What an unforgettable experience!! From the moment we walked in until we left (we chatted with the staff until we kicked ourselves out), everything was amazing! The food, atmosphere, and service were top notch! From choosing what hats to wear (full wall of hats to choose from) to having to decide which sandwiches to eat, we left very full and very happy. I would highly recommend going here for a lovely tea party. Just remember, you need a reservation! read more

The charm of the place was nice. Very whimsical and felt like you were in Alice in wonderland itself. Went for Mother's Day and we had to get the high tower which was good, I think it was priced high for what it was. Shrimp sandwich was my favorite. Why I'm not rating it higher: I made the reservation 2 weeks before Mother's Day, the only thing available was a 10:45am so I took it. They called me two days before to confirm and said they had a 1:30 available, I started asking questions about the food more being suited toward lunch or breakfast, a bit snippy they put me on hold, I txt my wife quick and she said take the 1:30, the woman gets back on the phone and says sorry someone on the other line just took the 1:30... I said.... What! I was offered it and didn't give you an answer yet. She didn't care and was very dismissive. Won't be returning, read more

Absolutely unbelievable! let me start by saying my husband planned a wonderful special day for our six-year-old autistic daughter for Valentine's Day. Seeing as her birthday is next month, we wanted to go ahead and try to go to a tea house and see if she enjoys it enough to invite a few friends to our home next month and replicate the event.. now it is on the pricey side, but we thought it would be a special day just for three of us. We not only called for reservations, but then arrived early and although we were sat, we did not get any fresh brewed tea. we got hot water and no authenticity at all bagged tea not loose and if she tells you she had loose teeth, then the waitress was at fault, but I don't wanna blame the waitress either like she has so-called reviews that she answer she blames it on someone else whether it's the waitresses and there was a prefix menu, but she didn't have time where she's really busy or somebody had the flu or they're lying or a wall review. I am not that person I have been using yelp since it began. I am a top contributor and I have to say this was a very bad experience and I will not blame it on a single person except the manager and the staff themselves who were not doing anything in the back as we were watching like all the other if you said it takes forever it is a bad luck and they don't come back to the table and serve properly. They don't have time to even say hello and really get to the table in a timely manner. At that point, we got a small salad with no silverware and no cream and sugar so basically we were waiting for our beautiful two/three tiered high tea that was a prefix menu "supposedly??" But after 45 minutes and absolutely no one coming around and still no silverware cream or sugar we had to ask for three times including the owner and we still had nothing else. It was nearly 4 PM and my little girl was starving as was my husband who would've rather been anywhere at that point After the third go round we decided to leave! I'm diabetic and this was crazy! In my almost 46 years. I have never left a restaurant. I hope that you all have a better experience than we did...next time go to a diner! Don't waste nearly $60 pp something. You can buy at Sam's Club and serve yourself if it ever shows up! Angry is not even the word! Prefix my foot! ***Update: I saw what you decided to respond and like I said you are your own worst enemy because I have NO responsibility to tell you anything about being diabetic if I have to wait an hour for a $60 plate of food that you never served me what do I have to pay for? I don't believe that the world is built on you do nothing then I have to pay you for something? Wtf? I saw the other post you blame everybody by yourself. You blame when you're busy you blame it on Valentine's Day. You blame it on your waitress is having the flu. You blame it on everybody by yourself and as far as I'm concerned from sitting there and watching you for an entire hour go back-and-forth and do absolutely nothing. It's your fault nobody else's don't tagline my editorial because you think you wanna be right that doesn't work! I can go home and get hot water. Thank you very much for nothing. You are not only a nasty woman, but you also show a very sincere lack of understanding when it comes to how to run a business not only is it not my job to tell you I'm diabetic it's not my job to take my autistic daughter and have her wait over an hour for food. I don't care how many people you have. All those things are just excuses and as far as I was told when I grow up, it's about results not excuses!!!! SHAME ON YOU AND YOUR RESTAURANT WILL REPOST ALL OVER!!!! read more

Everything was incredible from the atmosphere to the service to the food. The tea was scrumptious. I highly recommend anyone looking to have a first class experience to try this place out. read more

amazing tea experience!! the 3 tiered experience came with 4 tea sandwiches, a scone, some baked goods, and fruit. i got the tuna, shrimp, brie and pear, and cucumber and cream cheese. my mom got the cranraisin and cream cheese, turkey apple and cheese, egg salad, and cucumber and cream cheese. all the sandwiches were delicious. the baked goods were also awesome. my favorite was the scone which had the perfect amount of clotted cream and jam. i got caramel apple tea and my mom got vanilla caramel and both were delicious. servers explained the menu to us. a really nice touch is the hats on the wall which you can wear during your meal! i will definitely be back read more

The Mad Batter Tea Room & Cafe - 3 tiered tea - American Near Me - Blue Point, New York

See all

Great service. I have had better high teas at other locations. I may be a high tea snob but the sandwiches left a little to be desired and I didn't really love the scones. read more

I have been to four afternoon tea places on Long Island, and let me tell you this is the real deal. It is super cute and welcoming. The food is delicious. The scones my goodness the scones- pure chef's kiss. The tuna sandwich simple yet so tasty. Brie and pear sandwiches divine. I went with mango passion fruit tea ,and I loved it. On the weekends you cannot share the afternoon tea towers, every one has to get their own. You definitely need reservations for this place. Definitely come here and thank me later. I would love to have an event here. I will be returning soon hopefully. read more

See all

Beautifully decorated staff wonderful we thoroughly enjoyed the delicious quiche and beet salad. We had a great time and will definitely return again!!! read more

The Mad Hatter in Blue Point feels like stepping into a storybook. The décor is charming, and the colorful display of hats gives the space a whimsical, one-of-a-kind atmosphere. Every detail has personality, making it a place that immediately puts you at ease. we eachordered the tea service, which came with four delicious sandwiches, a pot of tea, and an incredible assortment of desserts and a scone. Everything was beautifully presented and tasted just as good as it looked. It's the kind of spot where even a simple visit feels special. read more

Love, love, love this adorable Alice In Wonderland inspired Tea Room! We were there for a birthday celebration and had the best time! From the unique decor, beautiful China we were served on, elecletic furnishings and delicious foods, this is definitly a place not to be missed!!​ read more

I've been to tea spots all over Long Island, and I've finally found the perfect one! Not only is the decor cool and fun, but they truly put their money where your mouth is. From the sandwiches to the baked goods and even the homemade soup, everything was absolutely delicious. All of this is served in a gorgeous, relaxed setting that's perfect for unwinding. The amazing staff makes you feel so welcome and comfortable--it's such a treat! Highly recommend, and I will be back very soon~ Linda LaFleur read more

The Mad Batter Tea Room & Cafe - American Near Me - Blue Point, New York

Food was delicious celebrating in 98th birthday service was awesome. Recommended at three towels worth it. Try to variety of stuff on the menu. Will be going back soon read more

See all

Came here with a friend for their Bridgerton Royal High Tea and Trivia night and it was absolutely wonderful. The atmosphere is so cozy, fun, and quaint. The staff were warm and inviting. The food was delightful in both flavor and presentation. If you are looking for a cozy place to sit and read a book while enjoying some tea sandwiches and scones, or a spot to catch up with some friends and spill the tea this is the perfect place. read more

See all

Cute place with delicious food and great service. We made a reservation for 1230 and were the first patrons as they open at 12. The decor was adorable, each table had different trinkets and tea cups of varying styles. I felt odd as I had my baby with me and wasn't sure how it would be accepted bringing her to a tea room but they didn't bat an eye or make me feel uncomfortable. I ordered the tea tier option #1 which came with my choice of four sandwiches, assorted fruit, a scone, and assorted baked goods. The tiers were 'per person' but there was truly so much food. The sandwiches were half of a full sized sandwich, I was expecting finger sandwiches so that was nice. There was a nice selection of sandwiches to choose from, and about three scone options. I went with the lavender scone which was tasty, and came with a side of jam and clotted cream. There was also some fruit on the tray and a variety of desserts including a brownie, cookies, muffins, etc. Everything was good and fresh. For tea I got the raspberry, the tier option came with a full pot. Our waitress was very attentive, and even though it took us a while to work through our tiers she didn't make us feel rushed or like she was trying to push us out which we have had happen at other tea rooms. There was also a selection of hats on the wall that are cleaned daily that they offered to you to wear to better get into the tea party role. Overall, a great experience and I look forward to returning! read more

See all

Before I start my review I want to preface that my group and I are kind of tea house connoisseurs. It's a tradition we've had for years, and we've been to many tea houses. That being said, I think we might have unfair or high expectations. The ambiance is great and the place was so cute and fun. I loved that they have hats you can wear and really get the full experience. The sandwich's tasted good - favorite was the shrimp salad and the apple/brie/ turkey. My only complaint with the sandwiches was that I expected them to be on all different breads- I guess what we were used to from other places. They were way bigger than expected which I guess is nice since sometimes you feel skimped at other places. I just think it would be nice for maybe a variety of bread like croissant, flat bread etc. just my constructive criticism. The scones were really tasty and my only complaint here is that for a party of 6, they gave us 2 clotted creams/ jams when we each ordered the full tiered tea. We asked for another set of clotted cream/ jam and we're questioned by the waitress "oh that's not Enough?" I feel in this instance the customer is always right and the answer should've been of course! But it was awkward and we did end up finishing the first two sets before more was brought out. By the time a third came- we were all pretty much done with our scones. When it was time to pack stuff up she asked if we wanted a box for the cream/jam which felt like a dig. I just feel if we're all paying for the full tiered tea and each comes with jam/ cream we should each get our own or Atleast 3 sets for 6 adults. Overall we had fun and it was a good experience! I will also add that the waitress did ask multiple times if everything was ok and we just said yes. I'm not going to argue about how I think she handled the scone situation etc. or offer my suggestions on sandwiches. That would've been uncomfortable and we just wanted to enjoy our tea. We did advocate though when we were questioned if we really needed more cream/ jam. read more

The Mad Batter Tea Room & Cafe - Ambiance - American Near Me - Blue Point, New York

See all

Spent a rainy afternoon at the Mad Batter Tea Room with my daughters and granddaughters. It was warm and cozy inside and our waitress was so warm and friendly. We each ordered our favorite teas and enjoyed lunch. Three of us opted for the spinach quiche, made with puff pastry in lieu of pie crust. Very tasty! It was accompanied by an arugula salad. One granddaughter has the burger, it was huge. And the other gad mozzarella sticks, she is very fussy! Both girls had the red velvet cupcake with peppermint frosting for dessert. Lovely way to spend an afternoon read more

The Mad Batter Tea Room & Cafe - Quiche and arugula salad - American Near Me - Blue Point, New York

Looking for the most fun and exciting way to have some high Afternoon tea? Look no further! This tea room is so unique and exquisite. You can order a regular entree or the traditional afternoon tea tier with sandwiches, a scone and many delectable baked goodies. All the baking is done on the premises which means everything you taste is fresh and delicious. I ordered my own tier and my dining partner also. You get a choice of 4 different tea sandwiches. I highly recommend the Arugula pear & ricotta, Cucumber cream cheese & dill, Turkey Brie & apple and Crasin walnut cream cheese. I would venture to say any of the tea sandwiches are tasty. The bread was also fresh and soft . I tried everything that was offered . The baked desserts really were spectacular. I enjoyed the cookies , shortbread and brownie. The scone was also a treat , imagine a freshly baked scone - I was in love! A vast selection of tea for your own pot . I selected the Moroccan Mint green tea - so satisfying. The place itself is warm and inviting. Such cute decorations. There is also an option for a Kids afternoon tea . The tea room is great for groups , solo trips or events . The service was great, always checking on us and making sure we were enjoying ourselves . I can't say enough about The Mad Batter . This place was honestly my favorite experience in 2023! I look forward to suggesting the experience to others and returning for another adventure. read more

See all

We went here today for a birthday brunch with the Golden girl bingo. We had so much fun. The host of the event were very funny and on point with their characters. I was grateful to have won one of the events. And the prize was awesome a gift certificate to go back and enjoy another meal there. The food on the buffet was very good. They had a lot of variety for the price. It was definitely worth it. They had salad, eggs and waffles, also sausages, broccoli, pasta, shrimp, pasta, baked chicken, with carrots, and potatoes And an amazingly tasting strawberry muffin. The food tasted very good. The chicken was cooked perfectly. I normally don't like sausage legs, but these had a lot of flavor. I felt the salad could use a little bit more dressing and a little less onions (not a big fan of onions). The outside of the building is so cute. It's at the end of a strip mall with a couple of other stores. Parking wasn't bad but I could see this parking lot getting full quickly. Inside was decorated for Halloween and done beautifully. They had an amazing Halloween dollhouse And the decor was just beautiful. They even decorated the bathroom. The main room doesn't have a lot of tables which makes it very quaint. We were able to get around and probably the place could accommodate about 50 people. It was kind of full for the event. The Waite staff was very attentive. Anytime you moved your plate away. They came and took it so as to not have dirty plates all over the place. I also loved that all the plates were mismatched, but still beautiful. All the teacup were mismatched, but still beautiful. My friend had an awesome cup of tea. As you know I'm a water snob and the water here tasted pretty good. It had cucumbers in it and it had a mild taste, but delicious. It seems like it could be a great place to celebrate a special event. They seem to go over the top to make sure everyone has a good time. Our golden girl hosts did an awesome job of making us feel welcomed, and lots of laughs. Looking forward to visiting again . read more

The Mad Batter Tea Room & Cafe - Our group with our golden girl hosts - American Near Me - Blue Point, New York

See all

This place is beautiful! We had a wonderful lunch and cocktails. The tea service was well done and delicious.The service was perfect. We cannot wait to dine there again. Have A "Down The Rabbit Hole" cocktail along the your "Tier". You pick what you want on your Tier and there are plenty of choices along with seasonal offerings. read more

See all

I brought my mom for a surprise birthday party today and it was the best experience!!!! Lovely staff, delicious food, and precious ambiance. Make sure you make a reservation ahead so that you can be taken care of in the best way possible! My family will definitely be back again! So fun!! read more

See all

My mom and I like to try new tea places. This was a nice. A couple of things I wish they had. There was no wheelchair access outside but we managed. I wish they had fresh tea & not tea bags, different music (it didn't match the vibe) and different scones. They also didn't explain what everything was on the tier they brought to table. I guess I'm use to the waitresses doing that from other tea places. Overall, nice time. Mom enjoyed. read more

We had a bachelorette party here. The day was cold and we got flurries and rain outside. Inside was so cozy, warm, inviting and friendly! Great service! Excellent staff! Everyone is super friendly. Our serve was Dee (spelling I hope is correct!), She was amazing! We ordered a cake, specially made. Me and my friend both planned the Bachelorette Party, the staff and Dee made sure to keep the cake a secret just in case I didn't know! It was wonderful! We originally had a group of 4, but my friend had called a week or so prior and made reservations for a group of 7. They were great! They moved tables around and set everything up last minute. We felt that the food took a while to come out, however everything is made to order! We had so much fun that we hadn't realized 3 hours had gone by! It truly only felt like it was 30 minutes! In our group of 6 girls, we had a male photographer who also was included in our Bride Tribe. He certainly didn't mind being surrounded by a bunch of women today! He was such a great sport! I highly recommend Mad Batter and their wonderful staff! They were so helpful and wished us congratulations and the best of luck. They thanked us for coming and sharing this day with them. read more

See all

What a beautiful afternoon. Very impressed with the overall ambiance of this special lil spot. The choices of teas are never ending, I had the wild raspberry hibiscus and enjoyed the entire pot. Everyone is given their own tea pot and each eclectically different. We each ordered the tiered sandwich platter, and it was all so unique and exciting. Your able to choose 4 different tea sandwiches (the largest one) and dessert type stuff in on your top tier. Just getting to try a bunch of lil things is so fun, and all equally delicious. This place is a must do with your friends! My only complaint was that the tea was not piping hot, other than that...5 Stars! Will 100% return. read more

See all

Really cute and cozy establishment! Great for a date or bigger tea party. The tea and sandwiches are really tasty. The presentation is super cute. The tower is more than enough for one person, even a big eater like me, although I did order extra sandwiches (I have an unusually large appetite). I had enough room to try all the sandwiches on the menu - all were fantastic, with no crust as expected. My favorite sandwich, you ask? -- to my surprise, the cucumber cream cheese (I thought my favorite would be a sandwich with protein ). My Second favorite sandwich was the shrimp salad . Also, I had possibly the best lavender scone I have ever consumed. The service is excellent. Our waitress was super friendly and accomodating. The owner even greeted us and answered some questions we had while giving some background on the restaurant. Fun bonus! They provide fun tea party hats they clean daily. My gf and I enjoyed our meal while wearing some epic hats. read more

I had a wonderful tea with a couple of friends. The ambiance is exceptional; warm and welcoming, filled with delightful knick knacks and such. We could have spent hours drinking delicious tea and munching on food and cakes. Lucky for us, the tea room was decorated for the holidays! read more

The Mad Batter Tea Room & Cafe - American Near Me - Blue Point, New York

See all

Brought my mom to this lovely tea room. Decorated beautifully. We loved our Mother's Day Tea Tower. We opted for the loose tea. We Love the vibe. Everything was so fresh and the staff and owner were super nice. Can't wait to return on a regular afternoon tea day. Looking forward to attending the Tea Leave reading just one of many events they have here. If you haven't yet you must check out this really beautiful place. I was told today the outdoor patio opens soon. Can't wait. We Live in Oakdale and is it we did not know of this tea room cafe sooner! So nice to have this unique place so very close to home. read more

The Mad Batter is a lovely venue for a bridal shower. The staff was helpful and attentive and the rooms are pretty and whimsical.

I went with my family because my mom said she wanted to give this place a try. We got the largest tower to split between four of us. I find it interesting that they charge $8 more to share the tower with your party. Everything we had was good, the tower had tiny tea sandwiches, fruit and miscellaneous baked goods and scones. Everything was very tiny. The theme was a tea room with an Alice in Wonderland twist. The staff was friendly but seemed stressed and chaotic without a ton of people dining there. read more

The Mad Batter Tea Room & Cafe - Peach Tea - American Near Me - Blue Point, New York

Food was delicious, loved the decor I enjoyed the music trivia set during my lunch with my friend

very cute but wayyyyy overpriced. $200 for 2 adults and a kid with no alcoholic beverages I was shocked when we got the bill for high tea. I was disappointed it was only tea bags and not brewed tea and we waited a very long time at the table at every stage from walking in to leaving. I'm not one to complain and everyone was nice but they really need to reconsider the price for what you get on the high tea because it was certainly not worth it. read more

Had lunch here with some friends recently. The food, service & ambiance were all wonderful! The owner and staff were incredibly nice! The decor was cozy & cute. Looking forward to a return visit! read more

I just had my bridal shower here! My mother said that Delia was the easiest person to work with! The food and teas were phenomenal.... All the guests had an amazing time with the in house decor and the fun hats to really go on theme! I couldn't recommend it enough!! 1000000/10 read more

Beautiful tea shop! Great service and food! A definite must visit! Finger Sandwiches, Tiered Tower read more

See all

My friend and I enjoyed an absolutely delightful afternoon at the Mad Batter Tea Room today. We shared a Mad Batter salad and the large tiered tower. Everything was perfection. Our server Marge (not sure of the name) could not have been nicer. Delia, the owner was very welcoming and came to our table to thank us for coming and to ask us if everything was to our liking. Definitely recommend this establishment and will return in the future. read more

The Mad Batter Tea Room & Cafe - American Near Me - Blue Point, New York

Had a wonderful time . Tried so many different teas . The waiter there is so friendly.He helped us make some good choices on what to eat . I would definitely recommend going here the atmosphere the food the tea the service all wonderful. read more

The Mad Batter Tea Room & Cafe - American Near Me - Blue Point, New York

I have been wanting to go here for awhile. I went this evening with a group for Drag Bingo. It was so much fun, so entertaining and hilarious. Tom Catt and Toni Homeperm were fabulous! Entertainment aside, the venue was wonderful. The drinks, food and service were excellent! The ambiance in the main tea room is everything and more. Delia, the owner is a superb hostess who goes above and beyond to make you feel at home. We actually showed up the wrong night and they were closed and she still offered to make us a meal. She is the epitome of hospitality. I highly recommend The Mad Hatter Tea House can't wait to go back! High tea next time! read more

Was there for an amazing event on Sunday. The staff worked hard to keep the customers happy, even though it seemed like an uphill climb with some. They handled the chaos and varying attitudes with grace. The food was delicious, drinks were strong. The complimentary mint shake shots and pineapple cake were a sweet ending to a lovely bingo brunch. read more

The Mad Batter Tea Room & Cafe - American Near Me - Blue Point, New York

I was interested in trying out this tea room. I did not have a reservation, but the website said it was open for lunch. I stopped by around 2:00. Website said it closed at 4. I walked in, saw a quaint bar, and a small dining room set for tea. The main dining room had tables enjoying tea and lunch. No one came to the front, and even though I walked into the dining room, there were no employees visible. I went back to the bar, perused the menu, and still no one. I left. And will never be back. read more

My friends and I LOVED it here! The decor is so lovely - there's an Alice in Wonderland vibe with all different little curios around the room. It was very inviting and so fun to spot the different little Knick-knacks and bits of decor. Our waitress was lovely. She did a great job of listening to what we did and didn't want with our tea service. It took a bit to get the food, but the time was well spent sipping tea and enjoying the ambiance of the room. The food was delicious. The tea sandwiches were great - it was hard to pick a favorite between the egg salad and the roast beef and horseradish. The scone (chocolate chip) was SO YUMMY, and the baked goods were delish - especially the little waffle cookie! I highly recommend this spot - especially for a special Mother's Day treat!! read more

Wow! What a place! The decor, the food, the service, the woman owned business.... Just all of it. BRAVO! read more

The Mad Batter Tea Room & Cafe - Decor - American Near Me - Blue Point, New York

See all