Personnel are lovely and attentive. Salads good, Chicken strips good. Pizza ? OK for Cape Cod, but a 5 out of ten in the pizza universe. Still, a pleasant place to eat at a reasonable price. read more

Just ordered Chicken, Broccoli and Ziti for the first time ( usually just get pizza), it was excellent, and the best part? I didn't need a knife to eat the chicken. The pieces were a perfect size. We come to the Cape every summer, and always get take-out from here. Food is consistently excellent, and all the employees are very nice. I ordered a salad to go with my meal, and mentioned that I hoped I could eat it all, The gentleman then said....Do you want a 'side' Salad ( this isn't mentioned in the menu), and I said YES..he didn't have to do that., I was getting a salad anyway.......but it saved me a few dollars,and cost HIM a few....I was able to eat it all and didn't have to waste any of it. GREAT place..we'll be back again next year. read more

Pizza to go. Waited inside as I hadn't called ahead. It didn't take long, and the pizza was as I'd ordered. They're very generous with the toppings. Nice place! read more

Doesn't look like much when going in, but was pleasantly surprised with great service and flavorful pizza. Combo was outstanding. Was just as good reheated the second day. read more

Best pizza in town!! The owner is friendly and accommodating and knows his food! I'll b a forever customer as long as this owner is here.

The front of house staff is amazing. The girl that has been there forever is always so attentive and always gets it right. It is always a pleasure to deal with her. Keep up the good work. read more

We wanted to love the pizza but it was flavorless and overcooked. Crust tasted like cardboard and cheese couldn't have been mozzarella. Cheddar cheese tasted like cardboard as well. Unfortunately we will not be back! read more

The Gyro is *chefs kiss.* This place is as excellent as a pizza shop can get. The food is always delicious, always hot and fresh, service is fast, and the prices are right. Supreme is my go-to take out for busy nights- they have something for everyone in the family and the prices are reasonable enough that I don't feel too guilty about all those groceries I was too tired to cook... Thank you Supreme for being there for this busy mom and never disappointing. read more

Great Greek salads with chicken. Hot BLT best ever (I'm 76). World record bacon! More than that! Service great! I'm visiting but my friend left a $10 tip to thank them for service. read more

I love their spaghetti with meatballs always fresh, same great taste every time, just perfect! Service is fast, and the price is great.

Supreme Pizza in Falmouth next to the Teaticket plaza on 28 has some fantastic pies! Greek style pizza right to the crust, perfectly bubbly and cheesy pizza. 10/10 would recommend! They also have a bevy of healthy items and a wide range of options on the menu. read more

Supreme Pizza - Bubbly cheese pizza! - Pizza Near Me - East Falmouth, Massachusetts

Yummy, yummy food and good portions! I'm not sure why I never noticed this little gem, but we stopped in once for pizza and have returned many times for other menu items. Great selection! read more

Alright, I ordered a chicken parm calzone, but I didn't get no stinkin calzone. What I got was a delicious doughy base COVERED in hearty pizza goop then LAYERED in a THICC blanket of stringy cheese. It wasn't a calzone in any definition of the word, but good lord that thing was good. My girl and I destroyed this thing. One tip tho, the cheese blanket was so absolutely THICC, I felt it needed its own seasoning. I sprinkled garlic salt over the top of the whole thing and MOMMA MIA it made me do that thing where you make all your fingertips touch on one hand. read more

Supreme Pizza - Chicken parm "calzone" (it ain't a calzone but it's good asf) - Pizza Near Me - East Falmouth, Massachusetts

See all

Supreme served me an absolutely disgusting pizza. A true pile of garbage. If you're reading this just go get Peel it is much better.

If you ever come to the Cape, do not eat here it is horrible. We got our pizza well done, and it is still undercooked. Everything about it is horrible. read more

I've lived in Falmouth for decades and Supreme is by far my favorite place for pizza. Reasonable prices, friendly staff, quick delivery, and most importantly the pizza is just delicious. I often get pineapple and broccoli, or spinach and mushroom. Always hot, with a generous amount of toppings. Everyone has their own idea of what's a great pizza - this is mine! read more

This review compares the qualities of Supreme to almost all of the pizza places in the Upper Cape. We grew up on Bar Room pizza and couldn't find any when moved here. Then we found Supreme!!! Manga! Their sandwiches, subs are great too. The place is very clean. The staff are exceptionally polite. This is not a fancy place. It's a pizza shop with some Greek foods tossed in. Try it, you'll like it. read more

The best around. Great team! The service, food, consistency... are all great. I get takeout here three nights a week. The Ziti, grilled chicken, marinara are superb... read more

We just spent a week in Falmouth and made sure to visit our favorite corner eatery! We were introduced to Supreme when it was advertised at a CCBL game! What a hidden gem! Excellent pizza, subs, salads and pasta dishes! The staff members are kind and helpful! The owner is comical and very personable! Make sure to add them to your list of restaurants! You will be glad you did! read more

Looove Supreme pizza! Our go to for pizza delivery. The veg pizza is LOADED with fresh veg. I always get it without cheese and extra sauce. My family gets all kinds of crazy stuff and we always get a free coke or something else. Great delivery - quick and reliable. read more

Still one of the best calzones in the area. Even on a summer night on Cape. Ready in 20 minutes. Solid spot read more

Supreme Pizza - a slice of pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - East Falmouth, Massachusetts

See all

Great food, great service! Covid takeout go to's: Tuna club with brown mustard, pickles, wheat bread toasted, and banana peppers.... And Onion Rings. Pizzas are good but their entrees are even better! read more

Drove all the way from the North Shore with our football team asked for a delivery for our team... didnt even need to go get pizzas and miss any of the game they put them right on the bus for us! We love Supreme pizza thank you so much!!! read more

Great pizza for the price, definitely does the trick. Stopped by on the way back from Hyannis to Woods Hole. Parking is plenty, service was quick, bathrooms were clean. What else can you want from a pizza place? read more

Delivery was quick and the food was fresh and delicious. We will definitely order from here again.

It was easy to order exactly what I wanted on my sub online. The delivery man was so nice! My Italian sub was delicious! My husband got spaghetti with many meatballs. He said it was very good. We were very happy with our meals. read more

Best pizza in Falmouth. I'd suggest the supreme, it has never disappointed. Crispy crust, good amount of topping, and great tasting sauce.

I ordered a SMALL (8 inch) steak & cheese with sautéed peppers, onions, LTM on a toasted roll. There was hardly any cheese on it. At first I thought there wasn't any on it. The sub meat & ingredients were proportional but not overflowing. Overall, it was perfectly fine but it lacked flavor which was a bummer. I think it needed a little bit of s&p. It wasn't bad. It just wasn't delicious. (I was starving, I ate the whole thing). I wouldn't order it again bc it just wasn't that tasty. The fountain coke was awesome! The Calzones & Pizza look really good so maybe I will try those next time. read more

Supreme Pizza - Dining area - Pizza Near Me - East Falmouth, Massachusetts

Really great Pizza Done to perfection Just the right amount of Char Never disappoints The large vegetable pizza is to right about Simple Awesome The waitstaff are extremely friendly, they even have a Tip container for the helps school funds How nice is that? read more

Love their subs and am ALWAYS treated like they are glad I came in. One of my faves! Reasonable prices, quick response - no sign of staffing issues here. read more

What a lifesaver this place was when we were vacationing in Falmouth in June of 2021. Many of the restaurants and shops were (are?) understaffed and/or did not open/reopen for the summer and so we tried Supreme. Reasonable prices, incredibly fast cooking time, and delicious pizza & calzones. Will definitely be ordering from here again next year! read more

Last night we ordered from Supreme Pizza for the first time and we have to say that we were not disappointed with our choice. Living in East Falmouth we usually order from some of the pizza shops a little closer, but since we were in town we decided to try out this location. From the moment we ordered over the phone the staff was incredibly polite and they made our pizzas in under 15 minutes. The great customer service continued when we walked into the store and when it came time for dinner we love the pizza. We bought a supreme pizza as well as a mushroom and black olive pizza. Both pizzas were delicious! In the end, this will probably become one of our regular pizza shops in town especially since some of the other pizza places more local have definitely gone down in quality. read more

Supreme Pizza - About to grab dinner - Pizza Near Me - East Falmouth, Massachusetts

This place is a very popular joint that offers great pizza, calzones and sandwiches. They are typically busy during lunch and dinner. They offer delivery but that is only one great part as you can order online, pay for it and have it delivered to your home. One of my favorite pizzas is there chicken bacon ranch and my favorite sandwich is their buffalo chicken wrap. You will not be disappointed with their food but I would recommend eating there first to get a good feel for the polite and dedicated staff then order out. read more

See all

Service was fast and food quality is always great with good portions . Favorites are the Chicken cutlet sub and Grilled chicken greek salad

I grew up in Falmouth and never went to this place until recently. The Texas Style is where it's at. Cannot wait to try the Special Buffalo pizza, since the menu says it has shaved blue cheese. I don't know any pizza place in any city I've lived in that puts that much effort into a pizza besides maybe a few in Rome. Now they offer gluten free pizza. Wonder if they'd do a gluten-free pizza with no cheese since I try to stay mostly vegan... Oh, and the Greek salad is great. I really liked the pita and dressing it came with. I've heard their sandwiches and meals are bomb but I haven't eaten any myself. They deliver (PLUS), but the owners are super nice and pretty hot, so I'd much rather go in and eat. read more

See all

I'm truly mystified at the great reviews. I can only assume that the locals on the Cape have never had a decent pizza or freshly made food, or you are related/friends with the owner. As prior correct reviews stated, bland, tasteless, frozen food quality pizza. We also had a meatball sandwich that had a decent, well toasted roll, but again, frozen food quality/consistency meatballs and a pretty generic sauce and cheese combination. Clearly, not much of what we ate was made on site. You could go to the Shaws or Stop and Shop frozen cases next door/across the street and duplicate the tastes/quality yourself very easily, maybe better. On the plus side, tables were clean, staff was reasonably friendly and the food came out quickly and hot. The food was also very reasonably priced. Everything is in place for a pretty good restaurant experience if they actually would make the food there, but maybe it's acceptable as is for this area... Just not mine. I wish I could have given it a better review, but it is what it is. read more

I've been ordering from Supreme for years now. It's my go-to pizza place and I've probably tried just about everything on the menu by now. They make my favorite pizza - just enough cheese and sauce without a huge crust. Their pepper and onion is fabulous. Crispy mozzarella sticks, excellent stir fry and chicken parm sandwiches, and their club meals are great too! read more

Super friendly place right on the corner by the fish market and post office. When we pick up they usually offer us a free 2 liter, which is awesome. My bf's go to is the Buffalo chicken pizza which he likes because they drizzle it with blue cheese or ranch. I usually get the chicken wings. The salads are pretty fresh and they load the hell out of the cheese fries. I love having them so close read more

Ok-so, not only does Supreme Pizza live up to it's name by having the most supreme pizza around but it also allows the technology challenged, like myself to order it the 'old fashioned way' by placing a call! I really didn't want to create an account here, because we're only visiting. My brother in law had called a few different pizza places and if he wasn't placed on hold forever, they wanted him to create an account online just to order a pizza. Then I saw the yelp reviews for Supreme pizza I figured that we would try so I called and a very nice person answered on the second ring I made sure they delivered to our resort, and then placed the order, I was told it would be here in 30 minutes, and 26 minutes later, our order arrived, delivered by a second very nice person, and as I said above it was SUPREME! Thank you Supreme Pizza for staying accessible to the technology challenged like myself. You will be the ONLY pizza place that we order from when ever we visit! read more

Used online ordering and food arrived in about 45 minutes. The food was still hot and order was correct. Ordered: Pepperoni Pizza, Bacon Chicken Ranch Pizza and Chicken Parmesan Calzone. The pizza crust is likely refrigerated overnight and/or rolled dough verse fresh hand tossed; however the sauce is good and toppings were fresh and yummy. I definitely disagree with previous reviews that this pizza is the equivalent of a Celeste frozen pizza! I would ordered here again for sure. Later tried the buffalo chicken calzone and meatball calzone which were super delicious! read more

See all