This place is like one of your favorite pair of blue jeans, they always feel good and make you feel good, no matter what they look like. Staff is super, genuine and nice here, bear is called and the food is good. Not a lot of places to sit in. The tables are sort of weird, but that's OK, it's a recommend. read more

The Brown Baer - Bars Near Me - Elkhart Lake, Wisconsin

Great bar. Excellent service. Good variety. Awesome atmosphere. I recommend the Brown Baer. read more

Fun bar.. we didn't eat but the atmosphere seems like everyone has a great time! Christmas lights were an interesting touch.. my husband said the leather couches were comfortable and an interesting discussion piece.. we would go back! read more

Fun vibes, good dranks, sports on the tv. Download the Ami app to keep those good vibes going

Been coming to this place since it opened many moons ago. We live out of state, so only visit occasionally, but it is the same as ever-- cozy, quirky, and friendly. We had wings, burger and the grinder... all amazing. I love that they don't have a fryer! If I were local, I would be here all the time. Guess we just have to enjoy it every few years when we come to town. read more

The Brown Baer - Current menu - Bars Near Me - Elkhart Lake, Wisconsin

See all

Mostly rating the service provided by, who I think (by the way he acted) was the owner. Just not at all the welcoming vibe I was expecting in a small town WI bar. Dude doesn't make eye contact, smile, or make you feel welcome. Prices are higher than they should be for the place and quality. read more

Unique menu which is only written on the chalkboard behind the bar. We stopped on a weekday for lunch before heading on for more traveling. We sat at the bar and the bartender took our order. We had the schnitzel sandwich and bacon mac. Heard the bacon in the mac was really sweet so it had a different flavor than what you might be used to. Portion with the sandwich was pretty big - lots of greens and pickled onions on top of the pork schnitzel. Little sad it wasn't breaded and fried but still good. The chips had good seasoning on them. Saw the wedge salad and that was equally impressive. I'd be interested to stop by next time I'm in town to see what they'd have on the menu again. read more

See all

Great first impressions. Enjoyed food, drink, service and ambiance. I will return again.

Things are quiet here during the off season, especially on a Sunday night. Thankfully we found this tavern open and serving food. The quality and quantity was amazing. Our bartender M. was very nice and suggested the Cobb salad for my wife. I went with the cold cut grinder sub sandwich. Both were excellent. No fryer so chips were offered . Friendly ,clean bar with a lot of interesting decor. read more

Best salad I've ever had. Very large portions. Neat older atmosphere. Everyone that ordered food in the group liked what they got.

The food was fantastic I had catfish and I like that all the food is prepared with out a deep fryer! Unusual for a bar The bartender was very accommodating and he was funny and helpful It's 45 minutes from our home, but well worth the drive for something different read more

This is a fun, eclectic, little place with amazing food. The only menu is posted on a chalkboard behind the bar and you place your order with the bartender. You won't find standard bar food options here- there is no deep fryer; so don't come looking for fried anything. Select your sandwich (there is something for everyone) and your side (the side options are plentiful) and begin the countdown... My guy had the Pork Loin Sandwich w/a side of Mac&Cheese. Both were fantastic. The pork was seasoned perfectly and had a wonderful sear on it just to the point of caramelization. The flavor could not be beat. The Mac&Cheese was comforting and decadent. I had the cheeseburger w/a side of Brussel Sprouts. The burger, like the pork, was seasoned and cooked perfectly. The sprouts were an ideal pairing. The only thing I wished they had was an option to drizzle a little balsamic reduction- it would have sent it over the top but trust me, they were really good just as prepared. Peggy was working the bar and never stopped moving. If she wasn't with a customer or running food, she was actively cleaning and never slacking off. The patrons and service were her priorities not her friends or her phone. We loved her, the vibe, the decor, and the food- everything about this joint is a good. We'll be back. read more

See all

SERVICE Upon arriving the staff greeted me and I let them know I had called in an order. The lady behind the bar checked in the back and then let me know that I was "Next Up". I called ahead and was told it would take 25 minutes. I showed up 30 minutes after I called. I then waited another 20 minutes by the bar before my food was ready. I don't think they had even started on my order and I wish she would have just told me the truth and let me know how long it would likely take instead of leaving me thinking it'll be out any minute now. MEAL I did my research and went with what most people said was delicious... the pork sandwich and cornbread. Neither was anything to write home about. The pork sandwhich was dry burnt and all I could taste was the char on the outside of the meat. (That said, the tomatoes, onion, and lettuce that went on the sandwich seemed fresh and was crisp.) The cornbread was just okay. Nothing special at all. AMBIANCE This is a bar so don't show up thinking you and your family will enjoy a nice meal at a corner booth. And judging from what I saw cleanliness probably isn't much of a priority. I'd be scared to take a peek back in that kitchen. TIME I called ahead and was told it would be ready in 25 minutes. I arrived and waited at least another 20 minutes. I don't think they had even started on my order. RECOMMENDATION I was so incredibly disappointed by my experience. I was looking forward to eating here all day and my experience came up waaaaay short of the reviews I read. Maybe they just had an off night? Either way, I wouldn't recommend this place to anyone, and I wouldn't even give it another chance. That's sad because I had such high hopes. read more

The Brown Baer - Burnt... - Bars Near Me - Elkhart Lake, Wisconsin

Fantastic place and great food. Nice atmosphere. Ducked in here on a motorsports lunch break and wasn't disappointed.

Best burger in the country. Great service. Great beer menu. Awesome local vibe. Don't miss this spot when in Elkhart Lake WI.

What an interesting little place. The décor is wacky in the best way and the bartenders efficient and funny. No menu you have to order off of the black board behind the bar. I ordered the Teriyaki Chicken and patiently waited a really long time. The toppings and flavor of the sandwich were really good. The sad part is my chicken was so over cooked it was dry and tough. My husband commented that the idea of his sandwich was good and the flavors excellent but his sandwich was also really dry and needed more sauce. I like the idea of their simple menu and I would come back for drinks for sure. read more

The Brown Baer - Spotted cow. - Bars Near Me - Elkhart Lake, Wisconsin

See all

This place is mysteriously confusing. Eclectic for sure. From the swings to the over abundance of different decor, I don't know where to look. All jokes aside, the food is amazing! I had the crab cake sandwich and cornbread and it was so yummy! My husband had a cheeseburger and the cornbread and he enjoyed it! My mother in law ordered the wings, BBQ, and they were oh, so yummy! Very, very close to REAL Buffalo wings and it's not often that as a Buffalo native, I can say that! They don't have a deep fryer (so no French Fries) and everything is made fresh. They have some fun, good and unique food options. read more

See all

We were looking for a place to eat with a group of 4 adults and 5 picky kids. We were so happily surprised to find a fun atmosphere and food that made everyone happy! The burger was everyone's favorite! read more

Was in town for a conference and stopped by in for drinks with a group. Fun atmosphere with great drinks and service.

I was in town for a night and stopped by for a meal and a drink (not many options). Having been there I would choose to go even with more options. It's clearly a local bar. Everyone seems to know each other but that didn't stop me from getting fast and friendly service. The Bulleit old fashion was made well. The menu is written on a chalkboard behind the bar and featured some great looking flavor combinations. I opted for the Buffalo Cauliflower, Wings and Cornbread. The cornbread was as good as advertised. Moist and just a bit sweet. The other food items are all grilled and tasty. The wings were meaty and the dozen I ordered were too much for one person. The side of cauliflower was done just right (a slight bit of crunch) and the uniqueness of the buffalo sauce made it exceptional. Definitely recommend if you are in the area. read more

The Brown Baer - Wings, buffalo Cauliflower, cornbread - Bars Near Me - Elkhart Lake, Wisconsin

The service it's great. We were treated really well by down-to-earth staff who gave off an "everyone knows your name" appeal. The best part is the food. It's a little surreal how bar food can be this good. We had soup, burger, wings, cornbread, and drinks. EVERYTHING was amazing. Must visit! read more

The Brown Baer - Awesome menu on a chalkboard! - Bars Near Me - Elkhart Lake, Wisconsin

Great food, great people, great atmosphere. It's a local joint so you gotta brave a little discomfort at being an outsider sometimes. Love this place, have for five years, it's never let me down read more

Very cool place to have a beer and hang out The staff were a trip and the food was good def worth the it if you're in town read more

Delicious, large chicken wrap. Really good grilled zucchini strips. Awesome homemade chips with the sandwiches. Will definitely go back. Friendly staff. Unique place. read more

We stumbled upon a quaint little bar for a midday meal during a friends wedding getaway. The ambience was just what we were looking for - a warm and inviting pub. The staff compromised only of a bartender and a chef in the kitchen, but they handled the influx of tourists with ease. The drinks were top notch with a great selection of beer, ciders and seltzers on tap. I started with a fantastic, bloody mary that was a meal in itself - garnished with green olives, and a large slice of pickle. The Wisconsin Amber from Capital Brewing was exceptional, and the cornbread was so good that it would make a southern grandma envious. We also tried the fresh and delicious brussels sprouts, catfish -BLT, and chicken salad, which were all top notch. We ended up with more food than we could finish, but everything was at the highest quality. If you're ever in Elkhart Lake, this is the perfect spot for lunch, dinner or an evening of drinks. The experience was beyond excellent! read more

Good zucchini squash strips, had a sweet vinaigrette marinade. Burger was really good, wrap was tasty too. Not a speedy in/ out experience. More of a trendy, eclectic menu. Like everything prices are getting higher. Amazing decor for Halloween. Only a few tv's so not a sports bar. Eclectic seating- a funky booth in one corner and two swing- chairs. read more

I've been here before. My Dad lives in Elkhart Lake so I come to visit and check out local places. I've never eaten there before, but tried to last night. I ordered chicken wings. Waited for about 45 minutes for them. When they came they we're burned. I mean really burned. I can't believe they even brought them out of the kitchen and tried to serve them. Ordered a hamburger as a replacement. Ordered medium. Outside burned, inside raw. I hate 1/4 of it because I was so hungry. They did comp everything including drinks so that's why I'm giving them three stars. read more

Didn't try the food but the bloody Mary's were awesome. Great decorations and good prices.

A True Dive! The unassuming Brown Baer is a must for anyone visiting or passing through Elkhart Lake! Found this place when I was up in Plymouth for business, and I'm so glad I did! The place does not look like much at all from the outside, but the inside is a Diver's paradise! On top of that they have an outstanding beer selection with a wide range of local drafts on tap. The food is out of this world good. I NEVER would have guessed that this unassuming wooden shack could pump out such high quality food! The staff and locals were more than happy to buy us a round, tell us about the town and show us what the town favorites were on the menu...The crab cakes at this place are OUT OF BOUNDS! Chunks of crab, shrimp and scallops are found in this in house creation that I could not get enough of! You have to try this place!!! read more

Holy Cannoli. I wasn't expecting much after seeing on yelp that "all there was here" was a chalkboard of sandwiches and some sides. Man, Brown Baer will teach me to judge a book by its cover. As my sister (Maxine W) said - it is a BAR. There is ONE table. We did not know this and walked in with a party of 7, and the table was occupado. The staff was super helpful and accommodating to us, as we clearly were out of towners. The sandwiches - in one word, are bomb. Maxine's catfish sandwich - shoulda ordered that. I had the crabcake sandwich - which would've been awesome, if there weren't baby shrimp in the "patty." I have an aversion to baby shrimp, they creep.me.the.eff.out. So, if we ever go back to Elkhart Lake, I know for next time. The sides were also very tasty. The corn bread was TO DIE for, and the acorn squash and brussels sprouts were good too. Thank you to the staff at Brown Baer, for not making us feel like we were complete idiots not knowing what we were walking into. They were warm and friendly! read more

The food is THE BEST. Everything is so fresh and they make it right there in their little kitchen. It's not a sit down restaurant, it's a bar, so don't go expecting anything fancy. If your looking for good food, you can find it here. I crave their veggie burger every time I am away and when I can catch the meatloaf/mac and cheese special it is home cooking like i've never been able to do myself. The bar is also very fun, pool, darts, swings, an empty ant farm, and lots of bear decor. You really just can't go wrong. The bands they book are always really fun and somehow every time I'm out i always seem to end up here. read more

I love this place. First of all the staff is incredible. So welcoming and totally on top of customer service. The last time I went I got their signature pork loin sandwich and their cornbread. Both were absolutely incredible. And you can say that out too many bars. Highly recommend stopping in if you are in Elkhart Lake! read more

My favorite place to dine after a late night drive in from Chicago! And the owners are the nicest people ever! Get the cornbread -- it's top notch! Just be willing to sit at the bar if the two dining spaces in the place are taken. read more

We enjoyed The Brown Baer so much we visited twice in our short stay at Elkhart Lake. First off, the wings are amazing! They are grilled to perfection, tender and juicy. I had a turkey burger and grill zucchini, both were very good. My teenage boys both had burgers, husband had a chili dog, and everyone loved the corn bread. I even brought a piece of corn bread home for my sister in law who had tried out The Brown Baer just a few week earlier with her family and gave us the recommendation. Seating is very limited but worth it all the way! read more

Best bar food in the state. Wait, best bar food anywhere. Crab cake sandwich is my go-to meal. Note: shrimp AND crab in there, so if it matters to you, now you know. Get the grilled zucchini for a veg, if available. Desert is cornbread. Sometimes it blueberry cornbread, sometimes maple bacon cornbread, sometimes it it's plain. Rib night Mondays - don't show up and just try to order it. You have to call ahead on Friday at noon. And Brussels sprout salad. And meatloaf. That is all. read more

Great food, killer staff as usual. The band tonight was a little annoying they started almost a hour late & Craig should stick to writing music and not singing it, but the Baer is definitely worth the stop. read more

Being in town for work only , this place was totally new to me. Wasn't expect much butTmy co-worker said the wing is good. So I give it a shot. To my surprised, it was really good. The bone like not even attach to the meal, it was tasty and tender, I have to say it is one of the best wing I have in awhile. read more

This place is a delightful neighborhood pub, not a full service restaurant. If you want a pricey multi course meal with snobbery and high prices, this place is not for you. Rather, if you enjoy good music, conversation, and outstanding pub food, this place is exactly what you want. I had a half pound cheeseburger, veggies, and a side of chipotle Mac and Cheese that was to die for. The service was very friendly and prompt. Their beer selection is also excellent. The pub ambience was great, seating comfortable, and patrons interesting. So, if you want to escape the high prices and fake atmosphere found in local eateries, make sure to visit this place. Keep it casual, keep it real, and enjoy! read more

As earlier reviewers have mentioned, this is mostly a bar with only one or two tables available. As long as you're prepared for that going in, all is well. We sat at the bar. The beer was good and poured well. I had the pork loin sandwich and a side of cornbread, both of which were very good. My husband had a bacon cheeseburger which he thoroughly enjoyed. He chose a side of potato chips which we both assumed would be house made; we should have asked because they were just standard store bought potato chips. He also had a cup of the broccoli cheddar soup that he loved. We would definitely eat here again if we're back in the area. read more

The food quality and thoughtfulness has gone from great to completely subpar. Pretty sure most of their menu comes from the Costco deli and bakery. Bartenders spend a lot of time with their back to you and if it's even a little busy you'll stand by the bar for ages before someone comes to take your order. read more