I went there for the ice cream. We ate at an Italian restaurant across the street and afterwards we wanted a dessert and I didn't like their menu so I looked on yelp and it said that there was ice cream at this place directly across the street so we went there for the ice cream. The young lady who waiting on us said they haven't had ice cream in a year. They've told yelp 15 times to take it off, but y'all doesn't do it so we had a chocolate chip cookie which she gave us because we came for ice cream and they didn't have. It was very kind of her. She was a lovely lady and then we took it back to our hotel room and shared it with a cup of hotel coffee the cookie was easily one of the best cookies I've ever had so I'm gonna give this a five star because she was wonderful and the cookie was wonderful and yelp really dropped the ball on this. read more

super super yummy!!!!! The price was reasonable for the size of the cookie. The chocolate chip one would've been perfect if I had waited to eat with some milk, and the banana pudding one was very soft like a small cake but cookie like. Loved them so so much, can't wait to come back! read more

Sugar Shane’s - Banana Pudding Cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Sandy Springs, Georgia

See all

Stopped in to try a sweet treat, I was actually looking for the very popular viral Dubai Candy Bar. I was told they don't make them anymore, it was a special promotion. I tried one a couple of months ago at another Sugar Shane's location and wanted it again. Instead I ordered the Dubai brownie. I also ordered a Lemon Breeze, and it was to die for. I had to make a second trip to buy another Lemon Breeze for my daughter and myself. This will be my new favorite spot for my sweet treats. I just shouldn't make twice in one day a habit : ) I was excited to see that there was easy parking outside. read more

Sugar Shane’s - Bakeries Near Me - Sandy Springs, Georgia

See all

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Oh the smell when you walk in this shop is amazing.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] A little disappointing that they only had a few cookies left and it was two hours before closing BUT, the cookies were so yummy. The young man at the register was polite and attentive. They were baking more cookies and as I was leaving they had a small line. read more

Sugar Shane’s - Bakeries Near Me - Sandy Springs, Georgia

See all

I've been hearing a lot of about Sugar Shane's all summer. I finally had a chance to check them out. There were so many options to choose from. The employee was very patient and helpful. I loved that she did not rush me in making a decision. I ordered Carolina Pecan, Yellow Jacket, Between The Hedges, and the Pistachio Brownie. All were tasty but my favorite was Carolina Pecan. I plan to visit again to try smother flavors. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The store was clean and had a nice vibe.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Sugar Shane’s - Bakeries Near Me - Sandy Springs, Georgia

We went late so their wasn't a huge selection but we got the Biscoff cookie! They are huge and took several days to finish but were delicious. read more

Sugar Shane’s - Bakeries Near Me - Sandy Springs, Georgia

This spot is very similar to some other cookie spots, but they have some specialty cookies that are filled with things like oreo cheesecake, peanut butter, etc. Service was fast, and you just grab and go as there is nowhere to sit inside. We got a half dozen to share between 4 people and we were all very impressed. The red velvet and double shot (espresso) were so delicious and I highly recommend those. The only downside to me was $34 for a half dozen is very steep price wise, but for a special gift this makes a great spot. read more

Sugar Shane’s - Cookies and cream, red velvet, spooky s'mores, double shot - Bakeries Near Me - Sandy Springs, Georgia

The chocolate chip was one of the best cookies I had in a while... apart from my mom's homemade chocolate chip cookies. The bit of salt flakes at the top and the rich chocolate chips made this a really yummy cookie! It was definitely worth it. I would go back for the chocolate chip cookie. I also had the red velvet one but would prefer the classic chocolate chip. My mouth is watering looking at the chocolate chip cookie. Hehe read more

2021 Dessert Wars Judges' Choice Award Champion Shane Quillin is the creator of Atlanta gourmet cookie and bakery concept, Sugar Shane's. Sugar Shane's is located on the lower level of the Arabelle Perimeter Apartments at the corner of Hammond Drive and Peachtree Dunwoody Road. The eatery is MARTA accessible via the 5 bus or a half-mile walk from the Dunwoody Station.There are other bakery locations in Ponce City Market, Midtown, and Kennesaw. I was starving one Saturday and was looking for somewhere to eat in the Perimeter area that wasn't within the Permeter Mall area. I enjoyed a meal at Local Expedition and was walking to my car when I noticed this bakery (and I am so glad I walked in). [[HIGHLIGHT]]The bakery is small and narrow; however, you are transported to an eclectic, vibrant world with graffiti murals and abstract art.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The staff is equally as friendly and knowledgeable about the different offerings. Sugar Shane's features signature and rotating flavors of cookies such as crumb cake, banana bread, and the Betty White (chunks of Golden Oreos, creamy cookies 'n cream bars, and smooth white chocolate chips). They also have a selection of brownies, cakes, and Rice Krispy treats. Sugar Shane's offers a "sweet tooth" special on Wednesday--four cookies for $20. We experienced the: Chocolate Chip (chopped dark chocolate, dark chocolate disks, semi-sweet chips, topped with sea salt) Cookies & Cream (vanilla base and stuffed with white chocolate chips, oreos, and cookies & cream bar pieces) Spooky S'mores (graham cracker base, milk chocolate chips, marshmallow) Morning After (Brown Sugar Cookie Base Rolled in Cinnamon Crumble Topping) I fell in love with the first bite of Cookies & Cream, and the love affair continued as I sampled each of the cookies. When I got home, my husband popped the cookies in the microwave, placed them back in the box, and disappeared (I never saw the cookies again). Even the humble chocolate chip cookie was elevated with the touches of sea salt. The cookies are not cheap, but the price is well worth the gooeyness, richness, and buttery flavors. I have plans to try the Dubai Bar, which is a dark chocolate bar with kanafi dough and creamy pistachio filling, finished with white chocolate drizzles and pistachio garnish (anything with pistachio is a must try for me). read more

See all

I love Sugar Shane's and recently visited their Sandy Springs location for a Yelp event. This spot used to be a regular for me when I lived in the area. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The location itself is small, but decorated well.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Upon arrival, I was greeted and enjoyed a chocolate chip cookie and a piece of cake. I also ordered a serving of vanilla ice cream, which, while delicious, felt a bit overpriced at around six dollars for small scoops. The highlight was definitely the chocolate chip cookie--it was perfectly gooey in the middle and crisp on the edges. I savored the cake the next day, and it was wonderfully soft and tasty. Overall, Sugar Shane's remains a favorite, and I'm sure I'll be back for more of their delightful treats. read more

See all

Cool shop located in a prime spot in Sandy Springs. The employee greeted me with a smiling face and patiently waited for me to pick my pastry. I went with the banana bread and chocolate chip cookie. Banana bread was a huge slice (Good for 2 people) filled with yummy chocolate chips and drizzled with chocolate sauce. And the chocolate chip cookie melted in my mouth. Only reason for 4 stars is the lack of convenient parking spots. All I could see was a private parking lot with warning signs saying towing or impounding everywhere, so the whole experience of parking for even 10-15 minutes was extremely scary. I hope the store takes this feedback and provides clear instructions for parking near the storefront. read more

Sugar Shane’s - Banana bread Chocolate Chip - Bakeries Near Me - Sandy Springs, Georgia

See all

So if you like cookies, this is the way. They got all types of gourmet cookies and cakes and stuff like that if you're into all of the dessert things. I suggest that you order online, just to make sure that it'll be there at the appropriate time. I'm sure you could just walk in but they suggest you order online so do so. No I will say about the ordering, it was very great customer service and very personable because they even wrote my name on a box and a thank you when I pick my order up! Doing that every time, that means you're really care I assume! I can appreciate that. It's preferable to park on the inside so basically you have to go around the building on the other side as a parking structure for you. It's labeled so you don't have to worry about missing it. You just walk through the hallway to whatever store you want, which is going to be the cookie spot! If you keep walking it's going to take you all the way around to your facing me Einstein Brothers bagels and then you just basically hang a right! Or you can walk outside, that's also an option. But if it's raining or something along those lines, you want to stay inside as long as possible. The chocolate chip - this was really good, sweet salty and very chocolatey and when you put it in the microwave it went off! The cookies and cream - this one was okay. I wasn't really sure about the cream part but the cookies was really good. Would I get it again, I might not, but regardless of that, it still had a really good and savory and chewy taste to it. Again, and the microwave it's amazing! The m&m cookie - this one was the winner. It looks a little different as a big ball of dough, but one side is cookie and one side is chocolate cookie and it has m&Ms up and throughout it. It was a hit to me. Yet again, put it in the microwave it's amazing! read more

See all

A Must-Try Sweet Spot in Sandy Springs! My wife and I were craving something sweet, so we decided to check out Sugar Shane's in Sandy Springs. We chose this spot because of the amazing reviews from real people--4.8 stars from 800+ reviews! INSANE, right? I KNOW!!! Let me just say, this is by far one of the best bakeries we've ever been to! They offer a variety of cookies and gourmet treats like s'mores, banana pudding, and so much more. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The moment you walk in, you're greeted by an irresistible sugary aroma that immediately lures you in.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] With so many tempting options, I had a hard time deciding--but Sayyed (aka Say) came to the rescue! He broke it down for me, pointing out the top contenders: S'mores, Betty White, Cookies n Cream, and Chocolate Chip. Oh, and he made sure to highlight the cheesecake brownie! After much debate, my wife and I went with the Betty White cookie and the cheesecake brownie. Let me tell you--we got our sugar fix! Personally, I think this place is better than Crumbl. As for the price? I'll let you be the judge, but with treats this good, it's worth it! Just maybe don't eat here seven days a week--unless you want an express trip to the dentist! LOLOL Highly recommend Sugar Shane's for all dessert lovers! read more

See all

I LOVE SMORES! ratings: chocolate chip: 7/10 s'mores cookie: 9/10 free parking garage, no line read more

Sugar Shane’s - Chocolate Chip and Smores - Bakeries Near Me - Sandy Springs, Georgia

A spoonful full of sugar makes the medicine go down. The medicine go down-wown .The medicine go down. In a most delightful way. These were my exact thoughts as I took the first bite of this Sugar Shane's chocolate chip cookie. My whole life's existence started to play out right before my eyes as to why I hadn't tried Sugar Shane's before now. These cookies were soooooo good, but at $4-$6 a cookie..come on now. Highway robbery, but how can you say no to your greedy gremlin?!!? I had to bite the bullet on this one. It's so much better than insomnia or Crumbl cookies, in my opinion. The ladies at the counter were so welcoming and pleasant. Even the customers that made a purchase before me were raving that Sugar Shane's were the truth. I'm definitely returning to try more cookies in their display. read more

See all

Without heating up these were absolute fire. Dude Shane knows how to bake some goodies. They are expensive so bring a 20 if you wanna eat good. Staff was so nice it was crazy. If I lived here I'd be back. I need y'all to ship nationally! read more

Sugar Shane’s - Bakeries Near Me - Sandy Springs, Georgia

See all

I had heard of Sugar Shane's and tried them once when a friend had brought them, but had never actually visited a location! I came here to take advantage of Yelp's July 2023 deal for 2 chocolate chip cookies for $4.04. Parking is super easy with a deck next door and it's just a pickup location. When we entered on Sunday, the employee at the counter did a great job telling us about each of the flavors! We didn't try any others but the classic chocolate chip cookies, but all the stuffed cookies looked SO delicious and I want to go back to try!! The chocolate chip cookies we ordered were generously sized and incredibly rich. They were the right amount of sweet and even had salt flakes on top which I loved! I can't wait to check out other locations and their other flavors. read more

Sugar Shane’s - Classic Chocolate Chip - Bakeries Near Me - Sandy Springs, Georgia

See all

Will never come to this location again! Visiting and decided on something sweet. Placed an online order and finally got there to pick up. The worker at the cash register sold part of my order! Because I didn't come within 30 minutes to pick up. I placed it so the order will be ready for me and I wouldn't have to wait. Then when I politely asked why she got an attitude! Then I asked for a refund and she got even madder! Order at your own discretion! read more

I actually cannot believe I had never heard of this place or been here before. First of all, we came on a Sunday an hour or 2 before close and they still had tons of options! The employee also did the most fantastic job of explaining all the flavors and giving us a welcome introduction. I ended up going with the 2 classic chocolate chip cookies. And let me tell you... this changed my perspective on cookies. They were so GOOEY AND SOFT!!! These were some of the best cookies I have ever had. Not to mention they are massive and rich. For me they are giving insomnia a run for their money. Don't sleep on this place! I can't wait to try more of their locations and more of their flavors. Their slutty brownie also looked phenomenal. Really can't believe I went so long without this read more

Sugar Shane’s - Chocolate Chip - Bakeries Near Me - Sandy Springs, Georgia

The best damned cookies you can have delivered. Insomnia cookies are OKAY. Crumbl cookies are GARBAGE. Sugar Shane's are FABULOUS! I had the Virgo bar, biscoff blondie, and the boneless chip cookie... can't wait to treat myself every month! read more

Look no further for the perfect chocolate chip cookie! The sea salt on the top is perfection and the last ones I got were still warm from the oven! YUM! read more

Sometimes, we can have too much of a good thing... Shane's had some of the most overtly sweet concoctions I've ever had. It took me 3 attempts just to finish my Dashing Delta cookie, at which I failed miserably. I definitely didn't care for the Fruity Pebbles - the signature cereal flavor wasn't even discernible because of the high sugar content and vanilla flavor, unfortunately. Note: These are quite dense, so just pop them in the mic for a few seconds to soften. Lastly, I felt a bit of sticker shock, when just 2 of them came to approx $14 - YIKES! While Sugar Shane's isn't for me, should you have sweet tooth... at Sugar Shane's, consider it conquered. read more

Sugar Shane’s - Delta - Bakeries Near Me - Sandy Springs, Georgia

See all

I am about to make a bold, true statement: Sugar Shane's has the best cookies in Atlanta! My boyfriend and I have been enjoying Sugar Shane's for a while. Usually, we either order via UberEats, or we go to the 14th St location closest to my home. Yesterday, we happened to be near this location in Sandy Springs, so we stopped in. The staff was so sweet to us and welcoming, and the shop was clean and quaint. It was a tough choice since everything looked and sounded great, but we finally decided on 3 we hadn't tried before: Late Night Oreo, Carrot Cake, and Chocolate Walnut. They've updated their to-go boxes + bags, which are super cute. We took the cookies home, warmed them in my air fryer per the box instructions, and shared them with my mom. We loved all of the flavors! The cookies are always perfectly crispy on the outside and gooey on the inside. Obsessed! Thank you for all that you do! read more

Sugar Shane’s - Top left: Late Night Oreo Top right: Carrot cake Bottom: Chocolate Walnut - Bakeries Near Me - Sandy Springs, Georgia

Don't bother ordering online in the morning to "reserve" anything. I ordered items at 11:30 AM so that certain items didn't sell out before we got there. Set pickup time for 2 PM. Got there at 3 only to discover that they hadn't set aside anything. They started filling the box when we got there. One of the items we wanted two of (Dubai chocolate cookies) only had one remaining and had to be replaced with something else. I ordered the items at 11:30 so that the box would be set aside. And we drove the 35 miles specifically for the Dubai chocolate cookies and brownie they had this week. Extremely disappointing and a waste of time. The worst part was that the employees behind the counter could care less when I asked if there was more than one left when I placed the order at 11:30. Pretty sure I won't be making the drive down there again if they're just going to waste my time. read more

The vibe on this is weird. It's a really tiny shop and the staff didn't seem too happy to see us in there especially when we had questions because we thought the menu on the front of the store was the menu. It's not... Or it's out of date? One of the employees told us to use the QR menu but most of the pictures didn't look like the cookies on display so that was confusing. Like, a funfetti one in the pic was off white/yellow (like sugar cookie) but the one on display was hot pink so we basically had to ask what each one on display was & we picked the s'mores and banana pudding ones $6/ea We didn't want the cookies right away so they gave us a box with reheating instructions on it to take with us. We had the cookies the next day & they're good! They are sooooo rich though so prepare your water or milk or whatever because you'll need it. At $6, though, I definitely won't be getting them often especially when crumbl is so close by and cheaper and bigger cookies and easier to order but I'm really glad we tried it out! Parking is available in the attached parking deck for free There's no seating at this location though since it is a small takeout spot read more

See all

My first time at Sugar Shane was a great experience! I am a cookie lover but never seen a cookie like this. I purchased smores (not pictured) and Bulldog (pictured). I bought a betty white (not pictured) for my friend and the worker gave her a free cookie for her birthday. That was so nice of them. From the packaging to the taste im in love. I love to heat these in the airfryer because it gives it a hard but soft satisfying taste and the shape doesnt even change. They definitely put instructions on how to heat and reheat if need too but definitely not recommended. I will be back very soon cause i found a new love read more

Sugar Shane’s - Bulldog - Bakeries Near Me - Sandy Springs, Georgia

See all

Was open to the idea of dessert after dinner, and found Sugar Shane's nearby! My partner and I ordered the chocolate chip cookie and s'mores brownie to go - TASTE: 4/5 - the cookie was rich w chocolate, and we were so pleasantly surprised that the s'mores brownie wasn't painfully sweet! Loved the mini marshmallows and marshmallow fluff in it TEXTURE: 4/5 - the cookie was crisp on the outside, but chewy on the inside. The s'mores brownie was indulgently thick and gooey PRICE: 4/5 - definitely paying a little more for these large, handcrafted treats SERVING SIZE: 5/5 - the cookie was more of a standard size, but the brownie was massive! SERVICE: 4/5 - the folks at the counter were helpful in providing recommendations ATMOSPHERE: 4/5 - a small, fun space w large murals TAKEOUT: 4/5 - the takeout box was sturdy and came with freezing guidance and instructions for multiple reheating methods, e.g. oven, air fryer, or microwave PARKING: 4/5 - we parked in the free Bishop public parking garage and walked a couple blocks over read more

Sugar Shane’s - S'mores brownie and chocolate chip cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Sandy Springs, Georgia

See all

We really enjoyed the chocolate chip cookies, Dubai brownies and the cookies topped with the strawberry icing. Service was fast and easy. Highly recommend! read more

All I can say is wow! These cookies are incredible. My girlfriend is a baker and she agreed they are exceptional. We had 3 cookies while we were visiting Atlanta last weekend and we absolutely fell in love. We had s'mores, chocolate chip, and cookies and cream. I really wanted to try the one with caramel, but they were out. The taste, texture, and flavor were outstanding. We will definitely be ordering these in the future. read more

Sugar Shane’s - Bakeries Near Me - Sandy Springs, Georgia

See all

My fiancé and I came in and tried the cookies and cream cookie.... My goodness I'm still thinking about it to this day. Amazing cookie, amazing flavor, and they warm it up for you which is the perfect touch. Can't wait to come back to this location for more cookies! read more

If you are looking for a mega sized cookie, that is delicious and almost as big as a slice of cake, this is a place. Sugar Shane's has some of the best cookies I've ever had. The cookies are so large that the center of each cookie can remain a little on the underdone side and super gooey. My personal favorite is their cookies and cream cookie, closely followed by the s'mores cookie. Even though the franchise favorite is the chocolate chip cookies with walnuts, I personally think these other two cookies that I recommended are leagues above this. read more

Sugar Shane’s - Bakeries Near Me - Sandy Springs, Georgia

This business has amazing desserts, with high quality ingredients. Prices are high, but are reflected in portion size, quality, presentation and packaging. My only complaint is that menu selection is inconsistent. That brown butter frosted brownie you loved last week, may never be seen again. If you favor only an item or two, you may find yourself not ordering. read more

Came in as they were closing at 3 pm but still most all cookie options to choose. The cookie we got was bulldog and it almost tasted more like cake than cookie. It was baked fresh yesterday and very tasty. read more

Not a big sweets person but I was being greedy the other night and said let me get me a cookie....or 2. I got a chocolate chip cookie & the lemon cheesecake cookie. The lemon cheesecake cookie is lemony but not too lemony...it was disgusting and the choc chip was good but I've definitely had better & I wouldn't spend that much on them. They're $4+ a piece. read more

See all

These cookies are absolutely amazing! I definitely understand all of the hype and I am so glad I finally visited. The cookies are huge and they have such a great variety of flavors, they also swap out a few flavors every week so there is something for everyone. It is pricey but I think worth it. The service is also great and they are very helpful in explaining the flavors and answering any questions you may have. I would definitely put it on my must-visit list if you haven't already. read more

Sugar Shane’s - Bakeries Near Me - Sandy Springs, Georgia

The inside doesn't look like a typical bakery but in this case, looks don't matter. The staff member covering the front (I think her name was Danielle but don't quote me) was super nice and took the time to run down the ingredients in every cookie they had. Now, I had to take the one star off simply because almost every cookie, with the exception of 1 or 2, has white chocolate in it and I'm not a fan. This place clearly loves it if they added it every cookie. Regardless, every cookie I had was amazing. My favorite was the Nana's puddin. It really make me think of my grandma's banana pudding minus the bananas. These cookies aren't cheap at $6 a pop but they're worth the money for a once in a while treat. read more

See all

I came to this cookie joint as part of the Yelp "What's the 404?" event. It is a small intimate shop that does not have any indoor seating so is a more grab and go kind of setting. The woman at the front desk was quick and polite to fulfill my order asking if I wanted them to be heated up. Since I had plans to eat lunch, I was able to easily follow their microwave directions on the bag later on. The chocolate chip cookies were beautiful with little flakes of sea salt on top and tasted even better. I would love to come here again and try some of their other freshly baked good. read more

Sugar Shane’s - Two Chocolate Chip cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Sandy Springs, Georgia

Guyel is always so nice and welcoming every time that I come in!!! The cookies are also fresh and the taste never changes!! 10/10!!!

A quaint cookie shop that packs bold flavor! There were lots of flavors to choose from an the friendly employee took as much time as we needed to explain what each one was. After a thorough explanation, I walked away with 3 different flavors. I know the chocolate chip is their top seller and it's great. But if you're like me and enjoy butterscotch and spice, their cinnamon cookie will certainly hit all the right notes! There are no seats or tables, so plan to take this to go. You can have them warmed up if you'd like to eat one on the go. I'll be back when I'm in the area for sure! read more

Pricey but sooooo worth it! I'm ashamed to admit how often I order from them and the customer service is always a 10/10