Potbelly is everything I wanted (and needed) to get through the second half of my training day! I…read moreordered the skinny wreck, Diet Coke, and a lemon cookie. I'd forgotten how enormous the cookies are! I didn't get a pickle, which I immediately regretted, but was so full from everything else I doubt I would have been able to eat it! There next time I'm at the Carlisle, I'll be grabbing a pickle from Potbelly!

This was my first chance to stop in. I'm familiar with Potbelly Sandwich Shops and with a memory…read morerefresh from looking at their website, I knew I wanted their sandwich called A Wreck. It is a many meats and other toppings sandwich. I got it with "The Works", a set of toppings listed on the wall. This list includes hot peppers, I think I should exclude them next time. My sandwich was very good, toasted, and messy. Really good. Potbelly is an order at the counter and they make your sandwich to order, and there are tables inside if you want to stay to eat. The colorful décor is general and also Sarasota specific. The staff was fine, not chatty but got the sandwich made properly. No complaints.

I just finished my home delivery of grouper for dinner. I want to say it was very good and your…read moremeals so far have been far superior to another company I had been using. Thanks

Purchased a gift certificate for a family member for Christmas for food delivery. He went to use it…read moreand the website wasn't working. he tried calling twice and sent a text message and no reply. I sent an email and no reply. extremely frustrating. I understand businesses change but at least respond. and he could've sent an email to those with outstanding gift certificates to let them know of the upcoming business changes.

The food was delicious. Rose was our server, she was…read moreamazing. Even the manager checked on us a few times. Will be back. Dan S

The restaurant is at downtown Sarasota. Parking is easy. There is a garage on top of the building…read morefor the first hour free. We were here due to a coupon with discount. We have the two meats combo and the smoke chicken wings. The two meats combo we have is the brisket and the sausage. The brisket is always my favorite. They are juicy and tender. The smoke wings also good. Love it. The two side are collars green and Brussels sprouts. Overall is good experience. Service is kind of odd. The server we have see her for the first time and we have to ask another server to bring our needs.

What a disappointing experience. It's sad because the food was actually pretty good. Ordered online…read morepicked up order the receipt was significantly lower than what we paid. When I called and questioned it said because I ordered through doordash. The online ordering says no charge orders through doordash. As you can see there's a significant difference between doordash and picking up in person. I am upset because know where does it tell you that there's a charge it actually says no charge but you can see by the receipt that they charged me way more. If you value honesty with a business go somewhere else. Please look at the photos it says no charge then you can see what they charged us and what the actual charge was. This was an in-person pick up. When I called and questioned it they said oh it's because you ordered through doordash. Beware scammers

The best fried batter on fish and shrimp I've ever eaten. I'm very reasonable and excellent quality…read morefood.

This part is not their fault, but there were sooooo many "love bugs" at their entrance. I could not…read morestand out there without freaking out. Once our large group was seated, there were fans around us, so the bugs went away. I am from California, so I am not used to good service lol, so I was pleasantly surprised with all the "Yes ma'am," "Thank you, ma'am," etc. The server was nice and a total trooper with the number of people he had to keep track of because we all had separate checks. He did an amazing job, and we were extremely grateful. I tried their Housemade Crab Dip, and it was delicious. It was a great portion, really creamy, and well seasoned. For my meal, I had the Admiral's Platter. Everything was delicious, not too oily, and I loved the dipping sauces that came with it. Overall, it was a great experience with great service. If I'm ever back in Sarasota, I would love to come back.

We were very disappointed with our food. This place is missing an opportunity to be a great…read morevacation dining spot. First, we'll start with the good. The location is amazing. We sat on the water and enjoyed a beautiful view. The decor and atmosphere is beachy and relaxing. The cocktails were good. The parking is convenient. The bad part that made it disappointing. The food was not great. My grouper sandwich was fair. It was kinda bland. The slaw was dry. The fish and chips was odd. The fries were decent. The fish was inside a very thick coating of batter. The crab legs were good. The coconut shrimp were good but too heavily battered. The green beans on the side were totally unseasoned. The worst was the chicken sandwich. It was tasteless with a a thick greasy batter. It was bad. Once we decided to send it back our server took forever to return to table to check on us. We were mid meal before we checked on. My daughter decided to pickup something else at a different restaurant after we left. How do you mess up a chicken sandwich? Unless you are just coming in for drinks(or crab legs) I would recommend a different choice of restaurant. The view adds one star to the rating.

Visited yesterday while in Sarasota for lunch. We decided to hit the drive-thru before heading to…read morethe beach. When we pulled up at the ordering station and a young lady answered to take our order. I'm not sure if the speaker was going o but it was hard to understand if the Order was getting through. We finished ordering and got to the next window and we paid and waited for our food. Overall it took about 10minutes for our food to be ready when we got it we started pulling off as my husband was handing out everyone's food he noticed they didn't put his sandwich in the bag they put a burger instead so I pulled back around so he could go talk to them inside. He explained that they gave him the wrong sandwich and when he told them that they kept saying they definitely put it in the bag so he came back out checked our bag and the kids bag and of cno blt chicken... he went back in and told him which they said they were 100% sure it was in the bag at this point there was no way I could prove except if they wanted to search my car I was so shocked that they made him come back out to look again! I told him to please get a refund and we aren't coming back over a sandwich that could have been easily fixed! They did give us a refund thankfully but wow what a hassle over a sandwich.

Solid franchise with a solid burger and fries. The fries are extra thin cut and delicious…read moreespecially when hot. Love the retro vibes of the place and prefer eating in to taking out. That was my mistake this weekend. I decided to do the drive through and the people in front of me were the slowest people in the world!! It would have been better to just park and go in. Granted it was my first time using the drive through so maybe it's not always like that.

We recently discovered this restaurant and are so glad we did. The service was amazing and the food…read morewas great. What really impressed me was a wash station that was right inside the entrance. No need to visit the restroom if all you need to do is wash up before your meal. My husband and I split the 5 Crispy Tenders and Fries meal. The tenders were huge and it was plenty of food for the two of us. Everything was perfect. We will be back.

Decided to stop by for a quick bite before heading to the airport! You order from the self service…read morekiosk and then they call your name when the food is ready. It took some time as the food was cooked to order ... Overall, the chicken sandwich was okay. The fries were way too salty. Overall, it was okay.

My crew needed to find something to eat before it was too late so we chose this Popeyes. From the…read moremoment we pulled into the parking lot we should have left. The doors were posted open. This is Florida. It was hot outside and inside. Apparently their air went out. The hear affects everything in a fast food restaurant. The employees did the best they could under the circumstances. Our concern was if there was flies buzzing around the food. We purchased it anyway. We didn't open the food until we got home. My food was OK. It wasn't hot. Seems like the chicken had been sitting there for a minute. My cousin ordered spicy. It looked extra crispy and dark like it was burned. She didn't eat it and wanted to take it back but it was late. Check your food before you leave the store.

This location is permanently closed as of the end of May 2026. The food and service was always…read morepretty sketchy. A couple of years ago it was great! Always a long line of cars to order, the chicken was beautiful, and the biscuits and sides were delicious. Just really went downhill