Cancel

Open app

Search

The Forgotten Toy Box

5.0 (5 reviews)
Closed • 11:00 am - 6:00 pm
Updated 2 months ago

The Forgotten Toy Box Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - The Forgotten Toy Box

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

3 years ago

Helpful 6
Thanks 1
Love this 9
Oh no 0
Photo of Maya C.
451
1233
4856

4 years ago

Helpful 5
Thanks 0
Love this 5
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Toy Stores 671 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Gotham City Limit - FCBD 2026

Gotham City Limit

4.9(29 reviews)
1.1 mi•Southside

Every time that I swing by to pick up my pull and any time that I walk through the door, I'm…read morereminded why our local geek community loves Gotham City Limit so much. The energy is always high, the vibes are immaculate, and the staff keeps the shelves stocked with a ridiculous variety of comics, collectibles, action figures, FUNKO Pops, short boxes, supplies, and more. It's literally the kind of place where you can lose an hour without even realizing it. First off, say hello to Pacer, the AMAZING shop dog and official mascot of Gotham City Limit. He's the sweetest, the best greeter, and the best browsing buddy. Who doesn't want to shop with a good boy by your side? If you don't see Ben, you'll definitely hear his greeting from somewhere in the store as that man is just nonstop. Ben's dedication shows, especially on Free Comic Book Day and special release days, when Gotham City Limit turns into a full-blown celebration. On top of that, he partners with Jacksonville Public Library when they host comic-centered events and you'll see him at different conventions throughout the year. Ben makes sure everyone, from kids to hardcore collectors, feels welcome and included. Also big love to Jonathan (one of the OGs of comic shops in Jax) and Santana, who are always ready to talk storylines, their newest recommendations, or help you find the one issue that you didn't know you were missing. My pull list will ebb and flow depending on what is being released or if I want single issues of something. However, the numero uno items that I always want to see are the latest Baby Marvel covers from Skottie Young. The team has my account tagged for those specifically, and that kind of attention to detail is incredible. It's the kind of personal touch that makes you feel truly seen as a collector and fan. Gotham City Limit is a little slice of geeky heaven in Jax and one of the last remaining locally owned comic shops in this area of town. So make sure to swing by for a visit sometime soon and, as Ben says, always take it to the limit!

Great selection of Comics and toys and the owner, Ben is very knowledgeable and enthusiastic about…read morecomics

Photos
Gotham City Limit - Ben and team sold out of these but managed to find some more. They really know how to take care of their customers.

Ben and team sold out of these but managed to find some more. They really know how to take care of their customers.

Gotham City Limit - FCBD 2026

FCBD 2026

Gotham City Limit - Always has the best stuff in stock with a wide variety.

See all

Always has the best stuff in stock with a wide variety.

2nd & Charles - Interior wall decor

2nd & Charles

3.2(58 reviews)
2.4 mi•Southside
•$

I could have spent 3 more hours here and still not gotten bored. There are soooo many options for…read morebooks, merch, vinyl, DVDs, and so much more! The staff were super helpful and the prices were great!! You need to spend time sorting thru all the options they offer but it's worth it to see what they have. If you bring in items you can get points to spend on items for purchase. The vibes are chill but the staff are professional without being stuffy. If you're in the area, it's def worth going and seeing what they have to offer.

This store is in the area of the Town Center. It's always clean with many employees to answer any…read morequestions. 2nd & Charles is mostly a used book store but it is also a lot more. The books here are mostly in brand new condition and sold at a heavily discounted price. Books from travel to cook books to novels to almost anything you can think of are available. If you have collectors to buy for they have a huge collection of Funko Pops to choose from. They also have old and new comic books with many used comic books only selling for a dollar or two each. A few packs of unopened sports card packs are for sale and don't leave the store without a pack of Jelly Bellies which are usually kept by the registers. On this visit they also had many holiday gift ideas on a few of the displays. Fun place to look at stuff and buy things you need or things you didn't know you need. Check it out because it's a fun place or just a place to pick out a new book.

Photos
2nd & Charles - Another row of Pop

Another row of Pop

2nd & Charles - A few rows several deep of Funko Pops for the kids or collectors

A few rows several deep of Funko Pops for the kids or collectors

2nd & Charles - My book purchase

See all

My book purchase

House of Collectibles

House of Collectibles

5.0(7 reviews)
27.0 mi

Fun local store packed with vintage books, magazines, toys, and records. Owners are friendly and…read moreknowledgeable. Definitely worth a visit if you're in the area.

Really loved experience we had at house of collectibles. The owner, older gentleman named Mr…read more French., could not have been nicer and more helpful. And he has a few stories to tell. His son came in at one point and helped us with the purchase of some albums. They have albums that are open and albums that are sealed, and they have a lot of genres of music to choose from. I ended up buying a Pink Floyd album that I had been trying to locate and it was sealed. I didn't want to open it because that would decrease the value so I called back to see if they had an open copy which they did so I went back the next day and bought it. I don't know I could really explain everything that's in the store. Their books, paperback and hardback. But more than that, they have first edition, signed books by the author and kids books as well. You know what else they have? They have albums, but I already mentioned that. But what I didn't mention was I have three or four rooms of albums. They're on the floor. They're in boxes. They're on racks. So if you're looking for certain music, make sure that you leave yourself enough time to look.. They also have comic books. And trade paperbacks. And graphic novels. They have baseball cards. They have garbage pail cards. They have collectibles, figures, Star Wars, stuff. Yes, lots and lots of stuff . Thoroughly enjoyed shopping here and meeting Mr. French and talking to his son. I know this may not be everybody's jam, but for me I really enjoyed spending time browsing looking and yes, buying.

Photos
House of Collectibles
House of Collectibles

See all

Jack’s Comics & More - In the new location, the left wall contains shelves of graphic novels, trade paperbacks, and other comics collectibles.

Jack’s Comics & More

4.9(14 reviews)
31.5 mi
•$

This store now has a new location (in the same shopping center) and a new name: Jack's Comics &…read moreMore. Owner Jack Tolzmann has made it fully a comic book store now, devoting space that used to be shelves of used books to more graphic novels and collectibles. There's a selection of kid-friendly comic books at the back right corner and teen graphic novels to your right when you enter. New releases go up on the wall every Wednesday. This store has been helping Saint Augustine geek out since 1986.

Honestly there is no easy way to start but here goes, THIS PLACE IS AWESOME. Being my first time in…read morea comic book store this store has tons and tons and tons of comics going from old to new releases. I've been hunting MAD Magazines for the longest online doesn't help with people setting outrageous prices for them, once I collected my comics I asked the cashier if he had any MAD Magazines and once he said yes it was like the heaven sound I immediately left majority of the ones I had before and went through that box with an urge lol I found so many and took almost half since he had them for the best prices I didn't get the chance to get his name but the cashier knew his stuff me just browsing around and overhearing his conversation with someone else and him knowing so much about regardless of the topic I most certainly and definitely will be returning here no doubt it best service by far. Highly recommend

Photos
Jack’s Comics & More - The store sign now reads Jack's Comics, reflecting the change from All Books and Comics.

The store sign now reads Jack's Comics, reflecting the change from All Books and Comics.

Jack’s Comics & More
Jack’s Comics & More - The exterior of All Books & Comics, which is across from Target and next to Ray's Tire.

See all

The exterior of All Books & Comics, which is across from Target and next to Ray's Tire.

Mythical Mountain Jacksonville

Mythical Mountain Jacksonville

4.5(24 reviews)
8.9 mi•Southside
•$$

We planned to be in Mandarin over the weekend so I suggested be stop in at Mythical Mountain while…read morewe were out that way. If you love comics and pop culture in general, you really need to stop by this store. We try to stop in whenever we're over in Mandarin. While I've never been big into comic books, I've always loved pop culture collectibles. I know they can't carry everything in store but every time we're in there I'm amazed by how much they do have on hand. Sure, there are huge online stores that you can order tons of things from but like always, I'd rather support a local Jacksonville business if at all possible. Especially if it's a place I've received great customer service from before and that's the case with Mythical Mountain. We've called ahead before when we were looking for gifts and had them remember the call hours later when we got to the store and helped us find the perfect gift. I took a few pics to share but I still don't think it gives you a good idea of how much stuff they have in the store. I didn't find anything I wanted to pick up today but my wife found a Mick Foley action figure that she bought for herself, so that's a win for America. If you needed any further proof of the level of customer service and care they provide, you don't really need to look further than the most recent post I made about them in the the Jacksonville Fun, Eats & Drinks Facebook group. I posted a recap of our most recent visit in the group and mentioned the part you just read about how I didn't find anything then I mentioned that I need to call them some time to see if they can get their hands on one of the Michael Jackson figures made by Blitzway because they seem like the type of store that might be able to get that type of thing. Then I went on to say that even if they can't get it, I'd still rather try if I can go through a local place first before somewhere online. Within minutes, the store owner left a comment asking me to send her a DM with information on what I'm looking for to see if she can help. See what I mean? You can't get that kind of customer service from any online store, no matter how big and bad they are... If you like stuff like this, stop in at Mythical Mountain in Mandarin some time. Even if collectables or comics aren't your thing, I bet you could find a gift for someone you know at this store with ease. As I mentioned, a version of this post originally appeared in the Jacksonville Fun, Eats & Drinks Facebook group.

A great place for anime fans and collectors. They have a great selection and the prices are…read morereasonable. The staff is very helpful and will try to order something if not in stock. Will definitely be back.

Photos
Mythical Mountain Jacksonville - Tried to work with mythical Mountain on consignment.  A female worker there berated me hard.  Then continued to disrespect a customer.

Tried to work with mythical Mountain on consignment. A female worker there berated me hard. Then continued to disrespect a customer.

Mythical Mountain Jacksonville
Mythical Mountain Jacksonville

See all

The Forgotten Toy Box - toys - Updated June 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...