Delish! Great choice in flavors & the ice cream is so good! I loved the pistachio! The area outside has some benches for you to sit on but other than that that, there is no place to really enjoy it. read more

Sundae's Ice Cream Parlor - Pistachio - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Towaco, New Jersey

It's close to my house and the prices are cheaper than a similar place down the road. However, the ice cream just doesn't taste that good. Last time I went they had coffee sugar free ice cream, but not regular coffee. My father in law got a pineapple sundae and said there was only a few pieces of pineapple. Their ice cream cakes though are amazing. read more

Budd Lake Location: OMG! I'm not a "sweets" person..but this place is so fun it just makes you wanna eat it all. So many choices..staff super friendly.. you have to come by and support them. read more

Sundae's Ice Cream Parlor - Almond joy with wet walnuts - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Towaco, New Jersey

See all

Lots of great flavor combos and tons of toppings, makes it hard to pick just one. Cute small town ice cream shop read more

Sundae's Ice Cream Parlor - Cookie Monster and Banana Pudding - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Towaco, New Jersey

See all

A nice neighborhood ice cream parlor. Take out only but plenty of benches & tables outside. Great ice cream selection. Very nice staff. Prices are ok. Long lines after town events or ball games...most other times no problems being served immediately. Great place to walk to. Very limited street parking. Park in train station if you dare cross hwy 202. Excellent place to see locals out with their families. read more

Very cute little shop with plenty to choose from, loved the Italian ice! The outdoor area is family friendly with a basketball hoop for the kids. read more

Quality ice cream. Tastes fresh every time we go. Just started buying their cakes for birthday parties and they are outstanding as well. Friendly staff and fast service. I like their outside serving window for quick orders. read more

Ok. My update is not about the quality of the ice cream. I do really like it. When I see homemade ice cream I am expecting that it is made at the location. On a recent visit, I found out that they DO NOT make the ice cream. But rather, all ice cream is from Gelotti. Gelotti is in Paterson and they do make the ice cream and it is really good. Soooooo....the question is.....is Sundaes Ice Cream Parlor really "homemade ice cream" as advertised?" read more

Super yummy flavors n prices very reasonable ! Banana Oreo is my new fav !!!! Hubby loves caramel cone ice cream. read more

Sundae's Ice Cream Parlor - Banana Oreo and caramel cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Towaco, New Jersey

A small neighborhood ice cream shop with really good homemade ice cream and ices. And their chocolate fudge brownie ice cream is truly excellent. Beyond the ice cream, what now puts this place over the top this year is their expanded beautifully landscaped patio, complete with little kid sized picnic tables and a grassy lawn for the kids to run aound on after ingesting all that sugar, while parents can sit back, relax and enjoy a nice summer evening in the great outdoors. read more

I am a Peanut butter nut. At first glance, they seemed to not even have anything with PB in it. But when I inquired, they said it was in a freezer I didnt even see because it was out of sight, and the flavors were written on a blackboard hanging over it. I figured the flavor that would maximize my ice cream to PB ratio would be the PB cup. I dont know where they get the PB cups from, but I barely detected PB!! and the vanilla wasnt really flavorful. It was about 5.00 for a medium cup. I think next time I crave PB, I'll just head to a supermarket and get a gallon of some brand with PB in it for about 2.50, and I'll definitely get my PB fix. read more

Banana pudding was fantastic! This is now my favorite ice cream shop in Budd Lake. The prices are much lower than their competition which gets pricey when you have a large family. I'm so happy I stopped in. So pretty inside! read more

I almost always make it a point to stop for ice cream when I'm in the area. So glad i discovered it this summer, a real bright point during Covid. The staff is cool. I always get my basic flavors. Just very good ice cream in a nice environment. read more

Nice little ice cream spot. The staff is friendly. The best part is the large amount of outdoor seating to hang out. The train station is across the street so you their is plenty of people watching you can do. The prices are pretty reasonable too read more

Well went there today & was disappointed at the Towaco Sundaes. I wish for those who work behind the counter would be on the same page when it comes to the size of the cones. I asked for a small soft serve ice cream cone & when it was handed to me which I should have not accepted look to be a kiddie cones at a total cost of $3.91. I think there needs to be more training. It's a hit or miss when you go there. I hesitate at times to go there. I'm wondering if that's why the Sundaes in Montville closed down. read more

Sundaes is for several years now, disappointing. Skimpy portions, not very friendly and little appreciation for local patrons. My daughter walked over and was 5 cents short to get a cone. Instead of offering her a break the server refused to sell her the cone. Really? After several years of patronage, we still feel like strangers. read more

This place has great homemade ice cream! The mint Oreo is AMAZING & I hope they never stop making it! Also during the fall their pumpkin ice cream is to die for. Prices are decent and the workers are alway pleasant! read more

This is a really good ice cream place! It is 10 outof 10!! They have the best ice cream. There are a lot of unique flavors like Cookie Monster. It is dyed blue with chunks of cookies in it. The soft serve is very creamy.Even my dog loves the vanilla.They're very considerate about allergies. The outside is very unusual in a good way .The big rocking chair is so much fun! They have have tables ,umbrellas, and even a basket ball and a basketball hoop. read more

I was really excited when this place opened because it was so close to my house, but after going there a couple of times I was disappointed. The ice cream is ok, but nothing I couldn't get at the supermarket. It is conveniently located but not my favorite ice cream place. read more

No Gelato here. The ice cream was good, comparable to most other local ice cream shops. The signs say Homemade Ice Cream but it doesn't seem like anything is made on location, perhaps I'm wrong. read more

I went in to the ice cream shop with my family and was helped by a wonderful girl named Jamie! She got my order and even helped accommodate my little ones! Absolutely terrific, will definitely be coming back. read more

Your standard family-run ice cream shop. Lots of flavors, including the ones you would expect. I got the smallest size cup of chocolate peanut butter ice cream (I think it was the kiddie size) with peanuts on top. $3.11 and hit the spot! Just wish they would use paper cups instead of Styrofoam. read more

Quaint but the place has a strange smell inside. Had the caramel pretzel ice cream. Was great. Nice area to sit and watch the cars and trains pass. All flavors aren't in the cases. I didn't know until after I ordered that more flavors were available and were listed in a place that wasn't noticeable. I am happy with my choice but would have gotten something else on the hidden list. read more

I can not speak for the Towaco location, but the Pine Brook location is the worst ice cream I have ever eaten in my life. Forget about the fact that the store is laid out horribly, with only a few flavors displayed. Forget about the fact that the teenagers in there have no idea what they are doing. I could live with all of these problems if the ice cream was good, but it's not. I have been here about 5 times, trying different things each time, and I have never been pleased. I ordered a vanilla shake a month or 2 ago My wife and I each took a sip and we threw it right in the garbage. It was thin, watery, and it tasted like chemicals. More recently I decided to give it another try. I ordered one of the soft ice creams with candy mixed in. I figured, how could you possibly screw that up? Well, once again I took a bite and threw it right in the garbage. It was way to sweet and again it tasted like chemicals. I am really hoping this place will get their act together and figure out what is wrong with the ice cream. Get it tasting somewhat good and I will be your best customer. For now, since there are no ice cream places close by, I will have to stick with Mc Donalds or 7 Eleven. MB I read more

It was pretty great here! The ice cream was good and it was wonderful to have a view outside while eating. Nice options between frozen yogurt and ice cream as well. Only complaint is that they didn't have chocolate chip ice cream, which we had believed was a staple. But other then that, absolutely fantastic! read more

Generous portions and tasty ice cream sundaes with a great selection of ice cream flavours. Small shop but pleasant space to sit out and enjoy your ice cream with friends or family. read more

Just left the ice cream shop great ice cream poor customer service. Purchased an ice cream cup that over flowed. The employee saw me struggling and just kept wiping down her station. The cup dripped all over me on the floor so bad that I had to hand it to my husband. You would think she would have offered a napkin or at least offered help. She was to busy trying to collect money and get us out the shop. I went to the bathroom and washed off before leaving and told her to take it off our bill (Gave ice cream back). It was horrible service from the beginning we walked in and she was putting a new trash bag in the trash. As if she had just empty the trash she never washed her hands before helping us. read more

I'm not sure what is happening, sadly they recently closed on Changebridge Road.. we had to drive over to Towaco and they were out of Chocolate, Mint Choc. Chip, Chocolate Peanut butter!! WTH??? sadly, no ice cream for us!!! read more

Just came upon this little place last month...guess what, its our new go to place. So many home made flavors you don't know what to pick. The cherry vanilla is like when I was a kid, BIG cherries, huge, and so good. The brownies are amazing. We don't go anywhere else. The young staff that works there are more than friendly, they smile, say thank you and help you out when you can't choose a flavor. read more

GET NEW SPOONS!!! The ice cream is very good but the fact that an ice cream parlor has cheap spoons that literally bend while being used is ridiculous. You are serving HARD ice cream. I mean raise the price of the ice cream the 2 cents you are saving. They also took down all the umbrellas so no protection from the sun in the seating area for you or kids. So good product.....terrible management. read more