I LOVE this place! It is one of the best cake places I have ever been too. The cupcakes are amazing and the cakes are UNBELIEVABLE!!! I am in awe when I go in and see the cakes that are being made. I am in awe every time I go. The staff is super friendly and make you feel like family when you come in. If you don't know what you want, they are really good at helping you make a selection. The decor is cute and the facilities are so clean. So if you ever find yourself hankering for a sweet treat, DEFINITELY go to The Cakehole and shove one in your mouth!! read more

If you plan on having a wedding cake, you MUST have The Cakehole as your baker. Creamy, moist cake with icing that is blended so fine that I can guarantee your guests will rave. Every cake is handmade using only the best ingredients. You won't find any commercial ingredients in them! Every single of our 100 guests asked who did the cake. Compliments ranged from "it was the bomb," to "why didn't I eat another slice," to "I don't even like cake and I want more!" We cannot recommended Jovanna and her crew of bakers more highly. She was a dream to work with, professional, and able to manage our pandemic wedding date change without any issues. When our florist forgot about our flower order, she hit social media, asking her contacts if anyone could save the day. She is definitely my baker of choice for celebrations. Hire The Cakehole, you won't regret it. read more

The Cakehole - Our wedding cake! - Cupcakes Near Me - New Palestine, Indiana

Delicious and reasonably priced! We got a 2 tier cake for our little girl's first birthday party and The Cakehole did a fantastic job! It was beautiful AND so tasty and moist. I will definitely go back for any sweet treats that we need made. Everyone loved the cake. read more

The Cakehole - a blue and red cake with an apple on top - Cupcakes Near Me - New Palestine, Indiana

Their cupcakes are to die for. I bought 24 cupcakes for my sister's Harry Potter themed babyshower and everyone loved them! We had a put the order in only a few days before but they were ready right on time. Ordering was easy. Their hours of operation are tricky as they are only opened during a few days of the week until 3pm but they are friendly and professional. The store is clean and nice. read more

Absolutely amazing experience with The Cakehole. I had been searching all around for a bakery in the Indianapolis area to make my son's Wednesday Addams themed birthday cake. It's become a family tradition to have over-the-top birthday cakes, but I was striking out everywhere for weeks as it's May and therefore wedding season has begun. I wanted black buttercream frosting with minimal food coloring icing a red velvet cake, which means using black cocoa in it. Desperate, I posted to a Facebook group for suggestions, and the owner was tagged in the comments. I sent her a message and she worked some kind of magic to get me squeezed in last minute. The price was reasonable for what I was asking for, and I was happy to drive out to New Pal to pick it up. Not only was the order completed on time, but it is GORGEOUS, and it is exactly what my 8 year old had envisioned as he was describing what he wanted. I swear to you, I will make the drive every year for another one of her masterpieces and for her amazing and timely service. I'll just call her FIRST from now on. Thank you for making a little boy's cake dreams come true. read more

The Cakehole - Wednesday Addams themed birthday cake - Cupcakes Near Me - New Palestine, Indiana

I put my order in less than a week ahead and though it was not preferred, she was able to work it in. The cake was beautiful, exactly what I needed to fit our theme and even more, it was delicious! I ordered the turtle flavor and it is up there with the best I've ever had. You can tell she is a true artist and enjoys her work! Thank you so so much! I already have another order scheduled for August! read more

The Cakehole - Fishing-themed Birthday Cake - Cupcakes Near Me - New Palestine, Indiana

We ordered cupcakes for my sons birthday party and it was delicious! Super nice and easy to work with. Highly recommend!

I LOVE this place! It is one of the best cake places I have ever been too. The cupcakes are amazing and the cakes are UNBELIEVABLE!!! I am in awe when I go in and see the cakes that are being made. I am in awe every time I go. The staff is super friendly and make you feel like family when you come in. If you don't know what you want, they are really good at helping you make a selection. The decor is cute and the facilities are so clean. So if you ever find yourself hankering for a sweet treat, DEFINITELY go to The Cakehole and shove one in your mouth! read more

If you've ever wanted a unique cake in Indiana, this is the place to go. She designs all sorts of things and the more over the top the more I think she likes to create it! I recently had the S'mores cupcake and the Berry Lemonade Cupcake and couldn't stop there! The Oreo is awesome and a favorite seems to be the Black Bottom cupcake. Now a store front in New Palestine! Check out the website: http://thecakehole.net/ Mmm, good. read more

The Cakehole - This is the place to go for adorable and tasty cakes! - Cupcakes Near Me - New Palestine, Indiana

See all

Great cakes and cupcakes tastes as good as they look. Made with personal touch in New Pal

The Cakehole is an excellent cake shop if you need a cute cake or cupcake. My family has had the Cakehole's cupcakes catered to many events. The Cakehole's catering service is great for big events like anniversaries, graduations, and weddings. Everytime we have an event people always comment on the cupcakes from the Cakehole. Their custom cakes are spectacular because of their attention to detail. The cakes are always moist and a perfect sponge texture. Their frosting is creamy and delicious. Inside the business is airy and clean. The cakes are a very reasonable price for their intricate designs. Overall the Cakehole is an excellent place to buy tasty cakes, cupcakes, and cookies. -KB read more

Really good cupcakes. We have been here several times, and we just order what's available -- we have never placed an order for pickup. Anyhow, they cake is always a nice density, which seems to maintain moisture because I have never had a dry cupcake from here. I also really like their icing. The variety of flavors are nice, and the flavors really are spotlighted. I wish the hours we more friendly, but that is what it is. If you're in New Pal during their business, you should stop by for a cupcake or two ... or six. read more

It's rare to have a business owner that is so aware in the personal impact that their business has on people. Especially in a cake business. We've had multiple cakes from Jovanna over the years and she's taken such an interest in doing it right for us and our celebration. It's like she's making the cake we would make for ourselves if we knew how! Definitely recommend this for anyone looking to go above and beyond for a party or event. read more

The Pink Floyd birthday cake made for my husband was awesome. The details were on point and the chocolate peanut butter cake was so yummy!! I am excited to have found this bakery. Super talented!! read more

I want to preface this review with the fact that I had followed The Cakehole's facebook page two years before my wedding date. So I had already been a long time fan before I even booked with them! I wanted to have a long engagement to be able to pay for everything I wanted in a wedding so I had ample time to look at all of the amazing designs Jovanna and her mother have done the past several years and I am just absolutely blown away by how much talent spills over in that bakery of theirs. I think you can honestly go into their bakery with any cake or dessert idea you can think of and they will be able to create your vision into reality with no issues! I strongly advise visiting their facebook page to see all of the things they have created, you will not be disappointed. When my fiance and I came to the bakery for our tasting, we were greeted very warmly and all of our questions were answered promptly. I am actually not a very big fan of cake so whatever our flavors were I knew I wouldn't "like" but I still wanted to give our guests yummy flavors to choose from. I say this with 100% honesty, The Cakehole is the only place to ever have cake I actually liked! Their All Berry Lemonade cake is out of this world and was a huge hit with our guests as well as myself! And to top it all off, if you book with The Cakehole, you can contact the bakery a month before your one year anniversary and they will make you a replica mini cake of your wedding cake to eat on your first anniversary date for free! You can't beat that over eating year old cake in the freezer! I absolutely can't wait to be able to have our one year cake since I know it will look beautiful and taste amazing! My husband and I are now lifetime customers with The Cakehole because I know with future parties, baby showers, weddings, and anything else we need desserts for; we will always be contacting The Cakehole and you should too!! read more

The Cakehole - a three tiered cake on a table - Cupcakes Near Me - New Palestine, Indiana

Jovanna was amazing! Her cake tasted way better than any other bakers we tried. Our wedding cake was both delicious and beautiful. She was so easy to work with and gave us exactly what we asked for. I'm already planning when I can go to her bakery and get some cupcakes! read more

I was really excited when this place opened! The hours made it impossible for me to get a cupcake from here. When I finally found a day where I could go, I was disappointed. My expectations were very high and the cupcakes just didn't quite meet them. The cupcakes were very dense and had too much really sweet icing on them. It's not the worst cupcakes I've ever had, but I'm more impressed by the Marsh Bakery. Also my friend got a cake pop from here and threw up. read more

The owner does a fantastic job with cake commissions. Not only is she ready to adapt to unusual requests she is great at doing the research to make the end result extremely high quality read more

Jovanna from The Cakehole provided desserts for my wedding in May 2015. Our cake was absolutely stunning and tasted delicious - we could not have been more pleased! We also got cookies and mini cupcakes from her, which were also fantastic and very reasonably priced. Jovanna was very friendly and helpful when we met several months before the wedding, and was easy to communicate with through email. My family also used her for my shower several months back in December - another great experience. If I have future events that need bakery services Jovanna will definitely be my first choice! I highly recommend her and The Cakehole!! read more