Unfortunately, The Homestead is no longer at this location. It has moved to West Lafayette, IN. The…read morefood was excellent and it is sorely missed in the community.

Food is very good. Service could be a bit better, but overall is fine. Ambiance is great.read more

I had a great experience at New York City Deli. I ordered a turkey sandwich, and it was excellent…read more They make it really easy to fully customize your sandwich, which I appreciate, and they use high-quality Boar's Head meats--you can definitely taste the difference. My wife got the Italian which is her staple lunch selection. She really enjoyed her sandwich and a 1/2 was plenty for her. Portion-wise, it was perfect for me. I'm not someone who needs huge servings, and the sandwich was just the right size--honestly, it worked well as a half sandwich for lunch across two days. For a couple bucks more, you can get extra meat Which we did not do. Great quality, flexible options, and a practical portion size. I'll definitely be back.

I ordered the Big New Yorker which was supposed to be corned beef and pastrami. When I get home, 40…read moreminutes away, I got an NYC Special which is roast beef and turkey. They had it marked correctly on their order checklist but made the wrong sandwich. The toppings on it obviously were for the wrong sandwich too, which made it less appetizing. They need to get their sandwiches straight.

Very displeased lately. Salads have only been half of the to go bowl. With the prices, they…read moreshould be full. I haven't been getting what I have ordered either. I order thru Door Dash but this isn't their fault, it's Arni's. We stopped in on a Saturday and the young girls couldn't get our order right. I also stopped on an evening and ordered a salad, burgers and other items. The burger was the nastiest thing you could eat. I am about done with Arni's. It was not like this with the past owners!

FULL DISCLOSURE ... this is not my favorite place to eat. But my wife likes it so I have a go to…read moremeal that I will eat. But more about that in a minute. This afternoon, November 29, 2020 at 4:11 pm, I called in an order: - Individual sausage pizza - 1/2 Stromboli sandwich with fries (today's special) - Large Southern Fried Chicken salad (my go-to meal) The young man who took the order informed me it would be 20 minutes. So I hung up and waited a few minutes befor I headed over there. When I arrived, I put my mask on and went to the door that had the sign I am including with this post, on the door. I specifically says that all customers are required per our Governor's order earlier this month, to mask up. Well, lets start with that sign. It says specifically that the public is required to wear a mask to enter. It says nothing about the employees. Here are my concerns ... 1-Of the 4 employees inside; 1 female wore a mask correctly, 1 female had a well protected chin (mask was not covering her mouth or nose), 2 males had no mask at all. 2-I wish I took a picture of this ... there is no barrier between the customer and the person manning the register --- NOR --- between the customers and the food / pizzas being cut and packaged. You can reach over and grab a piece if you want one! Then came the order! Remember that at the beginning? The clerk tried to charge me $9.95 for an individual pizza they list as $4.99 + $0.50 for the sausage. Then there was the salad ... really the only thing I like on the menu. They gave me a small salad instead. When I called them on it, they were going to give me more lettuce, charge me for a large and I would have to do without the balance of the meat and toppings. My wife's Stromboli was ... different. It was supposed to be 1/2 sandwich and fries. She got that and potato chips as well. The screw up's with the food I can get over. You have to be sure of what you order, what they give you and what they charge. The deal-breaker is taking so LITTLE concern for me and their employees by not providing a barrier between the customer and employees / food. But the most damning part of this all is the completely lax attitude of the employees when it comes to complying with the very order of the Governor of the State of Indiana that they have no problem REQUIRING me to abide by. I am limited to 1 star because Yelp will not allow a "0".

Really enjoyed my sandwich combo! They have assortment of panini style pressed sandwiches, cold…read moresandwiches and create your own. Perfect deli spot to get a something for lunch. There are places to sit inside or easy to get your order to go. I got the roast beef with Swiss, yum. Served with chips as pickle. I thought for the size of the sandwich and combo it was priced well. Staff was really friendly. Highly recommend for your next lunch spot.

I am 77 years old and have worked in every state, 14 foreign countries, and seven major bodies of…read morewater. I love blue cheese dip and good smoked wings. Ollies has the very best blue cheese dip I have ever eaten from a restaurant or most people's home. The wings were smoked and they were excellent. Service matched for food. I gave Ollie's five stars only because there was no way I could give them 10. If you're in Plymouth, Indiana, and you're hungry, the quality and quantity of the food can't be beat!

Everything I've tasted so far has been absolutel fabulous and has tasted amazingly fresh!…read more I called the store today and spoke with Michelle simply to let her know how good my breakfast burrito tasted and that I love there cinnamon rolls!! Such an affordable and tasty hidden gem.

The atmosphere was charming. Very clean, well-maintained. Rem…read moreInds you of a small country store Or a quaint Amish store I frequent. The food cost is on the higher side. The quality is good. You place your order as soon as you enter. We were unsure as to how it worked so went to look at the salad bar. It was ok nothing spectacular. They also had soup. All food in this area is weighed and you pay by the ounce. Reminded me of a hospital cafeteria except it was more expensive. I was never sure how much per ounce. A friend had the chicken salad sandwich which was on the most wonderful croissant. Chicken salad is very thickly applied. It was good not over the top but good also we split a coconut cream pie. It was on the heavy side a lot of coconut and not much pudding. I like my coconut cream nice and fluffy. . For a very small salad and the chicken sandwich, it was 39. Dollars a bit much.

This is an adorable market/deli with great focaccia pizza and beautiful pastries. Service is very…read morefriendly too.

The little bites of focaccia as samples were a nice touch. It's a pretty cool market that has a lot…read moreof fun items to buy like coffee, pasta, bread, sauces, candy, etc. We got the motzo ball soup and salad. The matzo ball soup cup had dark meat chicken and didn't have a lot of flavor. It's also a very tiny cup. The garden salad was delicious and fresh, however. The side of coleslaw was also good. Maybe next time I'll try a sandwich or their focaccia pizza slices. Plenty of parking and lots of options for lunch.

One of the best Italian subs I've ever had. We're from outta town so wanted to grab something. The…read moreservice was super sweet and friendly. Cute little deli with lots of Italy supplies I could spend a lot of time in there.

Stopped in today after a work meeting for the first time and was completely blown away. I love the…read moreambience of the European grocery store/deli with a very nice dedicated seating area. All of the sandwich options they had available sounded amazing and my friend and I both had sandwiches that completely filled us up and were amazing. We were very impressed with everything about the place. Price quality and service was amazing. Can't wait to stop back in next time!

Little old fashioned deli butcher shop. Totally recommend them. The selection and prices are very…read morecomparable. Great service, excellent products

Online ordering apparently has errors. Ordered 6 3packs of sandwich ribeye and when picked up it…read moredidn't seem right I asked clerk is this 18 and was told should be got to my tailgate and had 6 steaks. I had 18 people so it was frustrating. I will say gave me a full refund but would have preferred the steaks.

Their Polish sausage is REAL POLISH SAUSAGE. Lots of other Polish items but this little country…read morestore by the side of the road is a gem.

You can order what want. It's all the best. Only place we get our fresh sausage. It is out of…read moreChicago. Been getting it from her for 10 yrs!

Awesome burgers - great friendly midwestern waitress and did I mention this is a destination spot…read moretoo?

Stopped here for a break and lunch while passing through Indiana. The Farmhouse Restaurant menu…read moresaid they offer a "quick & casual lunch" and well, they weren't lying about the casual part... We ordered two lunches, both the 1/2 grilled cheese and soup. One with tomato soup and the other with chili. We also ordered the *special* $5 egg salad sandwich. The grilled cheese came out as some cheese microwaved between a soft burger bun. Really disappointing and crappy. The chili and soup were okay. The egg salad sandwich was very basic and lacking flavor, served on classic white bread. It was also a weird dining setup, it felt like we were eating in a giant and deserted beer hall. Total transparency: we both expected more from one of the nation's largest dairy farms. We also thought the food would be a little cleaner, like a farm-to-table experience and less processed, but it tasted like food we could get at a gas station. My husband was disappointed with the ice cream selection at the milk bar, he was hoping for more of a variety other than the basic strawberry, chocolate, vanilla, etc. We also needed to get DEF for our truck from the Fair Oaks BP and my husband called it "highway robbery" for the cost we paid. He said it was 2 or 3 times what he normally pays. In summary, a total tourist trap with crappy lunch food. I also didn't know about their animal abuse case from 2019 until after we left. And the allegations about neglect and improper slaughter in 2023. Gross and sad.