First time trying custard and really enjoyed it. The pie in the sky had custard on top of a nice, warm brownie. May go back tomorrow to try another flavor. read more

Sheridan's Frozen Custard - Pie in the Sky - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fairview Heights, Illinois

Tried it on a whim and maaaan that custard is smooooth. Went with a basic two scoops of chocolate and zero regrets. Two people serving up scoops and concretes but it's worth waiting for. There's outside seating and a drive thru. I love it when an unplanned try turns into a winner--this place is a sleeper. read more

Sheridan's Frozen Custard - Menu of what they offer - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fairview Heights, Illinois

I love frozen custard and I've tried many of their products. Like every other business I frequent, the prices are kind of steep but you get what you pay for. The malts are the best, I get extra malt in mine and they have great concretes but my favorite is a toss up between the banana split and a couple of scoops of custard in a waffle cone (in a cup because it melts too fast while I savor). Service is friendly but the drive thru can be slow... It's worth waiting for! read more

Came all the way from Maine to have Frozen custard again and this was my destination! The chocolate is super rich and creamy, Vanilla is sooo good! Service was fast, but sometimes hard to hear them in the drive through. read more

Sheridan's Frozen Custard - Whoops, too yummy to take a photo before eating - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fairview Heights, Illinois

Custard is really good. Wish the outside lights would work. Service is quick too.........

Absolutely delish! However, it always says it's open online and on the building, when, oftentimes, it's not. Kinda a big waste of time & gas for the customers. read more

I had to run a work errand in Fairview Heights. My reward for the work errand was Sheridan's. I ordered a milkshake with caramel and Heath Bar. I love Sheridan's custard. I live very close to their closed chesterfield location and used to eat it all the time. The shake was perfect and I was able to drink it on my way back to work. They give you an extra thick straw so the shake can pass through the straw. Great idea! Of course I'll be back! read more

Sheridan's Frozen Custard - Milkshake with caramel & Heath Bar - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fairview Heights, Illinois

Dear Sheridan, This is what a two scoop chocolate waffle cone looks like read more

Sheridan's Frozen Custard - 2 Scoop waffle cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fairview Heights, Illinois

Favorite place around here. Sometimes it is slow, but always worth the wait. Mt Rushmore is my personal favorite!

If you are looking for some delicious frozen custard, Sheridan's is the place to be! They offer many great flavors and toppings! From their shakes, concretes, and sundaes, you won't find a better selection in the area. read more

Love all the options they have and definitely enjoy a sweet treat in the winter . They're fast and friendly and never had issues with my order . read more

It took actually twenty minutes for two kids to make two plain custards!!! Also the worst frozen custard I've ever had

Get the wedding cake concrete or a sundae with a slice of wedding cake and thank me later. Pure heaven. What I love about this place is the handcrafted, bespoke choices and its a place you can tell someone cares about and that they care for the community. Hiring local students, you know that kind of thing. I love coming here for a late-night treat especially since it is one of the only places that are open late. Other great choices are the smoothies. Very tasty. You can tell the frozen custard is made from high-quality dairy which is a plus. Some of the items are pricey but I am sure because of the high-quality ingredients they are sourcing. You can still get a nice Sundae with one scoop for around three dollars though depending on your toppings. I am a regular here and I will be coming back again. read more

This custard was amazing! So rich and creamy and tasted soooooo good. I will be going back for sure and I'm going to bring my family and out of town guests with me so they can see what real Midwest custard is like. read more

I'd only had Sheridan's on one other occasion and wasn't terribly impressed. I remember my concrete being less than flavorful and therefore less than impressive. But when my best foodie friend said that she'd experienced quite the opposite (thanks to the wedding cake mix-in), I was totally down to give it another try! While wedding cake wasn't mentioned on the menu as a possibility, after asking we found out that it was something we could order! While my friend went with the sensible and basic wedding cake concrete, I did my usual craziness - a concrete with wedding cake, Reese's cups, Oreos and peanut butter! Man, this concrete totally did it for me!! I'm so glad we came! The kiddos enjoyed the patio space (which we mostly had to ourselves) while us adults relaxed. read more

Sheridan's Frozen Custard - Regular size concrete with wedding cake, peanut butter, Reese's cups and Oreos - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fairview Heights, Illinois

See all

I ordered a lemon lush concrete and a dirt worm concrete and it was by far the worst ice cream I ever had. The vanilla had Zero flavor and it has a super milky taste. I honestly don't recommend, you'd be better off at McDonald's. I left leaving thirsty after tasting that ice cream read more

I looked at their online and it did not include any pricing. Now, I know why. This place is extremely over-priced. Most of the sizes they offer are regular and large. We all ordered regular I didn't want to spend $30 on 4 ice creams. They may call the size regular, but it is a small portion. I know prices have gone up, but this is just taking advantage. We wont be back. read more

They are sticklers about the "no mask, no service" policy, so bring your mask to order! The serving sizes are BIG and it's custard, which IS BETTER because its softer (and served 10 degrees cooler). This place is cute. I like their neon sign, too. read more

Sheridan's Frozen Custard - Brownie with ice cream! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fairview Heights, Illinois

See all

my husband and i wanted a "quarantine treat" and have been eyeing this place up whenever we drive by! thankfully, they have a drive-through and we were able to get a Dirt & Worms to share. it was super good! the custard was thick and really creamy with a plethora of oreos to add that extra yummy flavor. wasn't too sweet or too vanilla-y (don't think that's a word, but oh well). the sprinkles on top added a really good crunch and the gummy worms were super cute and yummy! i love how they get a bit frozen if you let them sit in the ice cream for a bit- so good! will definitely be stopping back here this summer! thank you guys for staying open- and thank you to the employees for working during the current circumstances! we are very grateful read more

Sheridan's Frozen Custard - Dirt & Worms - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fairview Heights, Illinois

See all

This place was AWESOME! We're from out of town and staying around here for a few days. We wanted to find some good custard and came across Sheridan's. Customer service was great and quick! They're open from 11am-11pm, so super convenient at all hours. Finally, the custard was great!! All the ingredients tasted fresh and made locally. read more

See all

Great Quality and Delicious. Service is always great! The ice cream is always fresh and quick.

I went here a few years ago and got ticked off and have not went back til tuesday when i took my nephew. I got the chocolate ice cream with pineapple. it was good but it is not good enough for my to trek all the way to Fairview Heights, the 1st gate of hell in my book. if you want whipped cream or shell nuts on your sundae be prepared to shell out 70 cents. just ok. the first time the service was rude. this time the service was ok. the poor girl was by herself with roughly 6 people to wait on. read more

Sheridan's Frozen Custard - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fairview Heights, Illinois

I occasionally frequent Sheridan's! My absolute all time favorite is their mango dango! It consists of mangos, pecans, and cherries with vanilla frozen custard. I've tried a few of their other items and it's not that great. As other reviews say, sometimes the custard can be runny but it's a hit or miss. I've never had bad service here. I took one star off because the other day I had ordered a scoop of ice cream. Literally half of the size of a baseball for 2$. If I would of known it was that small and expensive I would of pass or asked for 2 scoops considering it was a few cents extra. Most places that serve one scoop of ice cream is usually a lot but not this place. read more

See all

We are in Fairview Heights frequently from out of town and Sheridan's is one of our favorite stops. It is a very small shop but they do a good business. Generous servings and a good selection of toppings. The Pie in the Sky is amazing. Custard and brownie with fudge topping and marshmallow cream with a cherry on top! Enough for two people. read more

best custard I've ever had in the world it's my favorite place to go get ice cream. it's better than Culver's

This place was my first introduction to custard twelve years ago and we stop here every time we visit Fairview heights. The place is small and cozy and the service is speedy. The drive thru has one window to pay and serve but they move fast. This is an old school place that serves the same flavors the same way all the time. It's open from 11-11 in the summer so you can go for lunch and dinner. I love the salted caramel crunch flavor, the blend of salt, sweet with a bit of crunch is such a delicious flavors. read more

This place is a hidden gem, across from the former VFW. I am surprised it has lasted remaining open even throughout the winter, when everyone else closes. The ice cream is awesome, hard to go wrong there. The chocolatecustard is to die for, but can get costly unless you keep it simple with a cone or small sundae. The strawberry banana smoothie(I think) is also to die for. Never had a bad experience, line goes fast and even have sitting out front. Just be expected to pay for all that goodness. read more

Hands down the BEST. FROZEN. CUSTARD. in this area. I adore this shop. I've never had a bad experience. I love how quick the drive thru is, there is plenty of seating. Staff is kind. read more

We love Sheridan's!! I get the Mt. Rushmore with a chocolate chips added instead of gram crackers. Yummy! It's a treat! *updated 4/22/2010 * Ok the one in IL is better with customer service though. We love the ice cream, which is what keeps us coming back but the customer service at the one in Chesterfield isn't great. Each time we have gone there they have been confused and slightly rude. There was one time I was ordering and there was silence. I asked if the lady was still there. She said I was just going to fast. Sounded like she got upset and just didn't respond! So I slowed down, she was still rude. I didn't know what was going to make this girl happy. We get to the window and they seemed really confused. There were about 3 employees rushing around. One guy came to the window to hand me the ice cream. I hadn't paid yet so he said, "Oh I didn't know she didn't charge you yet." He takes the card and puts it next to the register. I made the mistake of turning my head and didn't watch to see if he swiped it. Silly me! Well another employee comes to the window and tells me the total. I pointed to the card on the register. She asked if I paid. I said I didn't know if he swiped it. She got mad at me for that answer. Then another employee came and added to the confusion! Confused yet? lol so was I at the time! The previous employee tells the other one, "She said she hasn't paid yet." I said no, I said I didn't know if he swiped it yet. All they had to do is look to see what the receipt said that was on the machine. They hadn't given someone their receipt. They were just very rude and confused. We finally got our order and left. I almost swore off Sheridan's that night. The following visits weren't that bad but they weren't good either. The frozen custard is good but the customer service is not! read more

A four for me, and the reasons are simple. No low carb or sugar free options for custard, and no military discount. I will say that the consistency and flavor of the custard is delicious. It is sweet and creamy and they have a pretty big menu as well as being able to create your own. Prices are a bit high but nothing unreasonable. Will most likely come back if we are in the area but wouldn't drive out of my way to get it. Parking on both sides of the building as well as a drive through. Only seating is outside, there are about 6 tables. Service was pretty quick too. read more

See all

Not as good as Ted Drews. Really an average ice cream place. The teenagers working here are nice, although they are not the swiftest of people. The prices are reasonable. It would also be nice if they had custard as an option. Also for hand packed ice cream, your choices are; chocolate, vanilla, or go on a diet. Seriously can't we at least have chocolate chip, or really splurge on strawberry? read more

Was visiting some friends and had a hankering for some custard. The took me here, it was also their first time. I ordered a smores concrete......Now, I am not sure how you combine the goodness of smores and custard and it still taste awful but this near magical feat came to fruition..... I will likely stick to Ted Drews or Andy's. read more

Sheridan's was a-ok. We stopped a got a quart of vanlla to top of some homemade brownies. It was okay, not necessarily the best custard that I have ever had. They do have a drive in. read more

I used to go to Sheridan's when my family & I would go for our weekend drives. Custards and toppings were always a treat for us from here. The prices were decent and service was always with a smile. read more

Sheridans is a waste of money depending on what you get, or what teen makes it. Last fall we stopped going to sheridans because the malted I bought was very thin and you could poor it out of the cup like milk. Also, we'd found a hair in a cup of ice cream. Last night over six months later we decided to give it another go because I was sure management had changed. Well the malted I got was great but this is a picture of the Royal Turtle which btw was over $5. Bobby's is right up 159 in Maryville and it's always great. IF you don't have time to go there, just skip dessert because this place is a gamble. It is a shame because a year ago I would say this was our go to custard stand. Now I won't go back ever. read more

Sheridan's Frozen Custard - Royal Turtle - "QUITE A BARGAIN" at over $5 - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fairview Heights, Illinois

Never had a bad experience with this place. Every time I've gone I have ordered something different and it was delicious!

I was extremely disappointed in this place. Our normal spots were closed due to the Memorial Day holiday so we gave this place a try. My scoop of vanilla custard was ok. My husband said his strawberry shortcake sundae was disappointing: too much syrup with stale tasting shortcake. My son got the Mount RushS'more concrete. We immediately noticed a hair in his dessert before we pulled away. I showed it to the girl at the window who showed a person I assumed was the manager. This person didn't address me at ALL and asked the girl "do they want another one?" The girl at the window asked, I said yes and when it was ready they handed it to me without a single apology, offer to give it for free or a coupon for a free item on the next visit...nothing! We will NOT be back! read more

The service was very great. Very polite employees. Lots of patio seating. Masks required (thankfully). But the quality of the custard was VERY POOR. It was not even solid. The concrete was more like a melted shake. The banana split was a boat of melted ice cream and some canned pineapples. I could not get a solid spoon of custard. Very disappointing. Will not return again. read more

My go to frozen treat spot. Always get the mocha almond. Any concrete or the like needs to be made like this. tons and tons of almonds! Will revisit again and again since they are open year-round. read more

The custard here is wonderful! Its super close to our house so it's nice and easy to get to for a snack! I definitely recommend this place!