Hello, I went to tavern 5 recently with my family. It was by far the worst experience I have ever had. First, my waitress was extremely rude and kept on leaving to answer her phone. I think her name starts with a d, but I'm not sure. Not sure if I will return to this establishment especially if she's my waitress, she needs to be respectful of customers and not rush them so she can go on her phone. Also, this restaurant did not follow the 6 feet apart rule at all, tables were too close together. I will tell my friends to not go there until they are up to code with proper guidelines. A really big disappointment. read more

We love it here and come often. Food is great, really fun atmosphere. The kids have a blast in the back playing cornhole. Perfect neighborhood spot! read more

We were here tonight. Party of 4. Chris was our waiter. I wanted to let you know that he was the absolute best server we've ever had. My husband has super high standards for service and Chris did not disappoint!! Thanks for great food and great service! We will definitely be back. read more

My updated review is tippin' on the 5 star level, but it's not quite there yet, but I know it'll be there soon!! My wife and I came here for Happy Hour on a Friday night and for HH, the bar was pretty full at 4:45. Happy hour is from 3-6.. Can I make a suggestion... Until 7pm would be better tho!!. We started with a couple drinks.. I a Manhattan and she a Sangria. Both were on the HH menu and for $8 and $6 bucks, respectfully, they were very yummy. Another suggestion? Why is your Jack and Coke $8? Seems a bit high when your one liquor HH drinks are $6. After a while, we ordered a few app's from their HH menu: Spring Rolls, Buffalo Wings, and Calamari - all for $7 per. The Wings and Calamari were very good, and chock full of flavor and you get a nice portion for $7.. The Spring Rolls.. Well, for $7, you don't get much :-( Only 5 small rolls - albeit good, but not a nice serving. That's my only negative about the night's experience. What you get here is an "upscale" HH experience rather than your stereotypical dive bar experience. Very Highly Recommended! read more

See all

good morning fellow yelpers....my sister and I came here late afternoon for early dinner and had a great experience........we both had house salads with their orange flavored dressing....very good.......had fresh hot bread with their garlic butter.....also very good.....my sister had the pasta with vodka sauce and I had sea scallops with asparagus and rice mix......both very good........we had great service, couldn't be better..(.we had a male server with a beard and I'm sorry that I forgot his name0......the drinks ( whisky sour and cc and ginger) were made well........the restaurant and bar is spotless and beautiful.....including the toilets......great outside area in which we sat along with a lower area with lg. picnic tables and a few corn hole games read more

The place is beautiful, staff is always friendly, and the food is great!!! the only complaint I have ever heard of this place is the price... in my opinion the price is beyond fair for the food and service they provide, I love this place! read more

This place was highly touted by friends. It has an appealing feel and decor. I love the backyard environment with corn hole and picnic tables. The wait staff were very pleasant. We started with a hummus appetizer. It was okay. The eggplant lacked flavor. I had the short ribs as my entree. It was very good...not fatty. It had a nice accompaniment of mash potatoes and vegetables. They were all prepared well with complimentary flavors. All in all, probably about a 3.5. read more

Staff was very friendly, It gets crowded very quickly, I would take the outside dining when available low ceilings make it very noisy. Food very good change up the menu every couple of weeks always something different. Parking could be a little rough especially during peak hours, But was able to find a spot off street parking is available. Make sure you save room for the ice cream I do not have a clue where they get a from but it is excellent read more

Really disappointed with this spot. The meals were very uneventful. I had the orecchiette which was very dull on flavor, very bland. My wife ordered the veggie tacos without the aioli sauce and asked for salsa on the side. Out came the tacos with the Aioli. They were sent back and came back out without the salsa. It was also very obvious that the chief had no formal training, the vegetables were cut totally wrong for tacos. Taco chips with tacos is not a side, it's like white rice served with fried rice. I want to just conclude with this. I called ahead to ask for a booth ( which by the way there were plenty open when we got there ) because my mom is handicap. I was told they wouldn't accommodate the request, then was told the manager would call me back ..... no one ever did. That's shameful. read more

We have been to Tavern Five regularly since my review and have enjoyed every meal. Delicious daily specials and the best hamburgers in the area! Incredibly helpful and friendly service. I was surprised that happy hour was limited to the lounge area and not the entire restaurant. Excellent choices of beer. read more

I've been here a few times, and usually enjoy it. Food was good, but this visit our service was horrible. After dinner our waitress didn't even ask if we wanted dessert, she just brought us our check. And then, she took it upon herself to round up our bill so she didn't have to give us change (coins). Granted, it was only like twenty cents, but who does that?! read more

Over priced run of the mill pub food. Look elsewhere, plenty of other good places right around the corner.

Not impressed. Very simple. NOT impressed.im going to say this a few times. So this gets posted as a review. Food was okay, not really tavern worthy, drinks were good, friendly waitress, but took a while to serve us. Not impressed. Not impressed. Not impressed read more

Bad bad bad. Don't take reservations. Waited over 30 minutes in cold weather to see people who came after us get seated. Go somewhere else

Our waitress, Nicole, and the owner, Debbie, were very friendly and welcoming for our first visit to this restaurant. Maple wings were excellent and we decided to sit outside in the backyard as it was too noisy inside. We had great drinks and enjoyed our salad and burger while dining under the lights. We'll be back. read more

Every single year the Wednesday before thanksgiving we get drunk here. So much fun. Best place ever. Food is great. Drinks are fluid

What a great first time experience! My husband and I and our 1 year old daughter enjoyed dinner on the beautiful outdoor patio! The atmosphere is cozy and comfortable and the food was amazing! We enjoyed everything so much and can't wait to go back! read more

We return to tavern 5 every few months or so. Tonight we had the best experience - amazing service by Chris. He was one step ahead of everything we might need. Our orders came out quickly and our drinks were refilled promptly. Incredibly helpful and friendly service. We had the empanadas and wings. Delicious. Ahi tuna with arugula salad was fresh and again delicious. Great place read more

Burger was great, great fries; was packed and loud; waitress didn't know a common bar drink such as a Long Island ice tea and was just rude

Nice but noisey atmosphere. Excellent and friendly sevice. The food was marginal. Very, very bland burger and frozen food service onion rings which were tasteless and soggy. My friend had the New England clam chowder which he described as "anemic"; I had a sample. It was watery and oddly flavored. The scallops and pasta serving was undersized and uninspiring. Four smaller sized scallops for a dinner entree? The scallops tasted ok, but the pasta was not cooked properly; it was mushy. I don't think the kitchen staff have a clue. I don't think I will return. read more

Minor misunderstanding when we got seated but Gary came to the rescue... Once we got settle on the outside patio things got resolved. Great server, Brianna, took good care of us. The burgers and wings were excellent... we will forget the misunderstanding and return for another meal. The place is well decorated, good appearance and atmosphere. read more

Really nice atmosphere ~ Definately a good place to go! The wait staff was wonderful! Food was also good. Dessert was AWESOME! Pumpkin Cake ~ Heaven! read more

My husband and I were running a few errands and wanted to grab a quick bite to eat. We figured we would try Tavern 5 as we have driven past it a few times and figured it was something new and different for us. We walked in and were immediately greeted and sat at a table. We loved the decor and the atmosphere very modern, warm and welcoming. The server came over told us about the lunch specials and took our order. We started with an order of fried calamari which were cooked perfectly nice and crispy! I had a bacon cheeseburger with mozzarella cheese with a side of fries, both were very good. My husband had the crispy chicken sandwich and he enjoyed it, We will definitely be going back! Great food, great service and a great beer selection as well! read more

Wanted to check out the old Gillys. Beautifully done interior but very noisy if you're sitting in the bar area or in the front of the restaurant. They do have a few tables outside as well as picnic tables and corn hole. Could be fun! Food was good enough but the portions are a little on the smaller side for the price...the fried calamari, although tasty, was definitely not enough to share. The burger was almost child size with lots of fries to fill the plate. Fish tacos were really good flavorwise except they came out cold and had some kind of very bitter leafy green mixed in. Served on the side was a chick pea & rice salad which was delicious...I just wish there was more than 2 forkfuls. All the staff we encountered was really friendly and acommodating. read more

Tavern 5 - American Near Me - Pompton Plains, New Jersey

I was reminded to write this from reviewing my credit card statement. My wife and I really enjoyed eating here 2 weeks, but the ending left a sour taste for us. It was a very nice evening, perfect for enjoying their expansive backyard (which notably is very kid friendly). They have interesting menu choices and each of our dishes were very well done. As it was a warm evening, I had 3 non-alcoholic iced teas, Was the waiter correct when he said management insists that refills need to be charged, or was it his own personal effort to pad the bill with an additional $5.50? Either way, who charges for iced tea refills??!! This scarred somewhat from what was otherwise a very enjoyable meal and will give us pause before returning. read more

Had a birthday celebration for a friend on Saturday and tav 5 staff hit a homerun ! Really made everybody's night even more special. Would like to thank our server Sherrie for the best service you could ask for. Love tav 5 and staff, will be back soon! read more

Very nice ambiance. Very clean. Wait staff are friendly but not experienced . Regrettably we were the first people for dinner coming in just before 5 PM. No meals can go in before that time.... Period. We were told twice. So first plates out any night are always interesting. My medium well burger was char outside and rare inside. My wife's fish taco plate was overly spiced. We may try again, but I am not sure it is worth the chance. read more

Delicious food cooked by Chef Anthony LoPinto! Cocktails were also great. We had the mussels, fish tacos, Tavern 5 Burger and chicken breast with mashed potatoes. All were excellent! Don't pass on the chocolate cake with cocoa nibs and salt! read more

Almost didn't get seated when we arrived with a party of 8. Was told no reservations, but when got there was asked if we called ahead. At least 1/3 of restaurant was empty. Owner accommodated us after my insistence that taking reservations and calling ahead were not that different. Was hopeful based on atmosphere and nice outdoor space. When half of my party went out to play cornhole, the owner came over and immediately said, "If I knew half your party wasn't here yet, I wouldn't have seated you." When we explained they were outside playing, she did not apologize and went on to explain to my friend why they have a call ahead and no reservation policy. Food was terrible, friend's fish taco had no flavor, husband's salad with salmon literally had a bunch of greens in it, daughter's steak was chewy and DEF NOT skirt steak, likely flank, for $25. Waitress was very sweet and accommodating. Will not go back!!!! read more

For my first time here. We were met with some negativity. My husband called to ask for a reservation for a Birthday celebration. They said they didn't take reservations normally but because we were a party of 9, they would take our name. BUT when we got here they claimed they knew nothing. We had to wait 25 minutes for the table. The volume of the clients is extremely loud. Some sound absorbing tiles would be good. The food was good and our waitress Katie was very nice. I may be back but never with a big group. read more

What a gem!! I was in the area for business and looking for a place to grab a drink with some decent food, so I googled places to eat near me and so happy I found and chose this place. The food drinks and ambiance were so good that it turned into date night for me and my husband. Sheri, our server, had such a great personality and was very familiar with the menus, made amazing recommendations! My husband had the pork chop and I had the short rib...all amazing. The drink were mixed well and they had many selections of cocktails wines and beers. There is live music and the entire staff was just so pleasant. Even the owner Debbie came to say hello and ask us about our experience. We are definitely making this one of our regular date night spots. read more

I just cannot fathom that a business that runs on customer service does not care about first impressions. I want to say they should get something for the effort to take over and redesign the previous restaurant, which by the way my family and I had enjoyed. It's just that it was so disappointing for our first experience that it took us several years to try it again. Well we tried and failed. Allow me to explain. We live 1.3 miles from here and we love to eat out and we do often so we were really looking forward to having this restaurant in our neighborhood but the reception we received in 2017 was downright chilly, the place was empty and the man with glasses who eventually sat us for lunch inside on a cold day acted like he was trying to get us to leave. And I got the impression that he was in charge. So after taking in the atmosphere of uninspiring homogeneous colors, the manmade materials used in the design of the tables and the boring lunch menu we did just that. The website states that their intention was to offer hospitality but perhaps that only goes towards people they know. Sadly to say our next attempt to try this place was also a failure, we had to leave due to poor service. We have never eaten here. read more

Just came in for dinner, tried arugula salad and scallops over risotto, everything was pretty good. Fast service. Definitely will come back!!! read more

This is my 3rd visit to Tavern 5. Service was very good. Server was attentive without being over bearing. Atmosphere was good can be slightly noisy but do able. We had burgers which were done as ordered, meat was tasty and the size of the burger was great. Nice place to meet friends in a casual atmosphere. read more

Too bad the service is atrocious bc the food is decent, but not great. We finally were able to get out for a date night, decided dinner/drinks outside at Tavern 5 would be perfect. Unfortunately, there was a wait for outside, no big deal, so we were seated in the bar area with a view of the band setting up and dying for a drink while we decided on some entrees/appys. That's where the service issues started. We were greeted after sitting for 15 + minutes and had to inform the hostess no one has come to our table, who in turn told the manager that instructed a waitress to come to our table. Once the server came over, her initial interaction was "are you ready to order everything now?" Wow, okay....we were, so gladly gave our drinks and food order. Drinks were delivered 10 minutes later and the food game out relatively soon after 20 min or so after ordering, not too bad. The server followed the runner delivering food and my husband luckily ordered a second drink since that was the last time we saw our waitress at our table for the remaining 45 minutes we were there. Soon after the food arrived, I finished my cocktail and left it on the side of the table to show I needed another. The sever was by the kios chatting with other waitresses, checking her phone, and didn't even look in our direction once. At this point, I needed a drink of anything liquid to wash down my spicy steak tacos, so I finished my husbands. Now we both needed drinks, as a server you want to up sell, come on ?!?! I tried to catch the managers eye as she was the one who instructed to waitress to greet us in the first place after waiting too long, but she was sitting in a booth chatting it up with her friends, I assume. It was quite awful as we finally caught an employees attention and she asked if we needed anything. My response was "I wanted a drink 30+ min ago and our server hasn't been to our table in about 45 min or so...." she was sweet and apologetic (the only one received that night), but the damage was done. AWFUL SERVICE and having a bad wedding band play at 8:15 pm in the dining room isn't a great look. If the band was even remotely decent, it may have been somewhat enjoyable even waiting for terrible service - NEVER AGAIN read more

I was so impressed with this restaurant. Every detail was so cute and thought out, from the silverware to the light bulbs. The food was really good! We got pizza and burgers, and didn't have one complaint! Denise was our server and she was so friendly and inviting! Definitely going back! read more

We love the food here! It is simple and delicious. I love the option to sit outside. Upscale vibe. Delicious food

I have been going to this restaurant for a few years & always had great service, especially from a waitress named Denise . Recently we have noticed a lot of new wait staff mixed in with our " regulars" & wonder why? The is concerning when you see a restaurant doing this to their loyal servers. Just makes you wonder about the owners and if something is amiss with their management. The food is always delicious, the atmosphere is great so we don't want to feel uncomfortable with this new mix. Keep your loyal staff!! read more

One of our fav places to eat! Food is always fresh and tasty and the beer selection and specialty drinks are great! Summer dining is especially enjoyable in the outside seating area. read more

This place is amazing. The food is incredible, and the staff is super friendly. The only reason they earned 4 stars is because while sitting outside we would occasionally get a whiff of garbage. If they relocated the dumpster, it would make it a 5 star restaurant. read more