I had a very disappointing experience at Mountain Mike's Pizza in El Cerrito. I arrived to pick up my order, but it wasn't ready even though I was told it would be. The employee was still making my pizza after I got there, which meant I had to wait longer than expected. During that time, I observed an employee touch his nose while preparing food, which I found unsanitary and concerning. It made me uncomfortable about the food handling practices at this location. Because of the delay and what I witnessed, I won't be returning. I hope management addresses both the food safety concerns and the order timing. read more

Placed a phone order was told pie would be done in 15 min just for me to arrive and have to wait an extra 40min

Bro wanted pizza so we checked out Yelp. Never had Mountain Mike's which was close to home. He wax enthusiastic so we ordered medium Everest. It wax loaded and very good! I was there a bit earlier so the place was clean with two tv screens with the 49ers vs the Browns. I got the pizza and the cashier was very cordial and the pizza wax hot. The cashier gave me packets of cheese and chili. The salad bar looked fresh . I will likely go back. The pizza was delicious! read more

Always get take out there. Put plenty on the pizza, maybe too much . Would like to taste the of red catsup based topping spread. Next time just mushrooms . read more

The delivery driver who had just delivered pizza from this exact pizza place location, to my best friend's house in Richmond a couple days ago, was very rude, and didn't let my friend sign a reciept, and get a customer copy. Very unacceptable! Don't be going to people's address with some kind of punka** attitude about the front gate, or gate code not working, acting like as if they're responsible to fix the gate. Who does that delivery driver think he is? If there's a problem with the front gate, or gate code of a condo, or apartment. You respectfully with at least some sort of common sense, let the resident know, or if possible, go to the manager's office (if and when someone is there) which the manager can contact maintenance, rather than you come busting out your car with a stupid attitude about it. It's not my friend's responsibility to fix the gate, so informing the manager's office is a better option. I swear I better not see that happen again whenever I visit my friend, and we just happen to order pizza again. Got it? I hope I made myself clear. read more

The staff here are not stingy about their toppings, there are usually vegetables and meat falling off of my slice when lifting it up from the box. The crust is crisp, and everything is cooked evenly. My regular selections are Pikes Peak and Pineapple Chicken Luau, they definitely satisfy my pizza cravings! A buffet option is available in-person; however, I have never went there and sat down for this because I don't think I can eat enough slices to warrant the cost. An additional factor was that the physical space was not temperature controlled whenever I picked up pizza during the summer; it would be pretty hot and humid there. I would recommend getting the mobile app and enable email notifications if you intend to eat pizza on a semi-regular basis. There are oftentimes deals that are sent out for weekends, holidays, and game nights. This might include free toppings or sides, or traditional discount codes that can go up to 20% on your entire order's read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Coupon for customers with the app - Pizza Near Me - El Cerrito, California

The app is a joke. They offer a free side but can't redeem it. When I brought it up to the cashier, she gave me the same response about not knowing what to do. She offered a $3 discount but then said she can't discount my order because there was a discount already applied, the discount that supposedly didn't work. I'd stay away from here. They're incompetent when it comes to honoring their discounts read more

Always good pizza here, I like this location because they don't chop up their pizza toppings in small pieces like the other locations. Nice & clean salad bar. Very nice staff. read more

See all

Came in a week before we wanted to have a party for our basketball team so we could book the little party room. We spoke to the gentleman at the register at reserved the room. At the time of the reservation we told the gentleman that we would be doing the buffet for the eight kids and would be ordering a few large pizzas and drinks for the adults he said that was fine and that he would probably be working that night. On the party night we came in a little early to add some decor to the room. After we set up i went over to the register to ask if they would be cooking more pizzas as there one only one half under the warmer. She said as there were not that many people they didn't make more so I told her had eight hungry teens coming so could they please make more soon. I told her that we were going to order the buffets for the kids and some large pizzas for the adults and she said that we could not do that we had to order buffets for everyone in the party or the individual pizzas. We were taken aback as it ended up costing us a lot more than we had anticipated and i felt like we had been mislead as we specifically asked if we could do that when we booked. Aside from that the food and service was good. Salad bar was fresh. They did make more pizzas and even asked us which ones we would like. So we have no complaints about the food or service. As far as booking a party here again I am on the fence because of the inconsistent information read more

See all

Good pizza! Good service! And ...they take cash and deliver ( on time!!!!!). You can't beat that!

Pic of the menu , great food, great service. Safe and quite place in El Cerrito. Remember that Wednesday are Buffett dinner . read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - El Cerrito, California

At this point, they know my name. LOL My family and I are here atleast 1/2 every week or two! The reason is beyond the pizza always being cooked perfectly! It's their customer service! Whether I call in the order or go in person to pick up, whoever is standing behind the counter is always so kind, attentive and shows appreciation for making a purchase with them! THAT is rare these days and THAT is why we keep coming back! read more

I don't think they know how to make a thin crust pizza; they are very thick. Also, their medium size pizza cost like a large size pizza at other pizzerias. Won't be back. read more

Always have loved their pizzas ever since the first time I tried them 5 years ago. My 93-year-old mother enjoys the barbecue wings.

Clean, roomy. The pizza was really good and I don't know what they did to the pizza sauce but it was delicious!!!

I used the App, had some available discounts and coupons. Ordered a large specialty pizza. Note: I ordered when I was physically in Oakland via the App. I received a call while I was driving to El Cerrito, to verify that I was picking up my pizza. Not sure why the App is so intense... needs to verify via a call??! Once I got to the counter, I let them know my "verification" in person. It took a couple minutes to get that out the door. read more

This location was very clean, had friendly staff, and even refrigerated Parmesan! Never seen that before. Top notch read more

I needed pizza for a large group and I was running late to the party and everyone was hungry. Since I was running late, my friends hosting called me after i had ordered 4 "mountains" that half the people left. I called and asked to cancel 2 of the pizzas (5 min after placing the order) and it was no problem for them. I was amazed! I ended up getting 2 "mountain" size pizzas which feeds 7-8 people each!! Typically a regular large is good for 4 people, so this was awesome I could get just 2 pizzas and have the group fed. The pizzas were massive. 15 people and we had some left over. The pepperoni went really fast. The pepperonis were so delicious, the way they curled up into cups and had just the right crispiness and flavor to them. The veggie pizza was great too, veggies were perfect not too soft not too raw. The guy was so nice, he helped me carry the pizza to the car. And I forgot to mention all was ready in 15-20 min. Amazing! Was so happy with the service and food and everything here. read more

Came hear to eat inside but as soon as you walk in you get this strong chemical smell. When you walk into a restaurant the only thing you should smell is food not their cleaning products. So I decided to take it home instead. Got half Hawaiian and half pepperoni and it was definitely good the pepperoni is a little spicy but nice and crispy ! Wings were perfect not burnt or dry overall I would definitely order to go again. read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - El Cerrito, California

See all

Okay, okay I'm a Mountain Mike's fan. They are popping up all over the place and recently in my neighborhood. I have ordered twice now, once on Halloween and last night. Both arrived either on time or last night, before the estimated delivery time. My guy loves his pizza simple and I like spicy, so we compromised and I ordered half jalapenos on our sausage and cheese pizza. With online ordering you can specify exactly what you want and where. Want two completely different pizzas? You can do that. We ordered a regular crust the first time and a thin crust last night and I prefer the thin now because it was cooked perfectly. I even liked how they cut the slices kind of small, they were easier to eat and I think I'll ask for that again. Good pizza for delivery! read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Sausage and cheese with jalapeños on half. - Pizza Near Me - El Cerrito, California

Always 100% fantastic. The staff is always kind and accommodating. Orders are always accurate and timely.

Best part of the meal was the chicken, pizza is horrible, one step above domino's, skip next time and look for a non chain pizzeria

This location is great for take out or dine in. The pizza is awesome. I get the lunch special and order delivery regularly. Drivers are always prompt with a hot pizza. A big need during the playoffs! read more

Pizzas are consistently delivered on time and as ordered. Love the thin crust! We always order from the El Cerrito location.

First off, the overall delivery experience should be 4 stars because the delivery was about 10-20 minutes late both times I ordered, but I have no idea what caused it and I didn't bother asking why, so I didn't want to dock points against the restaurant (instead of the driver) for it. I've ordered delivery twice from this place and both times the food was great. It's pretty greasy, but not disgustingly-so, so it mostly just ends up being great comfort food. I also appreciate how they pile on the toppings but somehow nothing gets undercooked; it's all great! The wings I got were also great; they weren't dry and had a good amount of sauce on them. Finally, they package their deliveries fairly well. They provide all the condiments you could ever need, along with a container of garlic sauce, in a neat plastic bag (not just flying around everywhere in the delivery bag). Overall, if you want some great delivery, this place is pretty solid (modulo the delayed deliveries mentioned above). read more

See all

First time trying Mountain Mike's and also my last. There's something not quite right about the red sauce in their pizza. Pretty disappointing. read more

My family and I have been been doing dine-in or delivery from this location every two weeks for past few years. When we eat in the restaurant the staff is always very accommodating of my kids and will show cartoons on one of the TVs. We usually get a pepperoni pizza and I love how crispy the thin little pepperonis get. The draft beer is a great deal. We've also had the wings which were pretty tasty. The prices are reasonable and there is usually a promotional coupon on the website. I'm giving a five star review today because MM went above and beyond for my daughter's birthday. We asked for some extra pizza tables that my daughter wanted to use for a little school (Coronavirus home school) project. They sent us over a bag full of little pizza tables ! read more

For a local chain, this pizza is always great for a quick movie night or an easy meal after a long day at work. I always tell myself I'll make it to the buffet but I haven't done it yet, but hear that it is a great value. My personal favorite pizza to grab for parties is the chicken club, add in some wings and you're all set! Sometimes a little pricy but usually can find some deals in the app or on the website. read more

My wife and I just moved here from Illinois, which means we have certain expectations with how pizza is made. We had ordered the McKinley and oh sweet mother of God it was incredible. Perfect crust, perfect sauce, perfect amount of cheese. We can't wait to order them up again! read more

I tried their pizza for the first time today, it was great. i tried the everest which is a very popular pizza on the menu! I will definitely be back for more pizza! they always make sure my family gets the pizza they like! read more

The crust is soooo good! I've never had a bad experience with mountain mikes!! Chicken pizzas with white sauce! Yes! read more

See all

I have ordered from this location about 4 times now and I took a LONG break between the 3rd and 4th time and now this is the last. When I spend almost $40 for Pizza, no one better call me and have the AUDACITY to insinuate that I should come to your car and get it. If the EL CERRITO location is terrified to come into a Black and Latino neighborhood because we are all murderers and robbers, maybe they shouldn't! no one gives a damn about them in this neighborhood especially not on my block where a retired Richmond Police, a Retired Schoolteacher, A small business owner, a host of other professionals, and myself, a 15 year tech professional who works for major Fintech, lives. Do better! Meanwhile, I was the only one robbed by the driver withholding my change, like it wasn't money as well. To add injury to insult, the garlic bread was very dry and the pizza was very tasteless. Never again. read more

My boys and I love this place..they have great pizza our favorites were the combination of sausage, chicken, mushrooms and pineapple. Yummy!! read more

Nice clean location in the plaza next to Marshall's on San pablo ave. I got a coupon in the mail so I decided to give it a try since I've never had Mountain Mikes pizza before. Ordered the Everest online and did a pick up in store. They called me around 20-25 mins later saying that my order was ready for pick up. Went in got my pizza, Large Everest for $23. Not too bad. The pizza itself looked great. The ingredients looked fresh and smelled terrific. My only complaint was the crust/dough was a bit tough... not chewy at all like I'm used to. Not sure if it was over cooked but it was strange. Not a deal breaker at all, but would've been much better if it was a bit softer. I actually enjoyed the leftovers the second day after tossing it in the microwave as the dough softened up and tasted better! I'll go back again with coupons in hand and perhaps try another one of their specialty pizzas. read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Combo pizza "the everest" - Pizza Near Me - El Cerrito, California

So I was eating my pizza when I feel something hard and poking me. When I remove the bite that I took there was a piece of wood in my pizza! read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - The piece of wood that was inside a slice of pizza - Pizza Near Me - El Cerrito, California

See all

Eh, this place is not good. Their salads are seceral days old and the lettuce was brown when it got delivered. The pizza that I asked for half and half was wrong and had toppings on both sides. The pizza isn't good either. No more ordering from here again. read more

This pizza is ok for the area (not saying much), but not worth it. The crust is not chewy. It's like bread. The sauce and cheese are just average. They compensate for their lack of pizza-making skill by loading them with toppings... a lot. Not like in Brooklyn or Naples where they only put a few pieces on each slice. So if you like overpriced pizza with a ton of toppings, this place is for you. read more

They got my order wrong and brought me a pizza with no cheese. I double checked my order confirmation which clearly showed cheese. I called and the customer service was horrible. They refused to give me a refund or replace it even when I offered to send a photo of my order confirmation. It was also 40 minutes late. Will never order from here again. read more

So.....decided Pizza would be good for the 2 of us for dinner. New Mountain Mike's not too far away. I don't usually eat pizza much because it's so hard to find something decent. Haven't had Mountain Mike's Pizza since the early eighties so I thought I'd give it a try. I tried to call ahead first however the young man who answered the phone seemed to have a problem with spelling common words. I decided to go in and order myself. I got there just after 6 p.m. and the place was fairly busy. They have an all-you-can-eat pizza/salad buffet, which appeared to be what most of the customers were eating. I ordered a large McKinley, 6 honey barbecue chicken wings and 2 salads to go. The salad comes from the salad bar so I made them myself. Typical salad bar but no place to put your plate or container while you work. Hence ingredients were kinda cross contaminated. 2 out of 5 stars. The salad was the best thing I got for my $40. Got my food in 20 minutes, was home in less than 10. WINGS: Frozen generic seasoned wings that they throw into the oven and sauce. Mine? Mushy with no sauce on them. Did they forget? Less than 1 star. PIZZA: Already cold and soggy. 1 inch thick. Meaning 1/2 in of thick bready frozen dough with that Pillsbury biscuit flavor. 1/4 in of canned tomato sauce/catsup. The rest was the skimpy toppings. Very little meat, no onions and 2 cups of refrigerator cold diced tomatoes. All together a great thing for 6 year olds (sans tomatoes of course). Truly the worst pizza I've had in my entire life. Maybe they'll get better. I'll give them another try. In about 2046 AD. Until then, save your money. Oops forgot to mention. No WIFI........4G dead zone to boot. Figures. read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Popping fresh!! - Pizza Near Me - El Cerrito, California

Love Mountain Mike's pizza just moved back to NorCal from Santa Monica (L.A. has horrible pizza) and so happy to have Mountain Mike's behind our apartment. Place is clean and smells great. Gary is a great guy had a good conversation with him overall a wonderful experience and will be back a lot. read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Not a real Mountain Mike's without Crazy Taxi and a shooting game #awesome - Pizza Near Me - El Cerrito, California

See all