Sushi dates are my youngest son and I's thing. So we split time returning to favorites and also trying new places. This was our second time here and still as "mid" as the first time, according to my teenager... and that's more to do with the environment than the food. First off, my son loves watching them make the sushi because he tries to make it at home since it's his favorite food. As soon as we walked in, he was thrilled because we had the place to ourselves and we headed toward that area where there was a man visibly dressed in his chef garb... only to be blocked by the one female employee who directed us toward a side table in between low divider screens. I smiled and nicely asked if we could sit at the open chairs at the sushi making area or a table closer in order to watch and she said "no." I asked why and she said something in broken English I didn't fully catch. I believe it was because they had some to-go orders sitting on that counter, but there were atleast some closer tables we could have set at. After that, the experience just felt a bit cold. We ordered four different sushi rolls to start and waited for only three to come out. Had to ask where the fourth was and she acted like I hadn't originally ordered four. The special roll we tried was called a campfire roll and was supposed to come with marshmallows (plural) but came out with one. Then the fire kept burning. We didn't receive instructions or anything so we waited for it to burn out, which took a lot longer than the volcano roll experiences we've had in the past. The sushi was really, really good to be fair... but this is twice we just haven't felt particularly welcomed or gotten warm fuzzies from eating here. And it's too expensive here to not have great service. I don't consider myself overly picky but I am conscious of where I spend my dollars nowadays, so I would tend to return to one of our other sushi spots that atleast makes you feel welcome. Or any of the others that are much cheaper than this one. We drank water and had the four rolls and one side of fried rice and it was about $75. read more

Sushiyama - Inside - Sushi Bars Near Me - Noblesville, Indiana

Always loved the Sushi here. We have been gone for around 4 years and made this our first restaurant stop while in the area for a few days. It is still some of the best we find around the country. read more

It's very possible I came here on an off night because I've read many positive reviews. I LOVE sushi and am always excited to check out sushi places in the area, but the side salad was shockingly sweet and the sushi did not taste fresh. The spicy mayo that was on one of my rolls was also very sweet. I think I would maybe give 3 stars if the prices were lower, but we definitely paid premium prices for very low grade sushi. read more

By far the best, most friendly and welcoming Sushi restaurant north of 465 and east of US 31! I've never had a bad roll, we've had just "good" and usually "great" but never bad or designer type rolls. The family is very kind and friendly. We try to order from here weekly, but usually ends up monthly. For our young kids we order their chicken fried rice, it's absolutely the best CFR I've ever tasted. Just great. Come visit and support this wonderful family, absolutely worth the trip read more

No major complaints. The miso was a little underwhelming but it's complimentary. Everything else was delicious! read more

See all

One word Amazing. From having traditional sake cups and options to REAL traditional nigiri sushi this place is a true gem. The owners were very pleasant and accommodating! Service was prompt and did not rush you. The music is traditional and relaxing as well! read more

Sushiyama - a picture of a vase and a menu on a table - Sushi Bars Near Me - Noblesville, Indiana

Popped in here on a whim and I'm so glad I did. While a bit expensive, the prices were fairly standard for sushi. I must say that the food was absolutely amazing! I'm so glad I stumbled upon this little hidden treasure and I will definitely be back to try more rolls. I thoroughly enjoyed the Sushiyama specialty roll and the fire roll. read more

$35 worth of sushi, smallest rolls I've ever seen!! It was 45min before they're posted lunch closing but she didn't want to seat me. So I said I would take it to go. Specialty roll is supposed to come with miso, but if you take it to go it's $3.50. I pointed out that I wanted to eat in, didn't matter. She still wanted me to pay the $3.50. The sushi itself was fine, nothing special. read more

Sushiyama - Small Portions - Sushi Bars Near Me - Noblesville, Indiana

Highly recommend! Our family loves Sushiyama and we've been stopping in once a week for several years for sushi. The atmosphere is family friendly and the rolls are always delicious. Service is fantastic. In addition to the rolls, we also love their Chicken Yakisoba, Tuna Tataki, Soft Shell Crab, and the Campfire roll is fun for the whole family. read more

Excellent and really enjoy eating here. The fish is always fresh and place does not smell of fish which is a great sign . I don't know why we don't eat here more often. The best sushi place around noblesville for sure. Staff is always helpful, polite and attentive. Will be back for sure read more

See all

These positions reviews are LIES!!! This place is THE WORST! Ordered miso, and it came without tofu, and I mentioned this to the server. SHE LEGIT TOLD ME THAT "WHITE PEOPLE DON'T LIKE TOFU"! Like, what?!? How is that even possible to say?!? We've tried to go a few times during lockdown (the soup was last week and the last straw), and we've been told "carryout only" even when we called ahead to make sure they were seating in the dining room - out of respect, etc. There's no way they stay in business much longer. They're complete rubbish. read more

We were looking for sushi for lunch. The pork egg roll was the best we've ever had. Which is why no photo. Sorry we are too fast. The vampire roll also not photographed was excellent. read more

Sushiyama - Dynamite roll - Sushi Bars Near Me - Noblesville, Indiana

See all

Hands-down, best sushi restaurant in Noblesville. Wonderful atmosphere, gracious staff, and delicious food!

Years ago this place was amazing. It's changed owners several times since they opened. We thought we would take a trip down memory lane. Everything was coated in eel sauce. Even items that didn't have eel sauce in the description... like fried rice. Covered in eel sauce so deep it was like soup. Spicy tuna roll was covered in the Uber sweet salad dressing which again wasn't part of the description. Sadly disappointed. read more

Great rolls, have been coming here for years and they know my usual It isn't cheap but is pretty standard for pricing of sushi. It is definitely the best place in this part of Noblesville!! read more

We tried this place right after we moved to noblesville several years ago, literally desperate to find good Asian food/sushi (my wife is Korean). Thankfully, we hit gold! We've become such fans that we even befriended the family that owns the place. So rather than writing a biased review, I'll just let that speak for itself. Sushi is the specialty at Sushiyama, so don't go solely for the kitchen food. It isn't too bad, but unless you go on Friday or Saturday (when they have an extra helping hand), it will detract from the service speed a little. The sushi is unique in three ways, in my opinion... it is WAY fresh... the nigiri is sliced thick and hearty, and the chef has his own sauces that are definitely more flavorful (and some items spicy) than typical sushi places in the area. I think that can be attributed to the owners' Korean origins. If you want some sushi that's flavorful and skillfully made, give this place a shot. But as stated in other reviews... this is a family-run small business, so if you come during the week at crunch times, you may need to be a little patient with the service. read more

Sushiyama - Sushi Bars Near Me - Noblesville, Indiana

The reviews were very helpful. They're right about it being a hidden Jem! Very mellow and relaxing atmosphere inside. Super friendly staff. Welcome you, and everyone thanks you as you leave. It was super clean and the wait times were less than expected. I watched the sushi chef hand craft my rolls, it was an art! I had the Red Volcano Roll, it was great! The Dinner Roll Combo A is also delicious and such a great deal! Prices were lower than I expected and portions were more- I'd say that's a win! Lots of chef specialty rolls, more than most sushi places! Prices were between $8-13 per roll, again less but you get more! I'll be back! read more

Sushiyama - Red Volcano Roll! Tempura crab meat and cream cheese. Topped with crab stick, spicy tuna & jalapeños! Very good And only $11.99! - Sushi Bars Near Me - Noblesville, Indiana

See all

Disappointing for the price. Entree, sushi combo (7 nigiri + Cali roll) and a 6 pc spider roll was over $50! Prices weren't consistent on website links (said spider roll was $6.50 and we were likely charged $15). They also quoted us 30 minutes for the food and there were literally no customers in the restaurant when we picked up. The food was fine, but it's too expensive and we will not likely return. read more

Really pleased to have finally tried this place that has been around for years but we've consistently and inexplicably overlooked it. Amazing food! The shrimp lover roll was delicious. Best seaweed salad of the many I've tried at various restaurants. Prompt and friendly service. A new favorite spot for sure! read more

Awesome food! Sushi was fresh and wonderful. Some of the best I've ever had! Our server, Aiden was awesome. He was polite and took Gr8 care of us! Cute restaurant and def will be back read more

Sushiyama - Wonderful fresh sushi! Some of the best I've had. Service was awesome, Aiden was very polite and took care of us well! Highly recommend! - Sushi Bars Near Me - Noblesville, Indiana

This is a good little place for a quick sushi experience. The fish isn't as thick as I'm used to, and you could tell it was frozen at some point, but the rolls made up for that due to their wonderful toppings and sauces. Miso soup needed some work there wasn't any tofu or seaweed in it, but the flavor was okay. read more

These people are absolutely rude.. The guest in front of me walked in they got a high energy greeting when she walked in however the rude ass waiter didn't even speak to me or ask me my name or how can he help. So I walked out and didn't even get my food. Horrible customer service. My black dollars spend just like the white ones and I refuse to participate or spend money where I'm treated that way. If you're not white run for the hills. read more

I love this place! It's my favorite reasonably priced sushi I've found in Indiana. They also have great egg rolls and awesome ginger dressing on the side salads. On our first visit, for sushi we tried the Hana roll and the Sushiyama Specialty roll, and on our second visit we got the Hana roll again (we love avocado!) and I believe it was called the Volcano roll (it had broiled fresh fish on top of the roll and was covered in spicy mayo). That roll and the Hana roll are pictured. It's a really nice family-run business with fantastic food. Try it and your taste buds will thank you! read more

Sushiyama - Sushi Bars Near Me - Noblesville, Indiana

Coming from California I was a bit worried about the seafood sense we're not close to oceans. But this place is actually pleasant and delicious. Would order from here again. Thank you read more

I had no idea that this restaurant existed, until my mom heard from friends of her's who drive all they way from Geist to eat here. Standing outside of Sushiyama, the completely unimpressive exterior had me giving my mom a look soaked with second doubts. BUT I promise you that opening the door puts you in a whole new world. The restaurant's interior is superbly decorated with an authentic Sushi Bar in the back if you choose. Owned and operated by a Japanese family, the dishes are a mix of traditional staples and western remixes. The Sushi is phenomenal. I promise. Skeptic I was, but no longer. I try to get into Sushiyama at least every other week and love supporting the family run business. The restaurant keeps a steady stream of takeout orders going but I highly recommend surprising yourself and eating in once! Any specialty roll comes with the customary miso soup and salad if you do choose to stay in. I'll close it with just repeating what I've said. On the outside, you'll wonder if I'm crazy, but once you step in and give it a chance, I guarantee that you'll be back on Yelp! seconding my review. Cheers read more

These reviews are lies, this place is nasty, run down and overpriced. The food there is poorly made and the resturant itself is just gross. Payed 9 dollars for a seaweed salad and got this tiny little container, the rolls aswell are very scarce for being 15-20$ read more

I won't base this review off of their beer selection because that's not what this place is about. I had the red volcano roll and the spicy spider roll. Both were very good! Every sushi place can be expensive especially if you order speciality rolls. I think this place was cost me about as much as any other sushi restaurant. I would definitely come here agin to try something new!!! read more

Went here tonight to try. Very slow not busy at all but it's also a Wednesday night. Ordered two rolls a spicy California and a fire shrimp roll. California roll was good tasted fresh. The fire roll .... great idea horrible execution. It was brought out in foil then the waiter set it on fire.... cool yes but he walked away from the table as the sushi was on fire. I was disappointed because when it was opened it was burnt like charred so the whole roll was burnt Panko. Salad was all dressing but good flavor. Ordered a hibachi chicken... pretty sure I heard the microwave turn on when that order was placed. When it came out it did not look like it just came off the grill.... no flavor horribly salty and not worth $13. Overall nothing to get too excited about. I don't think that I'll be back. read more

I'm from California, and am used to fancy shmancy sushi rolls. I was relocated to this area by my company and was looking really hard for some good sushi. After trying many many sushi restaurants, i've found the best rolls in Noblesville - no, I would say in the area including Indianapolis. I've tried majority of their rolls and sushi, and couple of their best rolls include: volcano roll(salmon heaven on your tongue, my ultimate fav), fire roll(if you like a small fire show at your table and the toasty aroma, this is your roll), ladybug roll(the scallion makes this roll so yummy), vampire roll(if you are a texture person and loves crunchy texture, this one is yours). Writing this review makes my mouth water. Yummmmm. read more

Sushiyama - My fav!! Volcano roll!! - Sushi Bars Near Me - Noblesville, Indiana

See all

Fantastic service and amazing food. Best egg roll I've had in my life! The service was fun. We came for my son's 21st birthday. My brother, who travels the world for business, also said this was the best egg roll he'd ever eaten. read more

Sushiyama - 21st birthday party! - Sushi Bars Near Me - Noblesville, Indiana

Best little hidden Gem in Noblesville. It honestly has to be one of the best Sushi in Indy. The owners are very sincere and genuine and their food is always fresh and delicious!!! read more

Small mom/pop place in a strip mall in Noblesville. Had lunch there today. My party and only on other customer were there at 1p. Ordered the California roll lunch special for $7.99. It includes a California roll, a fried wonton, 1/2 an egg roll, house salad and miso soup. I don't care for miso so I can't comment on that. I enjoyed the egg roll, my wife did not. She liked the house salad, but I didn't care for the dressing. Normally I love ginger dressing. As for the sushi. Had a California roll which was "okay". Alia the dynamite and spicy tuna. Not blown away by any of them. I guess if I was in the area and got hit with a sushi craving I may go again. I'd probably choose to drive a bit farther and get good sushi and good service. A bit surprised by all the positive reviews. read more

They treated us VERY BADLY ... we went a second time the same guy and he left us with an out of place comment and we left. NOT RECOMMENDED BAD ATTENTION read more

Sushi yama yama, Sushi bang bang The ol' Ball & Chain and I ate here last night. Let me start by saying I don't east Sushi, but my Boo loves it. This is her favorite place to calm her sushi cravings up north. The exterior is nothing to brag about, and the interior is the same way. She claims the Sushi is great, but prices are sky high. So you better bring a Stack. The bathroom is nothing to write home about. We are talking a single seater with a lock I dont trust.....like my ex wife. They do not have Bud Light......So be prepared to drink The Silver Bullet. read more

I agree with all of the reviews. Expect a wait. I went at 12pm, and although there were no more than 6 folks eating there it was a 15 minute wait for my take out order. One caveat, if you order take out lunch special, you will not receive the soup, salad or egg roll, with the lunch special. Same price, but no sides. The food was fresh. The restaurant was intimate, quiet and clean. You would miss it because it sits in a strip mall. I ordered the spicy tuna roll and california roll. The tuna is yummy although not really spicy. read more

I've been coming here for ten years and each time I am impressed by the service, speed, and hospitality of the staff and heavily-involved owners. The authentic experience, fresh sushi, and incredible service are second to none. Many times over the past ten years I have recommended Sushiyama to anyone who asks where to get sushi in Noblesville. This place never disappoints...come hungry! read more

My experience here wasn't all that great. I ordered a couple rolls for lunch. They were average at best and way overpriced. Which makes me sad because there little to no sushi options in the general vicinity. read more

Really good Sushi and the staff are all super nice!!! One of the best kept secrets for sushi in the whole area!!!!

Compared to other sushi fare in the Indy metro area, this place isn't special, but compared to others in Noblesville, I suppose it's good enough, albeit a little pricey. Sushiyama has a pretty standard line-up of sushi--your regular maki and nigiri choices, shashimi, and so forth. They had a few lunch specials to choose from as well. I'll defer on the service, since I went there on March 11 and the owners (who I assume are Japanese) were a little distracted by the tsunami news from that morning. read more

Wonderful sushi and the price is just right. I've been coming here for years and have always been happy with the food. It's also never been busy when I've come. The owners are very friendly. read more