I lived in Carthage a long time ago. I was at the original location across the street that burned…read moredown over 20 years ago. This place was still pretty good. Attentive service. I was alone and I was seated immediately. The restaurant was clean. Nice decorations. I do love pizza, but I've been eating a lot of pizza on this trip so I got a pasta dish. The manicotti. It was a little heavy on the cheese on top for sure. It was good but in the end, I guess I wish I would've got a pizza. Standard selection of National and some regional beer. I got a bottle of Yuengling. Street parking out front, parking lot in the back. There's a rear entrance as well.

Just ordered wings,pizza salad to go who ever is on the fryer ,ruined those wings,fried to a…read morecrisp,Mr.Stefano would not have them served! DISAPPOINTED

Kind of disappointed. I've been going for years, and slowly things have gotten worse. Went in for…read moredinner on Tuesday, right around 6:00. I honestly didn't know if they were open at first because there was no one there. Went inside and was seated. There was one other table of people eating and no one else in the dining area. Also another table completely covered and not bussed. We waited for 15 minutes after being seated before anyone even came to the table to ask about drinks. Took our drink and appetizer order. 5 minutes later, server returns with no drinks and lets us know that neither options for appetizers were available. Needless to say, we left.

Slow service, bad food, very expensive!! Very very disappointing. Steak was overcooked, we…read moresmelled like grease when we left . Never again!!

Kind of a hole-in-the wall place with decent food and good service…read more Not much to look at from the outside and the inside isn't that spectacular either, but it is clean. Tried their burnt ends and they were tasty. A little heavy on the dry rub. The hubs got a king burger and he enjoyed it. I had the burger with peanut butter, and it was pretty tasty. Fries were the crinkle cut kind and were nice and tasty.

I'm a 67 year old white male with an affinity for good home cooking. I started going to the whistle…read morestop after my mom told me I ate way too many pancakes. I ate 67 in one sitting at the whistle stop! My favorite thing to eat at the whistle stop is the 67 Oz. Fried fish platter and the 6.7 oz serving of pudding. You have to try the owners special 67 sauce which they slather on everything. It is to die for! I could drink the 67 sauce by the gallon. The ambiance is simply amazing. Most of the waitresses are a perfect 6.7 out of 10. Some of them are so beautiful I would walk 6.7 uphill both ways in the freezing cold just to get a serving of 67 sauce. Don't take my word for it. Go here immediately and make sure you have enough money. I can guarantee you will tip higher than 6.7%!!

Cash Only. We moved…read moreto Carthage this year, and from what I can tell we have two pizzerias here in town. The reviews were good enough, and we would have come sooner but we usually order earlier than 4:30. We finally gave them a call when our pizza day ran a bit late. We were taking the dog to the park, so we had plenty of time to wait. We called them right at 4:30 to place the order right as we were pulling into the park. The place wasn't a traditional restaurant layout. It seemed like it could have actually just been a house with a pizzeria incorporated into it. There's no parking lot, just what appears to be a personal driveway. We parked by the curb next to the building, figuring it was just a quick pickup anyway. There's no online presence and no menu pics, so we just kept it simple and got a large pepperoni. No wings or anything extra, just because we wanted to see what the options were first. We got there some time after 5:00 where we found out we found out they have a specific protocol for ordering. They said they don't even start cooking until 5:45 I think, and they usually take all the orders for the night up front before they start. Everyone we talked to was very friendly though, and since it was just a pizza they said they'd throw it in now for us. We had actually regretted not ordering wings, but they couldn't throw them on without a considerably longer wait time so we stuck with the pizza. We had our dog with us, so we walked around the block while we waited. When we got back to the car, the pizza was sitting in the passenger's seat, so we didn't have to go back in. The pizza itself was below average. It had homemade low effort pizza vibes. Like what you'd throw together after work with dough and sauce you bought from Aldi. There was nothing special about it, and it didn't have much taste. I think most of the reviews here raving about the pizza are from people who grew up eating it, so that's a whole different thing. I feel the same way about my hometown pizza place. I usually order at least twice before I leave a review, but I don't think I'll be coming back. Nothing egregious on their end, and I always recommend you try everywhere once and see what works for you. They've got nothing every other place doesn't have better, in better timing, and usually with online ordering.

We grew up with this family & this restaurant and are so pleased that the tradition continues…read more Pizza & antipasto are always our "go to" but they have a nice assortment of sides too. Very friendly, always busy!

Unfortunately just moved away from Carthage and I miss this place already. I realized I never left…read morea review but this place is a gem. You can't go wrong with the food, the atmosphere, or the service. If more people on Fort Drum knew about it, I feel like it would hold a lot more going away dinners. If you're on Drum consider doing one here--they have a shot ski! I'll be back every time I visit and can't wait to have the wings and Hall Pass fries again.

Such a good time for Karaoke on a Friday night!!! Food here is delicious!! Drinks won't…read moredisappoint!!! Definitely recommend coming by and having a good time!! Fire pit in the back to get some warmth while you're smoking or getting some fresh air!!! Come check it out

Terrible experience. No air conditioner, salad bar had rusty lettuce and very little other…read moreingredients. The bathroom sink was half full of what looked like sewer water and an employee had just walked out without washing his hands. We decided to get a pan pizza to go. It had raw dough and gave use a stomach ache. Will never go back to that location.

Pizza tasted great. Service was great. Woman at the front, I think she's the manager was very nice…read moreand attractive. The restaurant was very clean and nice.

Great food. Fish Entree was fresh and tasted amazing. Large portions. We were thoroughly full…read more Appetizers were fresh ingredients and tasty. Love the Irish bar food on the menu. Everyone Hustled and worked together for an excellent service experience. Restaurant and bar look amazing inside. Highly recommend giving this restaurant a taste. Well worth traveling 20 minutes to eat great food.

Service was good. Atmosphere is nice. food is not too good. The cook can't cook a steak. Steak was…read moreraw. Boneless chicken wings were dry & pretty much tasteless. Poutine was okay though. A bit pricey, considering the lack of quality.

suuuuuumbitch! this some damn good pizza and you already know damn well for a bunch of drunk ass…read moresoldiers in the E4 mafia living in the barracks slamming booze all night you dont have to be too special to please us. Its right on post too and I've even heard about them being decently quick to folks that live over on the airfield, but we ordered 9 big pies and then we just kept drinking. But I do remember checking the time and we completed the order at 21:05 and I ain't even shitting you the delivery guy was at the CQ desk at 22:09 and because we were just getting wasted in the barracks the time between the order and the pies showing up went super fast! the delivery fella was a swell guy and requested that we check our pizzas right in front of him so we did just that and every pie was exactly what we ordered. I can understand how sometimes they'll get a bad review but for cryin out loud they're the only pizza place on post and open as late as they are on the weekends and theres a TONS of assholes like us living in the barracks and lots of times thats damn near all we eat on the weekends.......well pizza AND copious amounts of alcohol. So you cant be too picky, like my mama used to say "you get what you get and you don't throw a fit" hahahahaha but anyway it can be hit or miss and I'm sure they dont have enough folks working there during the hours when they need to have them. So needless to say as a bunch of drunk ass barracks partying soldiers we were thoroughly impressed and happy with our pizza pies baby yeeeeeeeeeah!

So i guess the driver wasn't satisfied with the tip i left so my recipt says one price but my bank…read moresays more. Driver just put in their own tip and i know they can do this since they asked me once when i forgot.

This place is AMAZING. The outside is very cute and the inside is cozy. Our server was very…read morefriendly with an awesome smile. We started off with the MP's (mozzarella sticks) and In The Trenches (Nashville hot chicken dip) which were so good I forgot to take a picture. The menu was super fun with a great variety. I will definitely be back here.

Food was delicious! My burger was cooked to perfection, fries were hot...crispy and flavorful…read more SUPER clean spot, with amazing staff. In the middle of nowhere but definitely worth the drive.