We live in nearby Mesa but heard about the grand opening by way of Instagram. We made a point of getting there before 11 AM and were down the line near One Stop Nutrition. This was a spectacular grand opening in many ways. We got menus long before the doors opened. Megan brought us small bottles of Costco water - necessary on a warm AZ day. Everyone from the store and from corporate went above and beyond to make the event terrific. Once we got in, we were amazed by the feel, the decor, and we definitely knew we were in an Italian pizzeria. Fantastic with just enough artwork high on the walls. "Trust the Craft" on the ordering wall let you know it was a Tony Gemignani joint. We ordered a Combo Americano, 3 meatballs, and 2 Mango lemonades. We got to meet Tony himself, and he even signed our copy of his book. He was so nice and he thanked us for being there. Definitely our new favorite pizza place in AZ. Check it out - you won't be disappointed. read more

As a New Yorker myself, if you live anywhere in the east valley this is the best pizza here. I tried their location in LA and I'm glad they finally came to AZ. This will be my go to spot out here. Highly recommend if you want quality New York style pizza. read more

We have missed Tony's pizza so much! Moving here from San Francisco over 10 years ago, Tony's was a regular spot for us. I even have friends and former roommates who worked at his North Beach location, so there are a lot of great memories and good times connected to it. We've been waiting for this location to open, and it definitely did not disappoint We came in on a Thursday afternoon. It was busy, but we didn't have to wait long at all. There were lots of slices to choose from. They offer several slices daily, along with a daily Detroit-style special and a regular special. I ordered the Bucatini with meat sauce, and we also had the bacon and arugula salad, three cannolis dressed with sprinkles, pistachios, and chocolate chips, a slice of pepperoni, and a slice of chicken bacon ranch. Tony didn't disappoint, and neither did his staff. Everyone was welcoming and attentive. You can tell the staff enjoys their jobs, know the menu, and is treated very well. They already seem to have regulars, which says a lot. Prices are reasonable and the portions are great! The atmosphere is welcoming and inviting. Tony even held one of his regular contests that he does when opening a new location, where people submit designs for pizza boxes. At this location, an elementary school student from a local school was chosen as the winner The location is extremely clean, including the bathrooms. There is also outdoor seating available. Overall, it brought back a lot of great memories for us, and we're so happy to have a Slice House here now. We'll definitely be back! read more

See all

Yeppers there's a new Pizza place in town and after trying their slice of pepperoni and meatballs I can say with confidence I'll be back to try their other pies. The pizza crust was perfect for me and the sauce had a great flavor and combination of spices. Plenty of pepperoni and cheese in every bite. Service was great for such a busy place. Very attentive young people behind the counter and doing a great job keeping pace. Seating inside and out. This place will succeed unlike the last one trick pony pizza place read more

Slice House by Tony Gemignani - Those boxes go fast - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

See all

This is my new favorite pizza place in east valley hands down! They have so many options in styles of pizza and it all taste very high-quality. Our favorite was the motorhead, wise guy and sweet Gino. And the special I think it was pops? With chicken cutlets. So good!! we also got boneless wings that were really good. East Valley was lacking a good pizza spot and this is it if you're ever in Gilbert go check them out! read more

Slice House by Tony Gemignani - Motor head, papas - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

In all fairness, my husband and I are pizza aficionados, so our standards are quite high. But once I read the over the top, self promoting, Gemignani award winning this, and award winning that, we absolutely had to try this pizza. We got a loaded Sicilian, and a 20" cheese NY style --- $80 later Ugh Its not even as good as Little Caesars. Save your time and money, it's most definitely not worrh it. read more

I've been going to the original north beach SF restaurant for 13 years, and loved the slice house next door for convenience when the wait was hours long at the pizzeria. We just ate at the original slice house in November 4 times (it's my pilgrimage when in SF). So needless to say, I was ecstatic when I learned there was going to be a franchise right up the road. We were out there lined up opening day, and the speed and efficiency that they took with that many people was stunning. A well run concept, and the food is on par with the original. We've been back 3 times already, and the only small disappointment was trying the meatball sub, which while still good, needed a little more time in the oven to really melt the cheese and get a little color on the bread. But I've talked to the franchise owner, and he seems to genuinely want to make this the best it can be, and I told him I'm going to let him know if it slips. My highest recommendation. No longer do we have to endure mid tier pizza at Venezia's, or overpriced pies at Vito's in the area. Everything else is mere mortals, while Tony's Slice House sits on Olympus. read more

See all

I was super excited to try this place, but I have to say, probably one of the most disappointing experiences I've had in a while. When I got there the line was long, but not like when it opened, it was just to the inside of the door. When I got to the counter, I ordered 3 slices of the honey hot pepperoni pizza and 3 meatballs. When I ordered, they had a whole pie in the display. The meatballs came out in about 2 minutes, but I stood waiting for my pizza slices. Mind you, I didn't order a whole pie. After about 15 minutes I asked where my slices were and she said they're working on it. I waited another 20 minutes and someone finally came over and asked what my order was, probably because at this point I've been waiting almost 40 minutes for 3 slices of pizza and was getting irritated. Everyone else who ordered after me was getting their orders, but my buzzer never went off, maybe they forgot about me? Finally someone approached me and said they "oversold" the hot honey pepperoni pizza slices, like they were selling seats on Southwest Airlines. She asked if I wanted something else and I said no, how much longer? I was told 20 minutes. Absolute joke. I finally got my pizza slices and sadly they were not good. They were stacked two slices to a container, they were completely covered in grease and oil, soggy, and had zero taste of honey and zero taste of anything hot. I guess when you're just trying to pump out product to catch up, quality goes in the shitter. It was not pleasant. And because it took so long, the meatballs were cold. And the sauce they used for the meatballs looked and tasted like they just opened up a can of tomato paste and dumped it on. The whole thing was forgettable, and overpriced. I hope one day they get their crap together and find a way to actually serve some decent slices in a reasonable time. Mind you this wasn't even one of those busy days where the line was out the door. For now, this is a skip. read more

See all

Slice House is hands-down our favorite local pizza joint. We come here several times a month, and it never disappoints. The slices are absolutely massive, and our go-to choices are the classic cheese and pepperoni. Also tried one of the Detroit-style specials, and wow--it was thick, crispy, cheesy, and glorious. The edges had that perfect crunch while the inside stayed soft and satisfying. I also tried the cannoli and was pleasantly surprised. The shell was crisp and fresh, not soggy like I often find at cafes. It was a great way to finish the meal. If I had one minor complaint, it's that the pizza comes out incredibly hot. I got a little too eager and managed to burn the roof of my mouth. That's obviously my fault and not theirs, but consider it a warning to let your slice cool for a minute before diving in. Honestly, if I had a bottomless stomach and a bottomless wallet, I'd probably eat here every day. Great pizza, great variety, and consistently worth the visit. read more

I have been wanting to try this place since I first saw the sign that it was coming soon. We finally were able to make it happen. We could smell the delicious pizza smell as we walked through the parking lot and got even more excited. When we walked in, there was a line to order, people waiting for their food, and all the tables inside were taken. There is an outdoor area which would be nice when it's a little cooler. We had initially planned on ordering a pizza and eating it there but with how busy it was and the options for slices, we decided to order slices to go. There were 9 pizzas to select slices from and all looked really good. We decided on the Pop's Special, the Little Italy Detroit style, the Traditional Detroit style , and the Wiseguy. The hands down favorite was the Little Italy. The crust was delicious and all the flavors were amazing. I think what helped make the Little Italy was the extra sauce on top. The Pop's Special had Nashville hot chicken cutlets on it and we expected it to be somewhat spicy but it wasn't. It was more like Nashville mild chicken. The Traditional and the Wiseguy were okay but nothing special. Maybe it would have been better if we had ordered a full pizza and it was made fresh. This place is decent, but definitely not the best pizza I've had. If we had only tried the Little Italy, I would have given it 4-stars. The staff were all friendly and the restaurant was clean. We might give it another try and order a whole pizza so it's fresh. read more

See all

My new favorite pizza!!! We have tried so many different types of their pizza and all of them are amazing! Definitely recommend!!

Blahhhhh... wanted this place to be good but the pizza is just meh. Tasteless almost... idk how it's award winnng. Ugh, tried several different slices and NONE stood out. read more

See all

Have been dying to check this place out since I first saw stuff about it opening on Instagram. And wow it was worth the hype! Not much of a wait, we got there 11 am at open but there were already people there before us! We got a bunch of slices to try, the ones I tried were the tomato pie which was a NY style slice and a Sicilian one with mozzarella, tomato, and basil! I also drizzled with their spicy oil. My husband stuck with cheese and pepperoni, we got cheese for our 2 year old too! Slices were delivered to our table fast, and the people working there were really nice, I think the manager checked in with us. Was on the pricier side but to be fair we did order a whole lot of slices. I also like how they offer to do "kids cut" for slices making it easier to eat. Also the bathrooms were clean which is a total plus. Also like how they have a patio, would be perfect for a cooler day! Pizza was as good as it looked, can't complain! Would definitely come back again. read more

Slice House by Tony Gemignani - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

See all

As a former NYer. I salute you! You have my approval. The Best NY pizza I have found in AZ and probably on the west coast. The crust was that perfect crisp, foldable, delicious flavors. Definitely coming back here!! Job well done! The people giving this place a one star is so baffling. Either they lost their taste buds? Maybe came in on an off day or just wouldn't know good pizza if it hit them upside the head. Self claimed efficient autos comparing it to Little Caesars is lol. Aficionados don't eat at Little Caesars read more

This place is serious pizza. The crust is phenomenal and I can't wait to return. I am not a sausage person for pizza but it is so tasty definitely give it a try. We will be returning. There is a parking lot. read more

115 degrees in the desert of Gilbert AZ. I didn't think stopping by my local strip mall on the surface of the sun for Pizza, was a brilliant idea. Nevertheless, Slice proved me wrong. Great service and fantastic pie. Welcome to the neighborhood Tony and Friends. read more

Pizza snob here. Reallllllly good pizza. They only been open 6 weeks. I had the DRUNKEN ITALIAN with a nice light beer from the tap! I'm so into this omg. The carmalization of the crust on this Detroit style was YUMZZZZZ. Sauce was good. They have both NY style and Detroit (salivating). This is an order and sit down spot. I really enjoyed my little chat with the gal at the counter (sorry I don't know her name) but I like her take on life lol!!!! Even the gal throwin down the fresh Tomatoe Pie (I got a slice of that to go for my wife) was super cute and friendly. I wish I lived nearby but sadly not. I was not aware but they have a station w fresh parm, oregano, pepper oil and crushed red pepper by the fountain drinks! Any way. That pizza saved my day and the beer made my life a whole lot better. Thank you. read more

First time here and definitely not our last! All of the slices looked so good we decided to try most of them -- and wow, every single one delivered. Amazing crust and a flavor bomb in every pizza! The hot honey is an absolute must-order side. And if you get the pleasure of meeting Kaitlyn, she will definitely enhance your dining experience with her kindness, knowledge, and sweet, friendly personality. She checked on us multiple times and truly cared about our experience! We were completely stuffed but somehow still found room for a cookie... and it was the perfect sweet ending. Slice House definitely has a slice for everyone -- they truly stole a pizza my heart read more

Slice House by Tony Gemignani - Wise SIC Wiseguy, sic pops, SIC Pepperoni, GMA Sweet Gino, Lott - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

My household hunts for good Detroit style pizza wherever we live, which rotates every 4-8 years, and slice house is a decent option in the Valley. I tried Cali, Burrata, and Hot Honey for Detroits and a large NY pepperoni. They were good, although not reflecting 13 international pizza awards or whatever is heavily toted when you call, but good. Crust was too chewy but a couple minutes in the air fryer fixed that. Also, for the Cali, only 4 small slices of prosciutto for the whole pie. Things did not look at all like the award winning photos. We will try it again if other options fail to impress. read more

Oh my goodness....this was exactly what all the hype was about. The crust the cheese and time in the over was perfection

I thought this place would be over-hyped. but I was pleasantly surprised that the pizza was as good as the reviews! I tried 3 different slices: New York style Pepperoni, the Detroit style slice of the day which was the Little Italy, and a Grandma style Sweet Gino. My wife and I split the 3 slices and I was stuffed eating the equivalent of 1.5 slices. The NY style slice is huge! The pepperoni was good cup style pepperoni and the crust was great. The Detroit style Little Italy was excellent with also a very crispy crust edge and the topping combination was delicious. I loved all 3 but if I had to pick one of the three I would say the Grandma slice was surprisingly good. the crust is light but crispy and the Sweet Gino flavor was terrific. I am sure it would be even better if you ordered a whole pizza of any of these but the slices were pretty fresh and tasty. Unfortunately this place is really far from me or I would be back often. The dining area is small but there were at least 8 tables inside and some seating outside too (it's getting too hot now to be eating outside). The pizza came fast (it's all pre-cooked in the case unless you order a whole pie). Sorry no pictures because I was hungry today. :) read more

My first time here. For $9 out the door, I'd give it a 1 out of 10. Very crunchy and overcooked, tastes like it was yesterday's reheated more than once. Almost cracked a tooth. Couldn't even eat it. Very disappointing! read more

So many choices ! Pizza was delish and wish I woulda ordered my wings a little more crispy but overall food was good. It was grand opening weekend so it was busy. (Which is expected) despite it being busy the staff remained knowledgeable and very friendly. There are tables outside and minimal inside. Definitely will go back to try other things on their menu. read more

See all

Love this Pizza! Not your cookie cutter style pizza and two slices is all I can put down. Highly recommend giving it a try.

The pizza is good. I was expecting more from the hype this place has been getting. This is a fast food pizza place with cheese and red pepper in packets. If you want a quick slice it will suffice. read more

See all

The pizza is so crunchy and delicious. I love the original slice. Questionable on the amount of workers though. Theirs like two workers for every job. lol. I also like how they display children's artwork. My daughter's friends is shown. Very heartwarming! read more

The pizza was really good and the topping were very fresh. We got the large 20" New York Americano and it was huge! I slice completely covered our dinner plate. I gave it 4 stars only because we were not allowed to add extra cheese being advised because there were too many toppings already on the pizza and second because I did request extra sauce but there was actually very little on the pizza at all, even seemed like it would have been considered sparse. Next time maybe asking for sauce on the side would be a good alternative. Overall pretty good! read more

Slice House by Tony Gemignani - Large 20" New York Americano. - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

Customer derived is beyond horrible. The manager that works there has an attitude. She shouldn't be working with customers. Tons of other pizza shops for them to treat customers like that. I even spoke to corporate about this and nothing was done. Again, this place is a joke. Go to Sal's Gilbert Pizza if you want good customer service and an even better slice of pizza. This place ain't it read more

bomb pizza lots of options. Clean inside & staff is nice!!! Only downside they charge $4 for a teeny tiny side of pesto and 4/5 times now when I go for a take out / pickup order they forget my sides/dressings & I find out once I get home! read more

The pizza was delicious, I had the Barrata Queen (sp) it was the perfect mix of flavors and the crust was a thin , just like I like it . We sat outside and the ambiance and customer service was just plain fun . We will definitely be back!! read more

Opening day here at the Slice House was GREAT!! I don't care for pizza, but my husband was so excited to be one of the first 50 to try the Slice I decided to join him... and am SO HAPPY I DID!! We ordered New York style slices of Pop"s Special, Hot Honey, Tomato & The Wise Guy.... Each slice was packed with unique flavor, a crispy crunch to the crust, and tasty cheese!! The Wise Guy has dollops of GREAT ricotta, and the Honey Hot - is just something you have to try!!! I can't believe I'm saying I LOVE pizza - but here at Sice House it's true - iLOVE PIZZA!!! And my husband was SO enjoying it, that we went back again at end of day to get another slice of the Pop's House Special. The owner, management and service team (as well as the cooks in the kitchen) were still on their game after serving up slices non-stop for hours! I hope they are able to keep up the good work and passion for pizza for years to come!!! Thanks for opening my mind Slice House!!! Great experience & great food!!! read more

Slice House by Tony Gemignani - My husband says it's good when the pizza doesn't droop - means it's not all soggy!!! No drooping here!! Just lots of flavor!!! - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

Slice House absolutely nailed it. I ordered POP's Special and it was phenomenal--easily one of the best pizzas I've had in a while. The flavors were spot on, and you can tell they really care about the quality of what they're serving. The only downside is the seating. Indoor space is very limited, and with Arizona heat, sitting outside isn't always a great option. If you're planning to dine in, just be prepared for that. That said, the pizza alone makes it 100% worth the visit. I'll definitely be back read more

Slice House by Tony Gemignani - Pop's Special - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

I stopped in last Saturday, not busy at all so the wait wasn't an issue, friendly service for sure!! I bought 3 slices, the Detroit, Pepperoni/sausage & the hot honey. All 3 were pretty amazing!! The flavors were spot on as was the crust, all very different but delicious & generous slices. A little pricey but what isn't these days. I will definitely be back. read more

I've never been a huge pizza fan, I thought all pizza tasted the same UNTIL my boyfriend introduced me to Slice House. I first had it in San Francisco and it was a game changer. The sauce had flavor, the toppings tasted AMAZING and the crust was just perfect. I tend to like pineapple on pizza and Slice House's version is SO DELICIOUS that I can't have it anywhere else because it just doesn't measure up. I am SO HAPPY they've opened up a location in Arizona!!!! Went opening day and it tastes just like the pizza from SF! I've been there four times since they've opened, I love their pizza! Every time I've been there the wait has been about three to five minutes. HIGHLY recommend Slice House to anyone that even remotely likes pizza. read more

Slice House by Tony Gemignani - Detroit style Hawaiian pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

See all

Busy, busy, busy ran out of the pizza that I've been waiting for by the time I went there *Should be noted I went 3 different times the SAME DAY because they kept telling me to come back later and those 3 different times and they never had it* read more

Absolutely recommend the Wise-Guy. My favorite slice here. Lighter sauce, the hot oil adds a little spicy to it. The caprese salad was great with the large basil leaf. I was expecting something different for $15 but I'm glad I tried it. read more

Slice House by Tony Gemignani - Caprese salad - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

Stumbled upon this place after a visit to one stop nutrition Immediately greeted like I was family during their soft launch! The pizza was soo good with a perfect crunch and the kids cut was clutch read more

Slice House by Tony Gemignani - Picante slice - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

See all

Amazing pizza by the slice. Big pizza slices and the crust is perfect. Had the Wiseguy, fire! Traditional was also awesome with thick fluffy yet crunchy crust. Can't go wrong with the cheese pizza. Staff was amazing and quick. Fair prices totally worth it. Check it out! read more

Very busy and hectic. Should be a nicer experience once they've been open for a while and it's less crowded. read more

Slice House by Tony Gemignani - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

My wife and I stopped for dinner at about 8:00 pm. We ordered two slices of pizza and a salad to share. The pizza was good and was delivered to our table very promptly. We canceled the salad order about 15 minutes after finishing the pizza because it was not ready. Overall, good pizza but the operation didn't seem to run very efficiently. read more