Cy's Deli was fantastic, and I'll definitely be back. There were so many sandwiches on the menu that I wanted to try, but we ended up ordering the Rachel and the Papa Bino. The Papa Bino was easily one of the best Italian sandwiches I've ever had. The Rachel was phenomenal too. It's basically a Reuben made with turkey instead of corned beef, and I was pleasantly surprised by how much I enjoyed it. Both sandwiches were very flavorful and were made with quality ingredients. The service was excellent too; The woman working the counter was incredibly friendly and welcoming. We ate out on the patio, and it had such a great vibe for enjoying lunch on a warm day. If you're looking for a quality sandwich shop with great food, and a relaxed atmosphere, Cy's Deli is definitely worth a visit. read more

The service was fast and friendly. Friendly prices as well. Had the Rueben, which was well proportioned and the marble rye was very tasty. The pasta salad was average for my taste, a little too salty but again, that's just my taste. The Persuasion bar was a perfect after meal addition. I'd definitely go back. read more

Superb lunch spot. Sandwiches are huge-- fairly pricey -- consider sharing with a friend. Even a half was a lot for me. Service was friendly, helpful and efficient. Cy's has a fairly large kid's meal selection that will surely have something that will please even your most finicky eaters. Cookies are also decadently large. Patio is covered, dog friendly and painted in cool, pleasing colors. Counter is well stocked with foil and other items to wrap up what you were unable to consume on site. read more

See all

Food, service, ambiance- all amazing! The sandwiches and the bread they came in were some of the best ingredients I have ever had in a sandwich! My mom got the Rueben and my sister got the tuna- both also delicious! Highly recommend the pasta salad as a side! The people that work there are so kind and patient! The patio is dog and kid friendly! Highly recommend! read more

Cy's Deli - The Rachel - Delis Near Me - Grand Lake, Colorado

My wife and I ordered the #1 Melt and Roast and Toast from Cy's Deli to go to take to RMNP. Both sandwiches were a nice size and came with a side. We ended up getting coleslaw and pasta salad for our sides. The melt was my favorite with a generous amount of avocado and the tasty honey wheat bread. The roast and toast was delicious with the roasted red pepper aioli. The service was excellent and the deli had a cozy atmosphere. Definitely recommend this deli if you're looking for a good sandwich. read more

See all

The food tasted fresh and the sandwiches were quite large and delicious. The order taker was friendly and helpful.

So good! Huge sandwich and terrific pasta salad. #1 Melt with turkey, Swiss, guac and fixings. Highly recommend and patio is dog friendly.

This is a perfect little lunch spot. Fresh tasting food with HUGE sandwiches. We had the Tic Tac and #1 Melt. Super good! Dog friendly porch area! read more

Cy's Deli - Tic tac sandwich with coleslaw - Delis Near Me - Grand Lake, Colorado

See all

Had great sandwiches made for a day on the water... great tasting and very filling! Wonderful for food for boating, hiking, or time at the beach!!! Definitely recommend Cy's! read more

The sandwiches were big, the bread was delicious and fresh and the sandwiches had great flavor. The staff was friendly and helpful! Great way to spend lunch in the mountains! read more

I love this place so much that I've gone there both days of my trip here! This cute and casual restaurant only serves breakfast and lunch. You order at the window and can either take it to go or eat outdoors on the patio. The latte is so rich and good! I also got breakfast sandwiches both days - eggs, cheese and a avocado on an English muffin. My husband enjoyed the breakfast burrito yesterday and the Rueben sandwich today. The staff is friendly and the food is fresh and speedy. Highly recommend! read more

Cy's Deli - Breakfast sandwich - Delis Near Me - Grand Lake, Colorado

Papa Bino is the way to go!!! Italian yummy-nes!! The Reuben was good as well, but I would definitely get the Papa Bino next time!! The bread with the Italian dressing... just perfection. read more

Ok .. I'm a foodie and kinda picky. I struggled to find anything really good to eat on this trip. Scenery and wildlife were amazing .. food was a struggle. I don't do burgers and struggle with meat. I was thrilled this deli had white meat tuna salad sandwiches. the bread was good ... sandwich was very good but large. I wish we would have just shared a sandwich and chips. My husband got the rubin and it was also good .. meat tender and lean. we tried the pasta salad .. it was just ok .. rather plain. If your in the area .. i recommend this deli. They had some seating inside and out. Dog bowl nice touch. read more

See all

Wonderful customer service! Friendly staff, went above and beyond to make sure we had everything we wanted. It's well-shaded outside and very clean. It was $24 for my daughter and I, so not very expensive considering this touristy town. The food was delicious! I had The Tic Tac and it was huge! I could only eat half. Thank you so much! read more

Leaving a review since I don't see enough people talking about the pastrami yumi. Perfect bread, perfect cookies, wouldn't change anything if I could. read more

Ordered the tic tic and king albacore sandwiches, with slaw and pasta salad respectively. Spacious outdoor area for safe dining during COVID. At $14.25 a bit pricey for deli sandwiches, but the taste was very good. read more

Came in with my wife and two girls ages 5 and 7. We all loved it! Menu has plenty on it and had lots of choices. Restaurant is clean and service is helpful nice and friendly. Food was great and came out fast. Chips, beer and wine are nice adds. They are under new ownership and unfortunately the Yelp page and website are not updated yet since they cannot get access. I would definitely come here again. read more

AMAZING! We enjoyed eating the deli sandwiches near the lake. You may have to wait a while for your sandwiches but it is worth the wait! read more

Cy's Deli - We both got their #1 deli sandwiches and loved it! - Delis Near Me - Grand Lake, Colorado

Best deli I've been to yet, everything we ordered was amazing! Everything in the sandwiches & wraps were refreshingly cold. Excellent sauces & flavors! Not your standard deli. Coming back for sure when we're out this way!! read more

The food is absolutely delicious and the service is great! I also love that they have vegan options.

New owners. What a shame the old owners are gone. They may have been the hardest workers in GL. They are gone and the owners of Blue Water bakery now own this place. blue water is notorious for putting out stale stuff and trying to pass it off as new. Stopped in for a breakfast burrito and it was almost 14.00. No thanks read more

Cy's Deli - Delicious - Delis Near Me - Grand Lake, Colorado

Amazing food nice people and great service I would highly recommend this place if your In grand lake

Great food and a sunny outside deck! Many options with beer and wine too. I go as often as possible in the summer. read more

We ordered several sandwiches for a family gathering. They did an excellent job working with us and had our sandwiches all ready when we arrived to pick them up. We were able to split the sandwiches as they were so big. The coleslaw didn't have a lot too it but it tasted good when added to the sandwich. read more

This place came highly recommended by two of my fave people. They're right to do so! The sandwiches here are huge. After backpacking at a nearby Twinberry Trail in RMNP we ended up with the most gnarly intention of eating all their sandwiches. Well at least that's what I had in mind. There's a line. Don't let that deter you. It's worth it. Looking down at my sandwich and then looked up at Boombox we both decided that next time we share one. Yeah. Even for two hungry female backpacking gorillas it's still too big. I had the Papa Bino. It's creamy Italian, Pistachio mortadella, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, tomatoe, red onion and pepperocini with French. Toasted or cold. I opted for toasted. It will get wet. By that I mean the bread. ( your dirty mind should stay dirty. I like that :) So that's where the sharing is coming from considering you can't bag this big bad boy. So yeah. Order at the counter. Find a place to park your sexy thing and then wait for them to call your name. read more

See all

Great sandwich and kind service. They will pack up your meal so you can take it in the park for a picnic. read more

Charming lunch oasis close to the western entrance to Rocky Mountain National Park in Grand Lake. There's free parking in the street and plenty of outdoor seating. You order your food and drink at their deck ordering window, and they take your prepayment and name, so you can later pick up your order at another window, where you can also pick up aluminum foil, napkins and utensils, and you can pick up some cold water as well. We sat in their shaded patio. Outdoor seating in the patio. There are small seating tables in the covered deck as well. I had their Reuben sandwich, which was huge and came with a side of pasta salad, and my girlfriend had the Grand Avenue wrap, with turkey/roasted red pepper hummus/provolone/cole slaw, also substantial, and with a side of pasta salad. We both ate one half of our sandwiches and foiled wrapped the other half to take on our hike later at Rocky Mountain National Park. With beers and tip the tab was close to $40, but the service was fast, the pickup setup was efficient, and you cannot beat the location if you are planning to visit the national park after lunch. read more

See all

What kind of Deli does not have oil and vinegar? This place is the perfect example of becoming too boujie. Massive disappointment. Also the staff did not know the difference between cheddar and American. If you have a picky kid do not waste your money here. read more

We tried 5 separate sandwiches and all were equally delicious. The Reuben was the best I've ever had. The #1 was super delicious, we added bacon. The Pappa Bino was tasty. The Roasted and Toasted was awesome. We had one custom made sandwich which was also good. The side slaw was delicious - vinegar based dressing was delicious. Can't beat a $2 Pabst Blue Ribbon with lunch. The outdoor seating area was breezy and clean. The service was fast, friendly and delicious. All sandwiches were super fresh and tasty. Staff was super pleasant. read more

See all

Big sandwiches! Easily one would feed two. Loved the bread they are served on. Went with the roast beef and red pepper delicious. My husband had the tuna fish and said it was good too. The pasta salad was good too' read more

Pastrami was outstanding and the turkey sandwich was very good. Also ordered a latte that was yummy. Good stop for to go.

We always look forward to spring and the reopening of Cy's! They have fantastic breads! I adore The Option and the Hearty Arti. The Tic Tac is also amazing. Yummm persuasion bars:-) Nice little patio to sit out on have a great sandwich and a beer. read more

Papabino & Ruben both highly recommended! Fast, tasty, great location! Great stop after a trip through the Rocky Mountain Ntl Park. read more

Cy's Deli - Ruben, pasta salad, dessert bar! - Delis Near Me - Grand Lake, Colorado

Service was very nice and friendly! Food was bland and had no flavor. Pasta salad was basically noodles in oil - no seasoning, no flavor at all. Save your $$$. read more

Best sandwich in Grand Lake, the godmother of the goods, really good coleslaw best added to any sandwich. I only wish it was open year around. read more

We went because the reviews were good. The sandwiches were just terrible. I cannot understand how it's reviewed so high. It's also very expensive, but it's in a tourist town so that's really not unexpected. read more

my "cappuccino", was just boiling hot milk with no froth, the sandwich was dreadfully bad, stone cold and took almost 40 minutes to come out, on a tuesday at lunch time. ridiculous overpriced sandwiches, slow service. avoid read more

Wonderful sandwiches. This place really knows what they're doing. Wish I'd found it sooner. And super clean!

The service was fast, friendly and helpful, the food was delicious and they could accommodate our gluten-free and dairy free family members. Definitely a great place to stop! read more

Cy's Deli - Delis Near Me - Grand Lake, Colorado

Summary- Very good sandwich place with fresh ingredients and friendly help. Food- 3.5 Stars We had "The Option" and a Roast beef sandwich the name of which I cannot remember. Bread for both was excellent. The Option was a very good veggy sandwich, we both enjoyed it mucho. The roast beef sandwich I got was fine, but was light on the meat for me (2-3 slices flat on a pretty big roll), and it was well done roast beef which I hate. I really really liked the house coleslaw, it may have saved them from 3 stars overall. Atmosphere- 4 Stars Nice outdoor area and clean inside. Service- 4 Stars Very friendly and nice help. Value- 3 Stars About where it belongs, I think cash loses value at high altitude from what I saw. read more