Always great pizza, subs and gyros. Friendly staff and fast service. We have never had a problem with out takeout orders.

Passing through and grabbed a pizza for the family. My family is very picky about pizza and they all agreed it was the best we had on the entire New England trip. Fast service and friendly staff. Will eat here again next trip. read more

He new what he is doing fridge never worked so well if you need someone get him very very good I have used him before

I was staying in the area for work and felt like pizza. This is a small pizza place in a little plaza. It's a little run down but had a steady flow of customers for take out orders. I ordered a meat lovers pizza and I was not disappointed. The price was average for a large. The crust was good and toppings were plentiful. If you're looking for take out pizza, I'd have to say it's a good go to. read more

See all

Great pizza! Cheesy. Hot. Delish. College town pizza. Wish they had dessert!! They deliver and have a small eating area inside. I've done both several times. read more

Been coming here for years during the summer and has always been my favorite. Although during the Covid restrictions and mask mandates. There was a staff worker not wearing a mask, we left before ordering in that instance. read more

Delicious pizza!! Highly recommend- 1 large fed 4 hungry adults! Nice thin crust and soft outer crust!

Awesome food. Delivered hot! Generous portions for reasonable prices! You gotta try them!

This pizza has been recommended to me for years, so I finally tried it. It's hard to make an unmemorable pizza, but they did it. The fries were also unremarkable. I'm not sure why this came so highly recommended, I would never go back. That said, service was good and we received our order quickly. The place was clean. read more

Tenney Mountain Pizza - "Average" - Italian Near Me - Plymouth, New Hampshire

See all

Ver good food. The delivery time was good Didn't have at the restaurant. Was good delivery service.

As a single mom our nights out or pizza night! One night while I was stuck without a vehicle and I couldn't get home I ordered my kids dinner. We were told an hour wait. Three hours later, at 8 PM, my kids still have not received their food. When they got it it was cold, and the cheese had hardened. No one offered any kind of discount and they excepted the full payment still. No I didn't say anything so maybe that was on me... Tonight I got two small pizzas, mozzarella sticks and some chicken tenders and the price was $53! So their prices are kind of crazy hi, they charge extra if you use your credit card, their delivery is very undependable. The people that work there seem really nice but as far as a business, thumbs down read more

By far the best pizza place in Plymouth. Not much else to say other than they've good really good food at fair prices and has generous portion sizes. read more

They have no sauce options for vegetarians. They have no marinara sauce offering, only sauce with meat.

I went to tenny mountain pizza and got a couple slices of pizza which I was happy with,however,I went to put a dollar in the tip container snd it was so filthy I did not want to push the top open to drop the tip inside it ,which is not possible without touching it,I placed the dollar beside the container and the ass ociate,questioned why I put it there,I responded" I didn't want to touch it because it is so dirty ,she grabbed the tip,grabbed the and the container,asked me why I was talking to her like that,and told me I was mean,and demanded I leave her store,u responded to her that I was simply pointing out that that it was in need of cleaning ,she then started to call me names ,and again demanded I leave,I told her that I was shocked at her response and I was simply asking her to clean something that is handled by many people every day and then I told her to go f herself ,sat down at a table and ate my lunch ,food was good but that woman at the counter was about as rude as they come,SHOCKING .FIRE THAT BITCH ,SHE IS BAD FOR BUSINESS. read more

Great pizza and great service! Pizzas were "specialty" and they were made correctly. Highly recommend to anyone in the area. When looking for somewhere I didn't know much about this place other than the reviews and I'm glad I trusted the reviews. read more

Best pizza in Plymouth so far(check out pics). Service and delivery is a great benefit of this place. $12 for a large pizza that can feed 2-4 people is a great value. Ingredients are definitely high quality. The cheese actually stays on when you take a bite, and the pizza was barely greasy unlike any other places around Plymouth. Fries were okay. Rate them a 6 out of 10. The batter was really good, but they were just soggy maybe because of delivery time? Although for $4 you do get a lot of fries. Sometimes can be rude on the phone.. Can't wait to get this pizza again in the future and will look forward to trying a calzone! read more

Tenney Mountain Pizza - Pepperoni/pepper pizza. 9.5 out of 10! - Italian Near Me - Plymouth, New Hampshire

See all

Typical small town pizza place, pizza is okay, kids liked it, but nothing special. Tastes like common place pizza. Also got Italian sub, tasted fresh but didn't have a lot of flavor, not sure what meats are used but it was unimpressive. read more

Great salads and they give ample grilled chicken portion for the salads. Great onion rings & steak subs. They have tables to eat there.

It is what it is. And what it is is fast, reliable, pizza that doesn't blow you away but also doesn't make any claim to. In the Plymouth region, I would put it safely behind some of the other offerings but, when we needed to feed 9 people on a time and budget crunch, this place came through! The interior of the restaurant is plain, basic pizza establishment; padded seats, a television on in the background, and tile floors. The pizza was fairly straight ahead; probably frozen dough, a simple sauce, and the kind of ingredients you would see in a "house of pizza". That being said, it was decent and just enough out of the way that it wasn't super busy and our 4 large pizzas were ready in a few minutes. The staff was VERY friendly and their consistency is why our group has been back once a year when visiting the region during a very busy time. read more

Never going to downtown pizza again. never had a bad experience with these guys, staff is always friendly, and their non-pizza food is on par or better than most places in the area. Only 4 stars because delivery has been kinda rough in the past, but they're working on it and it's nowhere near as sloppy as downtown. read more

2.5 hours to get delivery less than a mile away, and the food was COLD!!!

Yummy subs! Had steak and cheese and they put pizza cheese in top, cool. My roasted Turkey and provolone was excellent and the ham and cheese was also good! Nice people, friendly, fast. read more

Should have read the reviews before placing an order for delivery. Was in the area just for a night and decided to have two subs delivered. Was originally told it would take 40mins-1hour. After waiting for an hour and 15 minutes I called to check on the order and was told that ours was the next order, after waiting another 30 minutes (almost 2 hours total and still no food) we called and cancelled. Can't speak for their food, but their delivery service is terrible. read more

Popped in for a quick pizza. Very friendly staff and wicked quick! The inside was nothing special but the pizza tasted great and wasn't wet or greasy. Worth popping in! read more

The new employee Ken is so polite I thought I had called the wrong place lol!! Nice folks !! Great food!! And a call back to make sure my order was correct just short of amazing! Thanks Ken!! read more

The pizza is good, and the service is friendly and efficient. It's a clean family-friendly atmosphere. Feel free to bring children and grandparents alike! read more

This place is terrible. We waited twenty five minutes for a cheese steak that came without the ordered ingredients. Place is filthy, the staff looks like they haven't showered in days. Save your money and go to Subway up on Boulder Point. read more

The absolute worst service I have ever received in my life! Took 2 hours to deliver and they messed up my order after telling me the delivery time was between 30-45 minutes. I had to call twice for an update both times they told me the guy was on the way for over an hour. I asked for some sort of credit and she told me sorry nothing we can do for you we just messed up your order. This is the worst customer service ever please don't eat here! I only downloaded Yelp just to tell everyone how bad they are! read more

It's the only game in town for reliable delivery, and the pizza isn't bad. It's not NY style, it's not gourmet, but it's good enough and there are lots of choices, read more

Ordered a Lg Pizza and cheesy fry to be delivered. Was told to give them 35-40mins. Ok no problem. At the 1hr 15min mark I called and was told the delivery guy was behind and it would be another 30min. No apologies or anything. After another 45mims I called and was told they had to remake my food and it would be there in two minutes. Another 30mins later it arrived. The delivery person said they ran out of pizza. No apologies or anything. The food was ehh. Not sure if this is typical or not but I know I will not be ordering from them again. read more

This place has had the same good food for the last five years stop about once a week. The inside has been painted and cleaned up nice. They have in my opinion as good if not better steak calzones than top rated Ashland calzones. I eat at both. The salads are the same for five years now and I just love the friendly staff and good food. read more

The service is good, and the food comes out at a decent speed. We only went once, but the pizza and fries were great. If you find yourself craving pizza in Plymouth, stop by this little place. read more

It wasn't bad, the large cheese pizza has way to much cheese on it and then I ordered there again for delivery and it took over an hour to bring it to me. They still expected tip and full price. Food was rubbery and cold when it got here read more

Best pizza I've found in Plymouth so far. The buffalo chicken pizza is a bit saucy but still very good.

Pizza was good but the delivery took close to an hr and 15 minutes...wasn't to happy about that but it was warm still

This is my favorite pizza for the money. Not only are they reliable with their advertised hours unlike Keith's but they make better pizza for the money you spend and have it ready to pick up quicker. read more

This restaurant is garbage, the foods alright. But that can't make up for the garbage service I'm received every single time getting this place. 2 hour delivery times up the street? Phone busy/ no answer during hours and no delivery half the week. this restaurant should be called Tenney mountain no pizza because I don't think they enjoy running their business correctly read more

So I have since been back...I don't stick to my convictions well apparently and found that they have since improved their service. I still wouldn't rave about them, but for the limited options for the area, lunch isn't out of the question. read more

Ordered a calzone. Got a pizza instead. Wanted chicken on it. Got garlic instead. When we told them the mistakes, they offered us grilled chicken to put on it ourselves. They were slammed. I said sure. They never came back. Fiance complained. They "couldn't find our slip" and offered only to give us some heated up grilled chicken to put on our 2 remainding slices of pizza. Really sucks cuz I loved this place. We won't be going there ever again. read more

I LoVE their Pizza's & Prices (very reasonable!)... I would HIGHLY recommend the steak & cheese subs.... they are so mouth water good! I also very much like the crew there! I would highly recommend Tenney Pizza! read more