Used to go to this place in 94 when I lived in Geneseo. Best sandwich ever. Nothing else compared and I've had them in NYC and Philly but these sandwiches were so awesome. Glad they are still open 32 years later. read more

Sadly, we left with a bad taste and no food. Went in about 20 mins after they opened and were told it would be about 30 minutes before they could make 1 sub for us. The 2 guys were "doing the best they could" with 5 online orders which they chose to put before the only customers in the store. Not sure when online orders became priority over in-person customers? Won't be going back until the customer service is restored to what we remember, likely when it comes under new ownership. Used to be such a good place for food! read more

I had someone pick up a turkey sub for me. It was good! I love a Wegmans so I don't feel this compares!

This place is amazing! My husband and I were in town so we stopped by because we needed lunch and it was the first place we found. My husband had a tuna sub and I had a turkey sub, both subs were really good. The bread was so soft and the taste from both subs were really good! We will be back! read more

This place is a local legend. I had the occasion to try it finally and I can see why. Friendly service, generous portions, reasonable wait time. I ordered a steak sub that was prepared just right - fixings were perfect, steak well-seasoned and juicy. Luckily they had an open table where I could hang out and enjoy my edible work of art! I thought the office was also on par and reasonable as well. I'll be back for sure. read more

We stopped at Aunt Cookies sub shop for a quick bite during our travel. The place was really busy but Kat at the counter patiently took our order and also helped set up a table for us based on our request. We ordered 2 12" veggie subs with extra toppings - olives, pickle and green peppers in seeded bread. The subs were very fresh and bread was delicious. It was perfectly made and the portion was generous. We really enjoyed our meal - special shout out to Kat for amazing service! Only feedback would be on very limited vegetarian options, would be interesting see creativity around few veg options. I would highly recommend Aunt Cookies Sub Shop to anyone looking for a quick simple meal options / sandwiches in the area. read more

See all

We hit up this place on move-in day at SUNY Geneseo on a whim. Definitely was not disappointed in the quality of the sub. I ordered the Italian Assorted Sub and it was great. The meat combination (Ham, Cappicola, Italian Salami) was better than a Wegmans Italian in my mind. The service was attentive and pretty fast considering it was busy and is right on Main Street next to the campus. I loved the shop overall for its ambiance which stuck to its original roots, even having the original sub sign with the prices when it opened on the wall. The next time I am at Geneseo and I want a sub, I would definitely skip over Wegmans and Subway to get an Aunt Cookies sub. read more

I'm sort of a sub snob and have to say, this was a WOW!!! Came highly recommended to my team and I who were working downtown in Geneseo for the day. The small Cookie that came with it was a nice touch too! Great job! That bread is the softest doughiest sub bread EVER! read more

At the advice of friends, we stopped here to pickup lunch for a picnic in Letchworth State Park. This unassuming shop has great sandwiches on the BEST breads. We had our subs on Italian bread which was lightly toasted. Toppings and condiments were fresh and generous. The mac salad reminded me of something I enjoyed as a kid at a family reunion. We also snagged some Loganberry, which I've not had since college. This was a great stop and we will be back to fuel up for our future Letchworth hikes. Don't mind my photos where they got slightly smashed in our cooler. I can attest that they were AWESOME! read more

See all

When my boyfriend said he wanted to drive 45 for a sub, I was skeptical. How could a sub be different, unique, and amazing?? Well it was worth the drive! I think the main thing that sets them apart is that they slightly toast the bread prior to putting anything in it which gives it a really nice taste and texture - I don't know any other sub place that does this. Plus they don't skimp on the meats or sauces, and the quality is really good. Definitely the best sub shop around!! read more

My brother has been raving about Aunt Cookies for years so today we ventured south to get a sub. Good lord was that sub fantastic. I had a seemingly simple turkey sub that was anything but simple. Every single bite of the sub was perfection. Highly recommend read more

Aunt Cookies Sub Shop - Half turkey sub - Sandwiches Near Me - Geneseo, New York

Stopped for lunch today based on yelp reviews and this sub shop did not disappoint! I think it's really hard to find a really well made sub with great bread-and I have to say this was one of the best subs I've ever had. The bread was fresh, tasty and perfectly toasted. High quality deli meat as well. Also, a large sub is a lot of food so it's great to share or save the other half for later. The macaroni salad was also delicious and one of the best I've eaten. The manager was lovely and pleasant. When we come back to Geneseo, we will definitely stop in again. read more

This is a decent place to get a sub. Vibes are very much so a sub shop ran by college students. Service can be a little slow, but I'd say it's worth the wait. I def recommend the steak sub. read more

Love! Moved to the area in October and am grateful to have found Aunt Cookies. Best BLTs.

Here is the deal, I used to go here back in the 70's when they were in Brockport NY . That being said, a sandwich is as only good as the bread and ingredients it is served on. When you grow up around NYC you are spoiled with the very best of all. This place is good when you are so drunk and cardboard just won't cut it. They are cheap with meat cheese etc and overload with lettuce filler. They are still in business which tells me people in that region wouldn't no what was goodi if bit them in the Ass. Case Closed. read more

Stopped by after a visit to SUNY Geneseo. This place came highly recommended by both students and staff. It is a quick walk from the campus and provides fantastic service and sandwiches. The staff were attentive and the portions were great. A large sub is easily a two person lunch endeavor. We, like the Geneseo population, highly recommend. read more

Absolutely superb service at this establishment. Have not come across a better sub; however, the experience was made even better by Gabe. 10 out of 10. read more

This sub place is a staple to the Geneseo community. It also has some of the best subs I have ever had in my life. I keep wanting to try other meats, but always get the first one I ever tried because its so good. I get the Italian assorted with all the standard toppings. It is toasted to perfection! Right in the heart of downtown this place is a true gem! I will one day have to try their other meats, looking forward to the tuna salad. read more

Aunt Cookies Sub Shop - Italian assorted all the toppings - Sandwiches Near Me - Geneseo, New York

Location has moved a few spots over. Grateful that it's still around since it's still one of my favorite places. Ordered my capicola and wished they had toasted the bun a little longer. Still enjoyed it. read more

See all

Still incredible subs. If you have fond memories of this place, fear not, the subs are essentially the same as they have ever been.

Always a hit and best subs in town. Also happy the staff were all wearing masks and taking safety & cleanliness precautions which made me feel comfortable. The turkey sub with everything on it always hits the spot! read more

After reading the reviews, my husband and I decided to try Aunt Cookies Subs while passing through Geneseo. After opening our subs, while the bread looked tasty, our subs overall were disappointing. We both ordered ham, but they were more like lettuce subs instead. The meat/lettuce ratio was way off and the total amount of ham on each sub was subpar (2 pieces thick). The bread on the other hand was delicious. In addition my husband's sub didn't have all of the toppings requested. Perhaps the employee working just didn't care enough to make as good a sub as previous reviews. read more

The subs are fabulous! The rolls are fresh And toasted!! I ordered a half a turkey sub with bacon. It is a huge half of a sub. It comes with all the fixings and there are plenty of others you can add including pickles and peppers. They are generous with their meat. I didn't even finish my half. I was not crazy for the macaroni salad, but that is my personal preference. It tasted like it was made with Miracle Whip. I don't know if it was, but it tasted sweet. Others may love it! But the subs!!! Definitely are worth it!!! read more

Ahhhh these subs are SO good! We were passing through town with some friends who swore that this place had the best subs. At first I was like, ok guys it's just subs...but they were speaking the truth!! Small little place with a few tables and vending machines for drinks. I ordered a half turkey sub with mayo, lettuce, onions and banana peppers. They toast all of their bread and it's delicious. Honestly, I NEVER get my subs toasted so I was a little shocked to see that they only offer the bread toasted. However, the toasted bread is perfect, thin but not too think and the toasted part adds the perfect amount of crunch while still maintaining the softness of the bread. Ahhh I'm in love with these subs. Can't wait to go back again!! Do yourself a favor and check this place out!!! I just finished my sub and wish I got a whole instead of a half!! read more

Aunt Cookies Sub Shop - Turkey sub - Sandwiches Near Me - Geneseo, New York

Owner was rude over the phone, and when I asked for an extra side of mustard I was told there was already "enough" on there. I did still push for the side. Also very limited options does not have enough toppings or ones you'd expect from a sub shop. $9 for a small half sub, way overpriced. read more

Seriously one of the best subs ever. Roasting the bun was nice. Tender roast beef. Experienced server knew what additions worked best. Highly recommended. read more

If you're in for a good sub, I'd recommend going here. I've gone a few times myself and always leave clutching onto my sub so no one takes it read more

Great subs a staple of Geneseo many college students have eaten there... looks greT out front and been in Geneseo for years

The toaster sesame bread is amazing. Definitely one of my favorite subs of all time. A very unassuming spot in a small town, but worth the drive for sure! We had an Italian and chicken salad sandwich - all good. read more

Passing through town. This was a quick and convenient stop. Parking was easy (off season?). Tasty sub, we all agreed. A little on the pricey side but I'd eat here again. Undergoing renovation- need to finish. Inside currently way too plain. read more

Jesus Christ, I love this place. There's something special about the rolls here that make the rest of the sub spectacular. It's kind of like combining Misty May and Kerri Walsh. Sure, the turkey here is top-notch, but when you add the toasted Italian roll, you have a championship team that will spike a volleyball at your face and have you crawling back to Latvia. My personalized sub here is turkey and swiss on Italian, with oil, lettuce, tomato, and banana peppers. Don't get the "hot peppers;" it's a hot pepper relish, of some sort, that will leave your insides on fire until it erupts out of your body like molten lava. The drink selection via vending machines is also awesome and features white tea, green tea, Starbuck frappucino, 2-3 kinds of milk, pop, and a large selection of SoBe products. Only bad thing: Aunt Cookie's doesn't accept credit cards, so be prepared. read more

Great sub, even better service. Thank you so much to Gabe for making it a wonderful trip with my family when they came to visit!

I got a turkey and swiss on wheat sub here to go. I was surprised how empty it was but maybe it had to do with school not being in session or something. The interior is drab and dingy, with discolored carpeting and cheap menu boards, so the draw of this place is definitely not the ambiance. The sub was better than average. The bread lives up to the hype and compensates for the meat which is packaged supermarket cold cut grade. I like how the menu has plenty of options but not too many, and ordering was pretty straightforward. The price is not competitive at all, probably more expensive than wegmans, but I guess a little price inflation is the norm in college towns. I didn't feel totally ripped off but you definitely pay for more than what you are getting. read more

See all

While this is my favorite sub shop. I've been really disappointed my last 2 visits. I keep finding the workers without their masks on and they immediately put it on when I come in. I said something to all 3 women and not one apologized for it today. One in fact, she was a red head gave me an attitude. I told them I was now going to report it. As a nurse I wear a mask daily. They should as well I don't want to get sick because they are being lazy or just don't think they are going to get covid or spread it. Please correct this behavior. read more

Good tasting subs for a great price. Tastier than subway by a lot! Lots of tasty option. We got the capicola on Italian. Fair prices.

What a great experience my daughter and I had when we stopped in to the sub shop two days ago. We were just meeting for a quick bite to eat in the middle of our workdays and the staff of two young ladies was so pleasant and nice. We were able to get a sub made and eat outside very quickly. Positive attitudes and great customer service and the cherry on the top was their thoughtfulness. We were delighted when they brought us a complimentary cookie for dessert. Highly recommend this wonderful business and looking forward to returning! read more

Aunt Cookies is a Geneseo staple so I have to give them 4 stars. People love their subs. Personally I never went there often as they don't really have a vegetarian option. They have a veggie sub, but it's just lettuce, tomato, onion and peppers, which isn't very satisfying as a meal. read more

Literally best sub ever. As a Geneseo college student and therefore food connoisseur I would recommend this place to everyone.

To my surprise, these are some of the best subs i have ever had! Taste great however not many options as to meats, cheese, toppings, and sauces. Sometimes less is more and definitely is true in this case. Interior is not huge and slightly under decorated but subs are really really great! read more

everytime i walk into aunt cookies, i'm not disappointed!! the subs are truly delicious, the sub rolls are toasted to the crisp, and they are full of so many delicious flavors. i've never had a bad experience here and i recommend to everyone !!! read more