Fresh Nantucket

From start to end this store was Beyond helpful. My daughter was vacation on the island and we…read moreknew that her boyfriend was going to propose to her but didn't know when. I spoke with Lydia and asked if she could make a basket up for us with champagne, sweets and treats. The gift basket looks amazing and they were able to deliver it within the hour .

wonderful selection of wines. spirits, beer and soft drinks, All price points and excellent,…read moreknowledgable staff willing to recommend and assist! your purchase. They deliver, too!

Getting ready to Spritz and Stroll this weekend on Nantucket!

FALLING into the season...

See all

Fresh

2.5(4 reviews)

0.0 mi

Very cute exterior ! It's a combo store with wine and spirits, sandwich shop, gelato ,…read moresmoothies,etc, however over priced.

Its obviously a trust fund babies plaything- opens late in season, closes early in season.. Just a…read morelil hobby in between surfing, but my oh my are those sandwiches REALLY DELICIOUS. The Capone ( sub to die) The Caprese ( just kill me now) and that curry chix salad... Forgetaboutit!!! Great wines, lovely employees... Breakfast sandwiches awesome. You can't go wrong! Ack Favorite

See all

Liquor is right outside the window.

Murray's Beverage Store

3.2(16 reviews)

0.0 mi

Kids working behind the counter. Poor customer service, and grossly overpriced. Selling a $80 MSRP…read morebottle for $725.... At least throw in some free lube when youre screwing your customers. Such a shame. Plenty of other places on the island.

A great "packy" which is Commonwealth of Massachusetts vernacular for a Package Store; a retail…read morestore that sells beer, wine, and hard liquor. A nice selection of domestic, international, and local beers. A sophisticated wine selection too at very good prices. Drink mixers, sodas, onions and plastic cups. Years ago, when I partook in a cigar or two, I would buy one here, light it up and walk about town. Very good staff, good selection, wonderful location, and good and reasonable pricing. Also a good place to get a bottle of water if the Hub is too packed!

Murray's Beverage Store - This is a delicious Sauvignon Blanc called "The Oyster" that rebuilds Nantucket's oyster reefs. 100 oysters is restored for every bottle.

This is a delicious Sauvignon Blanc called "The Oyster" that rebuilds Nantucket's oyster reefs. 100 oysters is restored for every bottle.

See all

Nantucket Wine & Spirits

3.7(9 reviews)

0.8 mi

This was our go to place in Nantucket for beer, wine and spirits! This is a small shop, but packed…read morefull of a great selection! They have a walk in cooler and large cooler wall filled with beer and seltzers. Plenty of options if you want wine, whiskey or cocktails. This shop is attached to the grocery store, but don't let the size fool you! We stopped here several times while in Nantucket and each time we had a great experience and staff were friendly and helpful!

By far the most extensive wine and beer collection on the island. Staff are kind and just know…read moretheir product . Find them directly through the Stop &Shop or via their own access directly on Pleasant St .

See all

Islander Package Store

2.8(4 reviews)

1.2 mi

•$

So last year I gave 3 stars.. this year only 1.. his collection has doubled in size, why he moved…read moreit from behind the counter to a museum display case. His prices are so over the top ridiculous I wish he open a consignment store to sell my stuff if he sold any of it..

Easily the best liquor store on Nantucket Island. It's usually my first stop whenever I get to the…read moreisland in order to stock up for my visit. I usually end up returning for more throughout my trip, but every time is a great trip. The staff is friendly and knowledgable and you can't beat the selection. All around great liquor store. Don't even bother going anywhere else.

Store Front

See all

Hatchs Package Store

3.8(12 reviews)

0.7 mi

Great place to get gas, anything liquor related and best place for cigarettes on island…read more The pump attendees are so friendly.

Great renovations,beer, wine and drink options Absolutely everything you could want to pick up for…read morea gifts and or party. Snacks options as well.

Brotherhood of Thieves

3.9(506 reviews)

0.2 mi

I'm always cautious about a place that has such a huge, diverse menu: Bar food, burgers, salads,…read moreseafood, pasta, and a full menu of sushi and poke? How can you do all that well, especially at fairly friendly prices compared to most places on the island. But we were thrilled with our meal, which was frankly better than the overcooked shellfish they served over at CRU for literally twice the price. If you're in the mood for sashimi or sushi, I must recommend the chirashi: a generous portion of fresh tuna, salmon, and hamachi that's both terrific and a terrific value. And shout out to the sole picatta: properly cooked and generous, with a sauce that doesn't overwhelm the fish.

This place is super cool, it's an old whaling pub and they have kept the theming throughout! You…read moreMUST make a reservation, as they are like impossible to get into! The service was very nice and friendly, the food was so good!! We had the Philly cheesesteak roles app which were delicious. For dinner did the lobster fettuccine, absolutely worth it. So good, I forgot to take a picture before I ate it. I highly recommend it! Giving everything 4 stars, because unfortunately the drinks were not good. I had the peach bourbon smash and the mint was old and not good. We also had a Hugo spritz and it was so sweet it was undrinkable, so we asked to take it off and they did which was nice.

Tuna

See all

Top shelf margarita

Cisco Brewers

4.2(410 reviews)

2.2 mi

Great time at Cisco brewing! This place will get PACKED during the peak season so be prepared for…read moreit to be busy. It's such a nice place to hangout outside during a beautiful summer day. If you are visiting the island they have a shuttle which will pick you up from in town, it runs in a continuous loop about every 20 min. Once at Cisco, they were charging a cover of $10 a person to get in. Inside they have a large courtyard, lots of tables, and a big stage with live music. They have a wine station, full liquor bar, and the beer station so you can try all of the things they make. They were doing a signature cocktail with fresh cucumber which was delicious and refreshing! They also distill their own spirits and single malt whiskey. They had one of the best wine Frosè I have ever had, called the Nantucket Frosè. It has FRESH fruit and berries, SO good!

Our no longer so secret party spot. Even in the off season, it's ridiculously congested. If you…read morescore parking on premises, it's like winning an organ transplant. A few years ago, someone offered to buy my parking space for $500. (I declined.) There's often live music. (Check local publications or their website for up-to-date schedules.) There are often a number of food trucks present. On our recent visit, we had oysters from Hang Ten (enormous, meaty and sweet, but shucked with a ton of shell shards); tacos, guac and nachos from Millie's; and pizza from Eat Fire Pizza. And of course we had a number of decent beers on tap from Cisco Brewers. They seem to tend towards lightness, minimal hoppiness: good summer brews for warm weather. It's family friendly -- including canine members. Our pup is a seasoned New Yorker and accustomed to crowds, but even she seemed a little frazzled by the press of people at times.

Falafel from one of the food trucks

Nantucket Rose

See all

Bar area

BRIX Wine Shop

4.5(2 reviews)

1.1 mi

Not only is this an extraordinary wine shop, its selection of beers and spirits shows a willingness…read moreto stray from the tried and tired. If your drink selection includes cocktails during these Covid times this is the place to find the special ingredients that make your cocktail, well, special. They have a wonderful selection of cheeses including some old favorites and some that have now become good friends. Crackers and vintage glassware round out the offerings. This is the requisite stop to make before settling in for a stress-reducing glass in your hand.

GF and I decided that we wanted to have a picnic on the beach-- and for that we wanted to get some…read morewine. We stopped in to the cellar (it was on our way from town to the hotel). The selection overall was a little spare for my taste, but GF had no problem finding something that she wanted to drink. I ended up settling on a Gerwurstraminer that I'd seen previously and wanted to try. My favorite part of their offering was cheap, used corkscrews-- a whole basket of them right on the counter-- for people like us who are on vacation and didn't think to bring an opener. Genius. Unfortunately the rain didn't let up the whole time we were there- so we brought the wine back to the mainland for a later date.

Old South Liquors

1.0(1 review)

1.7 mi

they were harassing me and my friends because it was late and they wanted to go home. they kicked…read moreus out and their excuse was they had a bad day. threatened to physically attack us if we didn't leave. terrible establishment all together I wouldn't recommend ever going there. I've never wrote a yelp review before so this outlandish behavior had to be bad enough to make me.

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

6 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Pat R.

6 years ago

There's a bunch of places to get sandwiches on island but fresh is soooooo good. Can't wait for them to open back up this season. Their smoothies are also really good and they have a crazy liquor selection in there, which is a surprise for a sandwich shop read more

Kate C.

16 years ago

recommend FRESH for a new breakfast option this summer. nice and strong green mountain coffee and try the made to order breakfast burrito-- a generous portion filled with eggs, cheese, veg, and bacon. read more

Izzy V.

6 years ago

Fantastic sandwiches. Easy to order and great selection of wine too. You order inside and then wait outside and they bring you your order. 10/10 experience! read more

Tori E.

4 years ago

Best sandwiches on the island! Every time I visit this is my first stop. Call ahead if you don't want to wait, but it's worth it.

joshua h.

18 years ago

The capone a take on the classic italian is perfect with a six pack on the way to the beach what is easier than that!!!!!

Jen B.

7 years ago

SO good! From the food to the smoothies to the selection of beer,wine,beach ready cans and liquor!

Fresh Nantucket - tradamerican - Updated August 2026

People who viewed Fresh Nantucket also viewed

Henry’s Jr. Sandwich Shop

4.0

(43 reviews)

•$

5 Stars definitely.... Just know it's take out only. Had the Italian.... Thought it was small for…read more$11 but not even close. Very well made with in-house bread! Hugely recommend Henry Jr's. They have a sign at the register that says best of Nantucket 2006, I think Islanders have been missing the mark for the last 20 yrs. Time to revote!

Came here twice during our week in Nantucket…read more Great sandwiches. They make their sub rolls in house and it shows. To me the, foundation to a great sandwich is the bread. The big sandwich spot in town is claudettes, which is also excellent but I think overall I preferred the ones here. Friendly and quick service. No place to dine in so you just take the sandwiches to-go.

Black-Eyed Susan's

3.4

(286 reviews)

This is one of the most popular breakfast spots on the island, so we obviously had to try it. The…read morefood was genuinely very good. My Seasonal Vegetable Scramble was fresh and delicious, and the toast was really good. The hash browns were probably the best part, though. We also got the Blueberry Buttermilk Pancakes, and those might honestly be some of the best pancakes I've ever had. They were SO good. My biggest complaints are the size of the restaurant and the prices. It's incredibly small inside, and because it's so popular, you may have to wait a little bit to get seated. That itself isn't a huge issue, but the bar seating is so incredibly uncomfortable, and it honestly made the experience less enjoyable. The prices are also pretty ridiculous. My vegetable scramble was $26, which is insane to me. I completely understand that you're on an island and things are going to be more expensive, but $26 for a vegetable scramble is kind of crazy. Other than the uncomfortable seating and the prices, the food itself was very good and definitely worth trying if you're visiting the island.

Great little spot for breakfast in town. They also serve dinner as well although it can't comment…read moreon that. I had the avocado toast, my son had a pancake, and my husband had the French Toast and hash browns. Everything was delicious. I even purchased a super cute mug to go. Service was efficient and we only had to wait about 5 minutes to be seated although we came around 10 am on a Monday. Definitely expensive, but the prices almost everywhere on this island seem to be inflated a bit.

Yummy

4.1

(36 reviews)

Are these the best sandwiches on Nantucket? Might be…read more Conveniently located on the bike path. Yummy was the perfect place to stop for a sandwich after the beach. They have a big menu of burgers and sandwiches. They also serve ice cream, which appeared to be very popular. We got the wipeout turkey sandwich and added fries. The sandwich was great, exactly what we're looking for, and came with a mountain of fries. They were crispy, salty, and delicious. It was enough to split. You order inside, and then they bring the food out to your table. They have picnic benches and umbrellas for you to enjoy them outside. Will definitely be back to try other sandwiches or maybe ice cream.

Super grateful that Yummy exists at this location. They provided much needed breakfast, snacks and…read morecaffeine in the area and our rental was in the his area. Imagine biking to town just to get coffee!!!! Their ICED COFFEE is strong. Thank you. They have PICNIC TABLES so everyone could take a breather before forging on to where we're supposed to for that day. Smoothie bowls are hearty.

Something Natural

4.1

(186 reviews)

I got the Terry Terrific, which comes with smoked turkey, herb bread stuffing and cranberry sauce…read more You can't get a sandwich with the combo of these flavors and ingredients just anywhere. So to be able to have something different was a great change of pace from just your typical sandwich. I believe my Wife got the smoked turkey sandwich, added cheese and red onion. It was good but nothing to write home about. The star of the show though was the egg salad. Best egg salad my Wife and I have ever had. If you stop in at Something Natural you have to get the egg salad. They also have an assortment of local drinks and juices to get with your food. We got a strawberry lemonade which paired well with the sandwiches and the weather. They have plenty of outdoor seating. The walk to this place was beautiful. Strongly suggest going to Something Natural on a nice sunny day.

Went here for breakfast but at 9:30 in the morning although they were open they had run out of…read morebacon so could not make a BLT or any sandwich with bacon on it. I therefore opted for egg salad on herb bread with lettuce and tomato. We opted to eat our sandwiches there. When I opened the sandwich it was a crumbly mess that fell apart when I tried to pick it up. Both sides of the bread were soggy so it seemed as if the sandwich was made on a wet cutting board, I went back to show the young lady that the sandwich was inedible and she let me order something else and explained that the herb bread tends to be very delicate. I ordered salami and provolone on sourdough with no vegetables as I figured that was hard to screw up. After ordering she went to charge me for the new sandwich even though I didn't and could not eat any of the old sandwich. I had to ask to talk to a manager to explain what happened. He was not apologetic at all even though I showed him the sloppy,wet, falling apart sandwich. He did however make me a new one in the end without charging me. It is a beautiful setting I just think that they need to work on their sandwich making skills and their customer service.

Walter's Deli

4.5

(86 reviews)

We ordered sandwiches delivered to our hotel room in Nantucket. The Thanksgiving and the Caprese…read more The only let down was the turkey. I thought it would be real turkey it was lunch meat turkey

Love this place! It's a cute deli with tons of options that you can grab to go. We grabbed lunch…read morehere today and the prices are reasonable, staff are friendly, and the food is delicious! I had a warm lobster roll and it really hit the spot on a chilly afternoon. Definitely recommend and I'm sure we will be back!

Provisions

4.1

(165 reviews)

What a well run sandwich shop near the wharf. There were dozens of people ordering sandwiches and…read morewho were waiting for the sandwich orders but you could see into the kitchen how hard the assembly line of staff was working to make the sandwiches to perfection and get them out as quickly as possible. Similar to Claudettes and Something Natural the sandwiches are made on homemade bread and are GIANT! We shared the turkey terrific which was delicious. This was a perfect sandwich to share and a nice respite from the many fine dining meals that we had while on island.

It was a good sandwich. Maybe even pretty good. I like smoked ham and Swiss. But for $18 it should…read morebe amazing and huge, like an overstuffed one you'd find at a deli. Instead I'm left with the impression that Nantucket is just expensive for everything and good sand much for an affordable price is so hard to find. Still, if you don't mind the price, the bread was solid and we enjoyed sitting out by the water.

Straight Wharf Restaurant

3.9

(225 reviews)

One of my favorite restaurants on Nantucket! Their pre-fix menu is full of great options - I shared…read morea NY strip and a Salmon dish with my partner and we loved both so much. Cooked to perfection and the of course they use high quality meat and fish (at a fair price for what you get). Great spot for a night out with friends and loved ones, highly recommend.

Straight Wharf is staying its course. My most recent visit was solid, but I don't necessarily…read morethinks warrants 5 stars. The $90 prix fixe includes an app and an entree - pricey. The Buffalo fried fish app the waitress recommended wasn't my favorite and doesn't seem to be a dish that should be on the menu. It def felt like TGIFridays met Nantucket but not in a good way. Literally a deep fried block of fish smothered in buffalo sauce served on like a whipped blue cheese spread. Honestly, I think it was trying to elevate Buffalo when Buffalo can't be elevated. The fish entree I had was fine. Nothing out of this world. Actually quite unmemorable. Overall, $90 for 2 dishes that were fine, the app being even on a don't order suggestion, is a little jarring. Service and ambiance was great. I love the comp bread and little dip amuse bouche. Overall, fine. I think I ordered wrong, but I do think there are some better value and more exciting food happening at other places.

Yezzi's Nantucket

4.5

(8 reviews)

Kids' meal is only 3 tenders, even though cashier said 4 when we asked. One adult order + fries is…read morea better value than 2 kids. Staff should know the menu better.

So impressed with Yezzi's! We've become regulars on summer nights when we don't feel like cooking…read moreor are looking for a quick take-out option to enjoy on the beach. We love their Boston beef and fried chicken sandwiches. Big portions and good value (for Nantucket). I look forward to exploring more menu options!

Claudette's Sandwich Shop

4.8

(4 reviews)

Adorable little sandwich shop in Sconset. Amazing blueberry muffins and they have potato chips…read morelocal to the island which are pretty cute too. Staff were efficient and friendly!

My husband had an incredible meat-loaded satisfying sandwich ($18) and I was so grateful that they…read morehad a vegan gluten-free option, even if it was a simple PB&J! ($8) It was fresh and a much needed late lunch on the island.

Oran Mor

4.4

(254 reviews)