I absolutely love going to Old Buff! They have great food; a full bar; and friendly, hard-working…read morewaitresses. The rustic decor is welcoming, and their patio is large and beautiful. I am always recommending this bar/restaurant to friends!

Really enjoyed our first visit! We ordered the spiced old fashioned cocktail special. I was a…read morelittle skeptical because they use small ice cubes, which can tend to water down the drink, but they were really good! I had two! Sufficiently strong and not watered down. The onion rings appetizer were really good. Make with real onion, not chopped, pre-processed. Nicely breaded and crispy. My husband and a friend had the Thursday bbq rib special with Mac & cheese and slaw and they cleaned their plates. I got the traditional wings and requested them well done. They cooked them perfectly. The buffalo sauce is different, but really delicious! Maybe the best I've had! Towards the end of our meal we discovered it was bingo night! We played and it was fun! The only problem for us was being seated near the front of the restaurant so it was a little hard to hear the gal calling. Perhaps an extra speaker near the bar would help. Overall, our first visit to Old Buffalo was a success! It won't be our last!

Basic American bar with all the old school trappings, constant haze like Indiana overcast skies…read morehugging the lights, predictable limited selection of brews, no drafts, fun menu highlighting the outgoing diner eager to promote karaoke nights and after work eats. Us three guys wondered in a Wednesday evening to sample the casual dinner. Found the menu with all the usual fare, traditional and reunion familiar, Lacks the adventurous spirit of other local taps like AJs and Town and Gown, but there are few places in town to fully let loose and ensure the kids don't show up. We found the mac n cheese a bit watery, lacking the punch of full flavors, more budget Kraft than craft. Beef Manhattan did better with some echos to vintage cooking however better options abound in the area. Service was done right, sense of family here and enjoyable long night community.

The peanut butter burger may sound funny and yuck. But good ol mighty it's the shizzz!! Friendly…read morestaff. Although, there is one bartender who isn't very pleasant, rude and snotty. And not mentioning names bc she knows who she is. But all around it's pretty fun environment otherwise

My favorite watering hole in downtown Lafayette. Thieme & Wagner is Indiana's oldest beer that a…read morefamily member resurrected in recent years. Everything I've tried is delicious. Today, im enjoying the Grumpy Brewer hazy IPA. You honestly can't go wrong with anything they brew. The 1918 Bock is the original and is absolutely worth trying.

Delicious. Cozy. Great drinks. I tried to take a picture of the food and beer but it just plain…read moretasted too good.

We have a monthly social here and the staff is the best!!…read more Very accommodating, responsive and attentive. They have a great selection of local and regional beer: Goose Island, Revolution, Stone Brewery, Riggs, Triptyck, 3 Floyds, Maplewood, and Bells; all spanning the gamut of lagers, red and brown ales, IPAs and multiple stouts. Highly recommended this venue!!"

Nice quiet bar when we were there. Large bar along with tables. Service was friendly. We grabbed a…read morecouple beers before going on our way.

Classic timeless basement bar, noisy, crowded, and low priced sucrose flavored drinks, large can…read moreand bottle beer selection, staff made for fun times and served up a long island quick. Can see myself dropping down again soon to try the food!

The blind pig or BLIG as us locals call it. Is a staple of Lafayette. The food is better than…read moreHarry's and the staff and the people are fun. Love this place

Came for the special espresso martini menu and wasn't disappointed. We love the speakeasy lounge…read morevibes here and the bartender was so great to talk to. The star of the show (for me) was the strawberry espresso martini (Pickup Lines). They also had other flavors: herbal, Earl Gray, fig, and orange.

Go to Town and Gown, Black Sparrow, Red Seven, anywhere else. Four years ago this was a…read moresurprisingly downtown gem, exquisite top notch cocktail craft, fantastic menu and crafted food nibbles, a must do for this city starved for fancy fare. Yet this past year I fear I have to rewrite my review given the poor service and awful drinks taking over. Us four guys recently waited for ages, received expensive yet watery mixes without any balance or good flavors not even worthy of an Applebee's. This place has overly noisy, annoying, and thankfully we got better options.

Went to watch sporting events. Definitely had some customers who needed to be cut off alcohol or…read moresent on their way. Had a flat beer and went in my way.

I walked in there for a drink Sunday afternoon. I sat down and waited for the bar tender. He…read moretotally ignored me. He walked by me twice, didn't even look at me. Waited for 6 to 7 minutes while he went to B.S. with someone on the other side of the bar. I then left, I just wish he had the decency to say to me why he wouldn't serve me. I know 1 customer doesn't make a bar but I'll never go there or recommend anyone to go there. That was just rude!!!! Wish this site had negative star's so I could rate it properly.

small bar with tons of indoor and outdoor seating, great music (and you can play music too), darts…read moreand other games to play. they also have weekly events. very friendly bartenders and people who visit. only *complaint* for me personally was all the smoke but if that doesn't bother you then no complaints :)

My big problem with this place is all the smoke. If only this place would be affected by the…read morenon-smoking ban in September. They always have someone in there that will chat you up. Very friendly folks in here. Nice bartenders, bikers, hard working people just looking to have a good time and a few drinks.