Used to go to this place in 94 when I lived in Geneseo. Best sandwich ever. Nothing else compared…read moreand I've had them in NYC and Philly but these sandwiches were so awesome. Glad they are still open 32 years later.

Sigh :( I love Aunt Cookies. A staple of my childhood. But wow their staff needs some anger…read moremanagement classes. Lil' miss frumpy sub maker lady did not wake up on the right side of the bed today. When I asked if I would receive a text when my to-go order was ready, the response was "where do you think you are New York City?" in a tone that was more hostile than all the burroughs combined. But I knew exactly where I was and my tone and question did not deserve a response like this. Frumpy sub maker lady continued to dish out her rudeness saying that we were wasting her time for asking questions and sarcastically gave back the tip we had given. My tone never shifted from start to finish, even after calling out the poor service. I do not like to call out establishments, especially local businesses, but holy shit she was rude. Probably the rudest food service experience I've ever had. Best sub rolls in upstate ny though...that will always be true. It is always a choice to be an asshole. If frumpy sub maker lady reads this -- it is ALWAYS a choice. Choose kindness, my dear :) Just because your day is ruined by having to make a few subs, it doesn't mean you have to try to ruin someone else's day.

Visited on the Saturday before Easter. It was a pleasant experience with lots of beer options. The…read moredesign and the history of the building is amazing. Tucked in off 20A on Millenium drive. Definitely recommend a stop if you are in the area.

Burgers are small. A sandwich, burger joint that relies on…read morecheese for flavor. Most items have cheese. Reuben was dry, fries limpy. Swiss burger was bland until you add the sauce.

Honestly, the food is delicious. The home fries were well done, just needed salt. The BEST had a…read moreperfectly runny egg and well done bacon. Unfortunately, I will not be coming back. It was a little busy when we got here, around 11:50am, but nothing too bad. We ordered our food and sat down, after about 45 minutes we were wondering where our food could be. I asked the server and she rudely responded with "the wait time is an hour". We were NEVER told that when we came in, and honestly it was a bit ridiculous due to the amount of people in there. Won't be coming back.

We stopped by for a bagel and coffee but instead we ended up having a great breakfast with corned…read morebeef hash and eggs very good staff was very friendly and a cozy place off the main road. Loved it I highly recommend stopping

The food was so fresh! The gentleman behind the counter was very helpful as my Aunt and I could not…read moredecide on what to get, so he gave us great suggestions!!! The quaint restaurant had a calm and peaceful ambiance. Will be back when in the area for sure!!!

This is a wonderful lunch spot in Geneseo!! The staff is super chill and lovely to talk to. They…read moreare also on their A game. They have some great options to customize your own salad and everything is tasty and seems fresh. Highly recommend for students because the prices are fair for good portion size

I consider myself a sub/wedge/grinder expert, coming from New Jersey. These subs are very, very…read moregood. The combo, Tuna and, mushroom veggie are my recommendation. The service is very friendly. The ambiance is typical sandwich shop but, a step above. Please give them a try.

Pizza is super thin! Sauce is awful. What happened?? It…read moreused to be good. They also took away their pizza sub which was excellent!

Usually this place is amazing however, my experience today was very upsetting. Burned food and…read morethey let me leave with it--. I drove half an hour home to find burnt grilled cheese both sides and burnt hot dogs- both sides and that extra meat sauce that I paid for...not there. My order total was $16.68 and I didn't have to tip on a to go order but I thought I was being nice by making it an even $20...very upsetting.

Reviewed 3 months ago, and I don't know what is happening. I get it, it's a college town, I guess…read moreyou can do whatever and you'll still have people eat downgraded quality food. Two of my friends got UHots and so I thought of getting some. One friend was missing a side of fries. The other didn't have a bun for a damn cheeseburger! For me, I got grilled cheese with a double order of mac and cheese. Mac and cheese was good, but god the grilled cheese has been burnt consistently the past week or so. Do the people not know how to make a grilled cheese without making the bread completely black and charcoal tasting? It's become too consistent now to give a, "oh, but they typically are fine"-esque excuses.

Worst place to eat . Staff always on phone and chatting it up with each other . Ignoring orders …read more Rude and way to talkative. Girl barely speaks English and is super slow at making subs and doesn't heard a word when you tell her what you want. Guy with tattoos is always on his phone.

Worst sub I've ever had!!! It was bad ! And the kid that made it.... I think he was dead !!!!!read more

Lunch was delicious, we started with salsa, queso, cheese dip and guacamole. I had the burrito with…read morethe 3 sauces, the green sauce is definitely spicy and the burrito was huge. My partner had the taco salad which he thought could have had more chicken. Overall good with average service

The food was delicious from the warm chips and queso dip, to my quesadillas and hard taco. Service…read morewas very good. We were in right at lunchtime on a Tuesday. Very pleased with our meal. I found the decor welcoming and clean. First time going there, will for sure return.

We were driving from Buffalo to Newark and had to make a quick food stop. We spotted Mama Mia's and…read morepulled right in. We got a slice of their pepperoni pizza, and it was so good we ended up ordering two more! It's thin, a little greasy, and light - just yummy. We did the lunch special with a drink for just under $10, totally worth it. Service was good, fast, and friendly, and the ambiance was cozy and clean.

The pizza is really good. It is thin crust. I also thought the service was pretty well. He actually…read moreput extra dough in it to make it a little extra wider for me and the place is clean when I went to pick up the pizza and it was really quiet there was no one there.

Ordered chocolate covered cookie dough and chocolate peanut butter ice cream. It was SO good. Also…read moregot the Holy Cow which is a classic. Staff was friendly and offered me a sample of the banana ice cream. Great experience!

So don't give me wrong I love their milkshakes completely. I went with my kids to get one over the…read moreweekend and I saw something gray in the blueberry ice cream and didn't realize what it was until I took a closer look and it was a pen. I told her about it. She took the pen and threw it out, and I asked her if she had another tub of the Maine blueberry and she said real quick, no. So we waited there a while and then I also let the cashier know about the ice cream and nobody ever took it out in the 20 minutes or more that we were standing there. I think that's gross.