While in Sarasota for a doctor's appointment, we decided to stop off for a slice at the original Solorzanos. The pizza slices were huge and the pizza was amazing. It was like a slice of home. (I really miss really great pizza at a consistent rate.) They were friendly and everything was reasonably priced. [[HIGHLIGHT]]I really did love the decor because it reminded me of home and the old school pizza shop on the corner in Jersey.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] I really wish I lived closer to Sarasota because they do have all the good food up there.. read more

8/10 good stuff the pizza is quite good, i personally prefer the silician. the garlic knots though i didn't really like them but it may be due to personal tastes im not sure. [[HIGHLIGHT]]the inside seating is not the most comfortable but tolerable, though the aesthetics found within the main dining area are nice.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] besides that, the staff are quite relaxed and friendly! would recommend a visit here read more

Ordered chicken parm and ricotta pizza and sausage/meatball pizza so we'd have leftovers tomorrow. First time here. Steady stream of takeout orders. They busy. Servers so nice and helpful. Manager came out to check on us as I'm writing this review. Really excellent pizza! Our new Sarasota favorite! read more

Solorzano's Pizza - Webber Street - Chicken parm and ricotta - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

I love this place pizza is the bomb I come here basically every day and I never get tired of it so many good options 10/10 read more

Solorzano's Pizza - Webber Street - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

The food here is amazing and I love it so much. It's New York and New Jersey pizza and I eat here almost everyday. Best place definitely 10 stars. read more

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Place is so clean and super friendly service.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Pizza and garlic knots best I've ever had hands down! Even the desserts look yummy. I'f I could rate it more stars I would read more

Solorzano's Pizza - Webber Street - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

See all

i pass this place by on my way home from work all the time and i finally tried it and it's the best pizza i've had in a long time. i got a pepperoni slice ($4.75) and their garlic knot ($1.50) and also [[HIGHLIGHT]]the ambiance is great[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]], the location (webber) is great, and the guy behind the counter was so welcoming and friendly! this is my new regular spot read more

See all

Love this place! I've tried the pizza at the other Solorzano's locations, and for some reason it's not nearly as good. In the service here is top notch. Definitely worth the extra drive to come to this one versus the other ones. read more

Pizza plain slice is exactly what we wanted!! Perfect crust and sauce is good. Service was decent walked in for slices to go ,fast service For a pizza slice in Florida this was a good 6.5 Garlic knots are huge they looked really delicious but they were not the highlight of the visit. If you are looking for a NY slice they have it!! And it does hit the NY crave!! I'd come back! read more

Solorzano's Pizza - Webber Street - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

Very good pizza & made as ordered. Pickup time was accurate & pizza was hot and ready. Our new go to place for pizza when we're here for the winter. Will be back! read more

I often search for good New York style pizza so I decided to try this place based on rave reviews. Met by friendly staff I placed my order at the counter, their popular Hoboken heart attack pizza with a side of meatballs. I have to say the meatballs were exceptional, served hot in a flavorful marinara. Unfortunately I found the pizza somewhat disappointing. My idea of a really good pizza is one with thin, crisp crust that holds under its own weight and high quality cheese. The crust immediately flopped while the topping easily slid away, folding helped as usual with most any pizza, In their attempt for my requested crisp crust I found it slightly burned on bottom. Overall I'd consider this a good option for pizza if in the area. read more

See all

The best in Sarasota, no question! Love the salad and the pizza! Oh and the garlic knots! Sauce and pizza crust always consistent!

Try this place. Really good pizza with a [[HIGHLIGHT]]really nice atmosphere.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]Makes you feel like you're back in NY.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Ordering issue. Selected the LBK location but the order placed to Sarasota Weber location. My mistake but they weren't helpful at all. With all the pies they turn out you'd think they would do something except complete a bad experience. read more

Great value and fast service!! Loved it!!! Food tasted great!!! I will be back for more!

Good but expensive. Not sure if it is open all of the time. Would recommend but not my favorite.

I've been living here since July, but I haven't ordered pizza from any place except Solorzano's! Because I know nothing will be better! Great food, great customer service, happy staff, happy customers! Can't say enough! Thank you! read more

Great tasting pizza. you can thank me later as you come back for more and often like I do.

Ordered a Margharita (with mushrooms) for Super Bowl Sunday, to bring to friends. They told me 5:00 wasn't possible, but 5:10 was, and that's precisely when I showed up. That's precisely when they took it out of the oven. It was a very good pizza, kind of a marinara red sauce...not what I'm quite used to, but damn good. The crust had a perfect char, and was really good. They didn't skimp on the fresh basil, and the mushrooms were plentiful and fresh. It might not have been Frank Pepe's Apizza (NewHaven), but nothing is. It's a damn fine pizza. The woman who took my order in the morning was very pleasant, and I think it was the very same pleasant woman at the counter at pickup. I can't comment on the eat in option at this place, but the pizza was good enough so I'd come back without hesitation! read more

Best gluten free (if you have to) and they don't burn the crust ! [[HIGHLIGHT]]friendly service always smells amazing, since on point[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] and I'm a jersey girl grew up eating the best pizza read more

1st visit for slice and beer at lunch. It was perfect NY/NJ style with thin, well-done crust. Simple menu (pizza, sub, calzone). I like that they stick to the basics. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Customers included families with small children.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]Added to the fun vibe.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

First visit. Tonite. Was waiting for the pizza. Ordered a glass of wine. Not blown away by the pizza but was blown away when the guy up front brought over my wine, which looked very small. I said oh! it's a half glass of wine! He said oh no!!!! It's 6 ounces! Then ...HE LITERALLY HELD UP A PLASTIC MEASURING JUG to show me! He had poured the wine from the bottle to the 6oz mark on the jug. Then into my glass. He was proud. He was smiling! I was in the restaurant biz for 35 years and never in my life have I seen wine poured by the measuring cup. The rules in this place are very strict obviously, and he was abiding by them. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Thanks for being tacky! Yikes.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] I also don't appreciate the wine going from the bottle into a kitchen utensil then into my glass. Gross, and more contamination potential. If you are that fussy about the pour and don't trust your employees then get the glasses that have the 6/9 oz marks etched on the wine glass. I'm also wondering if this is a code violation. Not going there again. Nope!!!! read more

We love this place for pizza. We order from here whenever we come to Sarasota. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Usually eat inside; this time we got carry out after a long day of driving.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

We arrived at 10:14 and they would not let us use the dining room because they close at 11. [[HIGHLIGHT]]There were people in the dining room and it was busy.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] They lost out on about a $75 tab. We will not go there again. Terrible service for a "late night pizzeria". read more

This is a long overdue updated review. Unfortunately, Solorzano's Pizza continues to go down in quality. I recently ordered a Large pizza with half sausage for delivery. It was basically all dough with a minimum of sauce or cheese and an "ok" amount of sausage. Since I came up about .10¢ short of their "minimum" order for delivery (this was a Large pizza) I had to order a basic salad too. With a fairly good tip, the total was $41.50 That seemed excessive to me, especially in light of the average quality. I may give them a try again sometime in the future but I wouldn't count on it. read more

This is my very favorite pizza place in Sarasota. I would rather get a slice of pizza here than an entire pizza and other places. The service is outstanding, they listen to you and give you what you ask for. [[HIGHLIGHT]]It is what you expect from a pizza place plenty of seating and enough parking.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]I like the way it feels.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]It is a great neighborhood pizza restaurant.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Very good pizza and a cool atmosphere! I had their white pie and added Kalamata olives and spinach, which was a great choice. You order at the counter and they bring you your pizza when it's ready. In addition to soft drinks, they have a decent selection of bottles and cans of beer, as well as wine. I only give 4 instead of 5 stars because I prefer a little more chewy crust around the edge, but that's really just my personal preference. The pizza was very well-made and the bottom of the crust was perfectly baked. read more

Solorzano's Pizza - Webber Street - White Pie with Kalamata Olives and Spinach - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Friendly service in a good real pizza atmosphere.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] I got their largest super duper large margarita pizza. It was good. The way they make it leaves it 80% sauce with pats of cheese. Sauce was good, but a bit tangy and with it being primarily Sauce this factored in as did the size which allowed for understandable flop in the center. To judge a Pizza should probably just got the standard size. I will definitely go back. read more

This place has a great ambiance and you get the feel of a New York Pizzeria. The garlic knots here are by far the best I've had, absolutely delicious. You can order pizza by the slice or pie. I grabbed a slice of the mushroom and thought it was very good. It's more of a grab and eat or grab and go type of place rather than table service but thought that was just fine. Will definitely be back. read more

Solorzano's Pizza - Webber Street - Interior - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

See all

Found this place on our recent trip to Sarasota and ended up ordering multiple times throughout the week! Great pizza (Bada-Bing was my favorite.) [[HIGHLIGHT]]Not much room to dine-in when with a big group but great ambiance overall.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

See all

Pizza- excellent. Service- excellent. Cold Shock Top! Excellent!!! We love this place (Whitfield)

Just as good as I remember! Love the pizza...but the real star is the garlic cheese bread! Yum! Next time I'll ask for some garlic butter on the side, as that garlic knots were a little dry. read more

Solorzano's Pizza - Webber Street - Sausage pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

See all

One of the top 3 pizza spots in town. This place does it right every time. Welcoming staff. Prompt service. Consistent ingredients and experience each time. Big fans. Has a great pizza place feel also. read more

I made it another week without needing coronary artery bypass surgery, and every week I make it is another week to celebrate by eating a large pie. I consider the consumption of the dough a great pancreas workout as it has to work extra hard to keep my blood sugar levels within range of not dying. Solorzanos has long been one of the best, if not the best pizza spots in Sarasota. Good for dine in with a great atmosphere and some TV's, but it's main business is take out. It's advertised as Jersey (joisey) style pizza. I don't know what that means, but it's delicious. The crust is always cooked well and passed the flaccid test with flying colors (as shown in the photos below). It's always nice and crisp and cooked perfectly. I got the chicken parm pie, and even with all the toppings it still wasn't soggy and floppy, the same can be said with the sausage pie. They're always generous with toppings and prices are reasonable. So far they are in my top two pizza places in SRQ. Seems to always be the same guy cooking the pies every time which helps with consistency. read more

See all

Ordered here for the Super Bowl. I had pre-ordered my pizzas and they arrive on the dot to my requested time. Food was amazing as always! read more

Solorzano's Pizza - Webber Street - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

If I could give this place a negative 5 star review I would!!! Especially julianna the owners fiancé who is the manager as well. Ordered a dozen garlic knots for our table because I brought a family of 9 here from out of town after waiting forever they arrived cold!!Asked for more sauce for them because they barely gave us any and they charged us 4 dollars for it mind you I had to ask 3 times for it first. Brought our pizza out it was messed up I asked them to remake it because they messed it up after a hour and our family being done with the other pizzas I got I went up to the desk asked to get it refunded because they were done there pizza and she said I never asked her to remake it which I DID. would not remake the other pizza or take it off the bill or remake the other one without charging me even though I already paid for the third pizza which I sent back!!! Julianna is beyond rude and unprofessional. The worst pizza place I have ever been to in my life honestly. They gave me an issue the entire night with everything so beyond disappointed. Will NEVER RETURN DO NOT COME TO THIS PIZZA PLACE!!!! Horrific experience all around. read more

I just don't like this pizza. We had it Saturday night and the crust was like cardboard. I have complained before and so many people sent me scathing messages but I just want to give my opinion! read more

Hoboken Heart Attack is one the best pizzas I've ever eaten!!! Prices are reasonable for the quality and quantity of food! Usually eat here twice when I I'm in town! read more

This Solorzano's is a local gem. I stopped by to get some pizza after a long gym session (haha) and was pleasantly surprised with the service, quality, and taste of the pizza. Colby was most considerate and amiable as I placed the order and upon arriving the pizza was fresh and hot. I was pleasantly surprised with the crust as it was on the thinish side but substantial; the flavors of the pizza were excellent as well. I am always seeking New York similarly styled pizza and this hit the mark. I admittedly am very picky about my pizza and I liked this pie better than other local establishments I have tried 'zas from. I really enjoyed the white with broccoli pizza and look forward to trying more from the restaurant in the near future. Situated at the end of a shopping strip plaza at the intersection of Beneva and Webber St. there is parking adjacent. There is outdoor seating and for COVID era there is an outside walk up order/takeout window. They also do contactless local porch delivery I believe. If you are in the area Solorszano's on Webber is a must try. Check them out for yourself! read more

Solorzano's Pizza - Webber Street - White with Broccoli Pizza (please excuse the bad lighting) was excellent!!! - Pizza Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

I felt the pizza was fine but I heard great things and it was just okay. All in all it's too far of a drive for me to get pretty good.