The Cubby Hole

The waitress was in hurry even after I told her we have never been there. She didn't pickup that…read moreour eyes were still on the menus. I ordered the Mac Daddy burger and my wife got the house brat with no sauerkraut and with cheese sauce . We moved our seating to the bar and the bartender was really cool and friendly! It was too cold in the back left corner of the dining room. He took great care of us! The rest of the meal was delicious! The brat came on a pretzel bun and was much longer than a Johnsonville! The Mac Daddy smashed my hunger! It was grilled perfectly and the Mac was Deluxe! Initially, we were going to pass on this place after our first choice turned up to be closed for the day, but we are glad we didn't and we will be back again in the future!

Great food, great location, service is slow. Inside atmosphere is good. Beer is good. Def worth…read morestopping in!

Inside

Sausage sampler

See all

Fig mule. So good!!

Herner's Hideaway

4.2(135 reviews)

0.9 mi

Possibly the best chicken tenders I've ever had!!!…read more This place is pretty unassuming. I came for the line dancing but I'll be back for the food. The chicken tenders came with ranch and a bbq sauce and as a sauce girl I LOVED both. I had no idea this place had won awards for their burgers. Basically what I'm trying to say is I'll be back to take a stab at the rest of their menu.

They are expanding it looks like on the outside and it is decorated with a Christmas theme complete…read morewith Santa hat chair covers! The staff is friendly and accommodating. Wide selection of food to eat! We took the honey barbecue pulled pork tacos, and the taco salad bowl. They had dog the bounty hunter on one of the big screen TVs then on the smallest TV they had a western TV channel on. I thought that was a funny mix of shows to be on in a tavern. Small pitchers were used to serve our sodas in, another funny thing! The taco salad lacked in the meat portion and flavor yet had too much lettuce in it! The honey barbecue pulled pork tacos were delicious and wet with all the vegetables and bbq sauce! Kassandra was excellent with helping us through this meal!

The honey barbecue pulled pork tacos

Santa hat seat covers

See all

Lots of corned beef on that Reuben! Always love that sandwich with a couple of cold beers.

Sand Bar & Island Grill

4.2(214 reviews)

1.9 mi

We enjoyed our dinner. Oysters are always delicious. Big and meaty!…read more We love that we can bring our little doggie inside too!

We had an excellent meal at Sandbar on St. George Island. The fried shrimp was delicious (8/10),…read moreand the blackened scallops and grouper were outstanding (9/10). The chicken nuggets and hamburger were surprisingly great (10/10), and the pimento cheese side was the star of the meal (12/10). Everything was cooked perfectly and full of flavor. I'll definitely be back for many years to come and highly recommend this spot for casual, delicious coastal food. Mark

View of the lake from our table

Oysters

See all

Allllllligators!!!

Old Mill Inn of Wonder Lake

3.5(2 reviews)

5.3 mi

Nice atmosphere. Good service. The French onion soup was a disappointment. It was certainly no…read moremasterpiece. My t bone steak was tough. It was served with 3 small sweet potatoes. My wife's vegetables were overcooked. You can get a better steak at outback.

We hadn't been here in years. Decided to try it out for a birthday dinner tonight. Was a little…read moreskeptical when we got there. No one was there except us....the entire night.....weird compared to back in the day. The deck was a little overgrown and we didn't see any ducks. The paddle wheel is now on land and not in the water, but hey, I am sure I don't look the same as I did 20 years ago either. Once we got inside, It was just like old times. Quaint. The service from Barbara could not have been more personable and attentive. We truly enjoyed her! She mixed a wicked Brandy old fashioned and was quick, but not too quick with her service. The food was all excellent from the relish trays, to the beer cheese pretzel ball and mozzarella sticks. Our dinners ranged from prime ribs...fantastic by the wAy, to meatloaf, butt steak, a burger and ribeye. All were cooked wonderfully. Excellent flavor, fresh salads and nicely prepared potatoes. They prepared a homemade birthday cake. Our entire experience tonight could not have been better in any way. Although it has been 20 years since we were last with you, it will be soon that we return. Don't miss this diamond in the rough!!!

Donovan's Reef Sports Bar

4.0(10 reviews)

4.3 mi

OMG....we literally just got a pizza from Donovan's and it is probably the best pizza I've ever…read moreeaten. I'm from Chicago and moved to Wisconsin 13 years ago, only to bemoan the fact that nobody makes good pizza in these parts. I am glad to have found this awesome gem of a place! Perfect crust, perfectly seasoned with perfect proportions of ingredients! Very reasonably priced too!

Friendly staff and a fun atmosphere. Fair pricing and good pizza! Heather might be most well read…read moreperson, let alone bartender, I've ever met.

Donovan's Reef Sports Bar - Summer enchantment : the history of Twin Lakes / by Greg Saucerman for the Western Kenosha County Historical Society. (1994)

See all

Summer enchantment : the history of Twin Lakes / by Greg Saucerman for the Western Kenosha County Historical Society. (1994)

Dilar Restaurant

3.7(49 reviews)

2.3 mi

This place is surprisingly large inside and had super quick service on a weekend. Our waiter was…read moreincredibly kind and attentive. Hashbrowns could have been crispier but I enjoyed my skillet and the raisin toast.

My friend had the breaded pork tenderloin, and I had the roasted chicken. Both were excellent with…read moregood sized portions. The mashed potatoes were real, and they had the skins on which was a plus for us. Green beans on the side were really fresh. The salad was plentiful. We did not try the soups, but I bet they were excellent. Will be back if I'm up in this area again. They have some pretty nice desserts too.

Cute rustic place

Their generous Roasted chicken plate, ummm... great!

See all

Doyle's Pub

3.6(112 reviews)

0.7 mi

Have been here a number of times in the past and always provided 5star reviews. It had been 2 years…read moreand was looking forward to a treat, Was very disappointed Corned beef sandwich- beef was dry and bread soggy (falling apart) Fries were overdone. Fortunately beer was good.

I have been here several times in the past. It is a die hard Chicago sports fan bar. I can…read moreappreciate that and enjoy their loyalty. I have never eaten here, but I have partaken in all of their fresh on tap Irish beers. Stopped on the way for some nostalgia and their was friendly service and of course the fresh on tap Smithwick's. They had some cute Christmas decor and the food looked like some good Irish Pub fare. Stop in and have a brew and an app. You won't be disappointed.

Christmasy Smithwick's

It was a gorgeous day!

See all

Overgrown view

KC's Cabin

4.0(147 reviews)

5.3 mi

Stopped in here after our Mud Girl Run for a quick brunch. My friend needed a dry shirt and they…read morehad a really cute one for a good price, which was nice. I ordered their burger with an egg but with the option in a wrap, which was different, and honestly pretty good. The food options overall were solid, and the service at the bar was friendly. I had a Bloody Mary with a beer chaser too, which hit the spot. It's your typical local bar vibe: busy, not huge, but comfortable. Nothing fancy, but good service and a good spot to hang out.

This is a very busy bar/restaurant. We came in with 3 kids and they found us a table for 5. The…read morefood was fabulous. I just want to say the best burger I've had in a very long time. We literally ate everything. The kids loved it. This doesn't happen often. Lovely wait staff who work very hard. Ambiance is lovely, tvs, decorations.

View from sitting at the bar

Pizza and burger

See all

Comfy joint

Bassett Creek Saloon and Eatery

4.0(9 reviews)

5.5 mi

Average service and food. Locals just stared at us. Used to be decent but went down hill since last…read moretime we visited.

Was there last Thursday. Owners were out of town and a gal was doing the cooking and had two…read moreteenagers back there with her. As much as I like the food there, the wait for food was an hour to hour and a half. The kids were just screwing around and the gal cooking had such a sour look and you could tell she didnt want to be there. Many people were complaining about the wait. Not sure if I'll be back. The bartender was friendly and working to keep up with a big crowd, but doing a great job.

Menu

See all

Menu

Richmond Cafe

4.3(61 reviews)

0.7 mi

We were greeted right away and was told to sit anywhere we wanted to. Josie was our waitress and…read morewas very friendly. She took our drinks and food order. Food came out really fast. Ordered the macchiato with almond milk. Comes in traditional size and they had it in a paper coffee cup. I would have liked it served in a coffee mug, since I drank it in the cafe with my breakfast. I had the chicken, Swiss, and avocado skillet. Came with 2 eggs, which I asked to be cooked over easy, and hash browns. Very delicious and avocado were fresh. Also, asked for hot sauce and they only offer Louisiana hot sauce. I was only able to eat half the skillet and took the rest home. My friend has celiac disease, so they made sure her order was GF.

I called ahead to check on their gluten-free options and was thrilled to hear they offer GF toast,…read moreGF hash browns, and skillets. We arrived around 10:15am on a Saturday and the vibe was immediately welcoming. The place is super cute, featuring a coffee bar where you can sit at the counter, a few cozy couches, and even a little craft display with items for sale. Because we got there just before the rush, we were able to sit anywhere we liked. They have an extensive drink menu, and I ordered a chai latte in a mug. It was absolutely huge, smelled incredible, and tasted great. When it came time to order, I informed our server about my gluten allergy. She was incredibly accommodating and reassured me that she would alert the kitchen to keep everything separate to avoid cross-contamination. I ordered a cheddar cheese omelette with hash browns, and the food came out incredibly fast. There was a minor hiccup where my omelette accidentally came out with ham in it, but it was large enough and easy enough to just pick out, so it didn't ruin the meal. The food was overall really delicious and the service was excellent. By the time we left, the place was completely packed, which clearly speaks to how popular it is. It was a really good experience with great GF awareness, and we will definitely be back!

Interior

The second try on the hash browns. Kinda oily. Kinda barely if at all cooked.

See all

Bloody Mary and Mimosa

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

2 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Jim T.

11

1

0

10 years ago

Have been going there for years ago moved back in the area and have going back the last few years never disappointed.

Melissa R.

Elite 11

249

148

0

16 years ago

2 words: Cheese balls. :)

The Cubby Hole - newamerican - Updated September 2026

People who viewed The Cubby Hole also viewed

Corner Kitchen

3.7

(21 reviews)

Wow. A hidden GEM. Excellent family made food and their pizza is phenomenal. It is truly clean and…read moredelicious food. Five stars. Also has a full bar.

Great service. Pancakes were fine, nothing special there. The corned beef hash skillet was…read moreexcellent. Would recommend for a quick bite in a casual atmosphere.

Manny's Snack Shack

4.4

(224 reviews)

Perfect! Everything I want in my breakfast spot with simple menu, nothing eclectic, reasonably…read morepriced, good coffee, good service. This is right up my alley! Just moved into town. Please plan on an addition to your regular customers.

Stopped by Manny's Snack Shack for breakfast and really enjoyed it! It's a small spot with random…read moredecor and a great atmosphere. Manny was behind the counter cooking for a full restaurant by himself, all while happily dancing and singing to some euro dance music and having a good time. It was honestly fun to watch! My breakfast came out super fast, the portions were big, and the prices were great. Everyone was really friendly and welcoming. Definitely will be back to support this local spot!

Lake's Pancake House

4.5

(74 reviews)

First off... the service, you are family the moment you walk through the door…read more Secondly, the food is great. I have never had anything that was not good, obviously have my favorites but everything is truly good. Third, the coffee, that's it, the coffee is great!! The ambience is quaint but a recent overhaul has the place looking amazing!

Food is 5 star. I highly recommended…read more Price is reasonable too. However the service is awful from Jackie. Not friendly or happy what she do. The only that I didn't like, NO soap in the bathroom. We didn't feel + vibes from her. NO smile, NO eye contact. And she keep on pouring from my behind my coffee w/out asking. But when it's time to pay it's different. Ambiance is good. It good be perfect is the server is pleasant & welcoming.

Sammy's on the Square

4.1

(174 reviews)

As in the name, Sammy's under square is under square in Walworth. Only negative part of this review…read moreis the parking as it's very limited or you'll be walking a little bit. At some point, they expanded the restaurant so it can easily handle over 150 people and I'm guessing anywhere is up to 180 people. Was very clean inside and appears that it had been painted not too long ago. Our waitress was Alaina. Hope I spelled, her name right. Very good waitress and made sure she took care of us. I had a few questions about the food on the menu and she had all the answers. I got what I think was called the sweet potato brisket skillet. My girlfriend had just eggs, toast, hashbrowns with bacon. She said the coffee was OK. She's a little fussy with the coffee so we've had a few places where it's been great. She says it's drinkable and she liked it. Good enough! They give you generous portions of food. The bacon was cooked crispy the way she likes it and the eggs were done perfectly. Hashbrowns taste fresh and good and never cooked perfectly. They under utilize salt, but there's probably a good reason for it and that's why you have salt at the table. The skillet I had, however, was real good! Generous portions of brisket and the sweet potatoes were cut strips and grilled and tender. It had chunks of green peppers which were grilled and you could tell they were fresh. Fresh grilled onions and chunks of tomatoes inside. It was loaded with cheese too. My eggs were done to perfection and I had the sourdough toast. Their sourdough toast is Home made style bread. I don't believe it's baked in the restaurant, but it was very good. Once again, very generous portions. The place is huge inside with plenty of elbow room. As for the price, their prices were average and in line with other places we've eaten breakfast in the area. The whole staff that is there greeted you at one point or the other. Very friendly staff. They are also open for lunch and dinner. The place is busy for breakfast so I'm guessing that they're Friday night fish fries probably pretty packed. I highly recommend Sammy's on the square.

Great classic diner vibes. Prices I think are very reasonable and plenty of people at tables which…read moreI think is a great sign of a great diner. I wanted to order the special of the day which was the fried chicken but my waitress made me feel she didnt want me to order them by saying "This would be an additional 20 minute wait. Are you sure that you want to make your table wait for your food?" So I decided on the sampler since I knew this would be my one time at the diner since we were visiting. BBQ sauce was a little too hot for my liking but loved their ranch and their cheese curds were very good! Thought the breading on my onion rings were good and complimented the onion well. The chicken tenders were just okay. Just regular chicken tenders.

Cubby Cafe

4.6

(25 reviews)

It's always friendly and fast here at the Cubby Cafe and we're here enjoying another breakfast! The…read morepumpkin bread french toast is delicious and very sweet! I got my usual pancakes deluxe with bacon and scrambled eggs. Our waitress was attentive enough to make our visit perfect!

Food is always hot and tasty and service is always friendly and quick. I can't wait to go back againread more

Red School Cafe

4.2

(110 reviews)

I've drive by this old schoolhouse a million times, but never stopped in until today. I really…read moreenjoyed my first breakfast at Red School Cafe! There's lots of parking in the gravel lot; several cute planters ring the entrance and outdoor patio. The cafe has several counter seats and maybe 10 tables indoors (there's also a covered outdoor patio with additional seating in warmer months). This is a first-come-first-serve sort of place; when you come in, you wait in line until a table or counter seat opens up. All of the waitstaff was cheerful and helpful and came around with fresh coffee a few times. I had a veggie omelet with a berry cup and sourdough toast. The veggies were cooked nicely with just the right amount of browning and flavor. There were a lot of interesting specials (country meatloaf with eggs and potatoes, for example) and the coffee and ice team were super fresh. We'll be back!

Not sure that I have much to add being that I only stopped by in a desperate search for coffee…read more If this cafe isn't the epitome of small town life, I don't know what is. Legitimately a converted schoolhouse, you get the feel of that as all. As you walk in to the dining room. There is a nice covered porch area for outdoor seating. The waitress was kind and quickly grabbed me a coffee to go. For a diner coffee, I was actually impressed by the palatability and overall just grateful to get some caffeine in me!

Local Folks

3.7

(50 reviews)

Food was good and at a fair price. Two home cooked breakfast for 25 dollars, can't beat it. It's a…read morelittle establishment with good food. Service was quick and friendly.

Pick up order, food was good, but my order was incomplete. This wasn't the first time. I did call…read moreand tell them and the employee was very rude to me. I wasn't accusatory, just wanted to let them know because it's happened twice before. Twice I didn't receive the soup and today I was missing cheese sauce. I didn't call the other two times-just let it go. She basically told me I was lying. I'm a woman in my 70s and was not only surprised, but sad an employee would treat a customer with such a lack of respect. The good news is this time I wasn't charged for the missing food.

Richmond Cafe

4.3

(61 reviews)

We were greeted right away and was told to sit anywhere we wanted to. Josie was our waitress and…read morewas very friendly. She took our drinks and food order. Food came out really fast. Ordered the macchiato with almond milk. Comes in traditional size and they had it in a paper coffee cup. I would have liked it served in a coffee mug, since I drank it in the cafe with my breakfast. I had the chicken, Swiss, and avocado skillet. Came with 2 eggs, which I asked to be cooked over easy, and hash browns. Very delicious and avocado were fresh. Also, asked for hot sauce and they only offer Louisiana hot sauce. I was only able to eat half the skillet and took the rest home. My friend has celiac disease, so they made sure her order was GF.

I called ahead to check on their gluten-free options and was thrilled to hear they offer GF toast,…read moreGF hash browns, and skillets. We arrived around 10:15am on a Saturday and the vibe was immediately welcoming. The place is super cute, featuring a coffee bar where you can sit at the counter, a few cozy couches, and even a little craft display with items for sale. Because we got there just before the rush, we were able to sit anywhere we liked. They have an extensive drink menu, and I ordered a chai latte in a mug. It was absolutely huge, smelled incredible, and tasted great. When it came time to order, I informed our server about my gluten allergy. She was incredibly accommodating and reassured me that she would alert the kitchen to keep everything separate to avoid cross-contamination. I ordered a cheddar cheese omelette with hash browns, and the food came out incredibly fast. There was a minor hiccup where my omelette accidentally came out with ham in it, but it was large enough and easy enough to just pick out, so it didn't ruin the meal. The food was overall really delicious and the service was excellent. By the time we left, the place was completely packed, which clearly speaks to how popular it is. It was a really good experience with great GF awareness, and we will definitely be back!

Herner's Hideaway

4.2

(135 reviews)

Possibly the best chicken tenders I've ever had!!!…read more This place is pretty unassuming. I came for the line dancing but I'll be back for the food. The chicken tenders came with ranch and a bbq sauce and as a sauce girl I LOVED both. I had no idea this place had won awards for their burgers. Basically what I'm trying to say is I'll be back to take a stab at the rest of their menu.

They are expanding it looks like on the outside and it is decorated with a Christmas theme complete…read morewith Santa hat chair covers! The staff is friendly and accommodating. Wide selection of food to eat! We took the honey barbecue pulled pork tacos, and the taco salad bowl. They had dog the bounty hunter on one of the big screen TVs then on the smallest TV they had a western TV channel on. I thought that was a funny mix of shows to be on in a tavern. Small pitchers were used to serve our sodas in, another funny thing! The taco salad lacked in the meat portion and flavor yet had too much lettuce in it! The honey barbecue pulled pork tacos were delicious and wet with all the vegetables and bbq sauce! Kassandra was excellent with helping us through this meal!

Tanas Family Restaurant

4.4

(71 reviews)