Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    The Cookie Jar 716

    5.0 (3 reviews)
    Closed 11:00 am - 8:00 pm

    Order The Cookie Jar 716 Takeout or Delivery

    The Cookie Jar 716 Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    More like The Cookie Jar 716

    Recommended Reviews - The Cookie Jar 716

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Soul Food 1,001 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Heaven's Countertop

    Heaven's Countertop

    4.4(27 reviews)
    3.1 miNorth Buffalo, Hertel Avenue, Parkside

    A warm and soulful restaurant. Once we entered it truly felt like we were with family. Our…read morewaitress, Milan was so friendly and made great suggestions about what to order. I ordered the Jamaican tea drink-so dressing and the Kingsley Street Fried Chicken dinner. The chicken was perfectly fried to perfection, the macaroni and cheese was cheesey, the yams were definitely what it means to be candied and the cornbread was warm with enough sweetness without being too sweet. I really enjoyed the ambience and hospitality here. I cannot convey how delicious this food is!!! This is in my top three restaurants to eat at now.

    Soul food has arrived to North Buffalo in a big way! Get the word out because I need them to stay!…read moreRestaurant is in the heart of North Buffalo, located on Hertel about two blocks from Parkside. Cute vibe inside. They do have a bar setup, but didn't appear it's used for alcohol. I was greeted as soon as I opened the door and was walking through. Being my first time, I did order a few didn't dishes, sides and desserts to try. There was NOT a bad dish. All the food was amazing. Great portions, tasty flavors and everything truly was cooked to perfection. I have given up talking about prices because let's be honest where can you go for cheap anymore. BUT I have to mention I got the Kinsley street fried chicken dinner, it comes with four prices chicken (half chicken, breast,leg,wing,and thigh) and two sides for 22.99, I felt this was actually a great price point and so worth it. Our next dish was the JP fish sandwhich and fries, again, the sandwhich was huge, the fish was seasoned and cooked to perfection! Fries were yummy. Next up was the TPs hot honey chicken sandwhich. Now I am over the hot honey chicken sandwhich as it's been done to death, but I still always feel the need to try eveyones hahaha, and glad I did another grand slam sandwhich! For the sides, I tried the Mac and cheese, pinto beans, collard greens and coleslaw. If you follow my reviews I am a Mac and cheese snob, don't think I order many that I liked, well thank you Heavens because the Mac and cheese was DELICIOUS!!! The Coleslaw was also top notch. I don't eat collard greens or pinto beans but my family told me they were good. They did not have desserts on the menu but I seen some on the counter, sooooo I order a slice of caramel cake, slice of sour cream cake and peach cobbler. Fat kid heaven they all were so good. Literally the best caramel cake since my mother in law! I felt like I just ate at my husband's family reunion. I had to go in and order, then I left ran to dash and came back in about 25 mins and my food was ready when I got back. So service was pretty fast. My only thing wish you could order on line first, parking is not the best in that area. Also Google has address as 1641 Hertel but it actually is 1633, not a big deal because same area but just a heads up.

    Photos
    Heaven's Countertop - Sitting area

    Sitting area

    Heaven's Countertop
    Heaven's Countertop - Collard greens

    See all

    Collard greens

    The Fire Spot Restaurant

    The Fire Spot Restaurant

    3.9(13 reviews)
    2.5 mi

    I really hate to leave a 1 star review, but I must be honest. I was so disappointed by this place…read more I had high hopes after seeing other reviews, but it just did not live up to the hype. I did takeout so not sure of the setup inside. I got a couple things to try, fingers with fries, and a steak hoagie. The hoagie was so dry. I mean the most driest hoagie I have ever had. It's not like it was super cheap, comparable to other places I guess. It was just not good. I asked for sauce on my fingers and got plain without anything to even dip them in. I would have been on if sauce was on the side, but nope nothing. Maybe when I went it was just and off day for them which I understand happens, but that was enough for me not to go back.

    We were warmly welcomed when we walked in! The dining area has several tables and a few booths. It…read morewas bright and cheery. The whole place was decorated for Christmas with table decor and a tree. The food we ordered took a little while to prepare although there were only patrons at one other table, there was a steady take out business going on. My dining partner and I both ordered a rib dinner with hot sides: mac n cheese, greens, yams, hush puppies. The ribs had a sweet BBQ sauce, no heat to the taste and they were just warm, the greens were not super well seasoned and they also were not served hot. I had to add salt and hot sauce and asked if they could be heated up. The owner obliged and brought them back piping hot. The mac n cheese was very cheesy, however it lacked the depth of adding several types of, or at least a sharp cheese to it. The yams had a sweet seasoning with hints of ginger, cinnamon and nutmeg... We also ordered the fried chicken skins which came out freshly coated in a crunchy batter and fried crisp, they were served with hot sauce and Bleu cheese dressing. Very crunchalicious! The banana pudding was also very good... it was amped up with several types of cookie chunks, a cookie crust and cheesecake banana pudding...

    Photos
    The Fire Spot Restaurant  - Interior

    Interior

    The Fire Spot Restaurant  - Perfect bite

    Perfect bite

    The Fire Spot Restaurant

    See all

    Jackson's Soul Food

    Jackson's Soul Food

    2.0(3 reviews)
    3.1 miEastside

    I placed an already paid Too Good To Go order at 5:32 PM with a pickup window from 6:00 PM to…read moremidnight. I arrived around 6:30 PM after a 30-minute commute. When I got there, I had to ring a doorbell at what appeared to be a location connected to a private residence rather than a storefront. A woman answered and told me they didn't have any food available and were about to head out for the day. This was frustrating because the pickup window had just started and I had driven quite a distance specifically for the order. If there wasn't food available or the business planned to close early, the order should have been cancelled in the app beforehand so customers don't make unnecessary trips. Overall, the experience felt confusing and inconvenient, and better communication through the app would help prevent situations like this.

    I saw this place on social media and wanted to stop in to support this local black-owned business…read morefor breakfast. They serve lunch and dinner as well. I ordered a few different things off the menu since they were running some specials, including the fried shrimp, grits, the breakfast eggrolls, which I got with bacon and egg, as well as the breakfast sandwich, which I got with sausage patties. Everything was delicious and I really enjoyed everything I got! The breakfast eggrolls are a little on the greasy side, so something to keep in mind for the future. They were pretty busy that morning so it took a minute to get my pick up order but you can call ahead/order online to place orders which I definitely would to save you some time in the future.

    Photos
    Jackson's Soul Food
    Jackson's Soul Food
    Jackson's Soul Food

    See all

    Phat Catz Restaurant & Bar - Honey Cajun wings with Mac and cheese

    Phat Catz Restaurant & Bar

    4.1(94 reviews)
    4.2 miEastside
    $$

    Great service from our waitress. Was sat right away and most of our needs were met. I ordered the…read morepancake breakfast with the pancakes prepared well done, cheese eggs, bacon and a side of cheesy grits. My hubby had the catfish and shrimp dinner with greens, coleslaw, mac and cheese with cornbread. Breakfast: Pro's- my pancakes were cooked perfectly. Well done, crispy edges, fluffy and soft inside. Some of the BEST pancakes I've had in a very long time. Eggs were good and I really enjoyed the thick cut bacon. The consistency of the grits were the perfect texture and required NO extra salt. Con's- I asked for more strawberries and was denied. They said it was just a garnish. I would've paid extra if need be, so I was taken a back by the response. The fruit complimented the cakes like jelly does with peanut butter. You can have it alone, but together it's even better. Another con was they charge extra for cheese in the grits and in the eggs. The charge has become customary so thats no big deal, I just hate when you're not told it'll be an extra charge and get a surprise when you're settling the bill. Lunch: Pro's- Shrimp and coleslaw were very tasty. Con's-My husband was disappointed with the fish. He stated it lacked flavor despite it looking well seasoned on the outside. I guess it didnt soak into the actual fish. The greens were ok and he didnt care for the mac and cheese. Overall, good. However, just an ok lunch which was surprising because we used to come here for our Black History celebration every year and the food would always exceed expectations. The music playing in the background added to the ambiance in a good way. Give them a shot. Pro tip- Brunch starts at 12pm on Sunday so if you want to beat the church crowd go b/w 12-12:45pm that day. Definitely worth checking out. The brunch is delicious!

    This was my third visit to Phat Catz restaurant in Buffalo, NY, and the experience continues to…read moreimpress me. The vibe is always upbeat, welcoming, and full of energy. You're guaranteed to see people from all over Buffalo gathered at the bar enjoying great food, drinks, and even better conversation. The food is outstanding, and the servers are fun, attentive, and knowledgeable about the menu, which makes the experience even more enjoyable. The only downside is the wait time for the food, which can be a bit long at times, waiting an hour is the minimum. Even with that, the atmosphere and quality of the experience keep me coming back. Order the haddock and macaroni/cheese. #HappyEating

    Photos
    Phat Catz Restaurant & Bar - Strawberry mimosa

    Strawberry mimosa

    Phat Catz Restaurant & Bar - Country honey cajun wings

    Country honey cajun wings

    Phat Catz Restaurant & Bar - County fried chicken

    See all

    County fried chicken

    The Cookie Jar 716 - soulfood - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...