In at about 6:30pm on a Thursday. Restaurant was mostly empty. Counter service was helpful and friendly. Ordered a two piece catfish with 3 piece of shrimp. Much of the dining area was messy. Grabbed a booth and realized lights & tv weren't on. Staff did come to turn on lights, but not tv sets. Music in restaurant was too loud for a conversation. Best part of the dinner was the fries. Good amount of seasoning, interesting cut, served piping hot. Fish and shrimp were both bland and over cooked. Dinner was not worth $22+ per plate. read more

Super Shack Seafood & Grill - Seafood Near Me - Sherman, Texas

Wow! The food is good and the portions are huge! First place I've eaten where the actual entrees are bigger & better than the photos on the menu! Chicken Poboy & Crawfish Poboys came w FLAT french-fries, and they were GREAT! The Shrimp Guacamole Appetizer was too big to finish! All the food was really good. We were impressed! The only reason is didn't hit 5-stars is that a double-shot of Titos was $20! Kinda high-$$ for the meager pour. read more

See all

Very friendly staff. Very spacious and nice bar. The catfish was utterly amazing. The score on the breading was perfect. The coleslaw was a tad bland but lets go back to that catfish. Served hot and fresh with an outstanding tarter sauce. $15 for 2 pieces of catfish is a total rip off tho. But I was extremely hungover and it definitely held its purpose. This lady will be back on days when I need a mild hot crunch of delicious mild fish read more

Super Shack Seafood & Grill - 2 pc fried catfish & coleslaw - Seafood Near Me - Sherman, Texas

Both locations of these restaurants are AMAZING!!!!!! Clean, super fresh food, and the most amazing staff!! This is seriously one of our most favorite restaurants read more

Great food, always fresh you can dine in and they deliver. Highly recommended and cannot wait for my next order.

Wow! Catfish was not fresh and corn meal coating had no seasoning. Would only order their fries! They were amazing. Restaurant had a bad odor going on... Sadly, I'll probably never return. read more

Terrible food, way over priced. Find a tv dinner of fish or shrimp, it's the same. Go somewhere else.

Food was fantastic! Service was perfect. The restaurant and location are just right. There are many Mexican items on the menu including Birria tacos and Al pastor. The seafood selections just go on and on the menu. They range from simple boiled shrimp and crawfish (in season) to elaborate grilled oysters and many fried selections. This is the place for great seafood in Sherman. Don't miss out. Get here as soon as you can. Yum! read more

Super Shack Seafood & Grill - Service counter - Seafood Near Me - Sherman, Texas

See all

Catfish were full fillets not half like a lot of places, but they had too much bland batter in them. Fish and chips. Best part was the chips. Tartar sauce was also bland and watery read more

Went there for dinner and it took about 45 minutes to get our food. They had one cook and he was cooking one thing at a time. There were 3 of us and we all ate our dinner separately as they were bringing it one at a time. It was not busy in there either. I will not be going back unless they get another cook or change owners. Very disappointed in the service. read more

I just had the most amazing shrimp enchiladas! The flavor was great! I LOVED it! The place is clean although they are transitioning away from Pepsi to Coke today. The install team is here, but the food still came out fast. Thank you! read more

We tried Super Shack because we love good seafood. My wife had 1/2 pound snow crab; I had the catfish fillets (2) & shrimp (3). Both were good but not great. Portions were great & service was above average. read more

Birria 10/10 and good service , I would definitely come back! They're menu is big as well

Excellent seafood . My favorite is the Gumbo with sausage, shrimp and chicken. Fast casual dining. Quick service follows the counter ordering process. Extensive menu read more

Guys this is a must try 1st time i have given 5 star reviews the place is super super clean thx u staff fir that. The menu board is beautifully displayed. The food is amazing considering sharing portions are huge yes i will b bk read more

Super Shack Seafood & Grill - Cod - Seafood Near Me - Sherman, Texas

See all

Wonderful place! Clean, bright, friendly staff, quick service and delicious food! We stopped by for lunch on. Saturday and enjoyed the Coconut Shrimp and the Crawfish Étouffée. Our food tasted great and fresh! We highly recommend! read more

Super Shack Seafood & Grill - Coconut Shrimp & Fries - Seafood Near Me - Sherman, Texas

See all

Food was delicious, it was much more than just "good." The service was astoundingly quick, very helpful as well. The food came out less than 5 minutes of us sitting down. The ambiance is homey. Its very inviting and comforting. read more

Food was amazing. Soccer on all the TVs. Just a good place to be and to eat. Shrimp guacamole is the best I've ever had. New favorite place. read more

This place has become a local favorite for me and my wife. Their oysters are fresh and the majority of their menu is solid! I've visited the other location in McKinney, but I feel like the chef at this location takes a lot more pride in preparing food. The menu is the same but the finished product tastes completely different. read more

ordered the crawfish/bacon mac n cheese. The mac and cheese seems like its from Kraft and its too expensive for what you get. I was expecting homemade. The small calamari was greasy and cold. I will not order from here again. read more

For the first time experience of being at the Super Shack, the food was unfortunately bland (no a lot of seasoning going on). The sides for the Salmon, veggies and rice, we're almost too tough to chew or just plain. Along with the no taste, the bottled hard sodas were outrageously over priced... ($14 for a 12oz 5% alc). Other than the food and drinks, the service was great! The man behind the counter had perfect patience and was awesome. Appreciated him helping. Unfortunately, the decision to return to this restaurant is under 50% chance. read more

Seriously THE best meal we've had in ages! Crawfish Etoufee is heavenly and crawfish by the pound was legit! Service was great! Save room for dessert! Bread Pudding and Tiramisu were the bomb! read more

Somebody said on their review, the food they got was better than the pictures and the pictures are very good. That was true. This time as well. The food was great coconut shrimp was hand battered it wasn't frozen. Brea tacos were overflowing with Carnitas. They were incredible. The kids pasta was amazing my daughter says. read more

The reason for three stars is, the restaurant is very clean. Three of us tried different dishes. My seafood boil was a greasy mess. It reminded me of the Asian seafood places popping up everywhere. They say is New Orleans style but, it it not! The other two dishes were just ok but, not worth the price. Beer mediocre warm. We will probably not come back. There are better choices down south (McKinney) read more

Walking into this place is off putting. It smells of chemicals. It feels humid with not enough AC. They've got a fan blowing just to circulate air. It's only 91* which is not hot in TX so they shouldn't be having issues with AC. On to the next issue; the oysters were awful. They had a brown tinge to the juice, smelled off and went in my hub's mouth and right back out. We've had our fair share of oysters to eat, but these were beyond edible. It's sad because at one point and time they were decent-when they first opened. I ordered the tuna steak with rice and veggies which I've had before and it was great. Nope. Not this time. It had the consistency of rubber rawhide. The taste was like a chemical flavor. We left and offered to pay for our beverages, but the manager (I assume) told us to leave. Then he smarted off and said, 'Well if you didn't want the meal you should've told me.' Um ok, we were giving it a try because we know crap happens and bad batches of oysters can be shipped. We were trying to stay and give you business, but won't eat something that tastes horrible. Sad this business has gone downhill like it has. Definitely won't be back. read more

Outstanding seafood! Great service! Lots of beers on tap! Family owned.... Also one in McKinney. read more

See all

Most flavorless meal I've ever had. We ordered two nachos and three drinks and it was almost $50! I wouldn't be bothered by that as much if they t had been fantastic but it had virtually zero taste. read more

Great food. Reasonable prices. We've been there half a dozen times and it has been consistently excellent. I highly recommend the seafood chowder. read more

Portions were large and the atmosphere was pleasant, but the food seems a bit overpriced for the quality. I got the catfish which wasn't great (but I am picky about my catfish). Staff was very friendly. read more

The food was consistently excellent, and the service matched its quality. My wife finds the margaritas quite potent, though I don't have personal experience since I don't drink. The atmosphere is relaxed and laid-back, making it an ideal spot for a family dinner. However, I'm withholding a 5-star rating due to slightly higher prices and some subpar restroom conditions - they seemed a bit neglected. read more

See all

The food was delicious and the Atmosphere was pretty good too. We had that Salmon and it was Excellent! read more

Super Shack Seafood & Grill - Inside Super Shack - Seafood Near Me - Sherman, Texas

See all

Great Drinks and Food Going again soon for a Family Birthday. Hope they have Crawfish!!

This place was dead on Sat but it was dead Waitress was rude. I had to return the soft shell crab. It was so overcooked and battered, the bun was even burnt Took forever to get replacement. Save your money Go elsewhere read more

Good food, comparable pricing, very friendly staff. Here, you order at the desk then seat yourself. The food came in a timely manner and everything tasted great! The gumbo was excellent! It's the old Applebees in Sherman, so the building is a bit used, but they definitely made a name for themselves here. read more

Fish and Chips! Very good, huge flaky white fish and perfectly seasoned "chips", this was quite a surprise. This was my first visit, the menu has everything from burgers and tacos to steak and seafood. I definitely recommend and I'll go back for other items but it will be hard to pass up the fish and chips! Very friendly staff as well. read more

Super Shack Seafood & Grill - Seafood Near Me - Sherman, Texas

I placed a to-go order, and tried the 1lb shrimp and added a egg. I'll definitely be back to try the other seafood they offer! Had good flavor &spice, the service was definitely quick. read more

Super Shack Seafood & Grill - Hot shrimp boil with egg - Seafood Near Me - Sherman, Texas

Went for my first time to Super Shack on Monday afternoon. Everyone was very friendly and accommodating. Ordered a shrim cocktail and spicy boiled shrimp. Shrimp cocktail was really good. Lots of shrimp, onions ,spicy sauce, saltines. The spicy shrimp were amazing. Spicy, garlicky, corn and potatoes. This place is the real deal! I'll definitely be back read more

Super Shack Seafood & Grill - Spicy shrimp. Sooo goood. Spicy, seasoned well, and lots of them. I will definitely be back to Super Shack!! - Seafood Near Me - Sherman, Texas

Stopped by traveling through in family vacation. Great food and wonderful service. Crawfish Monica pasta was delicious. read more

everything was amazing i will come back! had very much flavor all of it was cooked very perfectly!!

Delicious! The spicy shrimp boil (crawfish boil style) with red potatoes & corn is scrumptious! We loved the crawfish étouffée, & fried catfish with fat potato steak fries was a hit too! Great service, fantastic drinks, & the best quality seafood! read more

See all