Some places can be reviewed with very few words and this is one of them. This bakery is one of the best I've ever been to. I usually get strawberry shortcakes and red velvet cupcakes and cakes from here. Their desserts are always fresh and tasty. Definitely worth every penny paid for. Workers are friendly as well. I had my wedding cake from here and it was perfect. No regrets with nothing bought from this establishment. I'd recommend to any and everyone. read more

Supreme Bakery - Red Relvet Cake - Bakeries Near Me - West Orange, New Jersey

If you want basic cake then come here. I order a carrot cake for my birthday and it was literally vanilla with little carrot bits in it. Look NOTHING like a traditional carrot cake. When I asked about it they said thats how they make carrot cake. If thats how they make it they should let their customers know its not a traditional carrot cake The manager was supposed to reach out to me but never did. Will not be going back. read more

I WILL NOT COME HERE AGAIN!!! Unfortunately I've had it with the staff. I couldn't wait to get home to write this review. This, after an exchange of words with Jessica, who could care less about customer service. She should be FIRED. What happened to customers first? This is what happened: I stand there next in line. Jessica looks right past me to the lady behind me and asks her for if she needs help. Mind you I'm a 6'2 man that's hard to miss. I asked "how can you not see me?" She said, "don't worry about it it's no big deal!" ("No big deal?!") that's when I lost it This wasn't the first time I had an issue with Jessica in particular. Last time she was rushing me with my decision and was visibly frustrated when a didn't have an immediate answer for her of what I wanted. It's a shame but, I'll be going to Montclair Villinamore for my dessert cravings now. Much better customer service. I'll pay the price. Customer service is underrated. And Supreme Bakery does NOT put the customer first. read more

Although my cake did not look like the picture I gave them, it was cute & delicious nonetheless! The customer service is meh. I ordered the cake and left a deposit like they asked me to (the suggested amount.) 2 hours after I left the store they called me saying I didn't leave enough money. I explained to the lady over the phone that I left the amount she asked for. She told me if I didn't bring in more money, they would not make my cake. So, that's why I took away 2 stars. read more

Supreme Bakery - It's totally not like the picture I gave them but it was still cute!! - Bakeries Near Me - West Orange, New Jersey

I ordered a chocolate mousse cake through Uber eats. The cake looked beautiful, so I immediately cut a slice for myself. Took my first bite and tasted the mold right away! I was really disappointed because I have been craving for this. (I'm 6 months pregnant) I'm glad I noticed it right away or else this could've gotten me sick! read more

Supreme Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - West Orange, New Jersey

See all

When faced with another year of getting my daughter a birthday cake that looked a lot better than it tasted, I asked the interwebz to find me a custom cake maker near Verona. Welcome, Supreme Bakery and thank you. We used an online cake maker to choose everything - the size, the type of frosting (whipped cream - excellent, so much better than buttercream), the type of cake (red velvet - spongy and packed with flavor) and the innards (fresh banana and strawberries - so perfect, pieces of strawberry throughout). We then added the text and clicked a few other things, paid, and our cake was ordered with a requested pickup time and date. It could not have been easier. They also have custom kids cakes and for $10 they will scan any picture onto edible paper to cover the cake. I called the day before to check on it and confirmed that it would be ready. The cake was amazing. It was actually too good for most of the kids as most kids are used to supermarket cakes with buttercream and garbage, but that just meant more for the adults (*pauses review to go get leftovers). It was about $40 and probably could have fed at least 12 people at a minimum. The store is centrally located right on Main St. in West Orange and is very nice inside - clean, orderly and full of sugary goodness everywhere. Tons of cupcakes, cakes, breads and muffins to stuff your morning face with. I didn't get anything else because I was picking up a cake, but next time it seemed there were some blue velvet and coconut cupcakes with my name written all over them! read more

Supreme Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - West Orange, New Jersey

Hands down the best BLT or any other type of sandwich I have had since I became plant based in 2015!!!!

This was a disgrace! First and foremost they gave me the wrong cupcake because they ran out of the one I wanted. Secondly, the cupcakes were extremely dry. I had no choice put to be very careful swallowing; fearing I would choke on them. The icing was superrrr cold and sweet. I feel as though these cupcakes are made and then thrown in the fridge. I was fooled by the presentation from the yelp photos. I will never order from this place again. read more

Supreme Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - West Orange, New Jersey

Clean and bright, a comfortable bakery to sit down having coffee and spend your morning. Came in with a living social deal. The girl who helped me was very nice and patient. Busy in the morning, and there were many people behind me in line. I had the $15 for $30 deal, which turned out to be a big and time consuming order but they did not rush me. I told them I wanted a dozen miniature fancy pastries mixed and placed nicely in a good looking box so I could bring them to a friend's house for a lunch party. I saw the girl very patiently selected the pastries and carefully placed them into the box without rush despite the long line behind me. Very good customer services and they were all friendly. Although located on Main Street, there is a huge parking lot behind the bakery store and better yet, it's 25 cents per hour meter parking!!! I still prefer asian bakeries, cause I don't like sweets. But if you are into sweet treats, you will definitely love this place. read more

Supreme Bakery - Miniature fancy pastry - Bakeries Near Me - West Orange, New Jersey

See all

They make rugelach that come close to those we'd get at Garden Bake Shop in Floral Park NY-40 yrs ago. I'm on the verge of putting in a standing order for every few weeks. Quality bakery. Not the easiest thing to find in the day of supermarkets. Good recipes-1/3 of the tripod. Ingredients 1/3 & the actual measuring, mixing & baking the final 1/3 + a little good sweat. Rabbinical approval can only be a plus. read more

Very disappointed!! Order cookies twice and looked nothing like the website. Total trash!!! read more

I can't speak on the customer service because my brother brought this cake for my moms surprise birthday party. But the taste was perfect to me! It was perfectly moist, not too dense, the strawberry filling was perfect. This to me was one of the best birthday cakes I've tasted besides carvel ice cream cakes simply because of nostalgia lol. I would definitely go back for another one for the next birthday party. read more

Supreme Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - West Orange, New Jersey

I ordered my 30th birthday cake from here a week in advance. Blue velvet and butter cream filling with butter cream icing. It was perfect. They did everything just the way i ordered it. And my family loved it!!! Supreme has really improved over the years. They did my mom's bday cake last year. That was good too. She had half red velvet and half blue velvet filling. I'll continue using them for cakes!!! read more

Supreme Bakery - Blue velvet and butter cream!!! My 30th Birthday cake! - Bakeries Near Me - West Orange, New Jersey

I always get my cakes from here and they TASTE GREAT!!! But the execution is subpar. The decorating of the cake was sloppy!! Whoever is there icing and decorating the cakes have to do better. My cake for my daughter looks as if the person decorating it didn't care. I only go for the taste of the cake, that's it. Everything else has fallen off the grid. So sad. The owner needs to fix this now or you will be out of business. read more

Supreme Bakery - Just sloppy! Poorly executed. It's as if the person decorating the cake didn't care. - Bakeries Near Me - West Orange, New Jersey

See all

Pretty good local bakery with a nice selection of bread, pastries, cakes and rolls. My only gripe is that they seem to run out of bread early and I hate having to buy supermarket bread which is never as fresh. read more

Place is cute and clean, but unfortunately I had the cutest vision of bridesmaid proposal cupcakes that they couldn't make come true. I'm sure their pastries are delicious, but I gave up on even trying to make an order because visually I needed more than just a basic cupcake. Initially I left to go try other bakeries, but I ended up going back and I loved my cupcakes! They were so cute! Check the pic read more

Supreme Bakery - Will you be my bridesmaid? Will you be my maid of honor? my bridal party loved it! - Bakeries Near Me - West Orange, New Jersey

This place is horrible. They ruin my mom's birthday cake. It was not what we asked for. The color was wrong and they didn't include bananas. We also had to buy our own sprinkles. What type of bakery ask their customers to supply sprinkles. This place has went down. Nicole who was suppose to be the manager had no clue how to service us or manage. She said she was just a key holder but the owner said otherwise. Smh read more

Can't say enough nice things about Supreme Bakery. Ordered a cake for my wife's birthday and another for my mother's birthday and both times they were delicious and perfect. We will for sure be ordering again for father's day. They talked me into getting the fudge icing instead of the buttercream when I was uncertain....they were right. If there's a better bakery in the area, I'd sure like to hear about it. read more

First, this bakery is local. Second, the quality of the baked goods is fresh and very good. And they have cakes like a Brown Darby that are hard to find. (You have to order in advance but that's no hardship.) And the bakery is kosher, which may be important to you. The service gets there eventually but it is a bit confused. Overall a good bakery. read more

My husband just came home with a box of doughnuts and they are horrible. They are probably AT LEAST 3 days old. It's a shame that a reputable business like Supreme Bakery sells bake goods as hard as a rock! Very disappointed. read more

Since this is my local beakers, I will come here on the weekends and get breakfast pastries and coffee. I'm not highly impressed but I strongly believe in supporting local businesses. The girls who work there are always friendly. I did have to tell a young lady there about a month ago that she shouldn't be working if she is that I'll. It's against health violations. Pretty much I was telling her that no one should force her to come to work sick. (She needs rest, her coworkers don't need to get sick, and customers don't need to get ill). I'm guessing the woman who was here manager who interrupted said "well you gotta do what you have to do when you have a newborn right?" to I'm guessing another regular behind me who didn't even respond. That was uncalled for and rude. But you get a free coffee for checking in with yelp. read more

Supreme Bakery - Super Bowl cookies - Bakeries Near Me - West Orange, New Jersey

I was looking up bakery's in my area and I'm glad I came across this one. This was like a month ago but the lady that was taking my order was going back and forth between money and the bread when I told her that she was grabbing money then my bread she responded with then don't buy it. Ridiculous especially with COVID happening. read more

It doesn't get much better than Supreme bakery cakes but even the greats make a mistake every now and then. That was the case with a key lime pie. We had just gotten back from Key West FL and wanted more of that pie. We paid to have it made and when I picked it up it was soft, yellow (not light green) runny and poorly made. Usually their items are awesome but if they can't make something they should just say "no we don't make that". read more

I ordered cupcakes from this bakery. Sent a picture of EXACTLY what I needed. I was told it would be no problem- they'd definitely be able to do this. When I went to pick the cupcakes up... -_- The fondant flowers were falling off the cupcakes. The base and fondant were 2 different shades of blue (royal vs navy blue) although I only asked for Navy. The royal blue really threw the look off. - I requested pearl balls- necklace etc.. they put oversized balls - that looked like gum balls on the cupcake. Didn't match the image I initially sent to them. Now - I asked for it to be fixed- a young girl in the front took it to the decorator in the back- all she did was put the flowers back on the cupcake. She brought it out and I explained this was completely unacceptable. And they explained I would get a call from the manager. The decorator didn't even come out to address this hot mess. It's now been 3 weeks and NO call from anyone. No I will not return! read more

Recently went here to tame my sugar craving. Got a cookie n cream, red velvet, and vanilla. They were honestly terrible. My mother also did not enjoy. Maybe it was a bad night, but I will not be back. read more

Ordered a Black Forest Cake for Birthday Cake, and I am so impressed with the freshness and so happy was everything I had asked for the cherries, frosting and chocolate . So good! excellent! Thank you! I have had bagels and also cupcakes from my work colleague and had been meaning to come by and glad I did. read more

Compared to other bakeries the cupcakes/pastries are great and responsibly priced. But the staff is very unpleasant.

If I could give it less than one star I would. My girlfriend ordered a cake for a baby shower with explicit instructions to have the fondant blankets in Dallas Cowboy blue and Philadelphia Eagles green. She left sample swatches, (the team banners) as a color reference. Today, a week later , she went to pick up the cake and not only the banners were wrong, the piping on the cake looks like it was done by an amateur! When she spoke with the manager to see if she could get it corrected or at least a discounted price , the manager said that she couldn't help her. Not only that, she discovered that the cake was recently made because fondant is suppose to have time to harden; the fondant blankets can be moved We will not be going there again...subpar customer service read more

Supreme Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - West Orange, New Jersey

See all

Got a Groupon so figured I'd pick up a few items. Customer service here is horrendous. They don't list prices or tell you what the cakes are. The first woman I asked couldn't tel me how much the cakes were or what they were so she had to try to ask someone else. It took 45 minutes to get someone to help and pick up cakes and cupcakes. When I finally did get someone to help she put the wrong cake in the box was rude when I corrected her and overall rude through the whole transaction. Based on eating the cupcakes, they are quite dry and the ratio of frosting to cake is lacking, you're better off buying a box and making your own. read more

Ah! Who can refuse a red velvet cupcake after a hard day at work? How about a dulce de leche or German chocolate one? I was in cupcake heaven this afternoon at this bakery. But just as good are their birthday cakes. I've had red velvet, carrot, maple walnut; you can custom order from a huge offering of cakes, fillings and frostings. They also have nice breads and rolls. It can get busy here and parking is tight on Main Street, so park around the corner in one of the municipal metered lots. read more

My family has been coming here for years. They make some of the best birthday cakes. Fresh whipped cream with the fresh strawberries inside. Makes me want to celebrate birthday just thinking about it. The muffins and pastries are to die for.. also, from cakes, cookies, fruit Tarts you just can't go wrong. If you struggle with a sweet tooth / this is the place to be... read more

It is completely beyond my comprehension how they've managed to get 5 stars from anyone. My brother commissioned a cake from them for our father's 60th birthday party. He asked if they can make a cake in the shape of a beer bottle with a picture of a Budweiser label. They assured him they could do this. Come the day of the party, when my brother goes to pick up the cake they did not make a cake in the shape of a bottle. They made a regular sheet cake with a Budweiser label painted on it, then took the Bud bottle that my brother gave them to model from and stuck it in the cake. They stuck the beer bottle in damn cake!! Who does that??? i'd expect such ghetto mentality from a bakery in Newark, that's why we went to West Orange. It's 10 years later. I'm planning a surprise 70th birthday/Retirement party for my dad. I spent 3 hours designing a picture to be painted on my dad's cake, now I only need find a bakery that can do pictures on the cake. In comes Supreme. They accept the job and assure me they can do the picture. $80 for half a sheet, plus another $`0 for the photo. I'm thinking the $10 is not bad although 80 for the cake itself seems a little steep. Maybe at that price their cake rivals that of Whole Foods or Magnolias. But I go with it. I make the arrangement and tell me brother to cake is ordered. When I tell him where I ordered from, he tells me it's the same place that screwed the pooch on the Budweiser bottle cake 10 years before. (I didn't know because he ordered the cake before.) Well I assure him it's just a picture and not special shapes so they shouldn't be able to screw this up.... silly me. The picture came out completely discolored with a weird pinkish hue. They didn't bother trying to fix it or offer a discount or anything. When I went to pick up the cake it was all business as usually, except for the fact that they couldn't find my order for about 5 minutes, but that's the lowest issue here. They completely effed up my cake that I spent hours designing and they didn't care in the slightest. And the taste.... We' you get past the age of 21-25 you learn the difference between good bakery sweets and cheep little Debbie cakes(sugar & sh!t). At the age of 34 I generally try to avoid the 'sugar&shit' and save room for real desserts. This cake tasted like sugar & sh!t. I would have better served my family with a smaller, less expensive, BETTER tasting cake from Whole foods or probably anywhere else. Never Again. If you don't believe me email me at GambitLW@gmail.com I'll send you the pic I designed for the cake, vs the pic they actually put on the cake. read more

Oh memories. Supreme indeed! For as long as my family has lived in that area, this was our go to place for birthday cakes, graduation cakes, just-because cakes, and other bakery treats, and they never failed. Moist cake, great tasting fillings, and the frosting... perfection! I'm not sure if they do buttercream frosting because we always got whipped frosting. I remember fighting over cakes with my brother after birthday parties were done. I'd actually get angry at him for finishing my birthday cake, and vice versa. My mom and aunt used to hide the leftovers because if they didn't, it would be all gone! Sad story: my uncle placed an order for a graduation cake for me last year, and we never picked it up. I still have the order slip, and whenever I go back home and drive past the bakery, I wonder if they would let me pick it up. I mean he did pay for it. I'll have to check that out when I go home for the summer. Anyway, great place! read more

FIRST TIME CUSTOMER VERY DISAPPOINTED....Very sad that this is my first time trying and ordering from them and they messed up my order..I ordered the lollipop cupcake, a coconut cupcake , strawberry shortcake square. Lemon square and also 2 Large pastries which I chose to be eclairs which I love..Anyone see something missing??? No eclairs at all so what exactly happened??? Very disappointed in my first experience with this bakery. I gave 2 stars because I got my other stuff and it was decent but for a first time customer and ordering from doordash I'm sorry but you left me disappointed and you came highly recommended. Don't know if I will order again or just go in person but I shouldn't have this problem..if I order something u should give it to me what I'm paying for..if u don't have in-stock then u call me ..very disappointed read more

Supreme Bakery - Coconut Cupcake, Lollipop BC Cupcake, Strawberry Shortcake Square, Lemon Square, - Bakeries Near Me - West Orange, New Jersey

See all

Best Strawberry Shortcake I'VE EVER HAD! This bakery has a large selection of cakes, pies, cookies, bread, etc, not everything taste good IMO. I've tried some things that are just OK, and others that are very good. Well, I recently tried their Strawberry Shortcake and was blown away, its perfect! The chocolate mouse cale, and cheesecakes are also above average. read more

This used to be my favorite bagel spot. But a few days ago I went in there with my son who was running circles ( which I don't approve of.) I believe there is a time and place for everything. So I was trying to get him to stop, trying to get him to wait to play, ( he is 5, so I had to say it multiple times). I go up to the register and say I'm sorry ( as in about him running around the bakery) and Marie one of the girls behind the counter was like " He is a kid you should let him be. Nothing to apologize about he is just being a kid.... basically giving me advice." I was mortified. Last time I checked, this was Supreme Bakery not Marie the Pediatric Psychiatrist. I didn't get into because I was in a rush . And my son was there which made it worse! He does not need to hear someone excuse him for poor behavior because he is a kid. Anyway, now I feel weird about going there. Which SUCKS. read more

I want to like it more than I do. Everything I've tried is just ok. Cookies, cakes, breads, even coffee are absolutely fine, but nothing is spectacular. It's a decent enough place to purchase a baked good to bring to a party, but its unlikely you'll wow anybody. Honestly, I'd just as soon pick something up from the local Shoprite. I've been more impressed by their stuff while leaving a few dollars in my pocket in the process. read more

This place will ruin your birthday or whatever special occasion u have they do not take orders correctly and by the time u realize it's wrong your occasion is ruined over with done just ruined some occasions you can't get back smh. read more

I ordered these to be delivered as a bday treat and was very disappointed on the presentation and how they arrived. I live in Las Vegas, so I went through UberEats to find locations in NJ and that is how I found this place. Flavor was alright, but not what was expected (per the bday persons view). read more

A friend's birthday was approaching and I was tasked with getting the cake. I ordered online and it was super easy. The cake was scrumptious - def the best bakery cake I've had in 15 years (and I'm in the food biz). Equally delish are their chocolate-frosted donuts, my weakness. I tried a choco ruggelach but honestly I've had better. I also ordered - of all things - a cinnamon raisin bagel & it was terrific. I'll be back for sure read more