AMAZING PIZZA! & great service. If you need a great spot to chill and grab a perfect slice of pie..- this is the place! Try the Boca Grande Origional. So good. read more

Sisters Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Boca Grande, Florida

Every place has a place for pizza. And Boca Grande is no exception. So, heading over for dinner it was worth the stop. Got there at 530pm. By 630pm it was packed with a line out the door. It is a local place with a good team. We ordered the pizzas and some salads.Also some pasta of course. It was all good. The sauce is ideal. The portion is perfect. The pizza was a good size with 8 slices. In the end, it all comes down to how you like the pizza. It is a very thin crust, More like a matzah bread crust. Very thin and covered with cheese. Being from NYC we like a thicker crust, and if you were from Chicago this is way too thin. So it is up to what you really think on this. To be honest, a left over slice the next day was not bad. You could cut it up and use as cheese and crackers with a glass of wine. That will work. In the end, it is not a bad place to be for the slice and a coke. It is a typical local Italian place at a price you can afford. Ciao! read more

Three of us had dinner here on a Saturday night. We were seated right away. College football was on multiple tv's which made us happy. We had friendly interactions right away. We had salad. Pizza and eggplant Parmesan. All was delicious! The house salad was pretty simple. One tomato wedge, 2 slices of cucumber and a little red onion. The eggplant Parmesan was so good with a side of thin spaghetti and sauce. I had a few bites of the Boca Grande pizza. It was phenomenal! This restaurant has a local feel with friendly service. We will visit again. read more

See all

Loved eating on the patio with my husband and baby. Waitress was super sweet and attentive. My husband got grouper fingers and they were delicious. I got a grouper wrap blackened-- also delicious. I love the home made chips too! Perfect place for lunch on a beautiful day. read more

Sisters Italian restaurant in Boca Grande is a rare find. A family run restaurant featuring great Italian and American favorites. They have an awesome meatball poboy and club sandwich. JX was our server and gave us excellent service as well as area information. We will back next time in the area. A great restaurant! read more

Wonderful service best pizza I have ever had they are so kind there just a great place for kids can bring you're pets for outside eating

Delicious food and friendly people. Sandwiches are always fresh and tasty and the pizza is great. It's not fancy, but we make it a habit to have lunch or dinner there every time we go to Boca Grande. read more

Love Sister's!! Their pizza, pasta, salads, it's all terrific, never ever have. I had a bad meal after they opened it 20+ years ago.! The sisters were really young men and they're still young and even cuter Five star in my book read more

The food is amazing! We were here 3 times this week. I suggest the meat calzone add mushrooms. Salads were fresh. The wait staff was impeccable every time. The seating outside was perfect for the experience during vacation. read more

Sisters Restaurant - Calzone - Italian Near Me - Boca Grande, Florida

Good service, great food, and great price. Philly cheese steak was delicious! Sat outside for the views and weather. read more

Sisters Restaurant - Philly cheese steak - Italian Near Me - Boca Grande, Florida

Great food Great Customer service didn't take too long outdoor seating was nice. 5 stars

We have not reservation but was seated with courtesy and promptness. The service from the entrance to the exit extremely familiar and professional. We heard about their lasagna and my husband and I, ordered the same. It was magnificent, plenty of meat, meat sauce and mozzarella cheese, The restaurant is located centrally and perfect for a beach environment. Do not expect Versaillais Palace, but is worth the visit for the food quality, service, care and location read more

Very happy to see this restaurant still around after many years. I love the casual atmosphere and good food! A true staple in the area. Our waitress was wonderful and attentive. Highly recommend Outdoor seating available read more

Service was very friendly. Our waitress was great. The food was okay. We started with mozzarella sticks and the batter was just weird. Definitely not a traditional breading. Something like tempura. Very oily. Wasn't great. For dinner My husband and I both ordered 2 different seafood pasta dishes and they were bland. We should've taken note that everyone around us was just eating pizza. The pasta was over cooked. The seafood wasn't great. If we try this place again we would definitely just order pizza. read more

Immediate seating and welcome. Efficient knowledgeable server(sister?) Gluten free pizza crust! Grouper sandwich, meat pizza, gf cheese pizza and the canzone were all excellent. Unexpectedly good food opinion shared by party of 4. II7i799 by read more

MUST VISIT when in the area. I judged this place by the outside but quickly learned not to make such a hasty judgemental. Customer service was a little rocky at first, but came through with flying colors in the end. We came here 2/3 days. Chicken Picatta was delightful, the calzones tasted super fresh with just an unbelievable texture to the outside. The jalapeño poppers were home made and very very good. I did enjoy the pizza even though it was not my favorite style. Highly recommend this place, everything is fresh and worth the wait. Enjoy! read more

Stopped for lunch with my family and was not disappointed. Both the food and the service were great! read more

Sisters Restaurant - Wings - Italian Near Me - Boca Grande, Florida

See all

Solid choice for the Greek salad...pizza is ok but dough isnt made in house which is reflected in the fact the center doesn't cook thru.

Quaint little restaurant in Boca Grande. Husband ordered their pizza; it wasn't his favorite. I enjoyed a grilled chicken salad and enjoyed it. This was a mid afternoon meal. I would return to try out their Dinner menu. read more

really great food - the place is small and it was packed on a saturday night, but they were able to accommodate our group of 6 and the food was outstanding - good service and good prices too Recommend the pizza and the ravioli read more

Tables inside and outside- they take reservations. We did not have one but they got us in quick before the dinner rush. The waitress was very helpful and friendly. The chicken parm was EXCELLENT and we highly recommend it. The pizza was okay. read more

See all

menu says NEW YORK style pizza. being from NYC I can assure you it's NOTHING more than a little tomato and less cheese on toast. service and hostess were a delight but food not much to write home about. wine and beer r offered at a price. a surcharge if paying w card and if u share a dish $5. many other places on island to explore. will not be back to this one read more

Sisters Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Boca Grande, Florida

See all

Very mediocre and slightly gross food. The server was not attentive and ignored my friend's allergy. The ambiance was okay, it was a nice day out and we were able to enjoy the weather but the food was unpleasant and the servers were just so rude. A restaurant should take an allergy seriously... temptations is better read more

This is such a delightful restaurant we stumbled upon after photos at the nearby lighthouse. It's small but mighty and had enough space and patience for our large family. The bread and pesto appetizer is 100% delicious, even my picky eaters ate this and I wanted more but we were having pizza! The pizza and price did not disappoint and I've been craving their food since we left. Definitely stop here if you're nearby! Plus the service was great and friendly to our kids! read more

Sisters! Wow! Great food. Fun outdoor atmosphere. Deck dining with umbrellas for shade. Indoor atmosphere seems old school and clique-would recommend seating outside. Menu has great Italian fare offerings. Lots of apps, salads and entrees. Our server Jax was amazing!! It was a busy Saturday. Takeout was happening and all tables were full! We were a large party and he more than accommodated all of our requests, he was generous, helpful and happy. The other servers and hostesses we encountered looked miserable and acted so- we were so pleased to have Jax! Calzone, pizza, tuna salad, Cesar salad, chicken Parmesan, all tasted great! The dipping oil is very tasty to accompany the bread prior to the meal. Would definitely come back here next time we are in Boca Grande read more

Pizza is huge with great price ! Clams soup with shell plate make food looks so yummy and very fresh ! Nice weather sitting outside feel really comfortable & relax ! Will recommend everyone to try it ! read more

See all

Dog friendly. Food was hot and good Outside seating. Waitress was attentive. Would return.

Good pizza and Lasagna! Pleasant service, nice place to eat, we go every 2 weeks,would recommend it to anyone that likes those things

Called for reservation. They put us on the waitlist and said to be there between 7 and 7:15. We showed up at 7 and they told us basically too bad - "we let people sit ahead of you or you can wait an hour." They were rude and flippant about the situation. We will never darken their door again. Not worth my business. read more

Stopped in with a batch of 9 lads (HS crew team in town to compete nearby for the national championship) and they wolfed down 5 large pizzas with gusto. We sat out on the front deck in comfy chairs under shade umbrellas, were taken care of promptly, and drinks were refilled when needed. Everything was tasty and fine. Reasonably priced to boot! Stop in and give Sisters a try! read more

Everything was great there. The food was great, the service was great, the atmosphere was great!

Fast service and very close to the beach. Offered gluten free pizza and pasta, The hamburger was good and the grouper wrap was stuffed with fresh fish and a slightly sweet sauce, delicious read more

Sisters Restaurant - Grouper wrap - Italian Near Me - Boca Grande, Florida

Excellent food.. fresh and delicious. Every time we go to the island we have to stop here to eat. We've even called in an order and left the beach to go pick it up and then have a picnic on the beach. Love everything we've ever eaten there - the grouper wrap, anti pasta salad, Italian sandwich, and meatball sub read more

Hands down our favorite restaurant on Boca! We ended up having dinner here three nights last week... the winners... the lobster pastas and the shrimp scampi. And you really can't go wrong w/ their pizza - crisp, nice topping distribution, hot! But the absolute Star over every meal is the darn bread and dipping oil... pure magic! One night we got curious about dessert and our super sweet waitress said we shouldn't get our hope up cause their choices are limited to "small cakes." Well we bit and had the BEST little cakes ever - moist and perfectly portioned for one. Loved them! Thank you for being a consistently strong restaurant! read more

Sisters Restaurant - Red Velvet - Italian Near Me - Boca Grande, Florida

See all

Small little spot on Boca Grande. Went for lunch. Sat outside. Really good thin crust pizza. Vegan friendly. 3 seats at indoor bar. Island vibe. Easy, low key, owned by a couple that moved down 30 years ago from upstate NY. read more

Great Italian food. Family owned by the sweetest sisters. always fantastic meals large portions. You can't go wrong eating here. I'm a NY'er so it takes a LOT for me to rate Italian food this high. 5 stars all the way! read more

Sisters was very good. Their menu looked great, but we only were able to try some salads and pizza. Staff was friendly and service was fair for how busy they were. They take alot of reservations so busy times of year you may want make one if you have a large party or want to sit outside. The side salads were a Good size and the pizza was tastey. Better then average. I would go back again and eat there for sure. read more

See all

We have enjoyed several dinners at Sisters and the staff could not have been more accommodating the four of us. The food was delicious and came out hot. Our server both times was Jules and she was so friendly and professional, she took excellent care of us. Thank you Sisters and Jules two very memorable evenings! Chris and Susanne from VT read more

Best pizza - love the Boca Grande deluxe. The olive oil for bread dipping is so good and the Caesar salad rocks. Sit outside or in, both are great. read more

Always great - love seafood lasagna and pizza - accepts reservations. One of our "go to" spots on the island