We recently moved to the area and were looking for a decent bakery to get sweets from. We are so delighted to have found this gem. We have picked up multiple cakes for birthday and anniversary events from this bakery. The smell of bread and sugar can be smelled walking towards the store. There is always a line of people here waiting to get their goodies. My chocoholic little one who loves to try out chocolate lava cake from different restaurants and bakeries, thinks that this place has the best one! Very moist and indulgent! I have not seen very many bakeries that make the "Brown Derby" cake. It is chocolatey, yet light and refreshing with the fruit. They have a deli counter, but we have yet to try any of the items there, as we always walk out of there with many cookies and other treats. But, we will one day. read more

poor customer service the ladies in the counter were not very nice. they must not like working there. read more

Petcher's in Harrison. Mazur's in Lyndhurst. Brother's in Kearny. Vitello's in Nutley. Every (baking) empire eventually... crumbles. (Dad's gotta dan pun, we can't help ourselves.) With all the old guard now in the history books I began searching for a new reliable bakery. Very first visit here and... I was on the fence. Second visit... okay, I'm a fan. Subsequent visits... actually I'm a big fan. From red velvet cookies to Sfogliatella to carrot cake - they have more than enough treats to quell your sweet tooth. The breads (the reason I find myself here most times) - incredible. Rolls (of varying sizes) as well as a damn perfect bastone (crunchy and flaky, ready to be piled high for a sandwich) not to mention... the almighty Pizza Bread?! Oh, yeah. A bit more rare to find but the only proper 'pane' if/when you're going to make an Italian hot dog. They also have a side/section with a full deli if savory is more your speed. Cool staff. Good pricing. Metered street parking but be warned... this one specific street feels more like a strip mall - with probably a dozen businesses (liquor stores to salons to fitness centers to a few restaurants to...) - all vying for those spots. (And if you ever need an icebreaker at a social gathering... tell 'em "da Vinci" wasn't actually Leonardo's last name. You're sure to be a hit at the party!) read more

I was able to sample a couple items from this spot as I did not attend. They did have deli sandwiches besides just all baked goods. I had a St. Joseph pastry with cannoli cream as well as a custard filing. The one with custard filing had some type of fruit topping as well. Both were great. The pastries as a whole were light while there was plenty of filing in each one. Neither cannoli cream nor custard were too sweet either. They were also of appropriate size. Will I go back? I did not physically go but would head there. read more

DaVinci Bakery - St. Joseph Pastries - Bakeries Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

Once again , I bought a beautiful custom made 1/2 sheet cake for my grandson's 1st birthday last week 8/23/2025. They never disappoint. I will be forever grateful for their professionalism, courtesy and listening exactly what I wanted. This is the 4th time I bought from them and will continue to do so. Anyone that wants a great bakery come here. Owner Roseann is extremely pleasant as is the girls that work for her. Thank you again read more

DaVinci Bakery - Black and white cake with banana and custard filling. Buttercream on top with hand designed - Bakeries Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

Have been here many times & never disappointed. bread perfect crust. Fig bars are a huge favorite with the coffee, seasonal cookies that are only available 2weeks before Christmas.. omg.. can't ask for anything fresher! Love the family that owns/works there too! read more

My favorite bakery in New Jersey. Excellent breads and rolls, cookies and pastries are outstanding as are their cakes. Delivering high quality specialty cookies for the holidays that are difficult to find. Also their subs on their freshly baked bread are outstanding read more

I thought they were the best bakery in NJ and, while their cakes, cookies and pastries are still some of the freshest and most delicious, the size of the pastries have shrunk considerably. Along with the high cost per item, this is very unfortunate! I've noticed this in a few recent visits. Their napoleon and their brownies, for example, both seem to be just a little larger than 2" squares. C'mon! Don't do this to your loyal customers! We deserve better!! Happily their service is still great; the girls who work there are top notch! read more

1st birthday cake! Black and white cake on the inside, buttercream on the outside. It was amazing, as always!! read more

DaVinci Bakery - 1st birthday cake! Black and white cake on the inside, buttercream on the outside. It was amazing, as always!! - Bakeries Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

Bread and Black and White were awesome. Service was fast and friendly. Meter parking in walking distance of Bakery. read more

My favorite bakery. The bread and cakes are always fresh Fast service and the is always clean and beautiful sandwiches are always delicious and the cookies trays are nice I've taken there pastries to ny, Massachusetts,Orlando fl read more

DaVinci Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

I'm a huge Calandra's fan, but DaVinci gives them a run for their money! My father absolutely loves coming here weekly for treats. While I think they make great desserts and bread, I've had better. It's still a family go to and staff is super sweet. Their cheesecake had a lingering powdered sugar flavor after each bite. I might be off, but I prefer a cream cheesier NY style. Still enjoyable though. Bread is always great! Plenty more for me to try and will update my review then! read more

DaVinci Bakery - Cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

I think this maybe my first bakery I yelped. The cookies and cakes are always fresh For the 4th I got an apple pie and it was still warm and must haves weighed over 5lbs Very fresh and so good. If you live in Nutley then it's a must go read more

In addition to being the most expensive bakery in the area, they can't even give you a bag. They want to charge you $.50 for a recycle bag.

Ordered a cannoli cake for my husband's birthday. The process was easy and staff was helpful. The cake itself was delicious. I loved how light and fluffy it was. It was the perfect balance of cake and filling. Would definitely love to try more cake flavors in the future! read more

DaVinci Bakery - Cannoli birthday cake - Bakeries Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

I ordered a jungle themed cake for my daughter's second birthday and I could not be happier with how it turned out! Not only did it look amazing, but it was absolutely delicious. Very pleased with the customer service as well. Awesome experience all around, I would highly recommend coming to this bakery! read more

DaVinci Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

The ongoing pandemic has definitely taken a toll on a lot of businesses and public places since a consumer's mindset to buy anything outside of essentials or to visit a public place like a park or beach, has crippled down significantly. Now by living with what has become the new normal, it is commendable on how these businesses and public places continue to remain open and cater to the general public by following the safety standards. It is now all the more important that we as customers, support these heroes during these dark hours to mankind. This is a great bakery in a very residential place like Nutley. The first time I got a chance to eat something from here was when my wife got a Creme brûlée from here and it was out of the world. That made me wanted to try out this place and in person. We visited this shop on Saturday along with our relative who was visiting us, the day after Black Friday just before the store closure. The shop was well-dressed with Christmas decors and gave a complete Holiday mood. The desserts were a treat for the eyes possibly featuring all colors picked from a color palette. We ordered a Creme brûlée, Tiramisu and a Cannoli. We had given a lot of hopes and buildup for the desserts that we started tasting the desserts while driving back home. The Creme brûlée was good but the Tiramisu was a total let down. It tasted close to being stale and we could not carry on with it anymore and the cannoli was pretty ordinary too. It was a total let down after taking an effort to impress the guest. The shop is usually a good bet on the money and that day was an odd experience. May be it's just an one time experience but I hope they can get back to what they do the best and rectify on what went wrong. read more

See all

I need to admit, that I personally have not had the chance to step foot inside this bakery, but my FiL gets all our baked goods from here for the past 2 years. So I HAVE eaten cakes, pastries, cookies, and breads from here 25 + times. We used to go to Calandra's in Newark, but their quality, service, and care has gone down, while their prices have skyrocketed. A family member recommended this place, and we have been coming here ever since! If you need any baked good, this is your place, even if you are not local! Their breads are super fresh! We get the both the long and sandwich rolls here all the time. Flaky and delicious. Their cannoli's are killer as well! Not too sweet, just perfect. For every event that we have, we get 3-5lbs of assorted pastries from here, and by now, I have probably tried at least 1/3 of them, and they are all amazing! You can see the care and effort that the bakers put into each one. They are not just mass produced. Sadly I am terrible at the names of most of the pastries... But the ones I tried are great. For Easter, their Italian pies and breads are the best that I've ever had!!! We got 1lb last year and 3 this year and it still wasn't enough lol! The cookies from here are great as well. They are always a hit every time we get them. All in all, if you need baked goods, this place is the place! read more

I was headed to a family event and was planning to bring a dessert, so I stopped into the Davinci Bakery to pick-up an Italian cookie platter. The assortment included buttery and sweet sprinkle cookies, chocolate chip ones, jelly-filled sandwich cookies, and more. The cookies were very fresh and well-received. read more

Amazing cake for my sons birthday. Would recommend to anyone. Service was great they took the time to box it up right. The taste was incredible. read more

DaVinci Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

Tried this place out for my bf's mom's bday back in August and have been getting cakes there for every special occasion since!! My favorite so far is the strawberry shortcake for sure. They have some fresh cakes prepped and ready to go daily in the fridge at the front or you can call ahead and ask for something more extravagant. One time they even accommodated my request to have a cake ready a day earlier due to a change of plans. Not to mention everything looks and tastes amazing, have to convince myself not to buy everything in there! The staff is friendly as well. Will be back DaVinci bakery but you knew that already ;) read more

See all

Great pastries just wish they had a larger assortment or something new/innovative. Friendly service always!

The owner of this bakery is rude, condescending, inconsiderate and arrogant and definitely needs to attend a customer service class. I placed a prepaid order and specifically asked if I would have to wait on line to pickup and was told no I was even asked what time I would like it ready. why wouldn't you have aline for pickup separate from the line of people coming in to place an order?! Given my Conversation with owner it seems she hasn't been able to figure that out. read more

So happy with the gender reveal cake from Davinci bakery. The cake was light and not overly sweet. The staff were so helpful. I also ordered a variety of pastries, pizza, meatballs. Everything was delicious. Highly recommend this bakery. read more

DaVinci Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

See all

Staff is extremely helpful and friendly! The bread is always fresh!!! We ordered a cake and it got raved reviews from family and friends that now we order it for all the holidays! (Yellow cake w/custard and whipped cream) read more

My father in law asked me to order a cake for him ... even though the cake was more expensive than a few other places I heard good things about DaVinci so decided to try it. It was fine when we picked it up but was cracked when we had to take pictures. I called to asked for a discount for my father in law who was very upset (wasn't asking for a free cake) and they told me it can happen when it's placed in the fridge yet they told us to put it in the fridge and never warned us that this could happen. read more

See all

Love this place! We get the bread and rolls, and all our cakes from here. The cakes are so tasty, and we buy them for all our events. read more

DaVinci Bakery - Custom cake - Bakeries Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

Best Italian rolls ever. I've been going there since they opened and never was disappointed the variety of pastries, cakes and cookies are exceptional. One of if not the best bakeries around. read more

Ok I spend way too much time in bakeries but this place deserved a review. First impression is the cleanliness......the bakery appeared spotless. The kid behind the counter was friendly and patient when I wasn't ready to order right away. I got a black and white cookie and a chocolate mousse pastry and both were very good and tasted fresh. I also got a French roll which was nice and fresh even though it was late afternoon. The bakery is located in a strip mall....if it wasn't for Yelp I probably never would have found it. The bakeries in Nutley and Belleville are so-so but I may have found a go to spot. They have a deli which I will try in the future. I will definitely be back to try the cookies and other pastries. read more

See all

I am not a huge fan of sweets in general, so it takes a lot for me to get excited about a bakery. I walked into this place, though, and I was immediately under its spell. I heard angels singing LOL!!! The smells and the sights of the cookies and pastries are intoxicating. I got some custard tarts and the Nutella cookies....... SO delicious! I have a long list of things I want to try, so I will definitely be back for more. read more

Everyone loved the cake ! Thank you for making my wifes 50th party great! Excellent service and great customer service. read more

DaVinci Bakery - Excellent job with my wife's 50th birthday party! - Bakeries Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

Da Vinci did an amazing job with our convalidation/wedding cake. We sent an image in advance and they did a great job creating our vision. They are also super easy and pleasant to communicate with. And most importantly, the cake was delicious! read more

Such a great bakery! I order from them all the time. I love their tiramisu cake and strawberry shortcake.

Its a very nice bakery, the bread is great and the pastries,pies and cakes are just above average, but................. if you're not walking there forget it!! There is ABSOLUTELY NO PARKING in that entire area 24/7. There are far too many businesses in that area for the amount of available parking. There are other quality bakeries in Nutley where you don't have to circle like a buzzard waiting for someone to leave and hoping nobody grabs the spot. And to add insult to injury......you have to feed a meter (typical Nutley). I had to pass it by again today at 1:00 p.m. on a Tuesday....NO PARKING. It's really unfortunate because they have very good bread. read more

Our Daughter and her Husband Abdel's Baby shower 6/11/2023 at Mamma Vittorio's in Nutley NJ, was the most perfect day we could have imagined. The perfection was personified by the exquisite cake made for us by DaVinci Bakery Centre St Nutley NJ . So many compliments from all our guests some which said it was the best they've had, Just as they did for her Bridal shower Davinci KNOCkED IT OUT OF THE PARK!!! THREE CHEERS FOR DAVINCI BAKERY!!!i read more

OMG where do I start ?! Amazing !! unbelievable !! I have never had a cake so fresh and delicious. I had a birthday party for my dad and heard such great things about this bakery ,so I decided to try it out. Thank God I did !! my party can't stop talking about the cake. Best Bakery around hands down !!! I will definitely be back !! read more

DaVinci Bakery - Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

Ordered a cake for my dad's bday. The cake was beautiful and delicious! Everyone kept asking where it was from. Also the employees here are so sweet and helpful. Will definitely be coming back! read more

I needed some bread to go with all my soup lunches and did not want to stand in line to get into ShopRite for one item, and standing 6 feet apart in line outside doesn't do much good when people are less than a foot away from you in the store. Kind of backwards. Anyway, I remembered someone mentioning the name of this bakery to me over a year ago (talking about how good their sandwiches are) so I Googled it and found that it was a 15-20 min walk from my house. I've been up and down Centre St many times but never noticed this place. It's in a row of shops and they all kind of look alike when you go by. Right now it's limited to 4 customers at a time in the bakery so you have plenty of room between you and everyone else, which is exactly how it should be. First, this place is eat off the floor clean. The level of clean that only your grandmother could ever seem to hit. The selection was insane. I wanted to spend $200 buying about 50 different things but I can only imagine how many calories are in all those delicious looking items ... so I ended up getting only what I came for, bread. It was delicious. You could tell that it was only a couple of hours old. I'm going to eventually go back for other things. I'm so happy I found this place. In reading some of the unhappy customer reviews, this place really strikes me as the kind of place that wants patrons to be happy and would replace whatever you were unsatisfied with. I mean it's a bakery ... if your cookie was stale they can easily give you one of the other 2,000 cookies they have. It's not like they have to custom make another one for you. read more

Been visiting this bakery for quite a while and I have to say their pastry's are amazing, specially their carrot cake and Caramel mousse with the Ferrero inside and on top!!!..z for a chocolate lover this thing is heaven!. Service is amazing and the owners hospitality is unbeatable. Thanks! Will definitely recommend and come back for more! read more

See all

Our wedding cake was perfect and delicious!!! Thank you so much!! DEFINITELY RECOMMEND!!! read more

DaVinci Bakery - Wedding Cake was perfect and delicious!!! Thank you so much!!! - Bakeries Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey