Great bakery and friendly neighborhood staff! I ordered a Strawberry Shortcake tiered wedding cake 10 years ago for my daughter's wedding and just ordered the same one that Mike was able to replicate for their 10th anniversary! The cakes not only look amazing but taste great!! read more

I have got a few items from Merritt Bakery and they all have been delicious. Some of our favorites to order are the: Italian and Irish apple cake and Italian cookies. This is a small and quaint bakery so it is a take out place just FYI. They have long hours usually 6:30 AM to 7pm on weekdays. If you are looking for something in particular, I would definitely call ahead! One time I wanted a cheesecake and I was able to place an order ahead of time so it would be ready! A perk here is you can order for delivery if you do not live locally! Check out their website! read more

Great pastries and lovely service! Stopped by on the way to a family function and and was so pleasantly surprised.

We buy the sprinkle cake for just about every holiday celebration. This year was such a delight to open the box and see the elaborately decorated cake! It was perfect! We also ordered a small cheesecake. My family loved everything. read more

See all

My cousin just shared the apple Irish cake! OMG so good. We will be visiting soon! We heard you also Make an Italian apple And peach cake. Can't wait to try it. read more

I bought cake pops from this place for the kids. I bought 6 thinking the kids would love them. They took one bite out of it and they said it was horrible and taste like soap. read more

I haven't visited the Merritt Bakery yet, but company has brought some delicious treats to my house. The cheese Danish ring was absolutely delicious, one of the best I've ever had. I can't wait to venture over to the actual bakery to try out some of their other goodies as well. read more

We ordered a birthday cake with some special requests. The owner took the time to call my wife to confirm particulars. The cake was extraordinary. Fresh. Moist. Delicious! read more

Family owned for over 50 yrs, their cakes ,pies , pastries and Irish Soda Bread are fantastic ! I know people who drive all the from Oceanside to purchase their delirious pastries . read more

3 Stars because I am being nice. They note delivery of cookies. I hope they are fresher than the stuff the are currently selling in the open store. 7 layer cake slice, might likely have been there from Mothers' Day as possibly the black and white cookies. 1.2 price mothers day cake for 8 dollars - only the one that says Mothers Day or Mom on it, not the others right next to it; listed at Costly for items that just don't cut it. (see pix) Where Francesco's is still at a standstill for construction finish in Hicksville, there are still places like Dortoni's that still have a line of people waiting to buy fresh bakery items. read more

See all

The muffins are fantastic! Blueberry, banana nut, apple crumb, raspberry--are all just damn delicious. I also enjoy their semolina Italian bread; it has a nice thick crust with a nutty flavor. We enjoyed it. I'll be back! read more

This BAKERY has been in business (and understandably so) for over 60 years. Their quality of baked goods have not changed from day one - only the best butter ingredients. I highly recommend any baked product that they make. Their cookies are especially divine. Shipping is always available and it's worth The cost of shipping. If you're looking to send a gift to anyone, a tray of cookies is always a sure bet. The recipient will be delighted with them. read more

I've been coming here my whole life, I'm glad it hasn't changed. Cozy store, great coffee, even better cheesecake. There aren't many places like this left around, and a family business is always leagues better than some chain grocery store cake! read more

Merritt Bakery - Cheesecake with strawberry. Apologies, I ate some lol - Bakeries Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

A family friend recommended Merritt's for my engagement cake and I could not have been happier! Mike made us a beautiful, white, semi-naked cake with napolean & fresh strawberry/blueberry filling, white buttercream, blueberries on top. It was absolutely delicious. It even had to travel from the bakery all the way to Ronkonkoma and it held up perfectly. Highly recommend. read more

Merritt Bakery - My perfect engagement cake! - Bakeries Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

Went to my favorite bakery to get a cheesecake only to find it being closed. Helped Italian bakeries in the area and Merrit Bakery came up. Decided to give it a try. Ordered the cheesecake and cookies. I found my new favorite bakery. read more

They make great old fashioned onion buns. A lot of onions in the middle. Great with cream cheese and lox

For every holiday. I order the custard crumb cake. It has been a family favorite of ours For over 50 years. The coffee in the morning is also pretty good. I highly recommend this place read more

Chocolate "Black & whites"/"Half moons"- finally after 40 years. Back in 1979, while in college, I would go to a bakery in Syracuse NY just to get their chocolate half moons. Since then, I've never been able to find them anywhere. Thanks to Mike, the quest is over. My wife was speaking to him one day while picking up some scones and mentioned it to him. He offered to make a batch for us, and before I knew it I was enjoying the delicious treat that I had missed for so many years. Thank you to Mike for doing that for us. BTW, they are delicious- for anyone who has never tried them- you're missing out. Thanks again. read more

Best butter cookies EVER! This bakery is my lifeline to great New York food since moving out of state. I highly recommend to anyone looking for authentic New York pastries and desserts! The owner of the bakery also ships out of state if you can't make your way to New York. You won't be disappointed! read more

In the land of shrinking bakeries, this one has not progressed, so so bread, not very crispy, smaller than usual rolls, very good rye breads but are shrinking in size yearly, raspberry crisps still terrific but jelly doughnuts have very little jelly only sugared on top not powdered. But with bakeries limited in our neck of the island it's there for a quick fix. read more

Even though the store could use some upgrading , I have to say - THE best Irish soda bread ever! Rolls are very good and I am addicted to the cream cheese cookies! read more

My family has been going to this bakery for decades. We love the chocolate bobkas and turnovers (my favorite is apple); my grandpa would bring them when ever he came for a visit. Recently I moved further East and will still travel the distance to get their delicious bobkas. For my bridal shower, an order was made so it could be the dessert. Anyone in the area or visiting from far away should try the chocolate bobka, it will not disappoint. read more

Really great bakery! Got the black and white cake for a great price (small for $12). The frosting was delicious. Only reason I didn't give 5 stars was because the white layer of cake was slightly dry. Otherwise perfect. Definitely would recommend. read more

Got a stale rainbow cookie chocolate cake for my birthday thanks to this bakery. I can't believe this place got 5 stars. The lady behind the counter was nice but that certainly doesn't make up this the disaster she sold us. read more

Everything at this bakery is great, but...the Rasberry Rafts are an all time favorite! It is a favorite for all my family and friends! I am even requested to bring them when I go to Florida! Thanks Mike and your staff for great service for so many years! read more

Had my mothers birthday cake made here! It was delicious! I highly recommend this place! My siblings live across Long Island but they will travel here for the next time they need a cake read more

I've loved Merritt Bakery since a kid when we would go on "Bun Runs"... We'd sleep over one of our house's and late at night (early morning) sneak up to their back door where we'd find racks of fresh baked goodies (mostly rolls) and swipe them for breakfast. Once my father came and the rack was still hot and he got burned. Ha. Serves him right! What father steals rolls with his son and friends??? How Embarrassing! Great cookies, jelly donuts, turnovers, crumb cake,... and memories. Thanks Mike~ read more

My family's been going here for years. They have the absolute best apple turnovers ever. I love the little mini ones. Everything's always made fresh everyday. read more

Been going here my whole life (45 years) plus some since my grandparents were customers too. The best bakery around, hands down. My son LOVES the chocolate chip cookies and black & whites. I have cookies delivered since I am no longer close enough to go to shop. They always arrive perfectly packed and fresh. The quality is always there and the taste can't be beat. read more

Been coming here for special events cakes/pastries since I was in preschool. The Dutch Apple Pie is to die for.

Best chocolate butter cream ever. Absolutely divine. Family and friends commented and complimented all with smiles. Service wonderfully congenial and attentive. My go to bakery. Gotta love this town. read more

This place is tiny little shop that bakes up some power cakes. I called and asked if they had preserves or fresh strawberries in the center of their strawberry shortcakes (my Dad is picky for fresh and it was his birthday). They said they used preserves, but could bake up a fresh one using fresh cut strawberries and cream. Did they ever? This cake made me very popular with my family. People that don't even like cake were devouring it. My Dad looked at me with loving, grateful eyes after he took his first bite. Now, I will definitely call every time I need a fresh one. They are truly outstanding. read more

I love this place! The breads, cakes, and cookies are off the chart good. You can taste the quality in every bite. I am a huge fan of the whoopee pies (ring dings) and frogs-a cupcake with a buttercream topping held captive by a delicious chocolate shell-woohoo! Its an old school bakery with old school quality. read more

GREAT babka, fantastic cookies, superb cheese strudel-- all served by friendly clerks. Mike the baker is always there, too, and he's such a nice man. Reasonable prices. We all deserve a treat in these hard times, so head over to Merritt Bakery. I was there today for a chocolate babka and a pound of rainbow cookies. So so yummy; a purchase from Merritt Bakery always puts me in a good mood all day! read more

Merritt Bakery kindly donated breakfast to the ESA NY Sundown Surf Shop's 4th Annual Surf Challenge, celebrating their 50th Anniversary. Incredible crumb cakes. Delicious buttered rolls. Everything was fabulous and their generous support of local businesses is the kind of gesture this World needs daily. Visit often and eat heartily! Thank You Merritt! read more

Merritt Bakery has been around , family owned bakery for years and I know why ! The most delicious cookies , cakes, and breads on the planet . They have stood the test of time because they are good . Really good . And the selection cannot be beat . Everything is made fresh everyday from scratch with recipes handed down through generations . If you've never been than I would say your missing out !! read more

Best Bakery in Town, Been going here for over 10 years every Sunday after mass. Freshest Rolls, Tea Biscuits, Muffins and of course Crumb Buns & Jelly Donuts. Counter help is always friendly and helpful. Mike keep up the good work. read more

I love this small little bakery. The prices here are so reasonable. I love the mini apple turnovers and the sprinkle cookies. Definitely worth a try and it won't break your bank like a lot of other bakeries do. read more

The Merrit Bake Shop in Farmingdale New York is one of a few old style bake shops on Long Island. The store is small in size but not in selection available. Assorted pies,cakes,doughnuts[try the cinnamon jelly,excellent!!!] Whipped cream cakes, breads. All are so fresh and tasty. These goodies are the real deal not filled with preservatives and flavorless fillings. Prices are very competitive and service is prompt and friendly. read more

What a great little jewel! I went in for the first time to buy a last minute birthday cake. All the ready cakes were too small so I was going to buy 2. Then the baker offered to make up a big cake on the fly! 15 minutes later, I walked out with a large custom square cake that not only looked beautiful it tasted great! Highly recommend this small bakery for both its products and its customer service! read more