We were happy to find parking super close to the front door and then dismayed to find out we had a 45 minute wait time with nowhere to sit or stand without being in the way of servers. We got lucky and had bar seats open up after about 5 minutes which allowed us to grab cocktails and relax. After a bit we ordered some Brussel sprouts as an appetitizer and before they could show up our table opened up. My wife chose the 2 piece cod fry with chips while I opted for the perch fry with fries. Everything was spectacular. The bartenders were jumping around each other to keep people happy at the bar and the rest of the staff get people's bellies filled with food. If you go keep in mind there are no reservations and will probably be a wait, but they will take great care of you and serve you some awesome fish! read more

I was heading to the Downer Theater after work for a movie on Friday night and of course wanted a fish fry beforehand. I surprisingly don't have many options in my "MKE - Fish Fry" collection that are near downtown, but Swinging Door Exchange was one of them. I was pressed for time, so I placed a to go order rather than dining in. I got the combo fish fry (two pieces of cod, two pieces of perch, and three fried shrimp) with potato pancakes. I was also very easily talked into the half rack rib appetizer. The ribs were good, even though I prefer sauce that's more sweet and smokey. Their sauce was on the tangy side with a tease of spice that really only became noticeable when the majority of the half rack was gone. If I were in the mood for ribs as my main meal, I'd consider getting theirs as an entree. The two potato pancakes weren't homemade; instead, they were premade hash brown patties that some other restaurants also serve with their fish frys. These were perfectly acceptable in lieu of homemade pancakes. The cod tasted great, but the breading didn't hold up very well. Either the fish itself was too wet or the two block walk back to my car allowed for condensation to wreck it or possibly both. The perch was not yellow lake perch but probably something like pike perch. Even though both kinds of fish and the shrimp were all good sized portions, $29 feels like a lot. I wouldn't say no to it, though, if I were dining in next time and avoid the extra cost of their takeout fee. Shout-out to the bartenders working that night. The bar area was absolutely packed, but both of the ones I talked to about placing my order were friendly and helpful even with being super busy. read more

See all

The place is small, and packed! They will seat you if at least half of your party is there. Which was nice, since otherwise we would have had to wait a long time. We were seated right away at 11:30, but by noon, there were people waiting in line. Service was delightful, vibes were oldish but very Milwaukee. A perfect place to come with visitors on a Friday for a fish fry experience. 3 Sheeps Chaos Petter (hazy IPA, tap) $6 Hany loved this IPA. He wrote it down to get some later. Mahi mahi bites $18 Actually a little bigger than "bite" size, more like fish sticks, with about 2-3 bites each. They were ok, but Wasn't a super fan of it. Probably will not order again. Combo fish fry $31 2 cod, 2 perch, 3 shrimp. Friend said it was great, and like the shrimp best. She also liked the cod better than the perch, and said it was less fishy. Red beans and rice with andouille sausage $22 This was a special for the day, and I thought it might be a little like a jambalaya... but visually it looked more like chili, a bit soupy. The sausage looked deliciously char-grilled. Friend loved it and left no leftovers. Clam chowder $9 Should have gotten the cup... and accidentally ordered the bowl. It was big and a lot of soup. But it was goooooooooood. BYO burger $17 Love that lettuce tomato and onion is included without a fee. The 1/2 pound Angus beef was cooked a perfect medium and seasoned just right. Solid burger. They charge extra for cheese, and lactose-intolerant Hany loved not getting it. Menu says it's $15, but we were charged $17. Not sure why. We only subbed the fries for Brussels, and that's supposed to be +1. Brussels sprouts Our server raved about the Brussels, so I was hoping to get the best Brussels. I must say, they were ok, but not the best I've had (cough cough, Cloud Red). I liked that they were cut into smaller pieces, but a lot of the leaves were burnt. I can see they're going for the "crispy" or "crunchy", but imo, a little overdone. Overall, a nice experience and definitely going back, but sticking to the basics for me. read more

See all

Solid place for dinner that's conveniently down the street from the Baird Center. The bartenders were friendly and I had some good chats with them while enjoying my food. Sandwich was a bit on the greasier side for my liking, but nonetheless had flavor and they give you a lot for the price. If you can tolerate some of the more interesting characters that roll through the bars in Milwaukee, then this is a great saloon to check out while in town. read more

This is a Milwaukee gem. It's in a historic building which is a bonus. It's rare to go here and not have a wait. The menu is full of great choices. I would describe it as elevated pub grub. On my most recent visit we had Katie as our server. Katie was incredibly attentive and welcoming despite how busy it was. Their sandwiches are served on rolls from Sciortino's rolls. They are one of the best bakeries in the area. The crunchy chicken is breaded in cornflakes and served with a delicious Cajun ranch. This place is worth the wait. Just go! read more

Swingin' Door Exchange - Crunchy chicken with beef barley soup - New American Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

Oh my God first of all I went here today to meet my Bestie at noon. I was 15 minutes early and I walked in and I couldn't believe that the place was jampacked. Like seriously packed the whole restaurant and bar. Anyway, I did find one stool at the bar. I texted my friend letting them know place was super packed. He got there and found me at the bar, but there was no steps left on either side of me so he walked around the restaurant. Five minutes later the person to the right of me left their barstool so I called him and said hey come on over I have a stool next to me. Bartenders are awesome, super attentive, could not complain. We had bloody Mary's, beer, wine, and ordered a BLT with fries, ordered Ahi Ahi, and the homemade chips with a Cajun ranch sauce. Oh my God everything was so over the top delicious. In fact, I cannot wait to go back. read more

See all

Swingin Door is a unique spot for great food and drinks. It is classic and quaint but note they don't take reservations, I recommend going early if you can! It gets pretty packed quickly, so expect a wait. Each time we've been, we always have the friendliest wait staff which I always appreciate. Their fish fry is one of my favorites and typically my go to on Fridays. Definitely recommend trying Swingin' Door out if you haven't been! read more

See all

Date of visit: October 28, 2025 Hadn't been here in years and wanted to take advantage of a friend from out of town who hasn't really spent much time in downtown Milwaukee and so glad that I did, we had a wonderful meal! We got there early--which is key given how small this place is and how quickly it fills up. Luck was on our side as we were able to get seated right away. Speaking of right away, that was the theme of everything and let me tell you, I was here for it. Service was fast, as was the food. Starting with the chips, which were good, and the ranch, which was better. You should always start with this combo, and go cajun ranch if spice is your jam. From there I had the grilled cheese with a side Caesar salad, another winning combo! The croutons were some of the best I had ever had and the American + Cheddar marriage was fantastic. Roll your eyes all you want, there are few things in this crazy mixed up world better than a grilled cheese sandwich done right! Glad that after all these years away, Swingin' Door treated my out of town guest right! read more

Swingin' Door Exchange - A very good grilled cheese--and ketchup was readily available, too! - New American Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

Excellent Lake Perch for Friday Fish Fry! Combine excellent fare w good bartop energy and great service (Daniel) it adds up to 5-Stars. This place is not a secret as packed busy on a Friday early afternoon. The regulars were welcoming and fun. I had to have my Lake Perch fix and Swingin' Door delivered. The perch was fresh and lightly breaded. I tend to overdo it when in Wisco and had a clam chowder as a starter. The GF had the Rueben which also served as breckie snack the next day. My future semi-regular stop when in MKE. read more

See all

Holy moly what a find! Was referred to this place by another foodie and was not disappointed. Came in on a Tuesday afternoon at 4:55pm. The place was packed, 1 open seat at the bar which is all I needed. The rest of the place is pretty small, maybe 20 tables, but I was told by a local that the place is always crowded. Got myself a Spotted Cow and ordered a blackened burger and loaded Brussel Sprouts. Asked for the burger medium well and they delivered. Once in a blue moon do I get a burger with any pink in it. This one was perfect, and the juices rolling out of the burger onto my fingers were hot enough to sting! The Brussels were also crazy good! Best meal I've had in Milwaukee and one of the top 3 burgers I've ever had. Service was fast and friendly. Will come back again in a heartbeat. read more

Swingin' Door Exchange - New American Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

Stopped in for dinner and a drink while in Milwaukee on a work trip. Awesome place. Lively but still quiet enough to have a relaxing dinner. Service was great. Everyone was super friendly and food came out quickly. Brussels sprouts were excellent, highly recommend! read more

See all

Wow, what a little hidden gem in downtown Milwaukee. We were meeting a friend there for lunch and arrive around 11:30 on a Wednesday morning. The place was already packed. When I walked in I was hit with the smell of cabbage after being greeted by friendly staff. It was about a 20 minute wait for a seat, which was fine. The bar has plenty of craft beer options on tap and can. There is something for everyone. After being seated the menu is impressive. It was filled with daily specials. For Wednesday, it was weiner Wednesday (chili cheese, Chicago, and a bbq dog), polish sausage, etc. I ordered a chili cheese dog and a build you one 1/4 black angus burger. The hot dog was amazing! It was a kosher, all-beef hot dog with a Chicago style bun. This was a 10 out of 10. For my entree the burger was amazing and cooked to perfect temp on the grill. The did not skip on the cheese (two pieces). The homemade chips were honestly the best I've ever had. They were crispy (not stale) and seasoned very well. My girlfriend got the polish dog and it was very good as well. It's served on a locally baked roll with some homemade mustard and killer kraut. If you're in the area, you HAVE to check this little place out. The staff is super friendly and the vibes are awesome. read more

See all

Man, if I lived in Milwaukee this place would definitely be in my regular rotation. A dimly-lit, cozy mix of history without the kitsch (it's in the ground floor of the historic Mackie Building), rustic without the dive-yness, and a solid menu of classics -- burgers, ribs, salads and more -- that are actually cooked to order. I was here on a taco Tuesday and was lucky to snag a seat at the bar, where I had a great view of the pro bartenders who never blinked while slinging a mess of strong drinks to a packed house. Seemed like there were a lot of regulars in the crowd and the place gets filled up quickly --- it's not that big, so be warned --- but even with all the bodies, my seared ahi tuna came out cooked perfectly, with efficient and no-nonsense service all-around, as I'd expect from a well-run kitchen and bar. It's open late, and there are theme nights like Weenie Wednesday and Friday Fish Fry, so I hope to come back and give those a try too. read more

See all

I love the swinging door, but what's not to love! Have been multiple times but most recently went to try out their $4 weenie Wednesday. They have a selection of hotdogs (Chicago, Western and Chili Cheese). We went with the Chicago dog as well as chips and chipotle ranch, all delicious. The space is cozy and service is always top tier. Only downside is they do not take reservations and the space is small, but who doesn't love an old fashioned at the bar! read more

First time here. In town in Business. Place was recommended. Love the vibe. Came in and grabbed a high top. Started with a spotted cow beer... Of course. Open up with the muscles. My server said that the chicken tenders were a big order and I should do the chicken sliders. Great suggestion. Glad I did. Everything delicious and would definitely return. read more

See all

Cute little cozy gem in downtown Milwaukee. We popped in for a late dinner on Saturday. The place was packed! We were lucky enough to snag a seat at the bar while we waited for our 2 top (45min-ish). The bar had great energy with excellent staff. We were asked if we'd like to eat at the bar, which we'd normally enjoy but it was a bit too crowded for us. We ordered drinks, 2 Tito's Press that came out to $24. A bit steep seeing as we ordered the same drinks down the road for $12. We were seated in the cozy dining area-very old school setting. We were greeted my our server promptly & decided to order the mahi mahi bites as an app. Delicious on their own but what really made the dish was the buffalo sauce! For my entree, I chose the ahi tuna dinner. All dinners come with soup or salad, I chose the Greek chicken orzo that tasted like a grandma made it! Such a great soup. The ahi was cooked to perfection, potato pancakes were crispy & the roll was soft & pillowy. If you're looking for a cozy spot with hearty food, definitely check it out! read more

See all

Our first visit to Swingin' Door Exchange won't be our last! We finally had time to wait for a table--and it was totally worth it. (Not sure how we haven't been here sooner, but it is what it is!) We ordered the prime dip and the patty melt, plus sides of caramelized Brussels sprouts and homemade chips with blue cheese. Everything was delicious and came out hot and fresh. Bonus points for offering NA beers and a great mocktail (Junipre & ginger beer with lime--so good!) recommended by our server. We sat at a cozy two-top by the back window. Even though the place was busy, it still felt very chill. Our server was attentive and checked in just the right amount. We had a great experience all around and will definitely be back! read more

See all

My go-to spot for a dinner in downtown Milwaukee. It has those old school eclectic supper club vibes, with a delicious menu to match. I love their wedge salad! It is right downtown and close to theaters, so wait time can be long, but if you get there early you'll get seated right away. Otherwise, put your name in and enjoy a walk downtown! read more

I went for a fish fry lunch and had a very enjoyable experience. It's got a really nice pub vibe and the fish, fries and coleslaw I had were superb! I actually liked the slaw so much I ordered a separate bowl full. The fish was flaky and moist and the fries were done to perfection. Our waitress was charming and answered our questions about other, non-swimming entrees for the others in my party. Despite ordering at lunchtime, we got our food quickly, which was a shame...I could've spent hours there soaking in the warmth and pub-ness. They have a varied menu and their portions pretty much guarantee a to-go box. Going there on a cold, snowy day made this cozy eatery even better. Had we been there later in the day, I definitely would have given their drinks menu a closer look. read more

When you walk by, you want to keep on walking but definitely go inside. It's small, dark, and just a cool vibe! There will probably be a wait so order a drink and wait! Trust me on this. I had the Tully Thyme and it was so good that I plan on trying to recreate it at home! I love a good French dip and a good one is hard to find so when I saw a prime dip on the menu I had to get it. It did NOT disappoint. A MUST get is the homemade chips for an appetizer. And a MUST even if you don't think you like them- is the Brussels sprouts. I'm serious- if you order them and don't fall in love, please let me know! They are off the chain good! My husband got the Reuben and I hate Reuben's and even it was good! This place is a MUST stop if visiting Milwaukee! read more

See all

Service is always on point! And the food is delicious! Sometimes there's a line but it's worth the wait. It's a small space kind of a dive bar feel but clean!! If you like blue cheese dressing, don't skip it! It's so chunky and yummy! read more

See all

Cool local bar vibes with all things you'd expect from an old world bar. It's in what seems like a good location of downtown Milwaukee. It was a Wednesday night and it was packed, so they're definitely doing something right. Food was pretty solid, I'd say 4/5 stars. Burgers and chili hit the spot. The service felt off. From the bar tender to the waiter Michael, they just weren't nice. read more

The vibe here is really cool. Such a hidden gem - highly recommend. Wish we could've sat inside to fully experience the atmosphere but we had our dog and they were more than happy to allow him to sit with us on the patio which was nice! The food was GREAT! My husband loved his ribs - they were a mix between a Carolina and a KC bbq sauce which is so unique. Delicious and fall off the bone. My tuna steak was cooked perfectly (I love when they consider your preferences and ask rare or med rare - not everywhere does that!). Had a really nice experience here and would recommend if you're ever in the area. read more

See all

The food was delicious and the atmosphere has a great old-school charm. The service was friendly and efficient-definitely a 5-star spot for a meal or a drink. Highly recommend read more

Swingin' Door Exchange was a great place to be! The location is an excellent old-fashioned, small town pub which you will feel like spending hours in. We also had the Ahi Tuna Steak and the Reuben sandwich-which was simply wonderful and tastier than the usual pub meal. The staff were pleasant and the old-fashioned decor is just ideal. Definitely recommend because of a delicious and warm meal. read more

This place is good if you like bar food and cheap drinks. Good Bloody Mary and good hot dogs on weenie Wednesday. read more

See all

Worth the wait! Best chicken sandwich I've ever had, they also have it in slider form. Our server, Michael, was amazing. Will be back for sure! read more

Went for lunch on a Wednesday and the place was surprisingly busy, but plenty of room to sit down and enjoy. They had a good number of specials, including hot dogs in a few different styles and prime rib. The sandwich was excellent and service was attentive, but I knew that before going here...it's been one of my favorite spots in town for years. Highly recommended but make sure to get there early if you go on a weekend, it's very popular. read more

Swingin' Door Exchange - The 4 C's salad - New American Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

Absolutely incredible. It's tiny and there's no reservation system, so be prepared to wait! We were able to get in at the bar and order fries while we waited for our table, and the bartenders were seriously the best. They were both so, so nice. Our food was next level amazing - I had the impossible burger with chips and ranch, and my husband had a ham sandwich. We both couldn't stop talking about it. The drinks were amazing - I loved the apple old fashioned. 100% worth the wait and I can't wait to go back next time I'm in the area. read more

See all

Honey with excellent vibes! Sat at the bar for dinner. Apple brandy old fashioned was perfect! The paper plane was also excellent. My hubby had the fish and chips. And I had the patty melt with Brussels sprouts. Highly recommend. The staff is friendly and attentive. I want to come back already. read more

Visited swingin door again to finally try their baked cod. I was skeptical as baked cod can be a hit or miss. Wow!! Was i surprised. Best baked cod in Milwaukee hands down. Cod is flaky with a Delicious char broiled smokey flavor and it is phenomenal. I ordered it with a side of potato pancakes. Best potato pancakes i have had. So crispy and perfect portioning. I ate everything. Old fashions of course are delish. Will be coming back for sure. Definitely worth the wait here. read more

A wait of 30 minutes at 5:30 on a Friday but the food and service was excellent. The Brussel sprouts were amazing with the aioli and nuts. My friends enjoyed burgers and a mustard and ham sandwich. Good sitting room as well as we waited read more

Tried out Swingin Door on a Saturday afternoon. It would have been a 30 minute wait, but they had seating outdoors. It was a little brisk, so they turned on the heaters for us. Service was quick and our waitress gave us a lot of recommendations. I got the sriracha chicken sandwich with brussel sprouts. The sandwich was great, but the real star was the brussel sprouts. They were roasted and had candied pecans and drizzled with an aioli sauce. The sauce really brought it home for me. It's easy to mess up sprouts, but they did a good job. My friend got the chicken tenders and while she said they tasted good, they were more like cutlets than tenders. I wouldn't really dock a star for that, it's just their take on tenders. But know if you order that, it may not be the shape you're expecting. read more

Swingin' Door Exchange - Sriracha Chicken Sandwich - New American Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Once again the Swingin' door Exchange does not disappoint. Solid food - good value. Classic vibes. Pork Sandwich with bacon and brussel sprouts on it. Side of beets. Oh My! Fantastic. When in MKE it must be tried. read more

Swingin' Door Exchange - Maple Mustard-Glazed Pork Chop - New American Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Only knocked a star off for the discrepancy between the wait and what we were told. But the hostess was kind about it. The food was really good especially the Brussel sprouts and Rueben. Def gives dated bar from Cheers but everybody food looked good and the service was good. I had the spicy carrots too. Those weren't as good but I'd highly recommend the Brussel sprouts. Candied pecans, some sriracha blend. I'd go back if I were local. read more

Waited two hours and a Friday night maybe iconic but they are fucked up never again. Not sure what the deal is here, but they certainly don't manage the place well Bartenders are overwhelmed but cordial. It's iconic but not worth the wait ....i left. read more

Very good BBQ pulled pork sandwich with fries, slaw, and a pickle for $15. Filling and tasty. Too bad I got takeout because the interior of the bar looks absolutely gorgeous. Old-fashioned decor and an intimate, cozy vibe. Great service, too! read more

Many times have tried, but no matter when we go we are told the wait is an hour plus. The hostess was too busy chatting with her friends to put our name on the list. Won't try again. No matter how great the food, bad customer service doesn't make up for it. read more

The Brussel sprouts are the most amazing thing ever. It is worth waiting for if there's a wait.

The food was the best I have had in a bar in a long time! I love the atmosphere of this place and the people watching is a great time too! Get the French dip... it's life changing! I would bathe in the au jus dipping sauce the sandwich comes with I were allowed! read more