Another wonderful night at the Broken Barrel. This is one of Carmel's hidden gems. Attached to Wolfie's, but a 21 and over space only . The ambiance is a quiet, private, speakeasy like environment. The only tv in restaurant shows black and white movies exclusively. Your choice- bar height tables or comfy leather chairs and loveseats with shorter tables. The service is impeccable. The bourbon and whiskey selection is top tier. The food is delicious with a large variety. Prices are very reasonable. Truly one of my favorite restaurants. read more

Just went for cocktails and they did not disappoint. Creative creations, attentively served.

Had girls night on a Friday night. It was slower than normal but Peggy took excellent care of myself and two friends. She had an awesome attitude the second we walked into the door. She made us feel right at home and automatically started helping make suggestions. Cocktails, local bourbon flights and good food. What else could we ask for? Low-light setting makes it feel like a relaxed speak easy. It was a great time and I would highly encourage anyone to go and say hi to Peggy, she'll treat ya right! read more

See all

The drinks, food, and service were all great! Great first date location! Start with a drink, if it goes well, move to the attached restaurant! read more

We loved it here. This was our first time and our server/bartender was so kind and helpful. The food came out quickly and the drinks came out in about 5-6 minutes as they are craft cocktails. Tuesdays and Wednesdays all their appetizers (except traditional wings) are Half Off with the purchase of a specialty cocktail. This is a 21+ establishment. They are connected to Wolfie's so you can get the same food brought over on this side. Both Broken Barrel and Wolfie's have separate (not dog friendly) patios. We enjoyed the ahi tuna - buttery soft and delicious - and the chips and dip. The queso came with pico on top and was so good when mixed together. There was also a salsa cup and it was pretty tasty! The wings both boneless and traditional were so good. The boneless ones were nice and crispy. All wings had lots of sauce on them. We would come back for the drinks alone :) these were great craft cocktails and had a huge variety of bourbon cocktails (sweet or bourbon forward) with lots of different flavors. It was pretty unique compared to a lot of other bars or craft bars we've been to. If you appreciate and enjoy bourbon, check this place out. There's also a few non-bourbon cocktails to choose from if that's more your style! read more

See all

This spot was wonderful. Fantastic cocktails. It is next door, like literally connected by an interior door, to a much more casual-feeling sports bar type restaurant. But that works out because you can also order food from there while at the Broken Barrel. The cocktails were fabulous, the service was great, and it was all so good it made me wonder why more people weren't there enjoying it all! The food was also pretty dang good and higher end than the general feel of the restaurant next door gave the impression of. Highly recommend Broken Barrel for a cozy cocktail hang! read more

Great food and atmosphere! I would definitely recommend giving it a try. Service was great as well.

Amazing ambiance. Bartender was fantastic and had great recommendations. Would absolutely return

Ambience is very cool. Service was top notch. Cocktails were great. We had an appetizer and it was good! We will be back! read more

See all

We popped in here with friends for a quick drink before our movie. I've been a craft beer girl for a long time, but I've been expanding into liquor and cocktails. I've developed a taste for Old Fashioned and was just going to get the traditional one...until I saw the P.B. & J...an Old Fashioned made with Screwball Whiskey, cherry liqueur, cranberry juice, bitters and fresh orange squeeze. I was sold! It was delicious! And I was suddenly sad we had a movie time to make. P.S. the hubby had a Tequila Old Fashioned. Also, very tasty! I will definitely be back to try more tasty concoctions! Plus, I really love everything about the interior...dark wood, comfy intimate seating, a speakeasy vibe. read more

The Broken Barrel - Carmel - P.B. & J - Whiskey Bars Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

Atmosphere is that of an English pub, staff is friendly, bartenders are educated in Bourbon and Whiskey. You can order food from Wolfies next door, one of my favorite places to go when you need a relaxing evening. read more

Great adult night date environment. Classy and quiet bar to enjoy mixed drinks and good service. Food is solid Wolfies casual dining.

This is a really great bar. It has a speakeasy vibe, with low lighting and soft music. It is on the small side, which I enjoyed. The drinks are great and at a higher price point than the surrounding area. This is the second time I've been here and there has only been one bartender. So, the service was slow. I do recommend this as a pre-date spot. read more

The Broken Barrel - Carmel - Menu - Whiskey Bars Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

Sometimes you want to go where they know your name...but it's probably just because I'm here so much. Celebrating a special occasion? Had a rough day? Happy hour with friends? Just don't want to cook your own dinner? This place is the answer. Jene provides the best recommendations, and makes sure every visit is a great one. read more

The Broken Barrel - Carmel - Birthday shots! - Whiskey Bars Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Delish food and fantastic cocktails. Bartender was so knowledgeable and made great recommendations

This place is SO unexpected! Located next to the casual Wolfie's Grill in Carmel (the buildings are attached and owned by the same person), this swanky whiskey and bourbon bar feels almost like a speakeasy. With its dim lighting, dark wood and intimate tables, it's the perfect date spot. There was only one server working on the Friday night that he visited, but he was working the room and keeping everyone happy. He was super fun and friendly, and interacting with all of the customers. I tried the Blood and Sand (Monkey Shoulder scotch whiskey, vermouth, blood orange shrub, cherry liqueur) and the New Old Fashioned (Bulleit Rye, brown sugar, bitters, orange and lemon). Both were SO delicious. Like, possibly my favorite whiskey cocktails I've ever had. They were well-mixed and not too strong, yet felt very strong. For $8-$10 dollars a cocktail, you definitely get your money's worth, as the drinks are very high quality and the service was great. You can sit st the bar, a few high top tables, or in the comfy lounge seats/sofas at the entrance. The place isn't too big, but fits around 40 seated and would be a great spot to rent out for a party. read more

See all

I have been here before and had a good experience. So, being in this side of town again, I told some friends it would be a good place to try some new bourbons. We sat in the front at a small table with lounge chairs. I immediately noticed the bottles behind the bar looked pedestrian, which was not comforting. The server did not have a good grasp of the bourbon selection, which is ok, but I might expect more from a bourbon bar. Looking at the bourbon list/menu though was a bit more comforting than looking behind the bar as they had a few on their "allocated list," that I was interested in trying. However, each bourbon my buddy and I ordered was "out." It was very frustrating. Had my buddy's wife not already gotten a glass a wine we might have left. I was quite embarrassed because I had lauded praise upon this place for the bourbon selection which apparently they no longer had. We attempted attempted to order 6-7 bourbons which were all out. It was very disappointing. They had nothing in stock we wanted to try. In the end we ordered a cocktail, which is not why we went there. I'm giving an extra star because the bbq pork nachos from Wolfies were pretty good. If you are heading here to try new and allocated bourbons, you may want to call and see what they have first. We were very disappointed. read more

One of the best bars in the area. Awesome atmosphere, great service, and delicious drinks.

What a great find in Carmel! I was in the area and decided to search for nearby cocktail bars and The Broken Barrel popped up. I previously lived nearby and still was unaware this place existed, so we decided to take a chance! I'm not normally a whiskey drinker, but noticed on their website they had other cocktail offerings. Inside the space was very dim with dark wood and an open concept. I ordered the PB&J old fashioned, which was a great beginners whiskey drink! They did offer food from the restaurant next door, Wolfies. I would definitely return with my husband! read more

See all

I really enjoyed my visit here with a coworker. I truly did not know this gem existed & I'm glad she introduced me to it. I really liked that they had such an extensive menu of cocktail choices as well as whiskey and bourbon options. I chose to start with the classic whiskey sour and it was fantastic! The cocktail was so well balanced, and made very well. I would absolutely order it again next time I stop by. Second I took our waitresses recommendation and tried the Broken Barrel Sazerac and I did not regret that decision. Again, a well balanced cocktail that was full of flavor but did not hide the wonderful smoothness of the rye. We also ordered some pretzel breadsticks with queso from the Wolfies menu to have a snack with our cocktails and they came out crunchy on the outside + soft on the inside - exactly what you hope for. Would happily join anyone for a cocktail at this spot! read more

The Broken Barrel - Carmel - Whiskey Sour - Whiskey Bars Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

I almost hate to give a review to this place because it is my favorite small bourbon bar and I don't want to blow up the spot. The bartenders especially Jenai are great! They engage in fun conversations, give great suggestions and are super attentive. The drink selection is amazing as well as the cocktail list. In addition, they usually have something special brewing like a local barrel old fashioned. I've become slightly hooked on the Peanut butter whiskey I've gotten in the PB&J. The sazarac is one of my favorites though. This is a great place but don't come. Because I love how cozy and quaint of a place it is and I'm sure you'll fall in love and try and take over my favorite place. Just keep this secret gem between me, you and Yelp. read more

The Broken Barrel - Carmel - Whiskey Bars Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

My friend and I decided to get a drink and they suggested this place! Walking in it is a dimly-lit 1940's era feel - there is a lot of exposed brick and barrels. The feel of the place is something that I have not experienced in Carmel but it was definitely an awesome place and you have to check it out! Our waitress, Jené, was very nice and she was very knowledgeable about the menu and the drinks! I ordered the Justy Special which is one of their craft cocktails - it was amazing! My go-to drink is anything with Gin in it! They use Bombay Saphire which is my favorite kind of gin - the drink had hints of botanical elderflower. I will definitely be going back to the Broken Barrel to try their other craft cocktails! read more

See all

We came here after a bite at Osteria on a Thursday night! Bartender was great and showed us a ton of stuff they had. The cocktails were excellent!! I wanted to try them all after having two lol!! This place is pretty cool. Don't let the fact it is in. Wolfies change your plans to go here... Definitely will return soon!! read more

Oh how I love this place! The rustic ambiance with a small little bar at one end and stacked barrels at the other. Delicious whiskey cocktails for any and all whiskey fans. Perfect setting to have a nice conversation and great time with someone. I keep coming back! read more

The Broken Barrel - Carmel - The smoked tobacco old fashioned - Whiskey Bars Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

This place has potential. The bar selection was really good. Lots of excellent whiskeys and bourbons. I for once had a craft cocktail - Manhattan. It was quite tasty. Others in the group had cocktails as well. No complaints. They have a lounge seating area that resembles a cigar bar but no smoking. Very quiet. Down side was the service was very slow and it wasn't very busy. Will come here again. Its worth the go and i expect it will improve. read more

The Broken Barrel - Carmel - Nice selection - Whiskey Bars Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

First time here and immediately loved it. Classic music with dim sexy vibes and whisky to add. Recently here from Hollywood, gave me a nostalgic feel. Whisky sour to the T but needs some work in the old fashion dept. sorry I seek out a good creator of my favorite drink and they did ok. Good first date spot! read more

See all

Sometimes you can find a secret speakeasy in the middle of the suburbs and this is the place. Tucked next to the larger bar next door, is a vintage styled, speakesyesque bar. Loads of options in the heavy bourbons and liquors and quiet and charming. read more

The Broken Barrel - Carmel - Whiskey Bars Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

My favorite place in the city. I'm even hesitant to write a review because I don't want to share. Either way, Jene (bartender) is awesome. The menu is great but she even let's me make up things sometimes. I love the variety of cocktails, especially the PBJ Old fashioned. I have to get that every time! The food is also good. It comes from Wolfies next door. My go tos are the wings and Brussel sprouts. read more

The Broken Barrel - Carmel - PBJ Old Fashioned - Whiskey Bars Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

My friend and I came here for drinks and dinner the other night, and we had so much fun! We sat at the bar, and she was delayed a little bit, so I had a great time talking to the bartenders while I waited for her. They were wonderful! We ordered dinner (which comes from Wolfie's which is attached to the bar) and drinks, and the service was excellent. Shout out to Shay, our bartender! She was sweet and fun. I'll definitely be back! read more

The Broken Barrel - Carmel - Great bartenders! They made me feel comfortable waiting for my friend by myself. We had such a fun time sitting at the bar with them! - Whiskey Bars Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Best cocktail I have had in awhile... coffee old fashioned! Jené was amazing at helping us navigate our way through all the amazing bourbons that they have. My husband was in heaven. P.S. she makes a mean martini!!!!!! read more

The Broken Barrel - Carmel - Coffee old fashioned and the best martini in Indiana! - Whiskey Bars Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

An amazing whiskey bar. Couldn't recommend this place more for anyone who loves whiskey; can even appeal to those who may not. Great cocktails, atmosphere, and service. read more

We decided to stop off for drinks. We are big whiskey drinkers and found this spot. It has plenty of parking in a shared lot. The place inside is very cute with a nice quiet atmosphere. Dim lighting and nice jazz playing, and candles on the table. They have a cocktail list and straight whiskey list as well. We ordered a few cocktails and tried out Sexton whiskey. It's recently priced and we really enjoyed our time here. There was only one person working so the wait for drinks was really long once it started getting busy. This place is a must visit, if you love whiskey. read more

See all

I'm mad i can't remember the bartenders name! But this place is dark and cute .. totally a speakeasy vibe going on here ... drinks were good & my server was quick and charming despite having a handful of people! read more

The Broken Barrel - Carmel - Trying a PB & J Old Fashioned ! - Whiskey Bars Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Nice bartender, decent selection of bourbons, we were there on a very slow night, so not crowded. Not a craft cocktail place, most are pretty standard. Good place for northside. read more

Stopped by here for a friend's birthday gathering and really enjoyed this spot. There is a variety of bourbon infused cocktails on their menu, so if you like bourbon, this is the spot for you. There is a neighboring restaurant which is connected to the bar and you can order small plates. The cauliflower and wings were awesome! read more

Drinks were tasty! We weren't expecting it to be attached to Wolfe's but they are attached and it is owned by the same people. We went on a Saturday and it was pretty empty in there. read more

Stopped in before catching a late weekday movie. There were only two tables occupied so we sat at the bar to discuss some of the whiskey options with the bartender. Plenty of spirits to choose from if you want to try something new and an exhaustive menu and creative bartenders for a twist on your favorite classic. I was introduced to their PB&J Old Fashioned and I am still talking about it weeks later and have even recreated it in my home bar. A 21 year and older establishment attached under the same roof of Wolfie's is a nice change. We need to support these places to encourage growth in the speakeasy styled bar read more

Stopped in here to check the place out. The decor and vibe was good. They had a great selection of whiskeys and bourbons. I got the old fashioned and it was spot on! The service was good. Had some great recommendations for the group. read more

The Broken Barrel - Carmel - Whiskey Bars Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

What a cozy find in Carmel. Our server, Brian, greeted us informing us this was a bourbon bar but then was ready with non bourbon cocktail ideas for the non bourbon drinker. I had a sweet and spicy mule made with Tito's, cherry juice and a touch of pepper. Hubs had the new old fashioned and said the cherries were the best ever. A very intimate place with Frank Sinatra playing and oddly, old westerns on the lone TV screen. Seats perhaps 40. read more

Can definitely see this becoming a regular spot for me! We came here after a comedy show and it was the perfect vibe for what I wanted. Sit, enjoy a cocktail and be able to talk to each other without screaming over music. Also, I didn't catch our waiters name but he was great and we made sure to leave a good tip for him. Super friendly and helpful. I will 100% be back. read more