Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Susie's Scrumptious Sweets

    3.6 (47 reviews)
    Closed Closed

    Susie's Scrumptious Sweets Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Susie's Scrumptious Sweets

    Recommended Reviews - Susie's Scrumptious Sweets

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Sweet 16 Birthday Cake.
    Angie S.

    I had heard about Susie's Scrumptious Sweets from two friends who said their cakes were amazing. So when my daughter's 16th birthday rolled around we went there for a tasting. They have open tastings Saturdays but I recommend making an appointment because it can get busy. We were there with three other groups and it actually made it a lot of fun. Everyone was talking about the occasion they were there for and the ideas they had for their cakes. Susie's husband, Wilt, does the tastings and he's hilarious. He's also really great at answering any questions you may have about the different flavors. Be warned - Come hungry! They usually have around 10 different cakes for you to try and they don't serve tiny pieces. You are going to get a whole piece of each and every flavor you want to try. And you can try them all. Seriously, try them all. You'll be surprised at how delicious some of the combinations are. They box up all the leftovers so you can take them home with you and eat cake for a week. My favorites were the almond cake and coconut cake. My daughter's favorites were strawberry shortcake (with fresh strawberries) and key lime. After you've decided on your flavor you will talk to Susie and work on your design. They have a ton of pictures of past cakes if you need ideas. We ended up with a strawberry shortcake cake that fed around 20 people with an anchor on top. When we picked up the cake for the party I was shocked by how large it actually was. The design was exactly what my daughter wanted and tasted amazing. Susie's will be my go to for cakes for many years to come.

    My wedding cake
    Missy W.

    Susie is AMAZING!!! This was one of very few things at my wedding that went FLAWLESSLY! The cake is as both beautiful and delicious! THANK YOU, SUSIE!!!

    Three fantastic cakes! They tasted soooooo good!
    Colleen R.

    Susie's Scrumptious Sweets creates delicious, creative and beautiful custom cakes. Actually, they make all kinds of delicious desserts, from cookies to cheesecake to cobbler to fruit cake, that I've enjoyed for years. I can't say enough great things about this bakery. Recently, Susie's made unbelievable birthday cakes for my dad's 75th birthday. We were throwing a tailgate-themed party and wanted a cake reflecting some of my dad's favorite teams. Our Philadelphia Eagles football jersey cake was impressive, delicious and a show stopper. Our Miami Dolphins baseball cap cake was also delicious and awesome. Such incredible detail work. Our guests couldn't believe they were cake. Susie's surprised us with a bonus football cake on the day of the party. Although I appreciate a pretty cake for its aesthetics, for me it's all about the taste. Susie's never disappoints. They make INCREDIBLE TASTING CAKE. For this party, we had a key lime cake with white chocolate and raspberry filling, a pina colada cake with pineapple filling, and a chocolate cake. Everyone at the party raved about how great the cakes tasted. Like totally raved. I can't tell you how many people asked me about the bakers and specifically wanted their contact information. I love Susie's Scrumptious Sweets and recommend them so enthusiastically for all your cake and sweets needs. They're professionals with tremendous talent. They really make awesome looking and tasting cakes.

    Gender Revealing Cake
    Lien V.

    I got a gender revealing cake and cupcakes. I give them an envelope from my doctor with the gender in it. The cake was either pink or blue Velvet Cake. Told them I want a monkey on it because it's the Year of the Monkey. They made it happen. The cake and cupcakes was moist and delicious. I would definitely come back for my baby shower cake!! There's a complimentary cake tasting every Saturday I would highly recommend everyone to attend, especially if you are unsure of what flavor you want.

    Ashley H.

    I got this cake for my bachelorette and it was the most amazing, delicious, and perfectly designed piece. Everyone was raving about how delicious it was... "it seriously was the best cake I ever had." Will definitely sending all my friends here

    Dalila G.

    The cake was absolutely amazing when it came to presentation and taste now be prepared to spend quite a bit of money but definitely worth it the people who own the place is a little older couple very pleasant so be ready to hear about their baby's aka their dogs and many facts from the gentlemen who is the husband but before u buy u go to a cake tasting wich is a little overwhelming if u are alone so bring some company over all amazing cake

    Deun W.

    I got my baby shower cake from here. So delicious. It came out exactly how i wanted it all i did was show her a picture. Reasonable pricing and not to mention the complimentary cake tasting. Most places give you small pieces while Susie give you a whole slice. Love love love this place. Cant wait to come back for my sons first birthday party.

    Susie made this purple heart exceeding my expectations! If you want a cake that will keep them talking go to Susie!!

    Susie did my 40th birthday cake for me and it exceeded my expectations. The experience of the cake tasting was the beginning of the journey. Wilt her husband is the jokester of the family business. You'll have a blast with all of the mouthwatering cakes you'll taste. You get cake education and jokes with it. Susie took my concept of what I wanted which I changed a few times and made it my reality. I was so blown away with the final product. I also appreciate that even though it seems like Mrs. Susie is a tough cookie she had a soft middle the holds a beautiful heart. She has a new extended family thanks to her sweet heart shaped cake she made for me. I am looking forward to Susie making birthday cakes and my sisters wedding cake creation. If you want a homemade love filled cake look no more if you found Susie. Thank you for the amazing, moist, beautiful and flavorful cake!!!

    Awesome cake!
    Angela P.

    Amazing! I had my Groom's cake for our rehearsal dinner done here. I sent a pic of a Jason Voorhees mask and the cake I picked up was nothing short of spectacular! Going to post a pic in here! It was DELICIOUS as well! When I walked it into the restaurant people were coming up to take pics of the cake bc it was just so cool! Thank you Susie!

    My cake they made for my sis. Awesome decor. The cake was decent. Too sweet forvmy liking, but everyone seemed to love it.
    Ashley K.

    The cakes are great and designs are amazing. The cake taster guy is super friendly and I love the atmosphere at the place. The woman who takes the order seems, sad and tired most of the time. Not a huge issue, but it is overlooked by their product. Highly recommend. I bought 2 cakes thus far.

    One classy chocolate birthday cake!

    See all

    16 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    16 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    15 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    13 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    15 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Susie's Scrumptious Sweets

    Review Highlights - Susie's Scrumptious Sweets

    Susie did my 40th birthday cake for me and it exceeded my expectations.

    Mentioned in 2 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Bakeries 6,695 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Milanos Bakery - Sandwich de Prosciutto

    Milanos Bakery

    4.0(156 reviews)
    2.5 mi
    $$

    Milano's is a charming Latin/Argentinian café with great food and a lively atmosphere. I ordered…read morethe breakfast platter, which came with hash browns, eggs, bacon or sausage and toast--simple, filling, and well made. I also tried one of their empanadas, which was delicious and packed with flavor. My friend had the breakfast sandwich which she enjoyed! The real star here, though, is the pastries. I tried a couple slices of cake and they were absolutely amazing--fresh, rich, and clearly made with care. There alfajors also melted in your mouth!! There's also plenty of seating, which is a huge plus. The only downside was the ordering process. Since it was my first visit, I didn't realize you have to take a number (similar to Publix) and wait to be called. I ended up standing in line, not knowing they were serving based on numbers instead. To add to the confusion, numbers were being called out in Spanish, which I don't speak. Once you know how it works, it's probably fine--but as a first-timer, it was a bit confusing. That said, I'd absolutely go back for the food--just probably not on a busy weekend!

    Milano Bakery in Tamarac has the kind of atmosphere that makes you slow down a little, even if you…read moreonly meant to stop in for something quick. The space feels warm and lived‑in, and there's a steady flow of regulars who clearly treat it as part of their routine. That alone says a lot. The pastries are the first thing that catch your eye--rows of croissants, cookies, and cakes that look like they were made by someone who actually cares about the details.

    Photos
    Milanos Bakery - Café con Leche y un Croissant

    Café con Leche y un Croissant

    Milanos Bakery - Masas Finas

    Masas Finas

    Milanos Bakery - Empanadas

    See all

    Empanadas

    The Wild Mug Coffee Bar - Iced lavender latte yum

    The Wild Mug Coffee Bar

    4.6(124 reviews)
    5.7 mi
    $$

    One of my favorite things to do is find new matcha places, and this one is definitely a gem! It's…read morelocated in the Carvel shopping center on Hiatus and easy to miss, but definitely more than worth a stop. I came in on a Sunday morning around 10am and it was super crowded, which was a good sign. Despite the crowd, the line moved fast and my order came out really quickly. They have more matcha flavors than anywhere else I've seen, so it was a hard choice. I ended up going with the marshmallow, and I'm super happy with my choice. The matcha and marshmallow flavors were both strong and complemented each other well. They have a pastry case that I completely missed because it's around the corner, or I might have tried something there too. I love the cute animal decor as well, and I don't believe they charged extra for alternative milks, which is always huge bonus points for me. I'll definitely be back to try other flavors and maybe an empanada!

    Decided to stop by Wild Mug since it was on the way and was very pleasantly surprised. The interior…read moreis definitely small and while I was there it was a bit busy so it felt crowded. I would recommend this as a good place to chat with a friend over a space for studying or working. Especially because I found the staff lovely and conversational. Their prices are far more reasonable than many other local coffee shops nearby which was definitely a major plus. I enjoyed the lavender latte, but would probably only get it hot in the future, and would try a different iced latte flavor. The spicy chicken empanada was delicious and I would definitely get it again. It had a nice curry sauce inside (though it wasn't as spicy as I thought it would be). The ham and cheese sandwich was also surprisingly good. Though simple, they tasted like quality ingredients.

    Photos
    The Wild Mug Coffee Bar - Chicken, beef and spicy beef empanadas

    Chicken, beef and spicy beef empanadas

    The Wild Mug Coffee Bar - Chicken panini

    Chicken panini

    The Wild Mug Coffee Bar - Egg panada (it's what I named it, comes with sausage)

    See all

    Egg panada (it's what I named it, comes with sausage)

    Ella Cafe - Cappuccino

    Ella Cafe

    4.3(1.6k reviews)
    4.8 mi
    $$

    Ella's Cafe is a cozy rustic little cafe with multiple locations across South Florida. It was the…read moreperfect spot to grab a quick bite after a morning at Sawgrass Mall. There are no menus. A sample of all food available is displayed on the counter and the coffee menu is on the wall. You order, the Barista hands you a number and you take a seat. One of their smiling friendly staff brings your order out. All staff at this location seems helpful and pleasant. All syrups are made in house, which gives authenticity to their coffee. It is a bit pricey but in my opinion you pay for what you get. At Ella's that's quality coffee. I absolutely loved the French Sandwich. A delicious combination of jam, Brie, pear and Spinach coupled together to give you a delicious bite. Looking forward to checking out their other locations!

    How have I never been here before? I had some time to kill during my daughter's physical therapy…read moreappointment at the next plaza over, so I decided to give Ella Cafe a try and I'm SO glad I did! This place is so cute. I love the charming vibe on the inside with the lights and the wood paneling. They have a sign on the wall that talks about their loud music and awesome coffee, and I am completely here for it. Both things were true; their music selection was amazing as was the iced cherry almond latte that I tried. Staff was friendly and warm. I asked them to choose my drink because I was feeling very indecisive and I have no regrets! I cannot believe this little gem has been sitting right here and I'm only now discovering it. Definitely won't be my last visit!!

    Photos
    Ella Cafe - Cappuccino served with some sunlight

    Cappuccino served with some sunlight

    Ella Cafe - Front counter / side seating

    Front counter / side seating

    Ella Cafe - Cozy space in the back

    See all

    Cozy space in the back

    Susie's Scrumptious Sweets - bakeries - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...