We have been back multiple times and are never disappointed. Love their new happy hour menu and the dessert of the month right now (strawberry rhubarb cobbler) is out of this world with the ice cream on top. They also added an small fresh made doughnuts with dipping sauces (spicy chocolate and strawberry....so delicious) to the desert menu the spicy chocolate Love the patio seating with the fireplace, really fun vibe on a warm evening! The brunch menu is outstanding, so many delicious options and they have a pancake of the week that is always creative and tasty. Our favorites are the caprese Benedict and the chicken and waffles! read more

We tried this new place based upon some positive reviews and can't wait to come back. My wife and I got a great outdoor table right away and James our waiter really helped to make sure we picked some great items. Started with the coconut shrimp which was the right amount of spice and jumped into the house burger and also had the salmon. Had to finish it up with the monthly dessert. Great to see and experience a place like this without having to head down to Old Town. read more

See all

This places comes highly recommended, and I can see why! From the moment you enter the door, it has a calm, clean, welcoming atmosphere and staff. The menu has a lot of great looking options, and what we got did not disappoint! The flavors were delicious and unique. I love that they have a rotating menu too, so there is always more to come back and try. We got lucky that now is peach season, as I loved my sandwich off of that seasonal menu! We definitely recommend this place, and can't wait to come back! read more

Simmer - Chicken and waffles, the not spicy version - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

See all

This is an update to my previous review. I stopped in to try the weekend breakfast brunch. Big mistake. The place was not super busy but had a few customers sitting at the tables and at the bar. Myserver was Willow. Willow was very sweet and friendly, but her service was greatly lacking. First off, I ordered a cocktail which once the bartender finally made it, sat at the bar with the ice melting while Willow never bothered to check on my drink. I had to ask another worker, looked to possibly be a manager, if they could check on my drink since Willow was not going to do it. The manager soon brought me my drink that had been sitting at the window. When I ordered a second drink, I too had to wait for this drink while I watched it once again sit at the bar without anyone bothering to deliver the drink. Willow did not once check to see if my drink had been made let alone delivered to me. Willow never even noticed that I had gotten my drink. The bartender needs to pay better attention to the drinks that they make and ensure they don't sit at the window for too long. No one wants a drink that is watered down from melted ice. Both the bartender and the service need to get their act together. Service was just terrible. Interesting to note, but later that same day, I saw the manager that had to get my drink sitting at another restaurant having a drink. Why not drink where you work? Service was that bad. As far as the food goes, it was just OK. I ordered a breakfast burrito and asked for extra bacon rather than having sausage as well. Willow told me that would be OK however, I'm not sure there really was any bacon in it as I couldn't find any. I did not say anything because the service was so bad I figured that to correct it would take all day nor did I want to deal with it. By this time, I was done. The menu states the breakfast burrito is spicy when it is NOT spicy at all. In fact, it lacked seasonings and flavor. Also, there was barely any green chili not that it mattered because the green chili really needs work as it is pretty flavorless. The Bacon Benedict tasted OK but the portion size is way too small for the price. It's not something we'd order again. The breakfast potatoes suck too. Fingerling potatoes and sweet potatoes mixed together are NOT breakfast potatoes. The potatoes lack any seasonings and would be better if made with onions and some green and red peppers. They just weren't that good. Between the horrible service and the mediocre food, I won't ever go back for brunch nor will I recommend this place for brunch. You get better service and brunch food at The Back Porch, Arise, The Blind Pig, or Snooze AM. We've dined here many times for dinner and have never had bad service or food. To say this was disappointing is putting it mildly. read more

Their new peach menu is incredible. Great place to meet for lunch with your girlfriend and sit outside on the patio. Great service!

Simmer is one of our favorite spots every few months. We love the seasonal changes in the menu.

The one star is deserved only for the ambiance, we really enjoyed the relief of a calm place where we could hear each other talk. But maybe that was because we were some of the only people in on a Saturday night. The first weird thing was that when we walked in we were asked if we had a reservation (which we did because I had read to do so in other reviews), however there were at least 20 empty tables inside and out at 8pm. All of the food fell flat, and we ended up leaving and having to find something else for dinner after spending close to $40, even after the most expensive item was taken off our bill. Lamb meatballs: ridiculously tiny, literally quarter sized diameter, sauce could have been richer, but overall ok. Bacon and Brussels: we love this dish normally and were really turned off by the sweetness. Not sure if it was natural juices from the apple or if they add apple juice but I wish I had ordered without the apples. Sweet potato goat cheese dip: loved this one, no complaints here. Steak tips in gorgonzola fondue: this one really ruined it for us. Waitress asked if we wanted pink or no pink. It came out in the tiniest little slices, completely overcooked. Waitress noticed and offered to try again. The replacement dish was literally raw. You would think after having to replace a dish we would be checked on promptly, but no. We sat there wanting to leave for over 20 minutes starting at raw steak. The prices are too high for the portions, and the flavors just don't hit the mark. The menu has so much potential but we think the chef needs to go. Will not try again. read more

Simmer - First try was completely overcooked, this was the replacement. We were given the option of pink or no pink... - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Such a fantastic experience!! We had the Buffalo Cauliflower appetizer & it was perfectly spicy and so flavorful. My husband had the Simmer Down Burger and said it was the best he's had in a long time. I had the Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich & it was amazing. It was indeed hot/spicy but not super overpowering. We highly recommend this restaurant! read more

The place was relatively nice, but the prices are insane for the food quality. I would say that the brea quesadilla was worth it, but my husbands $26 short rib was not worth it, very bland. It ended up being $65 for the two of us and I ordered off the kids menu. Service was nice though, moved it from a two star to a three. read more

Simmer - Brea quesadilla - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

I'd like to know which company handled their marketing postcards because the photos sold me real good. Overall, it was good but a little pricey. The bacon wrapped dates were pretty delicious, but way over priced for 5 pieces that were the size of my thumb print. $17 peach burger... Good? Sure. Worth the price? No. Glad I tried it. Wouldn't go back. Please send me the contact for the marketing company that was used. read more

Place has gone downhill. Last 2 times food has been barely edible and the service unpleasant. Used to be a go to, now a no go...

My friend told me to come here and now Simmer is our go to scratch kitchen. I really like the atmosphere, the foods, and the art. I was skeptical of making the trip to Fort Collins, but Faith was right on the money. This place is worth it. Because of Faiths recommendation I had an amazing experience will definitely come back!! read more

So, I have a lot of food inconveniences... due to a bladder disease. I love simmer because of their unique food offerings and the attention the staff pays to my specifications. So we order spinach dip which comes with bread and veggies. Knowing the menu as I did, I asked if we could have some gluten free bed for me for the dip. I could tell this wasn't a usual request, however my waitress was so accommodating and incredibly attentive. There were definitely some kitchen staff walking past our table several times to observe me. I think it's just easier to ask about the severity of my gluten intolerance instead of having several men walk past your table, but I'm used to it. I have a chronic bladder pain disease which affects my diet greatly so it's nice when people ask what the issue is instead of having people do laps and making assumptions. However! Our waitress and the staff that day were beyond accommodating; providing me with gluten free bread for the dips and even making me a second entree after I failed to see the "chili oil" on my dish description. It was 100% my fault for not seeing that and our waitress insisted on us not paying for the entree I couldn't eat and ordered us a new one free of charge, sans chili oil. I am beyond grateful for the non judgmental and completely gracious service we received. We loved Simmer before and love it even more now. Thank you so much to the staff and we will be back. I'll look more closely at the menu next time! Great spot, great food, great wine! read more

The best of the best. Hidden in plain sight. The entire staff is friendly and beautiful inside and out. The food is next level. Bison that's falling off the bones. Bacon wrapped dates. Jerk chicken as big as your leg. I've never been more impressed. Go now, you'll never regret it. read more

What is going on here???? Every plate from the coconut shrimp, The bacon wrapped devils on horseback, the squash, the cheese sandwich and the amazing Sauvignon Blanc is heavenly perfection. Where have I been all my life? Great service, clean and friendly - omg. I wish I was hungry again so I could order more! Bring friends. It's more than worth it. read more

Simmer - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

See all

Was a better menu and food last year overpriced and underwhelming . The table next to us was so loud and rude the birthday dinner was ruined who knew that four people could make so much noise that somebody's teenage birthday would be ruined read more

Food was delicious! My husband got the black and blue burger and it was really tasty. Loved the wedge salad, and the drinks were great. We had the chocolate mousse for dessert, so good! My favorite part of the dinner was how attentive and friendly the staff was...highly recommend!! read more

I'm new to Yelp and I honestly started an account so I could say how great my experience was today. I have been to Simmer before and wanted my mom to try is so we came in for lunch. Anastasia was our server and she was just delightful. Friendly and helpful. As wonderful as she was, I have to say the food was the real star of the show. We started with the Patatas Bravas (a dish I order whenever I see it on a menu) and they were absolutely delicious. Crispy, slightly spicy, mmmm. Mom ordered the burger from the seasonal peach menu and I had the Jalapeno Bacon Burger. Holy $#!t This is now my favorite burger in Fort Collins. The patty itself was juicy and cooked a perfect medium. The bacon was not the usual baked in a batch and left to die variety but rather crisp and chewy. The spice level was spot on, the cilantro chimichurri was bright and herbaceous. Just a truly outstanding burger. I can't wait to come back and try the Poblano Cream Pasta. This spot should be full for lunch every day with this quality. read more

Honestly was majorly disappointed by the food. I got the Steak Diane which was extremely underwhelming. The steak was over cooked and although it had some flavor there is no way the seasoned home cook would have over cooked it like this was. Overwhelming majority of the pieces were a pain in the jaw. This is the first Yelp review I have ever written because I had to make sure and voice that paying $27 for this dish was extremely aggravating. Additionally the seasonal greens just included about 5 small pieces of asparagus with some grated Parmesan and it felt almost insulting with again, the $27 price tag. Calamari appetizer was chewy and the fried outer layer would just come off with the first bite so it would be like a bit of bread followed by chewy squid. Mashed potatoes and the Diane sauce were delicious. Really the stars of the plate which was sad in a steak dish. I came to Simmer purely because of the awesome reviews but after that meal I have to imagine something was awry in the kitchen or this place is really not what it's supposed to be. read more

This was delicious and we will definitely be back. Great service by Emily, looked like the owner was helping to run meals (?), and our burgers were tasty. We had the angus burgers with mashed potatoes and that popper mashers side (brilliant!), a tomato bisque soup (perfection), and a hot drink. The sides were plentiful and the potatoes were clearly made on site. Arugula was fresh (I hate soggy lettuce bits). Service was ideal. They have a heated open patio (chilly but with a very cool cold weather discount!!), and an enclosed patio (looked warm but goes fast in this Covid restriction era). We are about safety right now, so we chose the colder patio spot (Winter/Pandemic). Maybe I would salt the mashed potatoes a little less, if I'm being picky, but no question we will be back. Please stay here, Simmer! read more

This restaurant truly aced every element. First off, the service was stellar. The wait staff and the bar staff were pleasant, kind, and genuine. All the food we had was unique and tasted delicious. I highly suggest the cauliflower wings or stuffed peppers. But go soon to try those! I hear they have a rotating menu. As well, the cocktails were amazing, and reasonably priced. Overall, I recommend this restaurant, and definitely plan to go back. read more

I came here for my husband's birthday, and our entire family could not be more than satisfied. They have all Covid precautions in place and are operating under the strictest sanitation and social distancing guidelines. Our waiter/bartender Kyle was amazing. They make all their food from scratch, everything from the sweet potato fries (that I usually don't like) to their cheesesteak and burgers were to die for. I am from out of state, coming in from Miami and New York, and the fresh-to-order food at this restaurant elevates cuisine to a whole other level. I am so happy that I made this choice in restaurant, and I feel bad that I couldn't take a second to take a picture of the delicious food. I will definitely be back soon when I'm in town, and it's worth the trip if you aren't ! read more

My daughter and I tried this place last night. It looks like it recently opened. One of the wait staff mentioned having just finalized the menu. The interior is open and inviting. I found my chair to be very low. I'm 6'4" and I almost needed to do a full squat to sit down. Our waitress was friendly and informative. We were visited by several servers and an assistant manager. All made us feel welcome. I will say the attentiveness could have been better, but to their defense, they got super busy super fast right after we got there at 5pm. We ordered bacon wrapped dates and zucchini strings with taziki sauce. Both were awesome and come highly recommended. For our main course, my daughter got the caprese grilled cheese. She loved it. I got the hot Nashville chicken sandwich. It was spicy but not overboard. Great bun, sour pickles and slaw. Now for the coke slaw. I will preface by saying I love slaw and order it whenever I can. I come from New England where slaw is a big deal with seafood. This coleslaw was one of the best if not the best I've ever had. There was a secret ingredient that made it special and wow it was amazing. Check them out. Simmer is worth a visit or two. read more

We really like Simmer! We like the vibe, the art, the outside patio and especially the food! We were told it was hamburger month. Who knew there was such a thing? I ordered the special hamburger created for this month. It was named Bacon and Brie burger, but what they didn't tell you was that it also had red wine glazed onions. It was juicy ordered medium, and might be one of the best burgers I've ever had. I ordered the side salad instead of other choices, but the handful of lettuce with some carrot medallions, cucumber rinds and 1/2 cherry tomatoes didn't seem special at all. After one bite of the hamburger, I couldn't have cared less about the salad. Both of my dinner partners ordered the Simmer burger which consisted of lamb, beef, and bacon mixed. Both of them thought it was excellent. The music is loud, but good to listen to. A very good scratch kitchen that we are happy to return to soon. read more

See all

So delicious. Everything was so fun, not a boring menu at all. And the food totally delivered. We really enjoyed everything we had, especially the bison short ribs, and will be back again and again! read more

What a great place. Up for the weekend to visit our kids. The food and service were both outstanding. Our server Tyler was great and the manager Brian also stopped by to introduce himself. 5 stars all around. read more

Went to Simmer for my birthday dinner. We had small plates, the muscles, devil's on horseback, apple salad. All really good, especially the devils on horseback, so decadent. It took us a long time to try Simmer because every time we tried it was so crowded! It was worth the wait. Such a nice place with good, original food in Midtown. The service was great, really nice people. Love the atmosphere, the friendly, inviting vibe. I will definitely go back, and most likely during the week when it's a more casual pace. read more

Amazing restaurant!! I found this little hidden restaurant today and stopped in for lunch and was absolutely blown away. Food was delicious, drinks were refreshing, and our server was so sweet and really efficient!! Definitely will be coming back! read more

Great food for a special night out. Reservations are recommended. Cocktails are not just your regular old fare.

Excellent meal! Are off their seasonal peach menu. Peach sangria was strong but tasty. The bartenders here are friendly and competent. I've eaten here a half a dozen times and enjoyed each meal. Today I had the halibut with peach pico on a bed of wild rice and green beans. The greens were were lightly sautéed, crisp and sweet. The rice was light and fluffy but full of flavor. The pico was fruity, not too sweet, not spicy. The fish was blackened, fresh and delightful. Sometimes halibut can be dry if not cooked properly, but this one was tender without dryness, but fully cooked. read more

The food and service has always been great. For some people it can be on the pricey end but to me it is worth it. I don't eat there often but it is nice for sure. read more

I always have a great experience when I come into Simmer. My recent visit was beyond expectations! Emily G. was my server and she did amazing! Very helpful staff and would recommend to any of my friends or family. A great lunch or dinner spot in Fort Collins! read more

The service was excellent, and food delicious! They seem to go above and beyond in service and food!

Decided to try Simmer since we love their other place called Rally 5 off Harmony Rd. Simmer was fantastic. What a great menu! My friend loved the beet salad and I had a chicken/brie sandwich that was so creative and tasty. They use Red Bird Farms chicken and you can taste the difference - it's what chicken used to taste like. :) Also, have to mention our waiter, the world's most polite young man, Cam R. We will go back for sure. read more

We....love...this...place!!! By far our favorite place to brunch. Our server, Dustin, was exceptionally professional and kind from start to finish. The menu has something for everyone, and our food was prepared perfectly. We love all the choices from the Bloody Mary bar. Do yourself a favor and take your family and friends here as soon as you can. A hidden secret from Old Town :-) -cheers read more

Two years ago, this restaurant was great. Unbelievable food. Good service. But something changed. Management? I've stopped going and, when friends suggest it, I change their minds. The food is only ok now. The service is annoying. They interrupt your conversations to ask if you want more water. Just fill them up. Don't interrupt my date. One time I was with a group of 10 people. We couldn't get the server to refill our teas. We must have asked five times. Finally I got the tea pitcher from the server station and filled them up for everyone. Someone needs to train their servers properly. read more

My boyfriend and I were looking for a new date night spot... After tons of browsing online we decided to give this place a try. Our server Maddie was so friendly, fun, and helpful with wonderful recommendations. We got the cauliflower hot wings and ricotta caprese to start, then I got a caprese baguette and my boyfriend had the bison short ribs. The ribs were fall-off-the-bone tender and full of flavor. The baguette was light, refreshing, and delightful. We especially loved the cauliflower wings. Every single bite was utterly delicious. It was also spotlessly clean and the decor and ambience are excellent with a great drink menu. It's safe to say Simmer is going to be our go-to date night spot going forward. read more

It was okay for FC. Service was good, prices were a little high. My biggest gripe is that they advertise a 16-ounce craft beer in their menu, but then produce a 12-ounce can at the table. I missed it. Not as outstanding as it could be. read more

Stopped in because I saw the yelp notification that there was a new restaurant nearby, happy I did. Food: I only tried two small plates. I got the bacon wrapped figs and the Brussels and bacon. Both were fantastic. Drinks: good recommendations, was satisfied with the cocktail especially for the price. Service: server was very friendly and always approached with a smile, other staff was also equally attentive. My water glass was never empty which is something I usually gauge service off of. Overall I'd go again and would be confident my experience would be equally enjoyable. read more

The best dinner I have had in Ft Collins to date. Can we just take a second to appreciate the menu they have put together? Seriously some awesome talent that my wife and I are super happy to have found. Personal favorites are the Simmer Down burger and their AMAZING flourless chocolate cake. Their range of unique and truly special drinks cannot be forgotten about. Already planning another date night here soon! Make sure to place a reservation for weekend nights as they are a hot spot. Thank you Simmer for bringing another delicious restaurant to Ft Collins read more