A beautiful inn with a homey vibe and with the best staff I've ever encountered (every single…read moreone!). I came with my husband and my service dog to celebrate our anniversary weekend and everything was perfect. The staff were very attentive, friendly, gave us recommendations when needed, helped us through the winter storm and gave us a little present to make our celebration more special. The room is spacious, well taken care of and very cute! The hotel is located right next to all the restaurants, shops and bars. I couldn't recommend this place enough.

Had a great extended weekend with my wife and dog at this inn. The staff is unmatched and made you…read morefeel welcome as soon as you step in. We had a wonderful experience during the storm of 2026 with breakfast included. The rooms were spacious and insulated so we couldn't hear outside noise or in the halls. Centrally located to many restaurants and bars just walking distance. Definitely recommend staying here!

Beautiful upscale boutique hotel! We normally wouldn't stay over in a place like this but we…read moresplurged for our daughter's wedding and we're so glad that we did. Amenities such as robes and slippers in the bathroom, a Nespresso coffee machine in our room and tasteful decorations were bonuses. Beautiful artwork upon exiting the elevator on every floor. But these 5 stars are for the honest care and friendliness of Danielle, in the morning, at the front desk. What a gem! I hope she is appreciated by her employer. Thank you for a fabulous stay.

This hotel is overpriced for what it is and it is misrepresented as a hotel and restaurant on their…read morewebsite. The rooms are modern, clean and well kept but they are very sparsely furnished. The rooms are spacious but not many places to relax and sit comfortably. There is more than enough room for a small table with at least two club chairs, a bench in front of the bed, maybe even a loveseat but instead it's just big open flooring with a king size bed and one chair- not really anywhere for more than one person to sit comfortably. There is a fridge which is always nice to have and the staff was pleasant and attentive. A free breakfast was included, they served egg sandwiches, yogurt, fruit and pastries but still not worth a price tag of almost $475+ a night. The website also makes it seem like the restaurant is open and available to guests but is was completely shut down, which was very disappointing. Again the staff was nice and attentive, the rooms were clean but considering how much we paid and how underwhelming the stay was I think 3 stars is actually a generous review.

We were so fortunate to be able to book rooms, including a lovely waterfront bridal suite and an…read moreamazing newly renovated two-bedroom apartment-style suite at the Lands End Motel for guests and the wedding party to end their evening after my daughter's wedding at Lands End. Al and Mary, who manage the motel, were so helpful and kind as we navigated all the planning that goes into planning a wedding and providing overnight accommodations. The check in process was seamless, the rooms are spacious and clean, the grounds are lovely and the location is perfect. I definitely recommend Lands End Motel to anyone looking for a place to stay in Sayville!

I would give no stars if yelp would allow me to! I recently…read moretried to make a reservation at this motel in Sayville, and I had an extremely disappointing and upsetting experience. As someone with a disability, I have a registered service animal who assists me with my condition, which includes seizures stemming from my time serving this country in the military. When I called to make a reservation, I was denied service simply because I have a service animal. The person I spoke to was not only unhelpful, but downright rude. They told me to "go to LaQuinta or elsewhere" instead of accommodating my legitimate request. When I tried to explain my situation and rights under the ADA (Americans with Disabilities Act), the representative hung up on me and refused to answer any further calls. It's unacceptable and discriminatory for any business to deny service to someone because of their disability or service animal. I would advise anyone considering staying here to look elsewhere - especially if you expect fair and compassionate treatment.

I love the Bayveiw Resort In the Hamptons! I've come here…read moreevery summer the last four years, and will continue to make this my home away from home. The rooms are great...always clean, has a fridge, microwave, comfy bed, free WiFi and many other amenities. The view of Tiana bay, the waterfront deck, salt water pool, kayaks, and free breakfast every morning make for a great vacation in a beautiful spot. Danny and the staff cater to every need, with professionalism, are always friendly and courteous. I always stay awhile when I'm here and can't wait to come back. 10 stars!

This little gem was such a happy surprise. The premises is neat as a pin and the location, right on…read morethe bay, is beautiful. Brian, at the front desk, was welcoming and helpful. The room had a microwave, coffee maker, small refrigerator, hairdryer, shampoo/conditioner/body wash dispensers in the bathroom (great water pressure in the shower BTW), WiFi, and a large flat screen TV. I will definitely be back. What a pleasure.

Cute hotel on the water. Reasonably priced and you cant beat the location…read more They are renovating the property which is from the 1800's. We stay in the captain's house. The only issue was that is smelled like smoke and a bit like mild dew. The deck is a great touch

I had a reservation booked for many days ahead to watch the world cup, we arrived and were told to…read moresit anywhere, we did, 20 mins into the game we were told to move because someone "reserved" the table. We were not moved to a different table, not a single apology. Specifically a staff member (blonde lady wearing a black dress) was extremely rude and snobby. Also if you are looking for a fun place with cool people this is the last place to be. This is where rich people with no idea how to use their money go to be seen. Every transplant from Ohio and buttfuck nowhere are here, and they suck. Never seen more horribly done Veneers. Three Aperol Spritz's costed 90 dollars. And they also serve Popeyes (overpriced)- better off going to Mcdolands for a 1000% better experience .

I recently stayed at The Menhaden on July 15, 2026, and it was an exceptional experience from start…read moreto finish. This boutique hotel perfectly balances a luxurious feel with a warm, intimate atmosphere. The highlights of my stay included the careful attention to detail throughout the property, from the beautifully designed rooms to the thoughtfully curated lounge experience (loved the retro board games and Vinyl Record collection) The staff was incredibly attentive and provided top-notch service, ensuring that every need was met promptly and with a smile. Honestly, I could not find any areas for improvement during my visit; everything was seamless and well-executed. Overall, I would rate The Menhaden a solid 5 out of 5 stars. I highly recommend it to anyone looking for a boutique hotel that delivers both comfort and luxury with outstanding hospitality.

This weekend was our second stay at Menhaden, to celebrate a combination birthday/anniversary…read more And Menhaden easily met every expectation. First - A shout out to Alex, and Kailee, and the rest of the staff we met for their wonderful kindness and support. Second, our King Room was exceptional, Clean, Large lots of windows for spectacular views. Third, maybe most important, We were able to bring our newly rescued 8 lb precious little Bichon Sadie. Sadie was made to feel at home and the three of us look forward to our next stay at Menhaden

Me and my family had a wonderful time at the Mattituck motel. Our room was comfortable and quiet…read more The owners are friendly and welcoming. We were just a short walk from the beach, dock and playground. Some of the activities we attended were the sunflower festival at Harbes family farm in Jamesport. We also made our own bouquets at the North Folk Flower Farm! So many wonderful things to do on the north folk! Check out the Mattituck motel,local farms, winery's and restaurants it's definitely worth it!

True to his reviews, the owner, Kerry, was more than hospitable, most accommodating and friendly…read more Was surprised to see how big the room was, complete with every amenity-stove, frig, dishes, utensils and even an iron, ironing board and hair dryer! They are located down a lovely, quiet street, near restaurants, wineries and shopping. They are also near the beach, but as we visited off-season that wasn't an option. With two spotless queen sized beds, we slept very comfortably. Would definitely come back! It was a wonderful experience.

Before staying at the Montauk Manor I needed to make some changes with my stay. I spoke with Regina…read moreand Janice regarding my reservation. BIG shout out to them! Their customer service went above and beyond! They were so extremely helpful and kind when assisting me with my needs. They made it easy and stress free! We have stayed at the Montauk Manor previously and I would highly recommend staying here while visiting!

My husband and I stayed there in the 1990's. It was a wonderful, gracious experience, even though…read morethe restaurant was closed for the season and one of the burners on the stove didn't work. On and off throughout the decade, each experience was worse than the last. We decided our last stay was when we were put in a room overlooking the garbage dumpsters, and the noise and smell were very upsetting. We made the mistake of trying it one more time in the early 2000's. I must mention that we often, but not always, have a little "get away" in mid-October as its our wedding anniversary and my birthday month. Well, when I called to make the reservation, I was told that the place had been converted to condos, and each owner was responsible for the condition of the room. It's a very expensive place, so how bad could it be? The joke was on us. Everything, except the thrift shop 1960's style TV was broken. Even some of the light didn't work, the management wouldn't even consider replacing lightbulbs. We bought food for our room and couldn't cook it, even the microwave was broken. There was absolutely NO patio furniture. When I called the front desk, I was told it was up to the owner. It looked to me like the room next door had "borrowed" all the furniture as they had a huge set up on the patio, and the furniture looked like the patio furniture we were used to from past visits. We had to take kitchen chairs outside. I have never ever had an experience like this, and we are world travelers. I have stayed in third world countries with better amenities and more gracious service than this place. A few years ago, we returned to Montauk and stayed in a different beachfront hotel, same situation, condos owned by various investors, and had a beautiful room. Whenever we stay there, we always request the same room. It's beautifully decorated and exquisitely clean. Montauk manor is a disgrace.