The minestrone soup was amazing!! And I'm Italian, so I'm picky. All the sweets looked fantastic, but I only got the lemon tart. Yummm

Stacey cakes definitely has some yummy things but there are items that leave you wanting something more. The cinnamon rolls for instance. They are so flat and they don't have that gooey texture you want from a cinnamon roll. read more

We had Great Cinnamon Rolls, sticky buns and ginger snaps. Only open Thursday - Sunday so make sure you plan accordingly. Yum!

I got the berry cake for my dad's birthday. He loved it and helped make his day special when I couldn't be there with him. Thank you Stacey Cakes! :) read more

Cinnamon rolls are addictive, absolutely delicious! Quiche is incredible every time - bacon, Gruyère, spinach in photo. Service is quick and easy. Dining area is quaint and just right for the menu. read more

Stacey Cakes - Sugar Bun, cinnamon rolls, quiche, and coffee - Bakeries Near Me - McCall, Idaho

This local small mountain-lake town bakery is what Hallmark movies are inspired by. It's hard not to fall in love with this tiny bakery that usually has a line out-the-door for Stacey's baked goods and coffee! There's plenty of outdoor seating and some space inside to enjoy your coffee and pastries. I visited this Stacey's Cakes when staying in a cabin in Donnelly, the next town over about 20-25 minutes away. It was a friend's birthday and we snuck out of the cabin to grab a birthday cake and luckily for us- they had premade cakes in the back that serves 8-12 people! We got the berries and cream cake and even picked up the perfect cake topper! The cake came frozen, so we left it out at room temperature for 4-6 hours. The cake was a hit, everyone loved it! The frosting was made with real butter and boy, could you taste it - it was decadent. Stacey's Cakes is a true McCall gem. If you're in town and want to romanticize your life, stop by Stacey's Cakes and get ready to fall in love! read more

Stacey Cakes - Menu + pastries - Bakeries Near Me - McCall, Idaho

See all

Tasty cookies and baked goods! Makes a good gift or treat on the way home from mccall

How do you review a spot with an excellent product and poor service? It can be a challenge. At Stacey Cakes in McCall you can expect quality baked goods in a small town setting and a cute, aesthetic environment. On the other hand, a notably difficult customer experience along with limited hours made our excitement about this spot deflate. Upon deliberating, discussing at length, and coming to a decision on a cake, the owner, who had been right there observing us announced from the open kitchen in a curt manner that the available cake (per their own sign) could not be sold to us. Confusion ensued as the sales person apologized & we looked for other options on the "still available" cake board. Then a few minutes later, as we had started the process of deliberating again, the owner called out from the open kitchen to her sales person (not acknowledging us, making eye contact with us or explaining to us) said "sell them the cake." (I'm assuming she retabulated her orders for the day.) Understanding the challenges of running a small business and inventory management, there is no reason to snap at your customers. A kind apology or thoughtful acknowledgement would have smoothed the whole thing, but instead we had a charged experience. I was fairly surprised about the interaction until a conversation with a local friend illuminated that this experience was not a one off, but a pattern. End of story is that we did buy and did enjoy the cake, but the odd, and tense interaction didn't meet our expectations for customer service. read more

Stacey Cakes - the outside of a restaurant - Bakeries Near Me - McCall, Idaho

See all

Best gingersnaps in the country? Friendliest people in the world? Cutest little bakery in town? If you are in town, go to stacey's cakes!

Oh my! This little bakery is DELICIOUS! I couldn't decide what to get so landed on the raspberry chocolate scone (pictured) and a coconut macaroon. The scone was huge and so delicious. It didn't taste fake at all. If you have a sweet tooth and want a really good baked good while in McCall, go here! read more

Stacey Cakes - Raspberry chocolate scone (don't mind that it's half gone!) - Bakeries Near Me - McCall, Idaho

Very tasty cinnamon roll and a cute and cozy place. I also had the hot chocolate but it would have tasted so much better if it was made with milk instead of water. read more

Stacey Cakes - the interior of the store - Bakeries Near Me - McCall, Idaho

This is an outstanding bakery in this kitschy town. The desserts are mostly shortbread based and it tastes wonderfully buttery. I loved the bag of molasses cookies. The riff on a twix bar cookie was outstanding. The lemon tart was delicious! Wish she was open everyday!! read more

See all

Went here for the first time and bought two bakery items. They were both delicious . Can't wait to go back next time to try out more of their bakery items. read more

Stacey Cakes - Vanilla shortbread cookies. - Bakeries Near Me - McCall, Idaho

See all

This is one of our must-stop destinations on every trip to McCall. You never know what tasty treats they're serving up, but you can guarantee they'll be fantastic. This time we tried the Coconut Macaroon, and a Twixter. 10/10 would get both again. read more

Stacey Cakes - Coconut Macaroon & Twixter - Bakeries Near Me - McCall, Idaho

What a terrific place! Located in downtown McCall, this wonderful bakery seemingly wraps its arms around you when you enter, as the incredible scent inside is so darn good. Walking distance from the McCall hub of Payette Lake and the Shore Lodge, this is such a must-visit stop. Open until 4PM, Stacey Cakes has its own parking as part of a strip mall, and will satisfy your sweet tooth cravings! Since I was just arriving from Boise, I needed to graze a bit, and walked away with three items which I loved. The chocolate chip cookies were awesome, chewy and huge, and I liked them so much that I ate the second one slowly, almost rationing it to savor it. A bag of ginger snaps were memorable, so delicious. But the highlight for me was the raspberry chocolate shortbread, one of the best pastries I have ever enjoyed. A truly great bakery that is still on my mind, and I can't wait to visit again. read more

Stacey Cakes - Bakeries Near Me - McCall, Idaho

Outstanding bakery. Check if they're open before going there. Best ginger snaps; dangerous

Stopped in for treats while in McCall yesterday - actually, we drove up just to see if they had cinnamon rolls - and we were not disappointed! $61 later we had coffee, cinnamon rolls, cherry tarts, berry crumble cake, cookies and a full size apple pie! Everything was amazing. We can't wait to return! Sadly, it was POURING out so we mad dashed back to the truck and I got no photos. Notes: The place is tiny so if it's full, plan to take it to go. We were a family of 9 and they allowed us all in at once but we ordered and dashed since the few tables were taken. Cash and card accepted. They only offer regular coffee, not fancy coffee so get your latte elsewhere. Outside seating, but if there's weather you won't want to sit at any of it. Parking is in lot in front or walkable from any street parking. No bathrooms that I saw. read more

Amazing desserts! We stopped in for an assortment for our family to share. Everything was amazing! We'll definitely be back. read more

Stacey Cakes - Chocolate chip crumb cake (half was eaten before the photo), cinnamon roll, salted caramel cheesecake, coconut lime scone - Bakeries Near Me - McCall, Idaho

Awesome selection of fresh baked goods. Both Savory and sweet. We tried the Cherry pie, strawberry tart, lemon cloud, and cinnamon rolls. All were amazing! read more

Stacey Cakes - a display of baked goods in a bakery - Bakeries Near Me - McCall, Idaho

See all

Was really really disappointed in the cake we purchased. We ordered the berries and cream cake for my husband's big birthday and we followed their instructions to let it sit out 4-5 hours before eating since the frosting is made with real butter. Very very little berries inside and the frosting tasted like it was made of nothing but butter. Would be cautious with ordering cakes with butter cream frosting for this reason. None of us finished our slices and threw the cake in the trash. read more

Food is soooo good! We were in McCall for 2 nights & had to go back a second time for their breakfast items!

AMAZING place up in McCall. They make incredible pastries..SUPER pricey tho!! My dumb ass paid $2.50 for ONNNNNE cookie -- ONE! Haha! Don't get me wrong, the cookie was INSANELY good, but yeah, if you don't mind emptying your wallet on some incredible cookies and whatnot -- this is your place. No matter what tho, it's always a great place to stop into if you're in McCall -- especially if they are open. They have very strange hours. read more

Delicious baked goods! Get there early on weekends for the best selection of breakfast pastries! The homemade pies are delicious. And the ginger snaps are the best. read more

What a great little place to eat lunch, and eat Stacey Cakes gingersnaps. My husband had the carrot ginger soup with the smashed chickpea melt add on, and I had the quiche and the green chili knish. Both were tasty and delicious. We had to buy a bag of Stacey cakes too!! Loved it, and everything they sell looks marvelous too! read more

First stop in McCall. Ordered a full assortment of Huckleberry treats. The Huckleberry Upside Down Cake was absolutely phenomenal. Unfortunately cake is missing from picture as is was eaten too quick. read more

Stacey Cakes - All gone Upside Down Cake. - Bakeries Near Me - McCall, Idaho

Always the best pastries, and ginger snaps! Can't go to our family cabin without stopping at Stacey Cakes at least once!

Two Words : GINGER SNAPS. Love this little bakery. everything is so delicious! but especially the ginger snaps. read more

We ordered a cake for my mother-in-law's birthday. I had gotten the date wrong and called to change it and Stacy was so kind and made the change even though they're so busy. The cake was so delicious. The buttercream was so fluffy and had the perfect hint of sweet and salty. The cake was not too sweet. I highly recommend Stacys. We don't live in the area but they will be our go-to whenever were in town. Thank you so much to Stacy's Cakes for a really wonderful treat! read more

Best darn chi rolls, coffee and Ginger Snaps in the State. But don't go there or they will sell out and I can't get mine!

This is the primo bakery in McCall. They have nothing but the best homemade pastries, cookies, desserts, and coffees. I know they do catering (and their cakes are excellent), but I usually stop in for a smaller treat (or several) to go. I actually have to avoid going in there sometimes because it's just so good. Food: THE GINGER SNAPS... try the ginger snaps! They're spicy and soft and chewy. They leave an interesting aftertaste and you won't want to stop once you've tried one. I always pick up a package when I'm in town. I've also had their berry tarts and cookies. Drinks: The hot chocolate is rich and creamy. They don't hold back on the whipped cream. Yum! The coffee is also really good. Atmosphere: It smells like heaven in there! There's limited seating but if you can't find a spot, just take your order down to a bench by the lake. Service: Quick and super-friendly! They can offer recommendations if you let them know what you like. Happy Hour Offerings: n/a Healthy Hack: n/a Tips: n/a read more

Stacey Cakes - Stacey Cakes hot chocolate and ginger snaps - Bakeries Near Me - McCall, Idaho

Everything you want in a bakery AND wedding cakes too? Sign me up! They have a great selection of cookies and pastry/bread items. Bagels and Knishes are out of this world! OUT OF THIS WORLD!!!!! And I though that the prices were very low for the quality (and quantity) of the items. read more

Stacey Cakes - Bakeries Near Me - McCall, Idaho

I aspire to be like Stacey. Seriously, as a baker I hold her and this wonderful bakery in high regard. It is truly a gem. Some people wait in line at Ice Cream Alley, which is a great treat....but I wander down the road for a pastry confection that is pure and simple and divine. This shop not only is one of my top 5 favorite bakeries of all time, but it is super wonderful to be in. It's cute, cozy, and charming. You can see the kitchen from the front of the store. It smells heavenly and is worth every last cent. If you get to this wonderful little town, make sure to stop by, you will not be disappointed. We love to get a box of goodies to go as well, so we can enjoy these delicious treats for a day or two more. Stacey is the wife of the head chef at Rupert's, a lovely restaurant in town. I say, skip dinner, go straight to dessert. read more

See all

Stacey and crew made our mountain-themed wedding cake. It was beautiful and delicious! We went with carrot cake because Stacey said that's her specialty, and it didn't disappoint. Like the rest of her products, I do feel like the cake was pricey, but I'm glad we went with her for this special occasion. read more

Stacey Cakes - Bakeries Near Me - McCall, Idaho

Wonderful cinnamon roll and raspberry almond twice baked croissant. Everything looked and smelled so good. Good coffee. You can watch the process of production as well. Fun t-shirts with "who tarted" on the front. Courteous service and clean. read more

Stacey Cakes - Bakeries Near Me - McCall, Idaho

See all

Love this cute bakery! Stacey is incredible talented, and after getting the quiche and a foldover savory roll (forgot the name), I couldn't help but buy more cookies, brownies, and a loaf of sweet raspberry bread to take home. On the pricier side, but worth it for a homemade small town business. read more

The great bakery items (including the amazing ginger snaps!) are overshadowed by the poor customer service. Today, two young ladies were at the counter, neither offered a bag and left our items (2 bags of gingersnaps and three bakery items, plus two drinks) strewn on the counter for us to awkwardly collect and try to carry out the door. No take-out forks were available or offered. The coffee was too hot to serve without a cup sleeve (but those also were not available and when my partner tried to ask about that, and a bag, one gal just blurted out "have a nice rest of your day!" and scurried away). By the time we struggled to our vehicle and tried the coffee, it's clear the reason it was so hot is because it had been sitting on the heating element all day and tasted so burnt we threw it out. Wish we could get our tip back. We won't be coming back after this experience. read more

Definitely hard to choose from the incredible selection of freshly baked goods. There was good energy going on as 3 or 4 gals worked happily in the kitchen though the cashier was a bit reserved. After I paid for my order, the person after me, obviously a local, ordered the lemon Danish and I was overcome with FOMO for a moment. Dang. The individual salted caramel cheesecake was unreal. We also loved the mini ginger cookies which were perfectly chewy and very gingery. The huckleberry coffee cake slice is tainting me from the fridge as I write this and I hope it will survive the night to be enjoyed on our plane ride home with a cup of black coffee tomorrow. The drip coffee was decent, definitely better than the coffee we had at the Mountain Java or the Payette dream diner. read more

Ordered a carrot cake for my wife's birthday cake for the second year in a row and both were amazing. Wow. Carrot cake with all the right spices topped with butter cream frosting. Looking forward to next year but I will make sure I order with plenty of lead time as we almost didn't get it done due to Stacey's busy July calendar. Lucky for me she had an extra one ready to go. read more

I don't know what else I could say other than this place is awesome! We've had a number of different items from their selection and have never been disappointed in anything. read more

Stay away from this place if you are trying to be healthy! My husband and daughter came home with peppermint red velvet cupcakes, raspberry fudge bars, chocolate explosion cake and some cookies for BREAKFAST! it was all amazing and I am going tomorrow morning to see what else they have YUMMM!!!! read more