We had a great date night at The Inn! From the moment we sat down, the vibe was chill and welcoming - perfect for a relaxed night out. We started with the Arugula Radicchio Salad (perfectly dressed!) and a cup of Potato Leek Soup, then shared the Duck Leg Confit (it was the best duck we've had in awhile, and braised cabbage! those duck fat roast potatoes!) and the Beef Filet with potato gratin (yum!!), watercress and red wine jus. Every dish had a nice wood-fired flavor. Excellent quality across the board, and the prices felt very reasonable for what you're getting. Our server was excellent - attentive, knowledgeable, friendly without hovering. The support staff kept our waters filled and dishes cleared seamlessly. We appreciated the NA beer, wine, and cocktail options. I had a modified French 75 and loved it - it's nice to have thoughtful non-alcoholic choices. Someday I'd love to grab seats at the counter in front of the kitchen to watch the action. We will be back! read more

See all

Visit: 8/5/2024 My apologies for letting this review fall through the cracks. Given the delay, this one may be a bit lighter on details. It was my birthday, and our friends wanted to take us to one of their favorite restaurants. This is a place they've been to several times and were excited to show off. They're especially known for their artisan pizzas. Food: Since pizza is their specialty, and two people in our group get very excited about a good slice, they ordered a Cheese, Sausage & Onion pizza and a Margherita pizza. The nightly special was Lamb Chop, which is one of my favorites, so I went with that. The last person ordered the Salmon. Overall, the food was very good. The lamb chop was nicely presented, cooked to the right temperature, and pesto-encrusted, which was a delicious combination. While it was good, it could have been a bit more flavorful. The salmon was enjoyed, though it leaned slightly dry. Both pizzas came out piping hot, generously topped, and very flavorful. There was plenty to share around the table. We had a little room left for dessert and ordered the Chocolate Nemesis. It was a good size and just enough to satisfy everyone's sweet tooth. They even added a candle to help celebrate my birthday, which was a nice touch. Service: Our server did a very good job throughout the evening. We were quickly settled in with drinks and menus, and the pacing of the meal was relaxed and well managed. We never felt like we were waiting on service. When they learned it was a birthday celebration, they went out of their way to present the dessert with a lit candle. It's a small gesture, but it really shows attention to detail. Atmosphere: The restaurant felt much larger inside than expected. We were seated in a separate room that we had entirely to ourselves. Each of us had an upholstered chair, which initially felt special, though it took some adjustment not to lean back too comfortably at the table. When we arrived, the room was quite chilly and drafty. We asked if the thermostat could be adjusted, which helped, though it remained a bit drafty. Overall, it was a very good experience and a place we would return to. Next time, I'd probably opt for one of the pizzas and request a table in the main dining room. read more

See all

Finally tried The Inn for lunch and it did not disappoint. Super fresh options (a departure from much of the bar food in the area). Service was attentive, as always. read more

See all

We went to the Hartland Inn tonight and had an exceptional experience. The service was truly five-star from start to finish. The food exceeded our expectations, and dessert absolutely stole the show. When we arrived, I asked the bartender for a wine recommendation and mentioned that I enjoy Pinot Noirs. He suggested a fantastic bottle that we loved so much we ended up ordering two and it was very reasonably priced. He could've done the server upsell on me with the $120 bottle right below it, but he knew a good tasting bottle of wine for a good value. To start, we split the large beet salad, which was perfectly dressed and loaded with beets and goat cheese and it was more than enough for two people. We also shared the Burrata pizza and asked them to add fresh arugula on top after it was out of the oven. It was unbelievably good. For dessert, we had the Warm Date Cake with bourbon caramel sauce and vanilla ice cream. If you've ever had sticky toffee pudding in England, or even if you haven't, it tasted remarkably similar. Rich, warm, creamy, with just a slight crunch that made it completely indulgent. I never expected to find such an incredible meal to share with my friend in Hartland, Wisconsin, and I'm a harsh damn critic, bordering on 'Karen', but this place absolutely delivered read more

What a gem in Hartland! Beautiful restaurant with multiple seating areas, the ambiance was as if a French cafe and a library were combined. Very clean and inviting. We were greeted by a friendly hostess upon walking in who was more than accommodating to get us a table without a reservation, I believe she was the owner (Maddie) while her husband was preparing food in the kitchen. These two know what they are doing and I would expect this restaurant to be a staple in Hartland for years to come. Food is on point, every thing is tasty. Many dishes are shareable with a good selection of main entrees to choose from. Always start with the fries! They come out hot and crispy with a garlic aioli. Five onion dip is spectacular, served with a light, crispy focaccia bread that you will be thinking about for days. They do offer a gluten free bread with this dish and there is plenty to share. Arugula salad was fresh and tasty. Topped with a lightly shredded parmesan, and crispy capers make it a nice add of greens to our meal. Pictured is a shareable size. Seafood crudo/ceviche was a special the night we were there, it was served with bread crisps. Light and fresh. The flourless chocolate cake was topped with fresh whipped cream. It had more of a chocolate pudding texture which I loved. Very different from the often forgettable conventional fudge-like brownie that most restaurants pass off as flourless cake. This is a great dessert option for gluten-free customers that want to enjoy dessert and we would get this again. We live in Pewaukee and I will pass several restaurants to go here again and again! read more

See all

Visited for the first time to attend their Bubbles & Bites event and it was awesome! They have soooo many great wines - we got to sample 7 of them. There were also tons of food options and all of them were delicious & unique. Caviar on a mini pancake?! Like come onnnn. I will definitely be back to visit during their regular restaurant hours. The food was too good! read more

We stopped in for a cocktail and an appetizer on 5/15. Service was great and fries were good. We ordered two pizzas to go as we had a show to attend. We did not check the pizza before we left. We have ordered pizza in the past. When we arrived home to eat both pizza crusts were burned. The dining room was closed so we did not send back for a new order. read more

The Inn - Pizza Near Me - Hartland, Wisconsin

Popped by for drinks and appies on a Wednesday evening. Bellied up to bar. Had delish cocktails and good food. Service was fast and friendly. The bartender even did a magic trick for us. read more

This was our second time here and both times we had a great experience! The Inn is beautiful decorated, has great ambiance, and wonderfully kind staff (especially the bartenders)! Both times we have been have been weekdays so we sit at a table in the bar area. Like most places, the cost of cocktails has increased, but at least they make them right! We had our usual, Gin Martinis For the food, you absolutely need to get the tallow fries... my goodness are they delicious! We also got a beet salad, some scallops, and the sopressata pizza which were all fantastic. The only reason for the 4 star rating is the cost. Pizza for $25 (while delicious) is a little high! That being said, we will be back often! read more

See all

So expensive it's pathetic. It seems like the crowd that comes here is to see who has the most money. It really isn't that awesome

Absolutely loved this place. From the moment I walked in, the energy was warm, inviting, and effortlessly cool-the kind of spot you instantly want to linger in. The food was exceptional. Every dish was thoughtful, beautifully executed, and full of flavor - you can tell there's real talent and intention coming out of the kitchen. It's rare to find a restaurant that nails both creativity and comfort this well. One of the owners came over to greet us which was the cherry on top to my experience. She was lovely. I'm planning a couple's dinner there soon and can't wait! This is one of those places you recommend without hesitation. read more

First time to the new establishment. Very well appointed dining and bar area. Nice job on the renovation!! Service was very attentive and knowledgeable. Server kept reminding us that their portions were to share, it became a running joke as she kept informing us of this portion sharing. Food: pizza was very good, the bolognese was extraordinary. Very good selection of desserts. Filet is over priced and we asked for medium rare and it was presented as raw to rare (seared) and we had to send back to medium rare. Price to value is why I gave a 3 star rating. read more

This place is unbelievable, and it seems all of Lake Country already knows it because I can't seem to snag a pair of seats at the bar any day of the week. The decor inside is stunning. I would love to know whom the owners hired to design the interior, because this restaurant is GORGEOUS inside. We have had nothing but exceptional service here, too, with a well staffed bar and friendly servers. The star of the show here, though, is the food. This isn't political, don't come at me, but I'm a big fan of beef tallow and I don't eat seed oils. The kitchen here is 100% seed oil-free, and I'm ecstatic about it. Their tallow fries are the most delicious French fries I've ever eaten anywhere in my life. I also love their mussel toast, and steak tartare is excellent. If you remember one thing from this review though, let it be this: order two pieces of date cake, one for dessert tonight and one to eat with your coffee in the morning. It's the most absurdly delicious dessert, with crispy edges akin to a brownie, and the most sumptuous sponge with the perfectly subtle smokiness of a whiskey caramel sauce, tempered by smooth vanilla ice cream or gelato or whatever. Good lord is it delicious. Wife and I often joke about lake country reviewed restaurants having an extra star because the reviewers grade on a curve, since restaurants in the area tend to be subpar compared to downtown Milwaukee, Walker's Point, and Bay View. But this place isn't "Lake Country good," it's Milwaukee good. A restaurant of this caliber would thrive anywhere. One complaint: The bar doesn't stock a wide selection of liquors. If you have a standard cocktail you like, you might find that you can't get it here. The cocktail menu is decent, but very small, and they're not exactly catering to a wide range of tastes. I should be able to come to a restaurant as nice as this and confidently order a Negroni or a Sazerac, or get a decent single malt for after dinner. I do hope they expand their offerings. This is Wisconsin, after all, we drink for sport. read more

Location is great, however it is not a top tier restaurant compared to the Palmer house or golden mast. No linen on the tables and they're not prepared for high end cocktails. Servers are excellent and wait staff are very friendly. Food was great but the menu is a little off. read more

I absolutely love this place!! If you haven't tried it make sure you do!!!! I have not found a single item I wouldn't recommend.

Place is cute inside but incredibly overpriced for the food. $30 for a small pizza? A salad? If you're going to charge $40+ for an entree, it better be edible. We had to send back a dish for the meat being too hard. Wanted to love it, the restaurant itself is really nicely decorated and the staff was nice too. Food is just really not worth the money, unfortunately! read more

Owner is a complete snob. Overpriced crap. They have the same food vendors as low quality restaurants. They offer no specials, no unique cocktails, and no happy hour. I liked it better when it was a parking lot read more

Another lake country disappointing Very Overpriced restaurant, pizza way overpriced and nothing special, entrees, appetizers and drinks definitely overpriced, $9 for a pickle plate, half roasted chicken $35, can get a rotisserie chicken from Costco that is better, halibut fish dinner $48, Culver's has a better fish fry. Place was better as a parking lot, service and decor was just ok, big deal you have an open kitchen, will not be back. Sticking with Marty's, Kurt's, Fishbones and small bars and restaurants in the area. I give them a half star at best!! read more

Mother's Day brunch was fantastic! It has been completely renovated and they have decorated it with a hip elegant vibe. And the menu- They had it all! Charcuterie table, tomato/beet salad, pesto noodle mixed greens, broccolini, mini crab cakes, shrimp, ham, beef, salmon, and quiche. I am certain this is not a complete list! Service was attentive and lots of families! Will definitely be going again. read more

See all

Good food and service. Can't wait to come back. Will bring more money next time. We ran out of $ on our visit.

Beautiful restaurant, definitely needs to upgrade their service and dining selection. We were told, from the initial greeting from our server, if you don't order shared plates, you selections will not be guaranteed to come out at the same time. That was accurate, salads were not served together. read more

They have a great new lunch menu. You need to get the fries, they taste amazing! Open for lunch Thursday through Saturday.

Great food, great service. Fairly priced and exceptional location. Chicken and steak frites are *chefs kiss* !!

Great addition to the Lake country. Very interesting and well done interior . Wine selection is quite unique and consistent throughout . Love the salads, focaccia bread, and the pizza. ...try The rigatoni Bolognese. Prompt and friendly service as well. read more

might change my review after trying again someday. Experience was overshadowed by how incredibly loud the room was. Each table had to yell to each other to be heard so the overall sound level was so so bad. Service was ok; very nice but she had to lean in to talk to us because it was so loud and it was pretty busy so we had to ask for water. Mixed reviews on the food. Pizza was tasty, basil pesto pasta was delicious but needed a tiny more salt. Fries were crispy and nice. Was expecting more flavor from the olives but the bee pollen was interesting. Desserts were delicious. read more

The Inn - Pizza Near Me - Hartland, Wisconsin

See all

The ambience at the Inn is so very nice. They've really done a nice job as it has a cozy, classy look & feel to it. But I would say that is the best thing going for The Inn. They offer a very pricy menu. Drinks are overpriced as well. My husband had 2 cokes - $14! We shared the smoked fish dip with our 2 friends and we all liked the flavor. However, the potato chips they served with it didn't hold up well to the dip. They kept breaking. Some thin crackers or ruffle type chips would have been a better choice. Our total bill was over $180 for 2 pizzas, 2 salads (the endive and blue cheese salad was too small for $16) 2 cokes, a glass of wine and one old fashioned. The pizza was tasty but nothing extra special. And the crust in the middle was floppy. We like crispy crust. Also the table next to the window in the bar is extremely cold. Don't sit there in winter. I don't think we'll be going back anytime soon. read more

Food was excellent and really enjoyed the ambiance in both the dining room and the bar