Please indulge me as I review The Donut Mill using two hypothetical donut situations. 1) If I get anywhere near this place I'm like an old satellite that's lost the ability to avoid the Donut Mill's gravitational pull before my face collides happily with a pile of donuts. 2) If my doctor tells me that each donut from The Donut Mill will cost me an hour of my life, I will choose to leave this earth with a mouth full of donuts and a smile. read more

This place is amazing. We always look for a donut shop when roadtripping, and this is our favorite by far. The shop looks a little run down on the outside, but the taste of the donuts makes up for this 100x over. So light & airy, and the Apple bear claw was to die for. The price was even amazing, $12 for 6 really big donuts. If I am ever in the area I am definitely going back! read more

The Donut Mill - 2x glazed, chocolate glazed, Boston crème, maple glazed, apple bear claw - Donuts Near Me - Eureka, California

See all

Went to The Donut Mill and was so impressed with the donuts! I had a maple bar that' was so delicious! I usually go to a more popular Eureka donut shop, but this was on my route so I gave it a try. By comparison this was a larger fluffier donut with a slight crunch to it, tasted better and was so much less expensive. I will be going to the Donut Mill from now on. read more

This place was pretty good! It was really cheap and the ENORMOUS donuts were delicious. I got a ham and cheese croissant and it was pretty good, but a little bit heavy. I saw a cop getting a doughnut here so you know it's real. read more

We got an apple fritter that had crumbles on top that was just ok. No apples that we could detect. We also got a custard stuffed maple bar that was divine. Even though only one of the two donuts deserved a five star rating, it was so good that my overall rating is a five. read more

Fantastic doughnuts with a large variety. However, very difficult to communicate with staff as they don't seem to understand English.

Good selection of donuts, fair pricing and fast service. They also have a drive thru!

Best donuts and croissants Been living in humboldt for 6+ yrs and we have passed by so many times. One day we decided to stop by and now that's the only donuts we buy read more

The donuts were so good, the service was amazing, it had a great environment, donuts and came out fresh and fast. The young asian teenager was so kind. Im definitely coming back here really soon. read more

WOW! The best donut shop in the area. Fresh and incredibly delicious with a wide variety of pastries. Not to miss. Loved the apple fritters. read more

Got a dozen jelly donuts for our Hanukah dinner party. They were the very best donuts I've ever eaten and our guests agreed. Light and fluffy not to mention delicious!! read more

The donuts and coffee at this establishment are unbelievably amazing! The latte was delightful and the owners are very kind and considerate. The Apple Bear Claw was SUPERB! I will come by again to try the boba! read more

The Donut Mill - Yummy old fashioned donut and Apple Bear Claw with lattes! - Donuts Near Me - Eureka, California

I bought the biggest and best apple fritters I've ever had. SO good! The gentleman at the drive-thru was very friendly. And the convenience of the drive thru window was very much appreciated. We will be back to try some of their other delicacies soon. read more

Donut shop with a drive-thru! [Eureka CA] Stopped by one morning for some road trip sweets heading to Crescent City. We walked inside to check out the selection. They have a nice assortment of classics with a lot of my favorites. I got a raised glazed, chocolate, and a cinnamon roll. The cinnamon roll was moist inside and not bread-like. Yummy fresh, pillow soft donuts! For those with time to spare, they have a few tables inside where they have complimentary morning newspaper for your reading pleasure. Read the papers while enjoying your coffee and donut. For timeline purposes the big news at this time was Russia invading Ukraine. I digress. The shop is family-owned and are friendly and helpful. Cool that they have a drive-thru window. The only donut places with a drive-thru in our area are chain establishments. Fast and easy and we were on our merry way... they are located off of Highway 101. You don't have to exit because US 101 cuts through the City of Eureka, I know, it's weird. Anyway... the best donuts in Eureka! Review #2520 read more

See all

Friendly and tasty boba drinks. Drive-thru service near humboldt library. Convenient. read more

The Donut Mill - Mango boba shake - Donuts Near Me - Eureka, California

Best place to bring your kids for donuts. Family friendly, great staff, organized but most importantly THEE FLUFFIEST NOT TOO SWEET DONUTS IVE EVER HAD 10/10 read more

The Donut Mill - The best donut I've ever had. - Donuts Near Me - Eureka, California

Wonderful fluffy donut bars. People get your fresh daily donuts here. Drive thru on your way to work.

haven't been there in years. hard to get there having to use the bus. back then the donuts were fabulous the best in eureka.

I love the Donut Mill. Not only do they have amazing donuts, but they also have amazing pastries and drinks! I love their croissants, especially the ham and cheese one. They have great prices and great service. Very friendly people. I love how I can drive up or go inside. 10/10 recommend! read more

The Donut Mill - Menu as of February 2024 - Donuts Near Me - Eureka, California

Friendliest people, best prices and delicious donuts!! We discovered Donut Mill after more than one negative experience at "the other place," that we supported for years!" read more

We were in Eureka over night and got up early to go for a walk. We came across The Donut Mill on our walk to the bay. It didn't look like much from the outside, but there were a few cars that had stopped, so we decided to get a donut and coffee on our way back to our hotel. What a great place. The owners are so sweet! The donuts were fresh and delicious and the coffee was hot and tasty. We were heading out the door when one of the owner's said, "see you tomorrow". We told him we were on a road trip and were heading out that morning. He asked where we were from and made a little small talk. Before we walked out the door, he wished us safe travels with the biggest smile. Cheers! read more

The donuts here were actually the best donuts i've ever had! it was not too sweet and super fluffy and light. The worker and service were excellent. read more

Donuts were excellent! My chai tea latte was also very good with fresh cinnamon. The double espresso latte was STRONG. The atmosphere was charming old school donut shop. There open till 5 pm and we're already making plans to come back Service was friendly warm and quick. Parking a little dicey-had to get a little creative but def worth it! read more

Humboldt is not known for donuts, to be honest, most of them are not great. This place however has the freshest, best tasting donuts anywhere around. They remind me of old school donut shop from LA donuts. The family that runs it is super friendly and kind and just make the experience great. They have a drive up service, but just park and go on inside for the full experience. It looks rough walking in from the outside, but I promise it will be worth it. read more

Sooo many options and all equally delicious, I'm sure. Bubble tea smoothies were fantastic! Service was quick and courteous. read more

THE best donuts I have ever eaten! Language barrier a little though but finally got there. They even fulfilled a special request of filling maple bars with custard. To die for!!!!!!!!!!! Latte, ok not perfect. Will be back! read more

Fresh delicious doughnuts and a very nice family business. They have a half size fritter, popping boba and excellent coffee.

Tasty and fresh donuts from a locally owned business. The brewed coffee was also very good with a selection of 4 different roasts.

Delicious classic donuts. I had a maple bar and an apple fritter from here. The maple bar was excellent--fresh, a high quality yeast donut with a great glaze. But the apple fritter was the real star! It was bursting with flavor, was very fresh, and the texture was on point. Those are my two favorite donuts (in the world of classic donuts) and the donut mill nailed both of them. read more

Great friendly service and a donuts are exquisite. Cinnamon rolls are probably the best

The french cruller doughnuts are the lightest, fluffiest I have ever had The maple old fashioned doughnuts are cooked to a golden perfection with a slight vanilla flavor and the most pleasant smooth maple flavor Going back on my way home to try more doughnuts and possibly a drink read more

I love the apple fritters here, at least for a while I will not be going back. The last two times I have been through the drive through they have messed up My order: first time I ordered two apple fritters, they gave me one and kept the change. The second time I again asked for two apple fritters, even checked the bag, though did not notice I got two cinnamon rolls. Today I went in to talk to them about it, and when I explained I just wanted to try to prevent it from happening in the future the manager laughed and told me "No." To be treated that way when I was only looking to problem solve, not looking for a refund or free donuts was insulting. Any business should treat customers better. read more

The people there are super nice and friendly. I came in on Mothers Day and they even gave me an extra small donut. The donuts are super good, freshly made and with many varieties, I wish they are nearby so that I could purchase from them everyday. read more

The Donut Mill - Entrance - Donuts Near Me - Eureka, California

See all

I love the Do it Mill. I do not order donuts (although they are great). I order buttermilk bars which are wonderful. I usually order them plain but sometimes I get a glaze on them. It is always a treat when we stop to order and the Buttermilk Bars are truly enjoyed! read more

Good food and service. Cute family owned restaurant. Good coffee. Just off PCH and perfect for a quick snack. read more

The Donut Mill - Menu - Donuts Near Me - Eureka, California

See all

Visiting from Fort Bragg and tried the donut mill for National Donut Day June 7th 2024, raised donuts were warm etherial puffs of spun angel dust, too good to believe. Never dont sop at the donut mill! read more

Amazing donuts every time I go, and always open when I need them to be. Super fresh donuts clearly made with love a great drinks. I think their seating is super cute & retro especially with the plants! Amazing service, making the best donuts in Humboldt! read more

We have lived in Eureka nearly 20 years, and have never found better apple fritters. The owners are pleasant, efficient and always friendly, even when they're busy... which is always, in the mornings. They rarely, but occasionally, run out of apple fritters, so go late, after I've gotten mine! read more

The Donut Mill - Apple fritters are AMAZING! The old fashioned donuts are excellent as well. Here's one, shown for size comparison with a fritter - Donuts Near Me - Eureka, California

Perhaps the Best Donuts I've ever had . The establishment is clean , the employees are nice and service is great. I'll most certainly be back ! read more

Asked for a chocolate bar and threw in donut holes on the house! It's always nice giving business to small establishments and these are nice, hardworking people. Soft, fluffy donuts that keep me coming back! read more