I cannot say enough about how impressed I was with this bakery! From the knowledable staff to the quick responses to all of my questions and their patience, they created the perfect cake for my baby's first birthday. I will be back over and over again. Not only was the cake magnificently beautiful, it was also delicious. I was able to get two different flavors for the tiers as well. One flavor was chocolate with salted caramel and the other was vanilla with chocolate mousse. My guests kept coming back for more. The cake shop is small and located in a shopping center 5 minutes from my house. It's decorated with their beautiful cakes and they sell some desserts as well as create custom. When I picked up the cake, they even went out of their way to teach me how to properly transport it as well as cut it. I will be running back read more

See all

We ordered a two tier cake for my baby shower, and six gluten free cupcakes. I had a very specific vision, dripping pink icing and fake flowers cascading down the cake and some pink cupcakes with little ghosts. Sweet Karma made a beautiful cake and cupcakes beyond what I expected! And to top it off it was delicious. All the guests ranted about how good it was. Delivery was also fantastic, on time and very helpful. Thank you so much. read more

Sweet Karma Desserts - Desserts Near Me - Plainview, New York

See all

I ordered a Too Good to Go bag from Seert Karma the other week, and was happy with the variety of items my family was able to try. When entering the bakery, you get to see all of the decorated cakes on the counters and shelves. These were pretty cool to see up close. When waiting for the bag, the owner came. He was really nice and seemed genuinely excited about the items in his shop. The desserts we tried were great. The doughnuts and cookies were soft, the cake pops were tasty, and the rainbow cookie croissant was an extra bonus! read more

See all

Very sweet things at sweet Karma in Plainview NY in a shopping center off of Manetto Hill Road. They have a s'more like cake and the marshmallows on top are toasted caramelized brown. It has really good chocolate and consistency. I thought I'd asked for one white cupcake but I got a chocolate one. Though the server did look and repeat my order. So I must have been so taken with the Chocolate that I'd chosen that one. I didn't see too many things with whip cream most were buttercream . Donuts , cupcakes and more. I'll have to go and try some others at another visit. read more

See all

Delicious cakes and cookies. Such an array of choices. Clean and bright displays. Nice people work there.

My complements to Amanda & Ryan ..they were very helpful, friendly and patient, the doughnuts were absolutely delicious, fresh and soft, we loved the crème brûlée, s'mores , cannoli were great, and we were impressed with the incredible Dubai chocolate, with pistachio & kandaif , creamy melts in your mouth , they also have a gluten free availability, they were recognized by Long Island Best, and they deserved the accolades ...also try the Lemon, meringue, and strawberry shortcake read more

See all

There was mold in the domes and the cupcakes. Both were stale. The cupcakes were hard as a rock and actual mold at the bottom. The domes had mold under the frosting. This is not what I wanted to give my friend to celebrate her birthday. She had to make herself throw up after realizing she ate mold! Just awful! read more

Sweet Karma Desserts - Mold! - Desserts Near Me - Plainview, New York

I had two events to go to in one day so i ordered a variety of items (14!) and got to taste about half of their inventory. I have to say their pop tarts are out of this world! Go for blueberry and then strawberry. I saw it on instagram and was so excited to try it. The macaroons are amazing, the churro flavor stole the show i wish i ordered more of them. All of their little cakes (apple, pecan, banana cream) were just fantastic. The cupcakes were great and not too overwhelming, i appreciated the jelly touch in the center of the rainbow cookie cupcake. 10/10 this is a very sweet and cute mom and pop shop in plainview that cares about their work. read more

Sweet Karma has DELICIOUS gluten free options! I have tried their gluten free cookies - sugar cookies + chocolate chip options, donuts and cupcakes and they are exquisite! Highly recommend Sweet Karma for your gluten & gluten free sweet delights! read more

Sweet Karma Desserts - Desserts Near Me - Plainview, New York

See all

My mother in law ordered my baby shower cake from Sweet Karma, based on the online reviews (we had never tried any of their food before!). Fortunately they did a great job. Their decorating skills are quite clearly top notch, as seen by the photo of my cake. They also did a great flavor wise making a gluten free vanilla cake with strawberry frosting. My mother in law picked it up the day before the shower and it still tasted fresh. All the cake was eaten before the end of the party, so I know even my gluten eating guests enjoy it. My husband took home the fondant bear from the top to snack on and I have to say, it's delicious. I am very impressed with their work and would return for other special event desserts. read more

Sweet Karma Desserts - Gluten free cake - Desserts Near Me - Plainview, New York

Adela K. Sweet Karma is an amazing bakery located on Manetto Hill Rd. in Plainview New York. Brian, his wife and his incredible staff are wonderful to deal with. They have been making custom cakes for my family for the past 6 years. Each cake is amazing. They are beautiful to look at and are just as good to eat. They are truly works of art. My grandchildren can't wait to see what amazing cakes they come up with and their friends only want to know where these cakes are from. Their everyday items are delicious as well. I have recommended many people to Sweet Karma and everyone has loved dealing with them. read more

Sweet Karma you did it again! Absolutely nailed my sisters's 40th birthday cake. Sweet Karma's team makes the ordering process easy and seamless from start to finish. They take pride in their work and it shows through their process, customer service and finished products. Can't thank you enough for sharing another important milestone with me and my family. read more

See all

So fresh and delicious. Stopped in late afternoon before closing, too! Worth every bite. read more

Sweet Karma Desserts - Boston cream, jelly, and Nutella tart... so fresh. Tart dough was perfectly flaky, cream wasn't too sweet, and jelly was well-filled 3 - Desserts Near Me - Plainview, New York

This cake was made by Brain the owner of Sweet Karma located in Plainview. He is the most talented cake decorator I've ever seen. I get all my decorative cakes from him read more

Sweet Karma Desserts - Desserts Near Me - Plainview, New York

Ordered on Door Dash for a neighbor and was very disappointed by how the item was delivered (see photo). The pie was not in a bag and was just left in the box on the floor. During this time where we are supposed to be extra careful, it's a little surprising that this would be sent without a bag. A loose box could attract bugs etc. - just odd. As for the the pie, I didn't get the report back from them yet but the bakery seems good from the other reviews - just be wary if you are getting delivery! Maybe it's door dash's fault but all items should be sent properly sealed and in a bag with a safety seal during these covid times! UPDATE: My neighbor said the pecan pie was delicious! So go to the bakery - just don't get delivery! read more

Sweet Karma Desserts - Door dash delivery left a pie in a box right on the floor, no bag! - Desserts Near Me - Plainview, New York

Everything they do is just wonderful. So accommodating. Love the cannoli filled rainbow cookies.

I LOVE desserts and I'm always craving for something sweet. I actually found this bakery when I searched for "dessert delivery". I mean what's better than having dessert delivered to you when you are at work? When I saw they had rainbow cookie cupcakes, I just KNEW I had hit the jackpot. They have quite a selection of cupcakes, donuts, cookies, whole cakes... you name it! They even have gluten free and vegan options, which is wonderful b/c we need more GF and vegan options when it comes to desserts. The one thing I was concerned about was the packaging. I was ordering through doordash, and I know the drivers aren't going to handle my cupcakes with the gentleness I would. Desserts don't usually travel well and what a waste of a cupcake if I can't take a picture and show it off. When I received my order however, I was pleasantly surprised. Sweet Karma has the best packaging for cupcakes ~ see my photos. Each cupcake was put in a cupcake holder type of container. That way, they don't move and 1/2 the icing isn't ruined. The same with their donuts. Definitely a plus here! I never been to the actual store so I can't speak on their customer service but I'll definitely make it there one day. Everything I ordered from them was delicious, no complaints at all (except all the extra calories). I think a cupcake is definitely worth the extra 20 minutes on the Peloton! read more

See all

Omg!!! The macaroons are to die for!!! Delicious this place is definitely in rotation

Ordered a red velvet number cake. It was very soft and fresh which is the most important to me! It was very also very pretty. Highly recommend to come here. read more

Was looking for a special place that could do exactly what I wanted. Friendly staff, last minute order and they were able to accommodate my request and came up with a fantastic cake- an exact copy of a cake that I sent them if not better. Red velvet sponge was perfectly layered and had good flavor, the only thing I did not like was the icing on the outside, I might just choose something else next time, but it was not really a big deal. I also grabbed some delicious hot cocoa bombs with caramel and marshmallow. Very pleased! read more

Sweet Karma Desserts - Red velvet galaxy cake - Desserts Near Me - Plainview, New York

Maybe this place is great for wedding cakes but we came here after hearing about the rainbow cookie cupcake and were left a bit disappointed. The staff did explain those ran out quick after a recent Facebook post and that's A-OK! So we decided to instead get a few other items. I had the cookie dough cupcake. The frosting was...Fine. The cupcake itself was dry. I then tried the creme brulee cheesecake. Again, it was...Fine. But it was nothing to write home about. They did have a lot of business and you could tell a lot were regulars based on how the staff showed favoritism. It's fine once you know repeat customers, however, don't blatantly ignore a new customer you were just speaking with to go speak with someone who visits all the time. The display cakes looked great if you like fondant. The actual pastries are pretty limited but the space is relatively small. read more

Truly a gem find in this pandemic. My daughter turned 2 on May 30th and I got in touch with them the beginning of May to arrange an Elmo 2 tier cake Not only was the cake spectacular in sight right down to every detail of the "sparkler fondant candles/balloons " but the red velvet with Oreo cookie filing was TO DIE FOR The cream on the edge of the cake between the fondant and the cake was luxurious...heaven we couldn't not stop eating this cake for days after haha I am so excited to have found my new go to cake place!! They also adhered to all the pandemic requirements with masks, locked storefront etc. but the ladies in the front did it all with a smile! Worth every penny!! read more

See all

Another amazing cake created by Brian. Brian and Jen are so easy to work with, and Brian truly makes incredible cakes. My husbands birthday was coming up and I wanted to incorporate his favorite things on the cake. The Mets, Metallica and a certain brand of scotch are things he likes and I wondered how all of them can be incorporated on the cake. Well, Brian's creativity was fabulous with creating a masterpiece of a cake which was also delicious tasting too. Once again, sweet karma does it again... fabulous tasting, great and friendly customer service and awesome looking dessert & cakes. Cannot wait to order again read more

See all

Conveniently located in A shopping strip on Manetto Hill Dr. , I read past reviews and decided to stop there for some special treats. When i mentioned my daughter in law just passed her CPA exam, the young woman helping me add ed a nice Edible Congratulations Sign on top of the Cheese Cake minis. Only reason i gave it a 4 and not 5 was because a separate cupcake was packaged in a poor container as it completely fell to the side and got squished. Nevertheless it was delicious thou the presentation was now ruined. Yummy desserts so i'll be back! read more

Sweet Karma made my daughters cake for her 1st bday and it was absolutely delicious. I am not at all a fan of fondant and requested it be made with buttercream . It was so smooth it actually looked like fondant! Brian the owner was so nice when I placed my order and wanted to make sure he made the perfect cake for our special day . I showed him a picture off the internet and he exceeded my expectations with extra special touches . Cake was ready on time as promised and packaged nicely for travel to the venue. Thank you Sweet Karma!!! read more

Sweet Karma Desserts - Top tier was funfetti with vanilla filling and bottom tier was vanilla with cannoli filling ! - Desserts Near Me - Plainview, New York

I needed to reach out to post this review to boast of this extraordinary feat of artwork. The owner Brian and his staff took their time to understand, helped us and guided us with suggestions to create this most magnificent work of art from my wife's 50th birthday. Here, take a look at this and tell me how beautiful that is and I'm not just speaking about my wife lol. thank you sweet karma for going way above and beyond for creating this cake for our celebration. read more

Sweet Karma Desserts - Desserts Near Me - Plainview, New York

Brian. You have no respect for women. You yelled on the phone, and hung up when called out for your mistakes. I'm so disgusted that a business owner would treat women like this, let alone a paying customer. I have never had a man talk to me this way. He is a liar and it is a shame that his business still stands. Brian needs to take a class on being respectful to customers and apologize for mistakes made by him. His lies are expected because of the untalented cake artist he claims to be. He did everything opposite i said. And as for the inspo pics i sent him claiming to be "hot pink, orange and white" i had proof that that was never said. My point being made clear that he is a LIAR. you also must wake up everyday lying to yourself that you own a great bakery read more

Sweet Karma Desserts - Apparently i sent him hot pink, orange, and white. ??? - Desserts Near Me - Plainview, New York

See all

Brian and Sweet Karma did an amazing job at creating not only the most stunning cake but one my guests are still raving about how delicious it was. I cannot thank them enough. Highly recommended read more

Sweet Karma Desserts - Desserts Near Me - Plainview, New York

Meh. I'm on the search for the best bakery around. Went in here, being aware of the mixed reviews, and I was really disappointed. Definitely seems to be known for their cakes but I wasn't interested in that. I wanted to try the smaller items. What did i order? - key lime dream: completely frozen. Had to wait over an hour to eat it. The whipped cream on top was ruined by being frozen. Very disappointing! - peanut butter mousse: nicely flavored. Not too sweet or overpowering. Fantastic! - salted popcorn macaron: eh. No flavor like advertised. More just a sweet caramel flavor. - churro macaron: very good flavor but way too sweet. - rainbow cookie cannoli: not a fan. Too big. Not enough cream. Fell apart quickly. - rainbow cookie with jelly: not a fan either. Not enough jelly. Cake was too thick. Fell apart. Other things to note: - nothing was labeled so I had to ask for someone to tell me what everything was - everything was really cold or, like the key lime dream, completely frozen. To me this indicates nothing was fresh. - had no problem with the service. The woman that helped me was very sweet. Glad I tried it but won't be back. Maybe I'll try a cake a someday.... read more

See all

We just went to this place to order a cake for a birthday. The girl at the counter gave us a cold shoulder and wasn't helpful at all to finally make a decision or even gave us any idea on what options we have and how the pricing will work. She has no lists or menu to show what our options were. read more

The most beautiful cake I have ever seen. They did such an exceptional job!!! I'm out of state, I found Sweet Karma online while searching for a custom bakery in Long Island. Everyone I spoke to on the phone was so kind. They took my inspiration for the cake and absolutely ran with it. They went ABOVE and beyond in the detail of this cake. I could not have been happier with how this turned out. I am so incredibly grateful. You all are a blessing and you truly made our surprise party one to remember. read more

Sweet Karma Desserts - Custom Birthday Cake - Desserts Near Me - Plainview, New York

See all

Ordered a cake for my sister in law's baby shower. Discussed a layered cake with custard and a fruit filling. We received cake with pink buttercream instead. It was disgusting. No one ate it and we were so embarrassed. Update-the owner responded by saying we should have contacted them before posting the review. We did reach out before hand. My mother who placed the order tried to speak to them multiple times and she was rudely cut off and yelled at in the bakery. How embarrassing for her, I felt so terrible and that's why I had to leave a negative review. read more

Sweet Karma Desserts - Pink buttercream not a fruit layer. There's one random blueberry. - Desserts Near Me - Plainview, New York

Ordered cookies, donuts and croissants for my family who was sitting shiva. As soon as my order was placed, the bakery called to let me know that the croissants would take a little bit longer. I appreciated the communication and everything was delivered right when they said it would be. My family was so happy with the desserts. They were beautiful and delicious. Thank you!! read more

Sweet Karma Desserts - Desserts Near Me - Plainview, New York

See all

I can't even begin to express my gratitude to this bakery!! I had been looking for a custom gluten free cake to celebrate my 60th birthday for weeks! I was having a 70's themed party. I couldn't believe the prices I was being quoted....Insane!! I originally wanted a fondant cake because I thought that would be the only way I could get my theme in. None of the places I called gave me options. The quotes started at $700!! And I called bakeries from all boroughs! When I called Sweet Karma I was about to give up and try to make my own cake!! Spoke to Brian and he had me send him pics of my ideas. He gave me options to reduce the cost (the full fondunt was in the $500 range) still lower than I was being quoted. He said I could go with one layer in butter cream and one layer in fondunt. Then he said he could use the colors I wanted and make me the cake in butter cream! So I went with that and the results were OUTSTANDING! Better than I could've imagined as you can see! Did I mention it was RED VELVET and CHOCOLATE CHIP CANOLLI!! It taste just as delicious as it looked! If that wasn't enough, Brian lives in my town so he delivered my cake to my door in the rain!! Thank you Sweet Karma and thank you Brian! You have gained a loyal forever customer!! read more

See all

Everything about this purchasing experience was handled with great care and professionalism. I asked them last minute for a rushed order. I ordered a custom cake, cookies and cake pops and asked them to make it all with a Texas Longhorns theme for my daughter's college commitment bed party. The cake was stunning and the girls thought it was delicious! I loved how it looked for pictures! Thank you thank you! She loved all of it!!! Hook 'em Horns! UT26! read more

Sweet Karma Desserts - College Commitment Cake - Desserts Near Me - Plainview, New York

I was in the area and in the mood for something sweet and delicious. I read the reviews on Sweet Karma and decided too give it a shot. I went in and it is a tiny little shop with very small selection of items available. The cakes they had looked amazing, But I was not there to eat a whole cake. There was a choice of maybe 20 deserts as they call it. I had a chocolate mouse gnash desert. It was ok not great, Not sure were all the hype comes from. Too me the selection was very poor and prices were high. The service was fast and friendly. I probably would not go again as I was not that thrilled with the variety. read more

See all

The store has a very bad smell to it, it doesn't smell like bakery, it smells like an old home that needs ventilation. I still bought some donuts and cookies. The donuts and cookies SMELL LIKE THE STORE !! They don't taste bad if you can hold your breath.. I don't know why I bothered to buy anything after smelling it. Please take care of your store ; there is no way in the world you don't smell it. read more

They say a picture is worth a thousand words, so I'll let these pictures speak for themselves. I sent Brian of Sweet Karma a picture of the cake I wanted to have made. The picture with the "A" on top is the picture I sent to Brian, who assured me he could do it. The picture with "Hailey" is the cake that Brian of Sweet Karma actually prepared. When I complained about the appearance of the cake and asked for it to be fixed, Brian and his wife Jen were nasty to me. They told me that I was lucky that they even sent me a picture of the cake in the first place because "they didn't have to do that". They told me that I shouldn't be concerned with the appearance of a cake when a pandemic was going on (as if the pandemic gave them license to do low quality work). I'll be the first to admit that in my disappointment and frustration I wasn't very nice in response to their attitude. As a result, Brian refused to give me the cake AT ALL, leaving me stranded an hour before the party (in the middle of quarantine when nothing else was open) with NO CAKE for a very special friend's birthday. I was shocked at the poor quality of the cake and the way I was treated since I had heard good things about Sweet Karma. After reading all of the other Yelp reviews, the consensus seems to be that if you work with Theresa, she does beautiful work and is a pleasure. But if you get stuck with Brian, BEWARE. Apparently, I'm not the first person to whom he refused to give a cake! One woman had to call the police to get her cake! read more

Sweet Karma Desserts - Photo of cake I REQUESTED be made (except with one tier) - Desserts Near Me - Plainview, New York

See all

I wanted a vegan cake so I called sweet karma ... well they didn't disappoint just so delicious chocolate goodness like velvety creamy I can't tell you must try it for yourself... treat yourself have it made to order thank you Jenn read more

Great little bakery, especially for gluten free items. Was looking for a bakery with fresh gluten free items. The cupcakes were beautiful. They didn't look like the typical sweets that looked "off", because they are "gluten free". They had Oreo cupcakes that looked like the regular gluten bakery item, but it was gluten free with even a "fake" Oreo on top. Great selection of macarons. Our gluten free hosts loved them all. Will revisit read more