Massive slice of pizza by the slice. Had the supreme with everything on it Ingredients were pretty good, nice sauce and cheese distribution Came out to 9.50 a giant slice If you want a snack, it's not for you because this is a whole meal. Pizza is reheated in less than 3 mins, very quick. They do have other smaller items like 6 or 9 inch hotdogs if that's up your alley read more

Super Slice Pizza - Pizza Near Me - El Cerrito, California

Massive slices. I thought it was far more than I needed but then...I finished. Above average on the picky pizza scale! 3.5 star rounded up. We had one cheese one pepperoni. Come in the late afternoon and they were close to selling out of things! read more

Thank you! I was lucky to get a kitchen sink to say goodbye! I am sorry to learn you are closing. Best wishes to you! This place had great vibes and food was always yum. read more

Went here for the first time and really enjoyed this pizza. I recommend this place because it was hella good, clean restaurant, excellent customer service, and great value. read more

See all

East bay gem right here! Giant slices, delicious pizza and the owner is really friendly and appreciates his customers. This is my 8 yo sons favorite spot and he tells his friends all about it. We recently ordered several pizzas for my sons birthday party and the owner went out of his way to make sure he had all of the ingredients, worked with me on the order and made sure it was hot and fresh (and perfect) for my sons bday party with more than 30 people! Do yourself a favor and check them out. We're lucky to have them in our neck of the woods!! read more

After my 3rd visit in one year. I can say their peperoni slice pizzas are freaking good. Perfect crust, temperature is nice and hot, flavors are sp good, and juicy pizza. The hot dog's flavor was super good too. read more

Super Slice Pizza - Peperoni slice and hotdog - Pizza Near Me - El Cerrito, California

Great guys, great pizza. Being from the east coast i like this a lot since it is a little thinner and doesn't have a giant loaf of bread for the crust. Plenty of sauce and cheese and the kids lived it so that's a bonus too. Definitely recommended. read more

Super delicious pizza! One of the best pizzas I've had. Tastes like all fresh ingredients. And the owner is so nice.

"Alright, so there I am at Lorenzo's - loading up my slice from the fixin's bar.. garlic and what-not.. mmm,mmm.. and I see this guy over at the pizza boxes giving me the stink-eye." - Cosmo Kramer, Seinfeld Da Scene: This time opt'd to swing by and pick a few slices from the display case, just like in many spots in Brooklyn. They had like 6-7 pies to choose from, so I grabbed 3 to bring home. Da Grub: 1 slice each of Pep, Cheese, and Margherita, left them room temp from the case as we fire up the oven to 550 at home and toss the slices on a pizza steel for a quick 2 minutes... perfect crispy crust without drying out things. The Pep & Cheese ARE quintessential NYC style, just like neighborhood spots in Brookyln, Queens and the Bronx. I normally shy away from Margherita in this style slice (preferring more traditional Napolitano), especially when I see actual tomato slices on the pie... we were pleasantly surprised, they did this one well, very thinly sliced tomatoes along with fresh mozzarella and basil, pretty damn good. We kick it up a notch and sprinkle a little pecorino on all the slices. Da Service: Friendly dudes, bright, clean shop, good assortment of pies, walked right in @ 11:30 on a Saturday. Parking in the center was crazy, I waited it out So... my 1st time out, had whole pies which were just ok. This time slices that were ON POINT. Upping my rating for their slices and will stick w/ those for now, it IS a Super Slice. read more

See all

This pizza tastes like memories of being a child eating pizza while watching the newest movies rented from Blockbuster. It's that good. I ordered the Caesar salad and the garlic chicken pizza. The pizza was cooked to perfection with a crunchy yet chewy dough. There's a very generous amount of chicken on this pizza as well as veggies. The drizzle of garlic sauce made every bite addicting. I want to try all the different toppings now! read more

Super Slice Pizza - Garlic Chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - El Cerrito, California

Mehhhhhhh. It's OK. It's pizza. It's not terrible and they give you a nice big fat slice. I don't know what to say. It's OK. !!! read more

First off, I'll start by saying that I've visited Super Slice twice. The first time I visited, we ordered a pre-made slice that was incredibly delicious and hit all our NY-style pizza cravings (my girlfriend is from NY). The cheese was great, the crust was great! Going off of our first experience, we decided to go backs second time to buy a whole pizza. We also brought along another friend (also from NY) who was craving pizza. We ordered a medium pizza to take home and enjoy but unfortunately our second experience did not match our first. The crust was so much thicker than the individual slices at the restaurant. It was almost like Domino's pizza or Digiorno style pizza crust... our friend from NY was really disappointed. So perhaps it was our bad to have assumed that this was NY style pizza, but just wanted to call out that the pizza styles between the pre-made slices and the made-to-order pies are completely different. Your experience may vary, but just wanted to let you know you might be getting something different if you order a freshly made pizza (compared to what you see in the pizza window). Sadly, we thought this would be our go-to pizza spot for large parties, but due to the thick crust, we will be sticking to the individual slices going forward. read more

Super Slice Pizza - Made-to-order pizza crust is completely different than the crust on the individual slices -- a lot thicker - Pizza Near Me - El Cerrito, California

Eager to try a new local spot, I stopped off here to pick up a quick lunch for the family. It was fast and convenient to pick out what everyone likes - cheese, pepperoni, combo and jalapeño slices, and then they were popped into the oven to warm up to a perfect eating temperature. The lobby is a simple set up and had soda and ice cream available for grab and go, and there were some small salads stored up front. The pizza was ok, but it seemed that the dough was ready made and the cheese tasted processed. Did my children eat it? Absolutely! Would I go back? For something quick and easy for my family to eat - yes. If they had a few chairs and tables available, I could easily see a quick stop after a baseball game to grab a bite. If you're looking for something gourmet, this is not your stop. However, the staff was friendly and fast, and I was out the door in less than 10 minutes with a decent lunch. read more

See all

My little sister has been wanting me to take her here since she first saw the signs after driving in the area last year. I finally took her for lunch last week. She said "They deserve 5 stars. This pizza is amazing." Lol She really enjoyed it and was amazed by how big the slices are. I like that the crust is thin. read more

See all

I was craving NY style pizza. This place is tasty. They sell everything from pizza, hotdogs, gyros & cheese cake. The slices were enormous. The guy working was fast & friendly. The location is small but there is plenty of outside seating. read more

I had an order of pizzas in multiple sizes delivered all the way to Oakland for an office event--and they still arrived piping hot! The super thin crust was perfectly crispy, full of flavor, and not greasy at all. They even customized the toppings to match our team's preferences, which we really appreciated. The owner went the extra mile by wrapping everything with an extra blanket to keep it warm--such a thoughtful and caring touch. We'll definitely be ordering again! read more

I drove all the way there from Berkeley because I was craving good pizza and someone mentioned super slice pizza and it was disgusting to say the least there was barely any cheese on my pizza. It was extremely burnt on the bottom and the sauce was super sweet. I would not ever go here again to top it off. One slice was eight dollars. read more

Dropped in here on my way from one doctors appointment for my son to the second. We agreed for pizza for lunch so I looked for something relatively close to his second appointment and super slice pizza popped up. Totally a small gem on San Pablo ave what I have driven past on multiple occasions. There's a bunch of little places that may be interesting in this little strip what I have passed dozens of times. The place is not much. There are ready slices or you can order your own whole pie. The menu is not much clearly inflation has made them change there original pricing and with the fluctuations in food costs I am sure it's been hard them to land on a consistent price. There is no seating no soda fountain. Everything is grab and go I got a meat and veggie combo slice and my son got a pepperoni slice. Theses slices are massive we could have shared a slice for how big these slices are. My son said they he enjoyed his slice and I loved mine. We are already talking about going back and taking my other son as well when it's not a doctor appointment filled day read more

Super Slice Pizza - the counter area of a restaurant - Pizza Near Me - El Cerrito, California

See all

Very friendly guys who seem to be passionate about the pizza. Has an authentic NYC flavor. We get the large single slices. My girlfriend and I like to go here occasionally, and they are always smiling and remember our order after seeing us a few times. Interior is clean and the ovens are as professional as you'd expect. read more

Inconsistent. I had a veggie slice which was very good & cheap. But another time my family ordered a large Kitchen Sink and it was not at all good. Paid nearly $40 and it was floppy and undercooked. Next time, I'll stick to a slice. read more

We wanted a standard 2 topping pie. We typically get excited to try a new spot, however we were fooled by the Yelp pictures. Bringing home the pizza and lifting up the top, it's looked liked how it tasted. Horrible cheap tasting ingredients. Furthermore it costed $40 for 2 toppings on a large pizza. You can visit a bistro and get the same pizza made with fresh ingredients and enough money to leave a healthy tip. read more

Cool chill place reminds me of the good ole days. You can buy by the slice or a whole pie. Pizzas really good and the slices are giant. Great drink selection too in the coolers and they got an ice cream cooler too I saw. Friendly owners, good price, and fast service too, def will be back. read more

Great tasty thin crust pizza. So glad I finally tried this place. Ordered a whole Carnivore and picked up slices of pepperoni and the garlic chicken. My favorite is the garlic chicken but all were super tasty. The service was quick and easy to order over the phone and I added extra slices while I was there. This will be our new go to since we live a good thin slice crust. The other local pizza spots have been lackluster with flavor. read more

See all

Honestly I wanted to love this spot First time recommended on everybody's Richmond page. We went Saturday 12:30 seemed like an ok time but walking in 3 slices of pepperoni and two cheese in the window that's it. And they were waiting for more pizza to pull out. 25-30 minutes away. So we left came back next day. Figured let's give them a shot. I think ordering per slice is probably they way to go. We felt like first time, let's try a whole pizza we ordered half one way and half another way. I don't know if they felt rushed to get the pizza done for us. He did say 25 minutes we were totally fine waiting. Large pizza 37.00 seemed a little pricey for what we got. But I wanted to make this work. Support a new business and all. Got home, and one of my slices had literally no cheese no toppings unclear if maybe when it got sliced maybe the toppings got pulled off?. Combo side of the pie all veggies were still crunchy and raw. Olives no flavor, and pineapple interesting ,it was not sweet at all. If we go back it would be for a single slice maybe that's where they shine. Good luck, they are super friendly. read more

Super Slice Pizza - Lots of sauce hardly any cheese or meat - Pizza Near Me - El Cerrito, California

See all

A huge slice of "The Carnivore!" After sitting in traffic for about an hour, I built up quite the appetite. Two slices of Veggie and this last slice of The Carnivore. The gentleman at the cashier was welcoming, kind, pleasant, and cool dude! Nice NY style and evenly distributed toppings. Cheese was fine. For $8, the size of this thing is definitely leaning me towards quantity over quality. Not saying quality is bad but this is a nice deal for the price for a specialty slice and is still delicious and fulfilling. This is definitely for a quick grab n go bite. read more

Super Slice Pizza - The Carnivore - Pizza Near Me - El Cerrito, California

Great tasting pizza and awesome service! I receive two large one gilroy chicken and another large half margherita and half combo! Sooo good!!! Wish I took pic but we demolished it all before I remembered! Will definitely come back again! I'm a happy to have found a great pizza spot by this area!! read more

The owner. Whoever was serving it was really nice.They're always real friend laying there.The people is good.I like thin crust I took. A slice to go , they also have sliced pizza which I really like read more

Excellent service, excellent pizza. Go here if you value quality and want to support a local business. read more

This place is what it is. It's not my jam but I don't hate it. I'm just not a fan of sliced pizza spots. It's been a good option for my kid and husband. I don't like the seating or the lighting in there. The service is prompt. read more

The pizza was amazing and the slices are huge! They definitely do justice to their name super slice. Everyone in the family was able to get a slice of the pizza they wanted, so there was no bickering over what to get (always a win with kids). We also tried their salads (Caesar and Caprese) and both were good, and the fried cheese sticks were among the best you can get in the area. But the star was the pizza. The staff was super friendly as well, making the overall experience amazing. We're definitely going back, and if you're in the area, you should try it out. read more

Pizza was great! My roommate didn't double check it was the right pizza, so we ended up with an x-large pep instead of a large peperoni, sausage, mushroom, but the crust was good and they gave lots of peperoni. Staff was super friendly and Sal said he'd take care of us the next time! read more

I'm a BIG fan of sliced pizza joints! I like the option of being able to come in and grab a slice on the go if I'm not in the mood for a full pizza. Also, the slices are HUGE! Big enough to where you can cut them and make 3 smaller slices, which is great if you have small children. Cheese and pepperoni will always be available and sometimes if your lucky the special of the day will be available. The two guys that work there are nice and fast. My favorite part is they will warm up the slice for you and then grade some parmesan cheese on the pizza slice right out the oven. Writing this review makes me want to go get a slice now! read more

Really good! Thin sliced neopolitan style in El Cerrito! The northernmost slice of the East Bay is fantastic, and you owe it to yourself to try it at least so that you can compare it to the great pizza that we have around here. And, if you live in El Cerrito or Richmond, now you have some serious quality at hand. Had a large margherita slice. I usually order two slices at a pizza place, but these were really large, like 1.5 slices. The toppings were fresh and flavorful. The sauce was comforting and good - do I detect San Marzano tomatoes? The dough was the star though. Clearly homemade, chewy and crispy, it really made for a perfect slice. They don't have any place to sit yet; this place is definitely for take out and delivery. The Peppermint Tree Plaza is in a dirty, automotive stretch of San Pablo, but this gem shines! The owner is super nice and happy to be here. Check 'em out! read more

Somewhat pricey slices, but the owners are great and this is exactly the kind of local spot I'm willing to spend a little extra to support. Pizza is great - thin crust and filling. Also love the vibes read more

I love supporting local new businesses! I heard of this place on next door and had to try it first hand. Kept it simple with a medium (14") cheese pizza. Pickup time they told me 25 minutes but I got there in about 7-8 minutes pretty early and it was out of the oven hot n ready in under 12 minutes total. The place was clean , looks like they remodeled, was well lit, and they were super friendly, made me feel welcome. Honestly even if the pizza sucked I would leave at least 3 stars on those things alone. You want to feel welcome and that the place cares about the cleanliness, I mean, duh, they are preparing the food we eat. As for the pizza, oh it was yummy. Dough was perfectly cooked, wasn't too much but wasn't soggy either. Sauce was very flavorful, tasted FRESH, and wasn't too garlicky. I devoured 3 slices in mere minutes and my 12 year old did the same . We're both picky on our pizza but did enjoy this. Next time I'd like to try their veggie option ... As for the prices, I checked dominoes and their large pizza is the same size as super slice's medium and is a dollar cheaper, but hey I'd rather support my local businesses than a corporation. Plus they are just getting started so perhaps they will offer coupon in the future . Either way I'm very glad I have found a bomb pizza place close to home that are very friendly. Oh and they don't deliver yet , it's only pickup but I'd rather pickup myself and still be hot vs have it show up all cold, bleck! read more

Super Slice Pizza - Medium cheese pizza ...yum! - Pizza Near Me - El Cerrito, California

Walked in to see if they had a phone number to call in orders and the owner gave me his cell phone number and mentioned that they are on Google. Clean and friendly place. No where to dine in. I took a photo of their current hours. Owner was friendly and courteous. Didn't order pizza-just inquired read more

I was very excited to try this place. The pics of the slices look wonderful, and I wish that was what I had tried. Got a medium with pepperoni a week ago and was so disappointed by the thickness of the pie. I had to wait to write a review because I knew it would have been harsher if I had left one right away. I was expecting thin crust based on the pictures, but the crust was SO thick, like chain pizza place thick. I really did not enjoy the pizza at all, my boyfriend absolutely hated it. The ingredients seemed like they were good quality. Was thinking this would be my new spot for take out pies based on all the raving reviews (there were about thirteen 5 star reviews on Google before they even had a Yelp page). Maybe one day I will try a slice, but I doubt it since they don't have any tables to eat at. Glad they seem to have other fans! read more

I'm glad to welcome Super Slice to the neighborhood. Staff are super-friendly. Slices are BIG and TASTY! I had pepperoni this time. Gonna try combo next time. They have cans of soda & pints of a Ben & Jerry's ice cream available, too. read more

See all

The best thing about this new place (new because we just discovered it last month), is that it's truly New York style. Crispy thin crust. My mouth waters just from thinking about it. We got the carnivore, which was perfect. Can't wait until the next time we have a larger group to host/feed, I'd like to buy at least 3 different pizzas! The worst thing about this place is the ambiance. I wish with all my heart they could expand, or create a parklette of some sort and put out some tables for customers to eat there. I bet the pizzas would taste even better right out of the oven! read more

Peppermint Tree plaza on San Pablo just slays. This place has large, NY style slices at reasonable prices. We often go for the midweek deal and get the medium pepperoni pie. The staff are friendly and communicative and we love having this place in the neighborhood. read more