The Cookieologist

4.5 (13 reviews)

Bakeries, Desserts, Pizza

Add Review

Call

Directions

Website

Order The Cookieologist Takeout

Order Takeout

The Cookieologist Photos

The Cookieologist - Dab of Butter is a tasty peanut butter treat. Delicious! - Bakeries Near Me - Englewood, Ohio

The Cookieologist - Bakeries Near Me - Englewood, Ohio

The Cookieologist - BlueDream Cookie and Blended Nut Milk - Bakeries Near Me - Englewood, Ohio

+27

The Cookieologist - BlueDream Cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Englewood, Ohio

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - The Cookieologist

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.

Start your review...

Browse more easily on the app

Reviews With Photos

Sam U.

Fantastic place to pick up some dessert. Cookies are a little pricey at about $11 for three but I will definitely be back. Chef Zay is a genius with his cookie flavors and combinations. The first time coming here we weren't sure how it worked and so we ended up having to wait the 20-something minutes outside so definitely make sure and order ahead online. The wait is absolutely worth it though for freshly baked cookies every time. Customer service was excellent, and Chef Zay let us preview his new cookie for the week while we waited and included a free bottle of nut milk. It was divine. I recommend this place to everyone and will be returning soon.

Combo pizza meal with pepperoni and blue dream cookie.

They have beautiful quite service or this place is booming. The pizza is crunchy and is actually seasoned to perfection and personally the blue dream cookie is my favorite it's soft and gooey topped with fresh blueberries lemon zest and white chocolate chips. The pizza is cooked to perfection and has fresh basil on top nice and crunchy and warm. Top with your favorite beverage. It's a perfect lunch or dinner for one or for the family.

Dab of Butter is a tasty peanut butter treat. Delicious!

Bob Z.

These cookies are so freaking good. Some of the best I have ever had. I highly recommend trying the Busta-Nut cookie. I ordered using door dash. They arrived fresh from the oven.

Notorious C.H.I.P. and S'mores Baked cookies

See all

Kayla C.

Elite 26

6

158

730

3 years ago

My blue dream cookie didn't even make it home. It was AMAZING. Parking is easy here and i was greeted as soon as I walked in. I ordered two cookies and two slices of pepperoni focaccia pizza. Everything was amazing and I would come back in a heartbeat. You should try this spot!! Great prices too. read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Shelly L.

56

19

2 years ago

I went here for the first time last night. Small, family owned. They share space with Slide Thru which is also excellent. Super friendly, hot, fresh, made to order cookies. I got chocolate chip, lemon blueberry white chocolate, and Mexican chocolate. Can't ask for better. I demolished 2 and saved 2 for today. Try them, you won't be sorry. read more

The Cookieologist - Lemon Blueberry - Bakeries Near Me - Englewood, Ohio

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jessica B.

Elite 19

146

105

616

3 years ago

Watch for this place on the Food Network someday--no joke. How is this in Englewood? I feel like I'm in NYC. The Cookieologist is the real deal--scratch gourmet cookies, pizza-like-art, and sliders that after only a month and change post-opening, are getting people talking. Our pizza-by-the-slice was sumptuous and generous--shockingly beautiful. In fact--THE most beautiful slice these well-traveled eyes have ever seen. This is not pizza it's an experience. The cookies are NOT willing to take second place--they hold their own. Solid gourmand. Luxuriously heavy. So many varieties it hurts to choose! They're made fresh and it shows. Owner Isiah Davis creates passion, love, and spirit on a plate you'd be a fool to miss. Don't let this opportunity pass you by--you now know where to go (this is why you came to Yelp, right) -- Get some! You're welcome. read more

The Cookieologist - Berry Dream Cookies: Strawberries, cream cheese, and white chocolate. - Bakeries Near Me - Englewood, Ohio

The Cookieologist - Queen B: Brown sugar cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Englewood, Ohio

The Cookieologist - Notorious C.h.i.p. Chocolate Chip - Bakeries Near Me - Englewood, Ohio

The Cookieologist - Glass Animals Cookie: Sunflower butter, oats, golden raisins - Bakeries Near Me - Englewood, Ohio

The Cookieologist - Dab o Butter Cookie: peanut butter base with candied peanuts - Bakeries Near Me - Englewood, Ohio

The Cookieologist - B.O.B. - Black on Both Sides Cookie: chocolate cookies with chocolate chips - Bakeries Near Me - Englewood, Ohio

The Cookieologist - Pepperoni pizza by the slice with fresh mozzarella and basil - Bakeries Near Me - Englewood, Ohio

See all

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 1

Sam U.

Elite 26

135

290

445

4 years ago

Fantastic place to pick up some dessert. Cookies are a little pricey at about $11 for three but I will definitely be back. Chef Zay is a genius with his cookie flavors and combinations. The first time coming here we weren't sure how it worked and so we ended up having to wait the 20-something minutes outside so definitely make sure and order ahead online. The wait is absolutely worth it though for freshly baked cookies every time. Customer service was excellent, and Chef Zay let us preview his new cookie for the week while we waited and included a free bottle of nut milk. It was divine. I recommend this place to everyone and will be returning soon. read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 1

Jameson L.

0

4

0

1 year ago

Zay's cookies are the best I've had. I enjoy trying whatever he comes up with! ordering online and picking them up has worked for me and their service is customer-focused! Big fan! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Stacy S.

Elite 23

94

382

212

2 years ago

The cookies are very good so we came back for the pizza. Pizza and umami bread are different - like that they use thick focaccia bread. Pepperonis were small though. Overall, we struggled to understand the rave of the pizzas. Umami bread was tasty but very hard and chewy when eaten after ordering but even more so the next day with rewarming. We had to toss it which was sad! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Sarah Michael B.

0

2

0

3 years ago

Couldn't find Slide Thru on Yelp but I remembered the man behind the counter told us Cookieologist!! Cookieologist is now in my algorithm after telling people about this delightful restaurant My fiancé and I have been meaning to try this place out. Today we did it! It's a cute little place attached to an ice cream shop. Unrelated so go through the street side; dinner before dessert! We ordered 4 different sliders and when the chef came out we laughed about how it must be annoying that I ordered one of each but he was gracious and lovely. These sliders are SUBSTANTIAL. With lovely buns and the take out boxes were even impressive. The regular beef slider was our favorite and the close second was the Buffalo chicken. We also got the beignet bites ...A beautiful little basket of bite sized fried dough. ***chef kiss** I'm trying to figure out how I'm going to get a tray of slides and a tray of beignet to my tailgates in the fall! Thanks guys!!!!!!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 1

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Morgan R.

30

7

1

3 years ago

They have beautiful quite service or this place is booming. The pizza is crunchy and is actually seasoned to perfection and personally the blue dream cookie is my favorite it's soft and gooey topped with fresh blueberries lemon zest and white chocolate chips. The pizza is cooked to perfection and has fresh basil on top nice and crunchy and warm. Top with your favorite beverage. It's a perfect lunch or dinner for one or for the family. read more

The Cookieologist - Combo pizza meal with pepperoni and blue dream cookie. - Bakeries Near Me - Englewood, Ohio

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Bob Z.

0

7

2

6 years ago

These cookies are so freaking good. Some of the best I have ever had. I highly recommend trying the Busta-Nut cookie. I ordered using door dash. They arrived fresh from the oven. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Emily B.

151

12

4

4 years ago

We online ordered the Notorious C.H.I.P. and S'mores Baked cookies for pickup. They were ready at the estimated time and fresh out of the oven (the box was still warm!). They were DELICIOUS. I'll be back, and I highly recommend you go, too! read more

The Cookieologist - Notorious C.H.I.P. and S'mores Baked cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Englewood, Ohio

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Shanda C.

0

2

0

3 years ago

Was excited to try, have been wanting a non-chain pizza place in Englewood. However, I was very disappointed. The crust was burned and just didn't taste good and most of the toppings were on the inside of the lid of the box. Barely any sauce on the pizza. Used a cheat day from doing Keto to try this place and I wasted it. The cookies were good but that was it. I won't be ordering here again. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 0

Oh no 0

L. T.

0

65

21

4 years ago

I always check Yelp for cookie recommendations when traveling and discovered The Cookieologist. The cookies are priced like the big Crumbl cookies, but are sized more like the regular sized Insomnia Cookies. Value comparison aside, I actually did enjoy the cookies. If the cookies were larger (or prices were lower) I would definitely return if back in town. At current sizing/pricing I'd probably just end up at Crumbl. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Alissa E.

102

1

0

5 years ago

Phenomenal cookies! Customer service is spot on! Our order was going to take almost an hour to prepare (now that we've had the cookies...well worth the wait!) but we had a little guy that needed to get home to bed. They gave us cookie dough instead and great service!!!! We will definitely be back!!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

More info about The Cookieologist

322 Union Blvd
Ste B
Englewood, OH 45322
Directions
(937) 219-5124
Call Now
Order Takeout
Start Order
Visit Website
http://thecookieologistdyt.com

Full menu

Hours

What time does The Cookieologist open?

The Cookieologist opens at 11:00 AM on Wednesday, Thursday and Saturday.The Cookieologist opens at 12:00 PM on Friday and Sunday.

What time does The Cookieologist close?

The Cookieologist is closed on Monday and Tuesday.The Cookieologist closes at 9:00 PM on Wednesday and Thursday.The Cookieologist closes at 10:00 PM on Friday and Saturday.The Cookieologist closes at 5:00 PM on Sunday.

Mon-Tue ClosedWed-Thu 11:00 AM - 9:00 PMFri 12:00 PM - 10:00 PMSat 11:00 AM - 10:00 PMSun 12:00 PM - 5:00 PM

Food & Alcohol

Does The Cookieologist serve alcohol?

Yes, The Cookieologist serves alcohol.

Outdoor Amenities

Does The Cookieologist have outdoor seating?

Yes, The Cookieologist has outdoor seating options.

Does The Cookieologist have parking?

Yes, The Cookieologist has parking options. Validated Parking

Other Amenities

Does The Cookieologist have free WiFi?

Yes, The Cookieologist has free WiFi.

From the Business

Specialties

Crafting irresistible, artisanal cookies & focaccia style pizza in Englewood, OH. Satisfy your sweet cravings with our handcrafted creations!

You might also consider

JD's Frozen Custard

This unpretentious little spot in Englewood is a fairly simple establishment that serves some…read morewonderful ice cream. It has the feel of a summer neighborhood gathering spot. You order from the outside window, though most of the seating is inside. The service was friendly and very efficient. There were many tempting decadent creations (sundaes, milkshakes, concretes, etc.) on the menu with a multitude of varieties. However, the base ice cream selections were streamlined. There was chocolate, strawberry, vanilla and lemon. The latter was intriguing. Added to this, the "Flavor of the Dae" when we visited was s'mores. I noticed they offered a 3-scoop flight for $6 and that was ideal for my wife and I to split. We tried the chocolate, the s'mores and the lemon. They were all terrific! The basic chocolate was the best I've tasted in a long time. It was wonderfully creamy and you could truly taste the chocolate. The value here was terrific and the ice cream was very enjoyable. The service topped off a pleasant visit. We'll be back when we're in the area.

Always a joy to come here. Menu has somsfun options. They also have the menu on the side of the…read morebuilding if you ever feel like one that does not light to feel pressured while you decide. Everything came quickly- and we enjoyed every item we have gotten from here! Definitely highly recommend if you like soft serve!

Photos

Menu

Seating Area at JD's Old Fashioned Frozen Custard

See all

Order Window at JD's Old Fashioned Frozen Custard

Jim's Donut Shop

Am on vacation in Panama City Beach. We got doughnuts at a famous location across the street from…read morethe condo called Amore Doughnuts. Good pastries with lots of filling but Jim's is 2-3X better! Jim's is simply the best anywhere!

Been here a couple of times since moving back and everything is what I remember as a kid. I don't…read moreeat many donuts anymore, but every time I do, it brings back a lot of memories. The girls who were working were always really nice. It's much appreciated.

Photos

Reliving childhood!

See all

Donut display

Freddy's Frozen Custard & Steakburgers

1.9

(27 reviews)

1.5 mi

I went to Freddy's in Englewood, Ohio when they first opened and honestly had a terrible…read moreexperience. The food was disappointing, the restaurant didn't feel welcoming, and the staff seemed miserable and rude. I left thinking I wouldn't be back. But I decided to give it another chance--and I'm really glad I did. Today's visit was the complete opposite. Chris took our order and was awesome. The food was amazing, everything was clean, and the staff was friendly and upbeat. The whole atmosphere felt welcoming. Huge improvement from opening day. I'll definitely be coming back.

What can be improved.... Let's see.... Service was slow, food took 15 minutes, food could have used…read moreseasoning. This place was terrible IMO

Photos

Worst burgers ever! The sandwiches and fries were cold after a long wait in the drive-thru. First and last time I'll eat here.

See all

Worst burgers ever. First and last time!

Airline Dairy Creme

In our effort to systematically knock out the entire list of establishments on the Ohio Ice Cream…read moreTrail, this was next (or more accurately, it was the most convenient place on the list we had yet to visit). And it turned out to be a terrific little spot in Vandalia. It's funny because it has been around since 1964, meaning that it's almost as old as we are. We grew up in the general area and we had never heard of it, let alone tried it. The decor was simple with a decent number of seats. It was set up to order from the counter. The gentleman serving us was friendly and quite pleasant. The ice cream flavors were limited, but that was fine for our granddaughter, who had a vanilla-chocolate twist in a cup with a cone "hat". My wife and I split a Banana Pudding Cyclone, which was like a Flurry. It was terrifically flavorful. We were pretty happy with our experience. It reminded us of the type of place we would have gone as kids. With tasty treats and good service, it is a place worthy of a return visit.

I'm here with my wife & mother-in-law visiting family and in our travels stopped at Air line Dairy…read moreCrème for lunch. This is a throwback to the 60's & 70's when my wife came here with her folks as a child. The food is your drive-in style place with hamburgers, hot dogs, chicken sandwiches, fries & shakes. I had the hamburger and my wife & mother-in-law each had the foot long coney with chili, cheese & onions along with fries and shakes. All was tasty and brought back that yesteryear type feeling. The staff was friendly & efficient in getting the food prepared quickly and correctly. The setting as I mentioned earlier is a throwback with Formica tables & seats. Very clean! Thank you for bringing back a great memory for my wife & mother-in-law.

Photos

Seating Area at Airline Dairy Creme

Banana Pudding Cyclone at Airline Dairy Creme

See all

Tables at Airline Dairy Creme

Jerardi's Little Store

Jerardi's Little Store is one of those hidden gems that instantly feels warm and welcoming. The…read morecozy storefront already sets the tone, but the food is where they really shine. I grabbed a sandwich, and it did not disappoint. Fresh bread, generous portions of meat, crisp lettuce, juicy tomatoes, and just the right balance of flavors--simple, classic, and done right. You can tell everything is fresh and made with care. The deli case is impressive too. From prepared salads to grilled items and Italian-style dishes, everything looks well-stocked, clean, and appetizing. It's the kind of place where you want to try something new every visit because it all looks that good. Overall, Jerardi's Little Store delivers quality food, great presentation, and that small local-shop charm that's hard to find these days. Perfect for a quick lunch or grabbing something delicious to take home. Definitely worth the stop--and the return visit.

The Cuban sandwich was very good. I really loved the roasted pork. I'm looking forward to trying…read moremore of their menu.

Photos

Deli counter

Italian turkey sandwich and pasta salad

See all

Front of the store

Dairy Queen Grill & Chill

I notice Red/pink hair was caught in the lid of my cup. So I walk inside DQ. I see the only lady…read morewith pink hair. I talk to another employee they go get the manager. The manager comes and ask me, "Are you the one here for a refund?" I say yes. I'm given a refund but I notice I wasn't given the correct amount. The manager gave me the correct amount and went back to work. A simple apology would have been nice. This was poor goods and poor customer service rendered. I'm incredibly disappointed.

*MAJOR HEALTH VIOLATION* Went on May 2nd, around 11:40 and…read morestayed in line for about 5-10 ish minutes and saw the worker cross contaminate multiple things in a very short amount of time commiting MAJOR health violations. She touched 2 different raw meats, fryer handles, different doors, cheese, buns, cooked meat, served food and the register without changing gloves. When working in a resteraunt industry you MUST replace gloves after touching even ONE thing. Knowing kids and families dine there it is not safe for people to consume food that's not only been touched by dirty gloves but those same gloves also touching RAW food. This needs to be addressed ASAP as the longer this issue waits the more likely someone will get seriously sick. Being in the resteraunt industry for 7 years and having a food handlers certificate I cannot let this go unoticed as this can lead to serious issues in the future.

Photos

See all

Cold Stone Creamery

Love this place, ice cream always is fresh and stocked. Service is always so pleasant, love coming…read moreto this location. Place is very cold when I come in, smells like cake lol.

Me and my partner went here with a gift card today, sweet employees who went above and beyond to…read moreaccount for my allergy, they got a brand new tub of icecream and cleaned the spoons. I got cheesecake and my partner got vanilla, SO good. Very quiet as well, think we showed up at a slow hour.

Photos

See all

Cafe 19

4.6

(35 reviews)

0.5 mi

Location: 19 W National Rd, Englewood Ohio Parking: street…read moreparking, a few limited spots on small lot Service: impeccable, friendly, efficient, very knowledgeable and helpful Menu: more than the expected basics, great quality Looking for a local coffee shop with great food? Look no further. Well, look closely for this little powerhouse of a coffee shop, tucked into a side street off US40 in Englewood Ohio. (It's a little tricky to find but you will be so glad you did!) This is a very small cafe. Four tables inside, 3 picnic tables outside, and a drive-thru window. We stopped in to try our luck getting a table and easily scored one inside after ordering 2 iced lattes and 2 breakfast sandwiches. We were prepared to sit outside but got lucky with a table inside. A happy perk indulging me to dine 'in' on a review visit so I can observe interactions with other customers and between employees. The staff is a great team - working together very well and helping to fill orders for the drive-thru window and counter orders. Very impressive overall and a level of service that really stands out - table delivery of drinks and food as soon as they were ready. I also noted 3 'to go' orders handled with the same efficiency. Well done, Cafe 19! The food options exceeded my expectations. Several breakfast options, several lunch options, and a nice baked goods selection. What really makes me love a coffee shop is the coffee, though (of course). The smell of beans being ground and brewed filled the air and our cold choices were lovely. Between the quality of coffee, food and incredibly great service - this has become my favorite coffee shop.

This place is amazing! Been coming here since 2023. The people, food, and coziness of this small…read morecafe is awesome. The staff has been friendly to me. I love how they do their best to know many of the regular customers. Even the regulars seem to chat to one another. They had a customer's order done before he was finished paying for it. I haven't had bad food once. It's all tasty. Their drive thru opens at 5 am, and the inside opens at 7. Both close at 4 pm.

Photos