check it out. We were greeted immediately by employees who were very nice and went over the menu with us. We decided on the Leonardo calzone. Omg! It was so huge. It was also delicious, the meat combination and the sauce were the best! It was so big we were able to save 1/2 for dinner the next night and were still full. We would definitely recommend! Sorry no photo, we had to dig on to it immediately ! read more

Great pizza! It's the closet to NY pizza that you can get in Fort Walton Beach or the surrounding area. my only complaint is if I'm going to pay four dollars per topping is that I need to have more. Make sure you try the cannoli too! I highly recommend but skip the tiramisu. It taste like it came from a grocery store. Everything else is fantastic but pricey. read more

This pizza is authentic and deliciously crafted. Lots of take-out order but highly recommend eating at restaurant where you get to visit with the lovely and vivacious owners and staff. Great ambiance - great pizza - great pizza choices! La migliore pizza della citta! read more

We ordered a pepperoni and sausage pizza and in my humble opinion it was cooked to perfection. Considering Sebastiano's pizza business is relatively new, they did a great job. read more

This place is amazing! Will put mainstream pizza chains out of business VERY quickly in my opinion (meat lovers was PERFECT)

What a pleasant surprise. One of the best pizzas in the area and not at an outrageous price(sorry Fubar). I ordered an onion with half tomato pizza for take out. While the outside look does not look a eat in place, I was also surprise at the decent interior atmosphere. Next time, we'll eat in. read more

I got one of the best buffalo chicken pizzas I've had in a long while. The slices are pretty big too.

Yummy pizza. Nothing revolutionary here but a good, simple NY slice. Got a fresh pie and it came out fast and was nice and hot. Mozz bites were also yummy. Won't punch you in the face with flavor, just a straightforward slice here. Enough grease to be called a NY slice but not to much. That was nice. It's a small place in a strip mall but the inside is nice. Well decorated, still smells like fresh paint. Cool spot, could be a cool place to hang. A lot of potential here for sure. read more