We've been coming here for 14 years, but after our latest visit, we won't be back. A few years ago,…read morethe restaurant changed ownership. They remodeled the interior, and while some may like the update, we miss the old-school supper club atmosphere. The menu has also been cut down and is now pretty bare bones. The service was slow even though the restaurant wasn't busy. We waited over 30 minutes for our food, and they forgot our appetizer. The prices have increased, but the quality and value have definitely gone in the opposite direction. I always ordered the Pub Special and could never finish it because the portions were so generous. This time, the portion was noticeably smaller, the bun was soggy, the sandwich had no flavor, and the au jus was only lukewarm. To make matters worse, fries are now an extra charge. Overall, it was a very disappointing experience. A place that was once one of our favorites has lost the atmosphere, quality, and value that kept us coming back for so many years. Unfortunately, we won't be returning.

They have a gluten free section on the menu but the chef doesn't have a clue. I ordered ground…read moresteak off the gf menu and told the server i needed gf as listed on the menu. It came topped with breaded onion straws which i removed and then found the meat covered with a creamy flour based gravy. I sent it back for a new order while the rest of the group ate. I asked to see a manager to complain and the server said the owner wan't there and didn't seem to be a manager there. The server said the chef wasn't familiar with the gf menu. Wow

Super yummy pub food, friendly and fun staff. Sign a dollar bill and pin it on the walls with the…read morerest!

I work in customer service, so when someone says they are going out for a fish fry I'll ask where's…read moreyour favorite place to go? 9/10 it's Murtaughs. So of course I have to try it and let me tell you... it did NOT disappoint! I have eaten there there before and had their delicious deli sandwiches and their burgers are cooked to perfection, but wow! It's all you can eat deep fried pollack. Made to order beer battered or cajun. Included Murtaugh's clam chowder(I WANTED TO BATHE IN THIS STUFF, SO GOOD!), coleslaw, rye bread, their famous made from scratch potato salad (YUMMO! ) or french fries, lemon & tarter. And yay! They had malt vinegar! I love that with my fish. And let's not forget our bartender (sorry sir, I forgot your name ) but he was just on top of EVERYTHING! Fast, polite, engaging and a great smile! Thank you folks at Murtaughs! Oh shoot!! And David the cook!! The Oz. The man behind the curtain. Thank you all for making it great!

In the middle of nowhere in Rhinelander, Wisconsin lies a…read morebar in the middle of a dark road its menu on a Friday was an enigma is it only the Friday menu? the fish fry was the main attraction, with your choice of perch or haddock Haddock I chose, with either fries or red potatoes as a side I chose the reds, but I had regret. I should have gotten the fries. the fish fry was good and flaky. the atmosphere was what you'd expect for a town of only a few thousand. Kitchen open until 9 or 10ish. Recommended :)

The bartender was friendly. Hamburgers are fresh, never frozen and tasty. Onion rings and French…read morefries were tasty and crispy. Other food options sounded delicious! They roast their own pork butts.

Ended up here because our first choice was closed. Glad it was closed because this place was so…read morephenomenal that we came back that night for dinner! Service was friendly and on point. Atmosphere was your typical small town bar vibe. My husband had the Cuban and said it was the best he has ever had. This place always a fun find for us in Rhinelander.

Genuinely WTF are you doing if you haven't gone here literally the best food too THE GARLIC CHEDDAR…read moreBURGER but honestly the whole menu is 5 stars never been disappointed

Our first visit today on 'wiener Wednesday'. We each had a $5 hot dog - traditional Chicago for me…read moreand BBQ for my guy (came with onion, bacon & BBQ sauce). Both were delicious! A tiny bit disappointed the bun wasn't poppyseed, but it was good enough as is. We shared sides of sweet potato fries (generous portion) and onion rings. Both were tasty & hot. Topped it off with some drinks & it was a perfect lunch. Our server, Nancy, was friendly & attentive. The place is cute inside - a sizable bar with a small dining room, decked out in typical Northwoods fashion. Check it out!

We have been here twice now and had awesome meals both times. Service can be a little slow but it…read moregets busy and there is one waitress. The food is worth waiting for and the wait time is just what we need to have a real conversation with the company we are with. First time lunch stop was on a Friday fish day and walleye bites were ordered. The report is that they were delicious and were tasted by two in the party. I'm gf and don't care for fish so did not taste. The other party member had wings and said they were excellent along with his side of onion rings. I had the Philly cheesesteak sandwich on a gluten free bun. The bun held up well and the sandwich with a side of sweet potato fries was delicious. Second time here my husband had the special of Chicago style hot dogs, I had the steak sandwich on gf bun and the other in our party had the hot beef sandwich. We all enjoyed our meals and look forward to coming back. The food is just downright good for a fair price. Not sure why only one waitress but guessing they only need one for the kitchen to keep pace. There is seating outside but I think it is just used when they have entertainment. Everyone seems to be enjoying their bar seats and restaurant meals.

I can't believe we haven't stopped here before. This place was amazing !!! We had a group of 7…read morearrive on a Saturday around 4pm for a early dinner/late lunch. The bartender was absolutely a gem and so sweet. Kam or Kal ? I know it was with a K. I lagged on writing this review so I forgot her name. I hope we get waited on again by her ! To start- the Bloody Mary- WOW. Absolutely huge and had awesome flavor. They make their own mix and the toppings were delicious. Loaded with deliciousness!!!! 10/10. Everything our party ordered was so amazing. To start - the bacon appetizer was out of this world, the cheese curds were probably the best I've ever had, and onion strings (again the best ever). From the steak, the walleye, sandwiches, pasta, prime rib, salmon, etc .... OUTSTANDING. Super flavorful and some top notch food. We absolutely cannot wait to go back !!!

Good food. New owners are constantly fixing and rebuilding…read moreand refurbishing. They are trying to update and make it look nice. Also, currently working on a new outside area, so summertime can be enjoyed even more. Expect more fun bands, and things outside.

Nice stop in the lake, a decent amount of boat parking. Inside is small and the outside area is…read morevery nice on the water, great views and lots of boat traffic. The staff as attentive to our table and quick. The drink menu was big. The daiquiri and pina colada were from a smoothie machine and not super frozen so on a hot day it doesn't last long. I got the chicken bacon ranch wrap with sweet potatoes fries. The sweet potato fries were good but feel like missing a dipping sauce with them. The wrap was a good portion, I prefer a little more sauce. The fish fry plate was big, 3 pieces of fish. The batter was crispy. The corn bread was yummy.

Fun place on the water. Good food but not inexpensive. Service was friendly but not particularly…read morefast. Must be patient. Sat outside close to the dock, was a beautiful sunny day and not too hot. Wifey had a salad with grilled chicken. Looked very good and ended up as part of the clean plate club. Friends had pulled pork sliders which looked very good. Three small rolls with pork, cole slaw and a dressing. Fourth adult had fish tacos with side of fries. Fish portion was modest. One child had beef tacos, must not have been very good because only a half was eaten. Child number two had a corn dog and fries. Can't complain about the food, but the prices were a little high for what we received. Recommend as a great place to stop while on the lake but would not journey there for other meals.

Stopped in one time for a meat raffle. Definitely a local bar…read more Bloody Mary was delicious and spot on. You were supposed to get the glass with it, they must have forgot. Only had the shaved beef sandwich to share, was 4 star. Good au jus to go along with it.

A Lake Tom staple! Great for a night out. Although if you aren't a regular it can be intimidating,…read moreeveryone knows each other. Always friendly and great staff. Go for the drinks and smiley fries.