This place is so insanely good. The Athena is like the best sandwich I've ever had. I come here every time I'm up this way.

Im from New Jersey, right outside of Philly, pretty much smack dab in the Italian capital of the USA. I was on a bachelorette last week and we wanted a quick breakfast before our adventure for the day. Imagine my absolute shock finding a deli in the middle of nowhere (to me at least) that had PORK ROLL and PHILLY CHEESESTEAKS. Felt right at home. I actually ordered a homemade cannolo that was as delicious as any Italian pastry shop has served me up here. Didn't try the Philly cheesesteak but this little shop made me feel right at home. Friend had pastrami and also loved it. read more

See all

Updated Review - I've always liked this sandwich shop in Nederland -- great people, good service, and solid sandwiches. I previously mentioned that the deli case needed attention because I saw some old coleslaw that had fallen through the grates. It might've just been a timing issue while they were getting ready to clean, but I wanted to follow up with an update. I stopped in recently, and I'm happy to say the deli case looked spotless. Everything was fresh, clean, and well-organized. It's clear they put in the effort, and I really appreciate that. Still great folks, great sandwiches, and now the place looks even better than before. Glad to see they took care of it! read more

The Deli At 8236 is still... A hole in the wall slinging out a mighty tasty sandwich! I rolled in, ordered The Toscana from a friendly cashier, waited for a few minutes then drove down to the lake to enjoy it. The Toscana had prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, roasted peppers, balsamic & oregano on a hoagie. We subbed the prosciutto for soprosetto and asked for all the fixings that they put on their regular sandwiches (lettuce, onion, oil, etc.). It was just the fuel we needed to continue on our epic mountain day! :D read more

See all

Fabulous Reuben with gluten free bread. Great back patio with view of the creek and mountains. Amazing service. read more

The Deli At 8236 - Back patio - Delis Near Me - Nederland, Colorado

The best sandwich I've had in the US. I visit friends in Colorado and have to stop for one at The Deli! My favorite is the Italian but their entire menu is amazing! If you have a chance to grab lunch, dinner or a travel snack from here, do it! You'll be back and a fan forever! read more

See all

This is as no frills as it gets. Nothing fancy or polished here. Home to old school, sloppy sandwiches to revive you after a hard day's night. The Deli at 8236 (elevation) is nestled along Nederland's main street. On a weekend, it's packed. They have seating, but mostly no one is there to dine in. It's predominantly used as a waiting room. I can see lines and ticket times going over the desired amount (ours was 10 minutes late), but ultimately you're armed with big ole sandwiches in tow. Spicy Chicken Parm ($13) // Chicken cutlets, mozzarella, parmesan, pepperoni, hot giardinerra. This thing was messy, but boy it packed a serious punch. The spicy peppers cut through the richness of the salty pepperoni and chicken cutlets. I felt like embracing my Italian American background and this hit the spot. *PRO TIP* take your sandwich downstairs and you'll find some underutilized picnic benches. My wife and I enjoyed our sandwiches looking at the mountains and listening to the creek. Our pups appreciated the space to roam without a huge hovering crowd. For a filling and satisfying lunch, hit up this deli. read more

The Deli At 8236 - Spicy Chicken Parm - Delis Near Me - Nederland, Colorado

See all

Recently went to Nederland and was looking for a quick bite to eat while out there. Stumbled onto The Deli off of First Street while walking around and wow, so glad I did! Ordered a half Italian and it was packed full of flavor and seasoned very well. Definitely will be back next time I'm in town to try other options and take a photo of the menu! Staff was very friendly as well! read more

See all

Got the cheesesteak sando and classic turkey press. This place is super cute and continent located right in the center of Ned's First Street. The cheesesteak is served on a fluffy roll and is the perfect cheese-to-meat-to-everything-else ratio (the onions and mushrooms rock too). My usual order is the Turkey Press which is a favorite but after going with the Cheesesteak today I may be a convert. Awesome deli with awesome vibes service and sandwiches. Come check them out! Perfect spot for a grab-and-go sando before a hike or trip to Barker Reservoir. read more

See all

Excellent house made while you wait sandwiches. Big enough to share. Boars Head products. Seating available. Service is not fast, but the resulting sandwiches are worth the wait. Canned and bottled drinks available. Nothing fancy here. If you are in Nederland at lunchtime, this is a place well worth considering. read more

See all

Great place to get a sandwich and buy some papers. Good view of the creek and community garden. Good vibes always!! read more

Been coming here for years. Best sandwich shop in town. Service is quick and food is tasty. Today's lunch was the turkey Reuben. Perfect blend of thin rye, moist turkey pastrami, and soft sauerkraut. read more

We stopped in Nederland on the way to Estes Park and wanted to grab a quick bite. We split the Italian and it was delicious! Really gotta hand it to them, they know how to make a great sandwich! Hoping for continued success for this place. read more

Philly cheese steak was lacking but that's on him for ordering a pile of meat on bread anywhere but the east coast. turkey press was fab. Bros behind the counter are bros I would love to Have as best friends. read more

The Deli At 8236 - Fire - Delis Near Me - Nederland, Colorado

Great sandwiches! I have had a Philly, Chicago beef and and Italian. All very good. Great atmosphere, super friendly employees and nice outdoor seating read more

Out of this world sandwiches and a nice porch to eat on. Great, kind service with a very-Ned- vibe.

Place reminds me of a deli I'd frequent back on the East coast. All the sandwiches are amazing. My go-to is the eggplant parm. The bread is always fresh and the service is on point! read more

The Deli is 5 star. Count on it. They make the best sandwich I've had since I left NY three years ago. It's not on the menu, but I order the American Combo, a classic made with turkey, ham and roast beef. Otherwise choose from the cold or hot sandwich menu read more

The Deli At 8236 - Delis Near Me - Nederland, Colorado

We ordered lunch for a visit from our CEO. Now we're stuck with the Deli for his next visit. They handled last-minute changes with aplomb, and were still ready on time with the best pastrami west of the Mississippi. Thanks, Ross and team. read more

A delicious deli with kind and generous owners, reasonable prices, and a nice spot to enjoy a meal. Their $8 breakfast sandwich with tomato and pesto is stellar! Highly recommended! I will be back. read more

LOVE this place. & it has a nice view. The Cuban is my favorit, but there's a TON of great choices

Mmmmmm... Love me some deli sammies. Wicked stoner joint. Great place to feed a crew :)

Great tasting, fresh, made to order sandwiches. Today I had a Vegetarian Reuben -Eggplant, kraut, Swiss cheese. Delicious! Friendly service. read more

The Deli At 8236 - Delis Near Me - Nederland, Colorado

Stopped at this small deli at random while passing through town, totally unaware that we were about to have the best sandwiches of our life. Husband ordered the chicken parm while I selected the Athena. This was on day 3 of a fairly romantic honeymoon trip through Colorado, yet I moaned more while eating that sandwich than I had for the entire trip to that point. (Sorry babe.) Service was also excellent, fast, and friendly, but I would have rated 5 stars if they had spit in the food and cursed us out. Sandwich is that good. read more

So many yummy options : I love the Chicken Parm & the Meatball Sub- and their breakfast sandwiches are delicious too! (**MUST ADD - spicy peppers!! ) ...and do not miss their Cannolis!! Best dessert in town! read more

I don't have a lot to say other than that this place makes consistently delicious sandwiches from fresh ingredients. My favorite is the mozzarella fresca and my husband enjoys the Chicago beef. A great place for a quick lunch, though less good for dinner as they aren't open very late, particularly on weekdays. read more

Absolutely delicious sandwiches! We had 3 different ones. Nice people. Not fast but worth the wait!

Decent eggplant parm. Parking a bit challenging. Prices good. Staff - owner was cool. Fun posters.

Advice: Go where the locals eat... yup EVERY TIME! This small deli served great subs with high quality ingredients. We had a Turkey Press, a Cheesesteak Hoagie, and a New England Clam Chowder. (We were so hungry and the food was so yummy that I forgot to take a picture!) ABSOLUTELY AMAZING! The ambiance was welcoming and staff was friendly. PS: music was also great:) read more

The Deli At 8236 - Delis Near Me - Nederland, Colorado

I was up in the mountains today and stopped by for lunch after checking reviews for this place which were very good for the most part. Service was good. The interior of the restaurant was decent, but dated. I ordered the Philly Cheesesteak to go. Just to let you know, I am very picky about bread. Unfortunately, my sandwich did not have very good bread. But, I think that most folks would be happy with the bread here. It's a very typical soft loaf, like what you might find at the supermarket. I'm not trying to be mean, just giving you my honest opinion. If you've gone here and like their sandwiches, more power to ya! read more

Subs prepared while you wait with delicious ingredients. Do not skip the potato salad since it was tasty too. The music added to ambiance. All in all a wonderful lunch spot. read more

Stopped in for lunch after a morning hike. After reading the reviews and seeing the pictures other yelpers posted, we were exited for a quick sandwich. They have both hot and cold sandwiches listed, we opted for the philly and french dip. With only a few people ahead of us in line, we weren't expecting a long wait. I'm sure we caught them at a bad time, but it was at least half an hour before we got our sandwiches and seemed at some point that they forgot about us. Three have several tables lined up against the wall and we snagged one in the back while waiting. When we finally got our sandwich, they were decently warm. The philly was good and flavorful, they didn't skim on meat and veggies! read more

Great deli! Chicken Parmesan sub was AWESOME! the guy who made it even seasoned and toasted the bread. He actually suggested the chicken parm and it was a great suggestion. I would definitely go back anytime! read more

Came in and ordered the turkey press. It was during an off time so it took a bit longer to get my food. The sandwich was tasty but a bit on the smaller side. (Remember the smoosh factor!) Overall, great stop. read more

The Deli At 8236 - Turkey press - Delis Near Me - Nederland, Colorado

Do you love sandwiches? You should eat here. I've been here a few times, but was really inspired after a trip last week to share the love. My Cuban was AMAZING. Hot and crusty without being greasy, it was perfectly toasted and the fresh meats and cheese make a huge difference. The staff person was really helpful as I tried to make up my mind about lunch (everything sounded delicious). He even gave us advice about other places to check out in town. The Deli is a great place to stop during events in Ned, after ski days at Eldora, or whenever you just really want a good sandwich from cool people. read more

The Deli At 8236 - The Cuban! - Delis Near Me - Nederland, Colorado

This place is so good!!! We ordered 4 different subs and they were all so delicious. We didn't leave anything behind. The service was quick and friendly. We will definitely be going back for subs next time we're in Colorado. read more

I had the steak(beef) and cheddar sandwich up here during Frozen Dead Guy Days. The staff did a very good job at cranking out good quality sandwiches in a timely fashion despite the large crowd that was here for the event. My sandwich was delicious and the brownie I had equally so! Despite the small restaurant being busy there always seemed to be someone there to ask me if I needed anything else. Very well managed! I went by another restaurant that I was considering but the line was out the door! Here at Bella's I was able to get a seat and enjoy my lunch! I will definitely keep this place in mind next time I am in Nederland! read more

The food from the Deli has stayed consistent throughout this crisis and in fact, the menu has expanded to include the best Stromboli and calzones I've had since moving here 15 years ago from the Philly area. Their door side system of paying and picking up works great. Go Deli 8236! read more

They have it all! From tasty subs to killer soups, the Deli in Nederland rules your tastebuds from start to scrumptious finish. It as if the people who make your sammich really care about the tender loving every sub needs from their hands to yours. They even have cannolis A must try for anyone visiting! read more

Stopped through Nederland during a trip to look at investment properties and found this little gem. They were taking orders at the door to keep everyone distanced. The sandwiches were so fresh! Everything from the fresh baked bread, to the sliced meat and cold vegetables were delicious. Another plus is they are fast. In less than 10 min I had my order. Will stop by again when in the area!! read more