Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    The Caledonian

    4.0 (52 reviews)
    Closed 8:00 am - 2:00 pm, 4:00 PM - 10:00 PM
    Updated over 3 months ago

    The Caledonian Photos

    THE CALEDONIAN ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Upscale
    Happy hour specials
    Outdoor seating
    Dogs allowed

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - The Caledonian

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Guo Z.

    We had both dinner and breakfast at this place. The food is very good so did the service. We had the best ever pancake, I never expect a pancake can be this good.

    Burger
    Javi L.

    The Caledonian was an awesome spot to grab a bite! The burger was incredibly juicy, flavorful, and cooked to perfection--every bite was delicious. The chicken wings were just as impressive, perfectly cooked with a great balance of crispiness and flavor. Combined with the welcoming atmosphere and great service, it made for an excellent dining experience. Great mimosas as well, If you're looking for a place that serves outstanding pub food, The Caledonian is definitely worth checking out. I'll definitely be back!

    Oysters
    Lucia L.

    I was lucky enough to be staying in the newly opened Kimpton, and even luckier to snag a walk-in dinner on a busy Friday night! Despite being newly opened as well, this spot is already bustling - with a 45 minute to 1 hour wait for walk-in's like me. We ended up ordering some cocktails at the bar and sitting outside in the courtyard, where there's plenty of couches, tables and fire pits to wait by. The Caledonian offers a menu of elevated, American cuisine crafted from fresh, local ingredients by a bustling open-concept kitchen where you can watch the chefs (if you're lucky to get a table nearby). My favorite items were the whole fish branzino (although I wish they took out all the bones), the Hokkaido scallops, and their sticky toffee pudding (which we literally came back the next night for). Every dish was well-thought out and cooked to culinary precision, with the exception of the yellowtail crudo, which arrived warm and not very fresh. Overall, I was very impressed with this beautiful, new spot, and I highly recommend stopping by if you're looking to celebrate a special occasion or have a memorable date!

    Eggs Mirador Benedict and breakfast essentials
    M W.

    Our server was quick to greet us and super friendly. Both our eggs benedict and breakfast essentials were great!

    Mirador martini service and carmelized onion dip
    April L.

    Visited shortly after they opened with a couple of friends for happy hour. The food and drinks were yummy! Service was a bit wonky but that's to be expected for a new place. Music was overly loud for the setting but I appreciate the live music. Perhaps a different location or set up for the band would work better. I'll give it a little more time and will be excited to return and see how things have evolved! Love that we have this new classy spot in town.

    Daily Oyster
    Denise S.

    We loved this new restaurant, the ambiance felt like you were on vacation ( we are locals) very attentive service and amazing food !

    Bar
    Jonathan M.

    The Caledonian at Mirador is aiming squarely at the top of the local market--and in some ways it gets there--but a few early warning signs keep it from sticking the landing. We visited during happy hour and sat at a table in the bar area. The room was comfortably humming: good energy, attractive space, the kind of ambiance that makes you want to settle in for a drink. That part works. The problem is execution. They've only been open a few weeks, and it shows in the service. Server orchestration felt clumsy--not disastrous, but not dialed. The kind of thing you forgive early on, but only briefly. The oysters were fresh and well-shucked, clean and cold--but oddly missing a spoon for the mignonette. A small detail, yet at this price point it matters. The Hokkaido scallops were genuinely good: fresh, nicely handled, finished with a bright citrus oil that respected the product rather than burying it. That dish suggested the kitchen can do things right. Then there was the baked pretzel. At $21, it was a stale, undersized abomination--clearly old, paired with a cheese sauce that was just as bad. It didn't feel like a miss so much as a red flag. Sysco-adjacent execution at a luxury price is not a great look, and it raises questions about consistency elsewhere on the menu. Cocktails, however, are a strength. The bar is above average for the area, and I'd happily return just for drinks. The Vesper martini was solid and confident--exactly what you want in this setting. The tension here is value. The Caledonian is priced to be top-of-market, but for the same money you can eat better locally--just without the ambiance. If they tighten service and fix the basics, this could become a reliable coastal bar-and-bites destination. Until then, it's a place I'd recommend for cocktails and atmosphere, with caution around the food. Strong room. Good energy. Drinks worth ordering. But at these prices, the pretzel shouldn't be a warning label. I'll head back for dinner and give it another go and another review.

    High prices, lousy service.
    G R.

    I eagerly watched the Kimpton Hotel be built near a church I attend. A welcome boost to downtown PG. My dad and I went for Sunday brunch and a gracious hostess sat us. The place was busy and having worked in Carmel restaurants growing up I know how hard the work is. Five minutes went by. Then ten. No coffee. No "I'll be right with you" from a server. At fifteen minutes we walked out and went to the Victorian Corner a block away for a tasty brunch well served. The website states "At The Caledonian locals and guests alike gather in our convivial dining room." This one local won't be back. PG has many other options with more reasonable prices and better service.

    Stephen H.

    We stopped by The Caledonian during the farmers market with our pup, and it ended up being such a wonderful experience. From the moment we arrived, the staff was incredibly kind and welcoming--not just to us, but to our dog as well. They even brought out water for our pup, which was such a thoughtful touch and really set the tone. A special thank you to Jackie, who checked in on us throughout our visit and took the time to answer all of our questions with genuine warmth. We also had the pleasure of meeting Chef Kyle, who came out to explain the food--such a kind gesture that made the experience feel even more personal. Between the hospitality and the care they put into everything, it truly stood out. We'll definitely be back!

    Crab dip and rosemary focaccia bread
    Pravina K.

    This place was amazing! Food was great and their service was even better! Everyone is so nice here. I would definitely recommend and will return when I come back to Monterey.

    Drinks

    Excellent service from Rigo. Very friendly and polite when explaining the dishes. Delicious drinks and the food was 100% . Atmosphere was great and the place looks very well kept.

    Roasted Chicken
    Merina V.

    We recently visited and overall had an enjoyable experience. The chicken was good, the salmon was well prepared, and the chips and dip were a great start to the meal. The wine selection was lovely, and the ambiance is beautiful. The sticky toffee pudding was the standout of the night and absolutely worth ordering. The reason for the 3 stars comes down to how an issue with one entrée was handled. One person in our party ordered the pork chop, and when it arrived, it was noticeably pink in the center. We brought it to the server's attention, and he acknowledged that he could see what we were referring to and offered to have it remade. However, by that point, the guest had lost their appetite and was understandably concerned about the dish being undercooked, so it was taken back. What was disappointing was what happened afterward. When the check arrived, the pork chop was still fully included. We were told it would not be removed because the chef believed it was cooked properly. This led to an uncomfortable back-and-forth discussion with the sever. From our perspective, we were worried about the possibility of getting sick from undercooked pork, while at the same time having to debate whether it should be taken off the bill. While half the charge was eventually removed, it felt inappropriate given that the dish was taken away and the concern had been acknowledged. Additionally, the steak we ordered was good quality, though for a $50+ entrée, the amount of sauce felt excessive almost like a dressed-up A1. At that price point, the steak should stand on its own. This is a newer restaurant, and we truly hope they continue refining both their food execution and how situations like this are handled.

    Broccoli

    Amazing! The food was incredible, the staff was so nice. Everything was so delicious! Can't wait to go back!

    Hostess area

    See all

    5 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Ron D.
    0
    96
    1

    6 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 1

    5 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Wendy B.
    0
    130
    355

    7 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 1

    6 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 months ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 2

    7 months ago

    Lovely ambience, warm and professional service from Connor, truly memorable cuisine. highly recommend.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    4 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - The Caledonian

    You might also consider

    Vivolo's Chowder House - Halibut fish and chips (house special)

    Vivolo's Chowder House

    4.0(2.4k reviews)
    0.7 mi
    $$

    Their clam chowder is good--rich, smoky, and loaded with actual clam meat rather than being packed…read moreout with cheap potato filler like so many other places. The calamari is also good, featuring a light, crispy breading but was not greasy. Instead of a mix of body and tentacles, they serve large, tender chunks of squid cut into clean squares, making it so approachable that even picky eaters with a limited palate won't be turned off by it. Service was attentive with water getting filled at the right moments. Would be back to try their other items.

    Had a wonderful lunch here last Sat and truly enjoyed our meal. We arrived a little after they…read moreopened and their friendly staff greeted and seated us right away and brought us water. Decor is modern and bright and they had plenty of staff to help. Items ordered- Clam chowder x2 - Not your traditional creamy clam chowder but it worked and was delicious. Kids chicken tenders- Fresh battered chunks of chicken and fries Kids fish & chips- fresh and perfectly seasoned and battered. Cioppino- Generous portion of protein in a light and flavorful broth. This came with a side of squash, swiss chard, and rice. The rice was just a tad under but still edible. Linguini calamari & clams- Plenty of fresh seafood in a light lemon sauce. Well done!! Loved this dish!!! Iced tea x2- As expected Truly enjoyed this gem and their fresh food!!

    Photos
    Vivolo's Chowder House
    Vivolo's Chowder House - Steamed clams

    Steamed clams

    Vivolo's Chowder House - If it's called a chowder house, they should have much better clam chowder!

    See all

    If it's called a chowder house, they should have much better clam chowder!

    Passionfish

    Passionfish

    4.3(2.6k reviews)
    0.3 mi
    $$$
    27 years in business
    Locally sourced ingredients

    Fresh, delicious food, and wonderful service!…read more We came to Monterey for a quick getaway vacation and we had a wonderful dinner at Passionfish. Located in Pacific Grove, this restaurant is well known for its sustainable seafood and fresh ingredients. Street parking is available but you may need to drive around to get a spot close to the restaurant. We made a reservation online, and we were notified our table was ready 15 mins prior to our reservation time. When we arrived, we were greeted warmly by the hostess. The restaurant was mid sized, but it felt warm and cozy. The menu was quite simple, but the selections were solid. We had the salmon cervice as appetizer, salad, scallop entree, and halibut entree. The cervice was delicious and we loved the innovative concept. The salad was great with perfect balance of veggie, dressing, and cheese. The scallop entree was very flavorful as well. For desserts, we gad the banana pudding with ice-cream, and it was the perfect way to wrap up our dinner. As for service, our waiters were attentive and friendly. The bill for our meal was around $200, which was very reasonable for the quality of the meal. Highly recommend!

    This was our first time going to Passionfish! And it did not disappoint us! The crowd was super…read morenice. We ended up talking to a few people which made it nice. The food was excellent. We had the bread rolls which are absolutely to die for! We had the jicama salad and the halibut. We shared this between two adults, and it was more than enough. And their wine selection is incredible! We will definitely be returning!

    Photos
    Passionfish
    Passionfish
    Passionfish

    See all

    Sea Harvest

    Sea Harvest

    4.0(2.6k reviews)
    1.0 mi
    $$

    Sea Harvest is a fish market / small restaurant. There's indoor and outdoor dining. It is…read moredog-friendly for outdoor usage only. They have a nice fresh seafood menu. I opted for their fish and chips. It was juicy and lightly breaded. I was very pleased with my lunch. My husband wasn't too hungry and he ordered their clam chowder. It had a lot of clams and potatoes. It was flavorful and rich... very good. The ambience is casual, nothing fancy. It is a great pit stop for a quick meal.

    Having been to this place several times, I'm sorry I didn't write a review previously. This is a…read morefamily favorite, their fish and chips are always reliable, with better than average fries complimenting the better than average fried fish. On our last visit, we decided to try something other than our go to (the aforementioned fish and chips) and tried their grilled rockfish dinner. It was a great choice! Nicely cooked through without being dry, it had a nice flavor that reflects the freshness of the fish. We also did their Baja fish tacos. We all agreed it was one of the messiest, tastiest fish tacos we'd had in awhile. Generous piece of rockfish, with a sauce that compliments, not overwhelms the fish. Unfortunately my sons aren't fans of raw fish (I should do one of those genetic tests to see if they're really my offspring, but I digress), I nonetheless will find an occasion to try their seared ahi tuna which I'll have on the rare side. They can enjoy something else, so there. Still, if it's a first time visit, it's hard to go wrong with their fish and chips. Enjoy!

    Photos
    Sea Harvest - Interior

    Interior

    Sea Harvest - Combination plate w/ shrimp, fish, and calamari

    Combination plate w/ shrimp, fish, and calamari

    Sea Harvest - Calamari and chips...my favorite!

    See all

    Calamari and chips...my favorite!

    Wild Fish - Petrole Sole - not appealing looking

    Wild Fish

    4.2(842 reviews)
    0.1 mi
    $$$

    This place cooks up local fish - like their market plate! Pretty chill for Sunday lunch. Cute…read moreplace on a cute street in Monterey. The Popovers were also quite special - we were the first when they just opened for lunch so it was super fresh and warm! Perfect. Not too greasy but light and airy. My hb got the tuna melt which he liked, noted that it's very cheesy but at the same time, not too heavy! Of course, got the Wild Fish Plate, which was petrale sole, but it was fried, which wasn't specified... I couldn't eat it so the chef renade me a version that was more steamed. Bonus points for that. And it was cooked perfectly. Absolutely delicious!!

    Wild Fish is a very cute restaurant in downtown Pacific Grove serving up a delicious assortment of…read morefresh seafood. We popped in for lunch and shared some appetizers and a sandwich, and everything tasted fresh and scratchmade. Our server was very friendly and attentive throughout. We started with the calamari, which came out piping hot from the fryer, and I absolutely loved the crunch of the tempura fry. It paired perfectly with a couple lemon wedges and a chili-lime aioli. We also ordered a bowl of the soup of the day, which was a seafood broth loaded with steamer clams and sablefish. They mentioned the use of coconut milk, so I had assumed the broth would be creamier, but it came out very thin and sour, almost like a Thai Tom Yum Goong. While the seafood was delicious, the broth was not our favorite since it felt a bit one dimensional and really needed some cream, cracked pepper and fresh herbs to balance the flavor profile out. For our main we ordered the spicy fried fish sandwich with a side salad. The fry on the fish was again perfect, and the texture was super flaky, but I found it to be a bit underseasoned and lacking spice entirely, which was disappointing given the name. While all of the veggies on the plate were super fresh, the side salad was very underwhelming since the dressing tasted purely of oil, so it felt like I was eating undressed spinach with a handful of cherry tomatoes. Overall, it is a great spot to have a pleasant meal, especially with the nice front patio for enjoying your food when the weather is nice, and the seafood in general is super fresh.

    Photos
    Wild Fish - Inside seating

    Inside seating

    Wild Fish - Popovers

    Popovers

    Wild Fish - Bar area

    See all

    Bar area

    Fishwife - Calamari strips, breaded upon order (Without tentacles) Served with our Caribbean tartar sauce.

    Fishwife

    3.8(1.3k reviews)
    1.2 mi
    $$
    Locally owned & operated
    Locally sourced ingredients

    This restaurant is placed at a great location -- can eat then beach, and vice versa. We tried their…read moreAlfredo combo, Marinara with grilled chicken, and pesto pasta. I will say I enjoyed the pasta noodles here. It's a little thicker than spaghetti, and it had a sort of bouncy texture, if that makes sense. We also tried their fish and chips combo. I wish it came with more fries. We also tried their Fried Oysters on their seasonal menu. I was a little disappointed that it only came with three oysters. We had a party of 5, so I wished they had mentioned that when we ordered. Everyone was very nice here. Service was prompt. It is a bit pricey so be prepared for that. They also only have street parking. They have two single stall bathrooms. The one I went in had an issue with their soap dispenser. Overall I would come again. I love that it's so close to the beach!

    I really wanted to give Fishwife 5 stars because there was so much to love. The ambiance was great,…read morethe food was delicious, and the portions were perfect. Every staff member we interacted with was smiling, welcoming, and genuinely kind. The customer service throughout our meal was excellent. The only reason I'm giving 2 stars is because of how my drink exchange was handled. I ordered the Razz Tini, took one sip, and it wasn't what I expected. To me, it tasted like cough syrup. I politely asked if I could exchange my $18 cocktail for something else and was initially told I would still be charged because it was the restaurant's policy. A manager then stepped in and graciously agreed to exchange the drink without charging me, which I appreciated. What left a bad impression was the explanation that customers "order at their own risk." While both gentlemen were pleasant and respectful, that statement didn't sit well with me. It reminded me of signs at the beach saying you swim at your own risk. If this is truly the restaurant's policy, I suggest adding it to the menu, perhaps near the notice about the 3% credit card processing fee, so guests know before ordering. The food, atmosphere, and service were all deserving of 5 stars. A more customer-friendly approach to drink exchanges and clearer communication of the policy would have made this a perfect experience.

    Photos
    Fishwife - Bloody Mary

    Bloody Mary

    Fishwife - Lamp Chops

    Lamp Chops

    Fishwife - Fishwife's Mule

    See all

    Fishwife's Mule

    The Spotted Duck - Berries, chocolate and whipped cream

    The Spotted Duck

    4.7(177 reviews)
    0.1 mi
    $$$

    The Spotted Duck is a small restaurant with the dining area on the main floor, with a cozy bar…read morearea, a few tables as well as the kitchen upstairs. Upon entry, we were heartily greeted by the owner and staff. There were only a couple tables left on the main floor as there was a large party of fifteen people seated in most of the main dining area. It was extremely loud with voices reverberating because of the gregarious group. The owner invited us upstairs to see if a high-bar table would be suitable. The table was quite small even though it overlooked the entire first level, so we declined as another table by the front windows had become available. The Charcuterie + Cheese board was a wonderful start to the evening. It consisted of prosciutto di parma, sopressata, duck prosciutto, bella vitano, triple cream brie, chèvre, almonds, and fig jam served with sliced grilled sourdough. Delish. We enjoyed their Sauteed Rock Cod entrée which consisted of pan-fried cod served with potato puree, artichokes + capers in a Meyer lemon brown butter sauce. The portion was of moderate size, and the dish was excellently prepared and plated. In addition, we had the Drunken Skillet Seared Octopus, which was a nice portion of octopus in a preserved black-bean honey sauce, along with Chef Jerry's seasoning. I recommend this starter as an appetizer or as a main entrée for a light appetite. All was quite delicious. This is an intimate venue for wonderfully prepared meal. The atmosphere of the restaurant is a little lacking which could account for the bad acoustic issue. The service is outstanding as the staff was attentive and watchful without interrupting the customer's dining experience. A serious negative would be that the restrooms are not located on the main dining level, and could pose a problem for patrons who need assistance. Food 4.9 Atmosphere 3.7 Service 4.9

    Very nice meal. Nothing bad to say. Wine as great, food was good, service was good. If I had to…read morechange one thing it would be the lighting, it was very bright in here for dinner, felt like a lunch spot. We ordered the duck confit fries and the octopus, both were very nice. For entrées we shared the scallops and the braised lamb shoulder. Both were cooked perfectly. The best thing I ate here were the Brussels sprouts as a side and it was perfect. I don't know if I'd come back, but I had a nice time and the service was speedy.

    Photos
    The Spotted Duck - Upstairs area

    Upstairs area

    The Spotted Duck - Duck Liver Pate

    Duck Liver Pate

    The Spotted Duck - Saké |$12

    See all

    Saké |$12

    Beach House Restaurant + Bar @ Lovers Point - Roasted Airline Chicken Breast

    Beach House Restaurant + Bar @ Lovers Point

    3.7(1.1k reviews)
    0.3 mi
    $$$

    First time eating here and all 4 were f us really enjoyed our meals. I ordered the ranch steak…read moresubstituted fries with mashed potatoes. All 4 of us voted my plate was the best. We would definitely come back. Also, I highly recommend trying the fire cracker shrimp appetizer. Nice view! My only suggestion is the waitress could have been more attentive but it was pretty busy so I wouldn't mark the rating down for that. She was nice and smiled just could be a little more attentive is all.

    We went here because it was convenient, right next to the beach and Stillwell Pool…read more They have a kids menu with a bunch of options. My daughter had the marinara pasta with Parmesan and she loved it, finished every bite. It's a good portion too, and it was only $9! In fact, she liked it so much we had to come back our second night so she could have it again. To me, the highlight was the warm bread. It's served with softened butter, and coming in from the chilly outdoors to it was heavenly. I also had their Beach House salad--the candied pecans and the tangy sweet vinaigrette were very good. The second night I tried their Filet Mignon Beef Stroganoff, and it was way too rich for me. I barely ate many and it unsettled my stomach. Should have just stuck with the salad again! Service inconsistent. First night our server was an older woman with a ponytail, didn't see her name. She was super unfriendly. Felt like we were inconveniencing her every time I asked her something. Second night our server was a Latino man, and he was fantastic. So friendly and helpful.

    Photos
    Beach House Restaurant + Bar @ Lovers Point - Fire & Ice Wedge: 
wedge of iceberg lettuce, applewood smoked bacon, grape tomatoes, bleu cheese dressing, FireCracker shrimp

    Fire & Ice Wedge: wedge of iceberg lettuce, applewood smoked bacon, grape tomatoes, bleu cheese dressing, FireCracker shrimp

    Beach House Restaurant + Bar @ Lovers Point - Filet Mignon Beef Stroganoff

    Filet Mignon Beef Stroganoff

    Beach House Restaurant + Bar @ Lovers Point - Roasted Airline Chicken Breast

    See all

    Roasted Airline Chicken Breast

    The Caledonian - seafood - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...