Nice small deli, very local and friendly to anyone who walks in the door. Had an excellent breakfast sandwich, didn't have enough for a tea so it was on the house. For the not even ten minutes I was there, I was a family like atmosphere and it seemed Talenti's is a nice stop for many on their day, or it's a great way to start the day. read more

Stayed here in Bayville for a week, so came here every day at least once. Everything was absolutely delicious! Great staff too! We visit here from SoCal 2 or 3 times a year and always look forward to breakfast here! Five stars!!! read more

Our go to for breakfast, bacon is cooked just right not clumped up and greasy, within walking distance of our home.

Great sandwiches and food at a reasonable price anytime I'm back in Bayville. I will go here for eggs, sandwiches, and lunch stuff. It's very tasty and the people are friendly. read more

I'm so excited that the owners of East Norwich deli are at Talentis. They have the most amazing homemade potato salad, macaroni salad & Cole slaw. Don't forget their homemade rice pudding with a meringue topping. All the sandwiches I've had are made to order and always delicious. You won't be disappointed with their food or service. read more

Hands down my favorite deli, I have never had a bad experience here and the whole staff is very welcoming and friendly. I'd recommend the teriyaki steak panini for any steak lovers out there but whatever you get, I'm sure you'd enjoy. read more

Talenti's - Italian Hero - Delis Near Me - Bayville, New York

See all

Unless you are a local who the staff knows by name, don't expect to be treated with any ounce of respect. Good food by a hostile and uncomfortable environment. Staff is noticeably short tempered with both the employees and the customers. Have tried this place 3 times now and each time I've had an unpleasant experience. Id suggest you try one of the many other delis in the area. read more

Often looked forward to their breakfast sandwiches at the start of the day, but something has changed recently and consistency has suffered. Eggs are sometimes overcooked, same sandwiches assembled differently throughout the week, etc. Hope it picks back up soon. read more

I love those rare moments when I'm jonesing for something specific and one of the best versions of whatever that might be just takes care of business. Talenti's sausage egg and cheese just forced me to stop everything and write them a yelp review. I had a breakfast emergency this morning and I haven't been too excited by the choices in my new town. So, this time I drove a little further to try the deli with the fancy sign, in a desperate search for a clean and decent breakfast. Three things stick out here... First of all, the quality of the food is really fresh and high-grade. They were out of bagels and even the "second choice" bread was same-day fresh. The sandwich ended up PERFECT. I ended up ordering a pound of mozzarella and a muffin while I waited just because the overall quality of everything in there was visibly obvious. I just tried the mozzarella and it's nuts. Second, props to the cook who stopped to ask if I wanted him to put the the sandwich into the panini press for a little extra crispiness. The guy had finished preparing the food and stopped to think about a way to make it even more delicious before letting go of it. You have to appreciate someone who takes that kind of pride in their work. I felt like I had a professional consultation and it made me all the more hot for this sandwich. It was seasoned perfectly too. Third, they have this super adorable woman manning the register who basically charms you to death as you wait. It was fun seeing this assembly line of guys with goofy expressions walk in, each patiently waiting for their two minutes with her. I'm not an easy blusher, but she got me too. Nicely played. That's all. I'm still working on this outrageously good apple muffin and am just really happy to have found a serious deli in Bayville. read more

Great food and great people running the place. Always come here on the weekends for either breakfast or lunch. Always reliable and the Cuban has fantastic pork...is the best you'll find around. read more

Kat is super friendly and the food is top notch! Antonio and Big Lou have a great report and a funny routine! read more

I go here almost every day for a little something and should have written a review a long time ago. All the food here is great and the service is always friendly. The sandwiches are exceptionally good - great bread. I'm also thankful for the very generous ice coffee portions. A small is a Venti! read more

Well, me and my friend were trying to get food for lunch two rude servers walked up to me and my friend, and began to harass us about that. The fact that we were yelling and being rude to the employees when we were just trying to show them what we are trying to order. They were very rude and threaten to kick to 10 year olds out of the store for no reason. The workers even begin to talk to us behind our backs to customers about how children are age I just want to make a big fuss and they should never serve to children again. Never go to this dump read more

We love Talenti's! We come here almost every morning to get coffee and a snack and their delicious French toast and hash browns!! I come here with my 23 year old special needs brother and I am only 12 and they are still very nice to us!! We walk there every day they open really early at 6 am on the weekdays and it is a great spot 5 stars would recommend! (Only issue is they close pretty early at 7 pm! read more

Same experience as at least 3 other reviewers - morning counter help was rude and abrupt. Simple, easy to answer questions were met with impatience and sarcasm. I had ordered the sandwiches the day before (from a really nice guy who was working in the afternoon) for morning pick up. I called in the morning to change the time and a guy answered and just set the phone down and forgot about it. After 5 minutes I hung up and called back. Took 10 minutes and three calls to accomplish something that should have taken about 30 seconds. I don't care how good the sandwiches are, nothing tastes good when you are treated like this. read more

Love the people. Anthony & Kat are the kindest people. The food is always fresh & top notch. Can't wait to return

Gave 3 stars because food is amazing but they literally never answer their phone for a to go order. Whenever they finally pick up the guy has such an attitude! I have heard this from multiple people around town. They really need to work on their phone system because the food is great!! read more

For the most part the menu is filled with great value pics. Always consistent. Always looking forward to the daily menu specials.

The best deli around staff is friendly and fast and Kathleen and Anthony the owners always have a pleasant smile to greet you on every visit! Love this place!! read more

I stopped in TWICE on one shift at work lol. Very personable. The owner actually assisted me on the first stop and that caused me to head back for lunch! I ordered a pastrami sandwich, it was great quality and hearty. Affordable prices. Definitely work the trip! read more

Great new Deli in Bayville, was hard to get a good cup of coffee in Bayville before this place opened , all the other places are inconsistent lousy coffee at best , Talenti's spot on everyday . Great Bagels , all food fresh .Its my new go to place. read more

I have never in my life walked into any establishment food or otherwise and saw what I saw when I entered Talenti's. The person who appeared to be the owner was very belittling towards his staff. A majority of the time the attitudes in this establishment are upbeat and very welcoming. I was embarrassed not only for the employees but for the owner who should know how to properly reprimand staff without making every patron in the building uncomfortable. Unprofessional and upsetting to say the least. Food is alright for deli food although it is very pricey and doesn't deserve the price tag it carries. I as well as quite a few others patrons no longer eat here due to these things. Hopefully if you go in there it's on a "good" day. read more

Best bacon egg and cheese on Long Island hands down. Their paninis are also incredible. This is a stand up family run business. Service here is top notch! read more

This is the best deli on Long Island! The food is the best quality and the people that work there are just awesome. The menu is filled with anything in mind and the environment is super comfortable! THE BEST!!! read more

Beat deli ever the food is always fresh and I wouldn't go anywhere else. Always a pleasure going in and fun love live love

I have just moved to this neighborhood and I went into this deli one other time. First time I went there, I was looked at up and down by the woman that works behind the counter. I proceeded to tell her that I was new and that I was happy to be there . Needless to say I still was getting stares from her. The second time I go in the deli it was crowded and I was waiting. The young man who work behind the counter was very pleasant but they overlooked me and took a couple of people before me. I just casually mentioned that I was next and I have been waiting when the woman behind the counter jumped in and said I had not been waiting and I just walked in. I proceeded to tell her that she was wrong and absolutely overlooked when he took somebody ahead of me. He apologized as he should have because that's how you treat customers but instead she treated me like garbage . She was absolutely rude to me Even if she thought I wasn't waiting that's not how you talk to a customer. Thank God there are two other delis in the area and both who hagreed with me that was outrageous how I was treated ! read more

This place is in the location of the former C-Side Deli. I think this place is great! My husband and I walk here all the time as our new local go-to deli. They are really friendly and their sandwiches are very good. We especially love their chicken salad. My favorite part: they are kind to my pup! We kept her outside the first couple of times we visited the deli, but the owner insisted that we can bring her inside if we would like. We will be coming back often! Thanks Talenti's! read more

Recently had a party and got a tray of assorted wraps, grilled chicken, sausage and peppers and some salads. Food was great! Very friendly service as well. Would definitely recommend. read more

Only good when the owner is on the grill. The new large fellow undercooked my eggs and made me sick before a long road trip

Awesome food!!! The homemade pastries are killer but not always available. Suggest they have them always!!