Lots of options to choose from on the island of Nantucket, and I'm very glad we tried this one! Located right next to the pier and ferry, it makes sense to grab dinner here before heading out back to Hyannis. There was a cute market attached although it was closed when we stopped in, or at least no one was over there. Service was friendly and we were seated inside nearly immediately. The chowder was so delicious, my son nearly licked the bowl. The lobster roll and salmon were both equally delicious and so friendly. Tables are bit cramped - me and another poor woman literally kept hitting each other with our elbows lol, but that's the price you get for being seated quickly! Wonderful experience here, and order the lobster roll! read more

Straight Wharf Fish - Seafood Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

See all

This place is beautifully set by the water. It's near the ferry port so lots of people come and go. They have a sit-down part and a to-go counter. We decided to sit and eat. Unfortunately the outdoor seating was booked (party of 5) so we sat indoors. It was quite busy for dinner. The menu is simple and just right. We ordered SO much food! The clam chowder was too watery for my taste. I'm a fan of thick hearty New England style clam chowder. I liked the onion rings with caviar but the batter took on most of the flavor. Caesar salad had a little twist: no croutons and topped with anchovies. It was yummy. Fish tacos were a hit; we ordered fried instead of grilled. The warm lobster rolls were delicious. I avoid gluten where I can so I got the fish sandwich without a bun. It was crispy on the outside, flaky and soft inside. Coleslaw made it whole. The rosemary fries and cornbread as sides were addicting! Key lime dessert was meh. It was busy but we got the attention we needed. The staff was friendly and had smiles on their faces. Definitely good for fried seafood!!! read more

See all

My girlfriends and I took a day trip to Nantucket and went to the Straight Wharf for lunch. We were pleased we didn't have to wait in line and the staff were all so pleasant and helpful. Our waitress was particularly nice! I wish I got her name to shout her out here. I was recommended here for their lobster roll and it was one of (if not) the best lobster rolls I've ever had. The views are beautiful too! read more

See all

Excellent food and service. We had fried clam basket and warm butter lobster roll, and both were delicious.

I kind have been telling everyone about Straight Wharf Fish. A new player on the block/wharf - it's casual, but still upscale, with a covered dining area on the water and a modern, cozy inside. No reservations and early season, we had no problem snagging a table for 2. However, a friend recently shared they were told a 45 minute wait the other day. Prices and portions are reasonable to that of the Brotherhood and the Trap, and well executed. The fish tacos were delicious and my son's burger was basic but delicious. Heads up, while no kids menu, they did say they had a secret one - I'm imagining coming from so many families popping in. The burger as was $18 and a double patty with no toppings and homemade chips. The chowder was also really good with I believe some pork in there. It's been a minute, so I'm a little rusty. Service was great and kind. I didn't order any cocktails, but they did look small for the price - they may be bottled? I could be lying there. I saw a many a fried seafood and fries platter go by and they looked so good and fresh and crispy, in the best way possible. Overall, five star addition! I'm sure the lines have begun, but it's worthy of a wait, especially over at the Gazebo, so perfectly convenient. Ps: they also have a retail portion but I did not pay much attention to that side. read more

See all

This is the original Yankee Pier. If you ever visited that restaurant in Larkspur, CA, this must have been the inspiration. Simple and delicious food. Casual, not fancy and great for kids. Tables tight on the water. Gluten free friendly, if that is of interest to you. stuck to the seafood. Lobster roll, fried clams and fish tacos. Btw, the fried clams are FULL BELLY, the entire clam, not just the muscle "clam strips" you used to find at places like Howard Johnson's. Everything fresh and literally right out of the water. read more

See all

The lobster rolls were amazing! Our waiter (idk his name, super tall brunette guy) was super accommodating and removed got the kitchen to remove the bacon out of the clam chowder for us! Super cute place with a view of the water. You can sit down to eat or take it to go! Would totally come back. Super convenient because its right off the ferry. read more

Straight Wharf Fish - Lobster Roll - Seafood Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

Food was ok. Over priced but considering the location I guess it's to be expected. The cold lobster roll was just ok, for $44 dollars I expected more lobster and better sides instead of chips I've had way better. The full belly fried clams were good. Reason I left a 3 was the service. Waitress had zero personality and felt like she just didn't want to be there. Order was taken and didn't see her again until we waved her down to order something else. I wish we had the male waiter that served the table next to us. She could learn some things from him. Probably won't go back there. read more

Excellent tasting food, service & atmosphere on the island using a hy-line ferry from c cod. We had a clam chowder prob the most loaded with clams & other seafood in a long time. Then we had the swordfish griddled with fries & cole slaw & tartar sauce delicious w other generous portion, also an halibut tacos all in all I rate 4.5 stars read more

Straight Wharf Fish - Swordfish swich & halibut tacos - Seafood Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

See all

We just stopped by for some oysters and raw clams to hold us over for dinner but they were amazing!! We came as a party of two on a summer Friday afternoon around 3:30pm and the wait was about 5 minutes. They have both indoor and outdoor seating and are connected to a little market/store. Would love to return and try some other items! read more

Straight Wharf Fish - Amazing oysters - so clean tasting - Seafood Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

See all

The scallop roll and clams were phenominal!!! Our server, Julie, turned things around for us after we were treated unfairly. The manager, Colin's treatment was unacceptable. When my friend ordered a limoncello spritz, he brought a margarita instead. When she corrected him, he rudely said, "No you didn't," and walked away. She was also the only Black woman in the restaurant, and the only one treated this way. As locals in the industry, we were really disappointed by the manager's dismissive and disrespectful behavior. I recommend this place because the food is fabulous and every other time the service has been great! Just be careful with Colin. read more

Straight Wharf Fish - Scallop roll - Seafood Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

Stumbled upon SWF towards the end of their very first week, when they weren't even officially doing takeout just yet. We were just walking by looking for a lobster roll and walked in to see a fish market! The lovely staff made an exception for us and we were so grateful. Not a seafood item but wow those onion rings were out of this world!! We got them with the lobster roll and wish we got the full side (for a bigger portion) instead. Totally recommend. Lobster roll was great as well especially at its decent price of $35. Loved that it came with a side of slaw as well. Would have loved to dine in if we had the time. read more

See all

Excellent lobster role, but they don't do boiled lobsters... they also boast a nice seating area over looking Straight Wharf. A very well packed fish market too! Reasonable prices and the staff are great, friendly, and have good recommendations. read more

Excellent fried clams ! I've been all over New England and these were delicious!!! I don't understand the reviews. This place is great! My only downside is $40 for these clams is a bit overpriced. But you're on Nantucket. What do you expect read more

Straight Wharf Fish - Seafood Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

Wonderful dinner! Best fried clams we've ever had. Sea Scallops and Roasted Salmon were amazing. We enjoyed the ambiance on the outdoor patio on the water. Key Lime Pie was the perfect dessert to end the evening. So glad our longtime Nantucket friends Ray & Barb shared this restaurant with us. read more

Straight Wharf Fish is exactly what Nantucket needed- it is part fish market and part casual dining. The food is exactly what you would expect.-exceptionally fresh delicious seafood cooked perfectly. I have been coming to the island for over 40 years and to me this is what best represents true Nantucket Island seafood . The service is excellent from the host staff to the weight staff and all the servers. It's super refreshing to see smiling and attentive employees! The dining room is perfect for families or couples. Thank you straight or fish for giving Nantucket a perfect casual seafood restaurant and fresh fish downtown. read more

Great food while in Nantucket! One of several place I got a lobster roll, think this was second. Sat outside but breeze had that smell that only happens on a wharf. Great service and very helpful read more

A very good seafood restaurant with a built in seafood market. The food was quite good and our waiter was very friendly. If you're fortunate you can get a seat outside overlooking the bay. read more

Great views and even better lobster rolls. Tried both hot and cold and can't go wrong with either.

10/10. Gabriel and his team hit it out of the park with this restaurant! First, the food: the caviar onion rings, clam chowder, fried clams, blue fish patê and smash burger were tremendous. Truly the best burger on island. Mouth watering. The fried clams were perfect, crispy and juicy! Clam chowder was delicious and caviar on onion rings? Need I say more? The staff was wonderful and kind, and the vibe is even better! The decor was beautiful. We had dinner on the deck which was a delight the chairs were comfortable and the view can't be beat. We could not have had a better experience, and will be adding this to our regularly weekly rotation! read more

Straight Wharf Fish - Caviar Onion Rings - Seafood Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

Great atmosphere and food was good as well. Recommend ordering sauce on side for the swordfish. It was a little over dressed. read more

Straight Wharf Fish - Blackened swordfish - Seafood Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

See all

Just incredible food, service, decor and ambiance. Go and enjoy this Nantucket essential experience. read more

New place with outdoor seating right on the harbor. Overpoweringly noisy inside the building...brick floor and wood walls/ceiling make for poor acoustics. Probably quieter on the covered deck. Clam rolls were as good as expected for $32/each, though the accompanying cole slaw was grossly oversalted. Worst news: about 6 cocktails are offered but all are "pre-batched" since there is no bar. Decent beer and wine selection. Clean bathrooms featuring the infernal hand dryers. NO reservations. read more

Amazing. GO! We were excited to try SWF having loved SW for decades. From the outstanding "clam shack" menu to service and atmosphere-it's quintessential Nantucket! We were given a warm welcome upon entering; there is a fish shop, grab & go and seated restaurant. We were ushered to the hostess and they accommodated us with a waterfront table on the wharf. Cozy night on the water with the fog horns in the distance. We had clam chowder, blue fish pate, caviar onion rings, fried clams, calamari &fish sandwich-all outstanding. Paired with a reasonable & great bottle of wine. Wanting a clam shack? Go. Want to dress up? Go! Great cocktail? Go! Wear a hoodie? go! It reminds me of old Nantucket-under stated, cool, not fussy. Extra star for the back server who ran me my rain jacket that I left by the table. Will be in the regular rotation! read more

I think this place can improve and hopefully it does- my lobster roll was drowned out by the shallots and brown butter - turned the lobster brown - the clams were big and chewy - not smaller and sweet - I asked for a side of fries as menu said it came with chips - the roll came with fries on the plate and a separate basket of fries - I feel the server should have said it came with fries.... Onion rings were good - drinks were small and fair - the physical space is great- so well decorated and designed- we sat on the porch and it was delightful - we are going to try it again when we return later in August- read more