This is not going to be an easy review to write. I have so many conflicting thoughts and…read morefeelings... reviewing a restaurant should never be this dramatic! Seriously though... speaking as someone who was a partner in two restaurants in NYC for 4 years, who does not claim to "know it all" but knows some tricks of the trade... I think they've got great potential and would like to share my thoughts with them. Saying they've "got potential" probably come across as smug, obnoxious, and ridiculous, especially because they've got like 4.6 stars here on Yelp! And that's mainly why I found myself here... Staying in Mansfield for the night, I looked up restaurants that were enroute to our hotel. Some of them had 3 or 3.5 stars and I said "no way." But 4.6 stars with as many reviews as The Farmer's Table has? Absolutely! The atmosphere is a little bit diner but cozy enough and has the farm as a theme. There are some cool design elements, like the steel ceiling, the tables... The bathroom was clean and well stocked, and that's a really good sign that the place is sanitary and organized. The waitress was really, really nice... and we loved that we were in this tiny little town and yet she had this really cool, funky image. Great fingernails! I'm jealous! A tip for her to make service even better... think about sequence of service. Think about the extras that the customer will want with the specific thing they ordered so that they won't have to bother you. If they order something with fries, definitely put ketchup on their table, and do it before the food is delivered. There were also a lot of empty tables with salt shakers, but it's had none. Some customers notice these little things and appreciate a server who anticipates their needs. On the other hand, maybe she was just really slammed busy before we got there. My wife and I waited like 2 minutes for her to take my order and she apologized profusely for having us wait so long for her. I was like, "am I in Manhattan or wut???" She was on point, generally easy to find when we needed her, she was never trying to hide from customers (a huge no-no) and very well-intentioned. Definitely a keeper. The food though... I was surprised we didn't like it very much being the reviews were so good. When I got the check to pay, I asked the server what their most beloved and popular dishes are. She said that ppl order a lot of the prime rib sandwich, and also the cat fish. Incidentally, I had ordered the prime rib sandwich, and my wife had the breaded cat fish. I was expecting a lot more meat on my sandwich, and the bun was just a regular burger bun, but it was ok. It came with 3 slices of pickle and cost $11.90. I was still hungry after that so I finished my wife's catfish 'cuz she gets full easily. I liked the catfish more, but neither of us thought it was anything special. What was special were the prices. The catfish included 2 sides, and it cost less than $14. Being from NYC, it was so refreshing to see pricing that reminded me of year 2000! A burger for $7.85 that's not Burger King? Incredible! But the cole slaw... ewww. I didn't hate it, but I kind of forced myself to eat it even though it had a strange flavor. The sweet potato fries were ok. Everything was basically O.K. I imagine that, if I lived there, I would go pretty regularly cuz it's probably the best thing the neighborhood has in a few square miles, and it's easier and more fun than cooking at home (if you're not a cook and you're busy at work). But I think that some improvement in the food could make the place more of a destination. And a destination could actually bring more business to the surrounding businesses! I can understand if the townspeople want very basic food there, but at least offer a few specials that are fancier, better ingredients, something that stands out and is memorable. I know I'm spoiled coming from NYC... a 4.6 star review in places like Manhattan are different than a 4.6 star review in a small town. But this place has some nice things about it. Take it all the way!

The Farmer's Table was the perfect lunch stop for our road trip. The server was kind and checked on…read moreingredients for us (stay away from the fries/sweet potato fries if you're gluten free). The food came quickly and was absolutely delicious! Cute decor and both large and small tables make the seating great for groups or a smaller party. Highly recommend!

Lived in Watsontown for many years and always enjoyed going here! Especially since moving, it was…read morenice to go back to a small town diner for a quick meal! It always seems to be packed and their phrase "where friends & families meet to eat" is very accurate! The servers are very friendly, the atmosphere is welcoming, and the food is great. Love this place!

Was on an 8 hour road trip and found this gem right at the four hour mark. We got there at 1 (they…read moreclose at 2) and the place was PACKED. It's a small restaurant with 10 tables tops. We sat at one of the 2-3 open tables. Waitress was a doll and engaged happily with our 2 and 4 year olds. The food was EXCEPTIONALLY CHEAP, so I'm thinking it's going to be low quality. Wrong. Bacon cheeseburger was cooked perfectly ( you'd be surprised how rare it is I actually get a rare cheeseburger), and the cheese was on top of the bacon instead of the burger which I thought was a nice touch. The cheesesteak was delicious- best I've had in a long time. The soup was also delicious and homemade. Do yourself a favor and eat here if you're in the area

They have great food and great service overall. I would totally recommend this place to anyone to…read moredine in and eat! Yummy

Dinner tonight was very good and we highly recommend it…read more Like previous reviews, we thought the salad was super simple and the baked potato was just average, but those are very minor concerns in our opinion. We had the stuffed pork chop with ham and bacon which came with a sweet and very tasty bbq sauce and some melted cheese. We also had a seafood dish that was stuffed haddock, shrimp and scallops. The stuffing we believe was crab and it was amazing. They ask you to make reservations but we walked in without on a Saturday around 6 and there was no problem being seated quickly. All the staff we interacted with were very nice and paid the right amount of attention to us. Prices were very reasonable and what was expected. They do pass on credit card fees to the diner if you choose to pay with plastic, but that feels like it is becoming more common so it was not a surprise. We will definitely return and anticipate another wonderful meal!!

Took my daughter for lunch. I had the octopus salad. The lettuce was scarce and not very fresh. The…read moreoctopus was rubbery and tasteless. I was disappointed. The service was friendly.

Outstanding food and service. Say hi to Ted in the kitchen. He and the staff make you feel right…read moreat home!

Always good to go to Heeter's. The food is great, the service good too. They have very good ice…read morecream too!!

I'm surprised this shows in yelp with a rating of 4 since it is absolutely not a 4…read more Food - frozen patties that are below grade. Hot dog bun that was 2 pieces like you find with cheap buns. Ketchup is some 3rd rate knock off brand. Service - the 2 that are working are busy but the waiter has a hard time keeping up. Soda could use a refill, maybe a straw with my drink, silverware came later. This isn't a 5 star place so service was as you should expect. 3 star Value/Price - 2 stars. $3.99 for a fountain drink. $1.25 to add cheese to the 3 oz burger? I think for the price you could get better quality food at a chain like chilis, fridays, or other. When i saw this place I thought it might be something like the red rabbit i duncannon PA but it isn't even close. I am sure it is a good breakfast place for standard egg fare I doubt I would go back

Food is fresh and delicious with generous portions. The mocktails are hands down the best I've had…read morethus far. Service is friendly and attentive. The atmosphere is quaint small town coziness.

The exterior is old school Main Street character and I ended up driving right past it. I'll blame…read moremy GPS. Most of the parking seems to be metered with an actual quarter. Each coin giving one hour means 50 cents should be plenty. Passing by the outside seating made me wish I wasn't dining alone. I was seated promptly and narrowed my choices down to three sandwiches. The parmesan bruschetta Panini, the Milltown Panther, or the Marilyn Monroe. I ended up ordering the former and kept the original side of chips. If I was super hungry I would have ordered Mac & cheese for a side. The panini was super crunchy and toasted to perfection. The chicken was sliced appropriately sized and cooked well. The toppings were justice but not to the point it would ruin the crispy bread. I would visit again and get the one of the same three items I narrowed it down to this first time.

Nostalgic clean ambience, cordial staff Wonderful food…read moreLarge portions value for $ A+ Fantastic coffee

We are up in Williamsport for a long day of baseball. We stopped in Dolly's for some breakfast. It…read moreis a cute little "seat yourself" diner with great breakfast options. We heard that the pastries were great but they ran out of sticky buns. The pancakes looked yummy and my omelet was very good. Friendly service as well.

very friendly staff, excellent food. Great atmosphere. very fast service. we were there on Friday…read more I had the haddock salad and stewed tomatoes. Very good. We also had onion rings sandwiches and wraps. Everything was wonderful.

Does the trick, the mixed one with curly hair and bushy eyebrows can be a nuisance at time but all…read morearound an enjoyable experience.