The pizza is very good, some of the best New York style pizza in the area. However, after years of being very loyal to this place my most recent customer service experience was so bad, I have decided I will not be returning. I ordered three pizzas off of their website and it cost a lot more than I anticipated for plain cheese pizzas. However the customization screen came up and nothing was selected. It turns out I ordered three of the New York style with pepperoni and olives and all kinds of toppings. I returned the pizzas immediately. I asked for three plain cheese pizzas in exchange and they refused to take the pizzas back, refused to refund me and refused to make me the three plain cheese pizzas unless I paid full price. After a very long call with the manager they offered to refund one of the three. Which I felt wasn't good enough. I didn't even ask for a refund. I did think a fair compromise was to just make me the three plain cheese pizzas without charging me (I paid $150 for the pizzas I ordered and it would have been like $60-$70 for the three cheese pizzas). Either way, they wouldn't be taking a big loss. Except by refusing me, I will never go there again and I went there a lot. They will be gone before very long mistreating people like this. read more

Got take out and the NY pizza was pretty good. Crust flavor is pretty good, crisp on the edge with a little bit of flop, but flavor on the pepperoni pie was spot on - sauce not too sweet, pepperoni is plentiful and enough cheese to keep it together without it being a grease pool. Giant slices. Margherita looked really good, but felt like it could have used a tad more something to punch it up a bit more (or maybe tomatoes are just no longer in season?). All in all, pretty good for a New York style pie. read more

This is NOT a place for big groups yall, sixteen is the max capacity! They make it fresh so you will wait about 10 min for your slice, just be patient. These slices are huge so come hungry. They have a great lunch special and we all had to get a to-go box!! read more

See all

My son must be a ninja turtle because he LOVES pizza. This is our favorite pizza place. We get the New York pizza, subbing bell peppers for jalapeños. The Greek salads are also tasty. Wednesday gets you $5 off. read more

I ordered the White Castle Cheeseburger giant slice. The slice was huge and filling!! We ordered our food and it was made pretty quickly. I didn't really care for the pizza because it was very, very dry and just didn't really have good flavor despite the various toppings. read more

See all

The pizza and salad was amazing! Food was hot and very fresh. They staff was super friendly and courteous. The spinach pizza was very good. Def a good spot. read more

The Original Brooklyn Pie - Pizza Near Me - Round Rock, Texas

My slice. Of pepperoni can burned on the bottom . We did take out so we didn't know til we got back to the hotel. Was disappointed on something so simple they burned . The other food we ordered a salad and calazone was good . read more

Pizza is great but the appetizers are WAY overpriced. $10 for 4 tiny garlic rolls is crazy. They weren't very good either. Its also strange that they are allowed to operate without a public restroom available, which I thought was required of restaurants in Texas... read more

Pizza was delicious and it hit the spot times 3. Will def be back for more. Slices are pretty big. read more

The Original Brooklyn Pie - Slice cut in half . They have pretty big slices. - Pizza Near Me - Round Rock, Texas

First off, the pizza slices weren't for me, but for co-workers I lost a bet too. Second , the moment I walked into the place, IT SMELLED SO GOOD. Third, as I handed my co-workers their pizza, they could not believe how huge their slices were !! Last, you gain Three New Customers, they loved and I am grateful , Thank You . read more

Had a craving for some pizza and came across this place not far from my house. Decided to get some takeout for lunch for me and my daughter. We got a medium meat lovers and I must say it was delicious. The toppings were plentiful and tasty, the crust was perfect. It was almost like the perfect blend of thick and thin crust of that makes sense? The addition of roasted garlic was super yummy! The one thing I didn't like was the price, $25 ($21 w/o tax) for a medium pizza. It was a very expensive pizza albeit delicious. I don't know that I'd go back because of that, but it was definitely tasty. If you want a yummy fresh pizza, you should definitely try it. read more

The Original Brooklyn Pie - Medium Meat Lovers With Garlic. - Pizza Near Me - Round Rock, Texas

Great staff great pizza. Great, atmosphere. Good job. Zach. Will return at a later date. read more

The Original Brooklyn Pie - yes, is a single slice of pie wow!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Round Rock, Texas

They absolutely love their pizzas, and the pizza by the slice really is huge. I wish they would make more mention on their website and in the store, of being able to buy the whole extra large 23 inch pizza. read more

Last week my daughter and I decided late in the evening that we were finally hungry so we settled on pizza. We ordered a small cheese and half pepperoni, small salad with ranch and an extra cup of ranch (mustn't forget the ranch). Their pizza is so good. The small salad was a decent enough size that my daughter and I had more than enough to half it. The total for our meal was about $19 and it was delicious! read more

See all

They've got seriously good New York style pizza and great service! Thin crust, brick oven, great sauce! Definitely give them a try and do not forget to check in for 15% off! read more

Loved this joint Huge pieces Great taste Nice people at counter Girls loves it!! Chewy and crispy at same Time read more

The Original Brooklyn Pie - Pizza professional in nirvana!!! - Pizza Near Me - Round Rock, Texas

This was our first and will be our only time at this establishment. We are staying at hotel nearby and found this place by chance. It is not conducive for "dining-in" so y'all are better off going to the Red Lobster down the street. There is only a small bar table and small bar shelves to eat. I counted four stools. No space for the massive Brooklyn pie you need to order! I would give five stars on the pizza as it is delicious and thin crust is crispy! However, the woman at the cash register was flippant and rude and really took away the pleasure of eating good pizza. Their bathroom policy is to send customers across the busiest highway to a 7-Eleven a block away. Just a shame. read more

Warning! 15% check in discount offer is not available at this location. Employee just said "we don't have it here".

Great pizza, prompt, courteous and professional staff. Just like the real Brooklyn's Pizza. Large pizza is a large pizza, and the ingredients are full of flavors!!! The value is worth every bite. Enjoy read more

We used to love this place but we've tried for a few times calling them to order and pick up (as we always did the past 4 years) they answer and just say "can you hold" and it's okay, they might be really busy but they literally just let you waiting and never answer the phone, no joke 10-15 mins and nothing, we called again, same, no one can forget that they have someone waiting on the phone (maybe once) but like I said this happened several times (even on weekdays! And we know they weren't tending any customers because we could hear them literally laughing and talking about what they were gonna do after "working") Seriously why are you doing this? Does the guy answering the phone doesn't like his job? Do they don't really wanna sell their product? read more

Very nice place to the eyes, but the taste of is like no other, excellent music, so you feel the wait is not that long to enjoy the food, also the tiramisu cake is like not other. read more

The Original Brooklyn Pie - Awesome area - Pizza Near Me - Round Rock, Texas

Ordered a large pepperoni and pineapple pizza, tiramisu, and garlic bread. The bread was fantastic! Crispy, garlicky and cheesy. The tiramisu was average. The pizza was okay, not quite the type of pizza I enjoy though I usually like thin crust. The pineapple tasted off and it wasn't very sweet. Probably the first and last time I'm gonna order from here. read more

We love it! This has become a weekly pizza fix. We order about once a week, usually a large cheese and large pepperoni, I think cheese is 17.5. And each toppings are 2.25 each, they do have speciality pizzas I'm pretty sure a supreme was 27.00 These pies are HUGE, we used to order 3-4 large pizzas from gattis/dominos/etc (so kids can have leftovers), now we order just 2. We have 2 fridges, and pizza boxes won't fit in either, we have to put leftovers in plastic bags. I've seen/heard customers complain on wait time, I always preorder mine online . read more

$80 for 2 specialty pizza's. 2 medium is a ridiculous price. You pay 12.50 just for the pizza with cheese plus 1.75 for each topping. Upgraded to 2 stars because the pPizza does taste good. read more

See all

Messed up on my order, and tried to call them once realized but nobody picked up. The pizza here is decent to go couple times a year but after this, doesn't make me want to come back read more

The Original Brooklyn Pie - This is supposed to be Pizza Margherita but where's the basil?? - Pizza Near Me - Round Rock, Texas

The pizza is consistent and yummy! I typically order the lunch special- 1/2 slice of pizza and 1/2 Greek Salad for $6.50. The pizza slices are pretty huge and yummy. I dislike pizza that has too much sauce (everything just falls off). The sauce was tasty and cheese was pretty darn good. I usually get the pizza slices and it does not take long at all for them to prepare the slice and salad. Their house and Greek salads are really freaking amazing! The service is consistently good. The workers are are friendly and they play some good music :) read more

The Original Brooklyn Pie - 1/2 pizza - check out the size next to the fork (lunch special) - Pizza Near Me - Round Rock, Texas

See all

My issue is ..The cashier/Pizza maker .. WASh your ××× hands after you touch cash,register, Credit Card , pizza dough, TOPPING etc.. i threw my slice away. I literally watch him do it GROSS... read more

Nice little hole in the wall. Prices are reasonable. Plenty of parking. Staff was nice. The pizza was pretty good. Didn't blow my socks off.

I love this place! The slices are massive and the quality is amazing. I always call ahead and they always have my order on time as well always accurate. My favorites are their massive single cheese slices, the White Castle cheeseburger pizza, and any of their salads. I highly recommend this place! read more

The Original Brooklyn Pie - White Castle Cheeseburger - Pizza Near Me - Round Rock, Texas

Contrary to the good reviews here, I had a completely different experience. Ordering online added $4 plus dollars to an already high bill. Three of us ate the pizza because we were hungry, but not one of us liked it. Toppings were sparse and nothing unusual. Will never go there again. MLH read more

Very good pizza. The single slice is MASSIVE! I like that you can pick your toppings even for the single slice. I was in and out in 10 mins or so at 11:30 on a Tuesday. The ranch is super good, very thick. read more

The Original Brooklyn Pie - Single slice with pepperoni, bacon, pineapple, & jalapeños. - Pizza Near Me - Round Rock, Texas

See all

Been in North Austin for 2 years now and this is the best pizza place around! Great flavors and excellent prices. Highly recommend checking them out read more

Worst experience getting pizza in my life. Do not order pizza here! Rude people!!! Absolutely terrible service... so incredibly bad! read more

I've been going to The Original Brooklyn Pie for yeeaaars! Never dissapointed. Their pizza is good and the price is comparable to the chain places. The staff are always busy but still friendly! Love going here. read more

Wow. Pretty good pizza, and that's coming from someone who's originally from NJ and ate lots of good pies! GIANT slices. read more

The Original Brooklyn Pie - Pizza Near Me - Round Rock, Texas

So, the pizza definitely tastes good....however, you need to check your order before you walk out the door. This is my 4th time to get an incorrect order and be charged for a specialty slice but given a slice of cheese.... I don't typically leave negative reviews but the price difference on these two things is quite a bit and... yeah... the disappointment when you want some bomb pizza with all the veggies but end up with a plain cheese is irritating ... read more

If you're worried about COVID-19 I recommend you STAY AWAY from Brooklyn Pizza. I walked in and the cashier did not have a mask on. I ordered a piece of pizza but as I was waiting I look towards the back and I could see that the person preparing my food had a mask on around his neck. it wasn't up over his face. It was around his neck and he wasn't wearing any gloves. I canceled my order but still lost five dollars in the process. I didn't realize it till I got out my car. I was so disgusted I didn't even want to go back in to tell him. My impression was that the cashier would probably argue with me anyway so I figured it's just not worth it right now. read more

Let's be clear. A review begins with how you are treated when giving your order. After being in hold for 10 minutes, calling twice and hearing someone pick up and hang up, I finally got some one to take my order. I take that back. I asked someone if I could place an order. A grunt and a mumble and a "Well, what did you want? Because we have like five orders ahead of you", I decided to thank the man for the time and avoid an encounter with people that should not be in the service industry. read more

They have the best pizza. I usually grab a lunch special. So good, my favorite pizza place in Austin.

Brooklyn Pie Company makes the best New York style pizza in the Round Rock / North Austin area. Nice crispy crust, flavorful sauce, and solid toppings combine for a delicious thin pizza.The total package doesn't reach the bar set by some of the heavy hitters in Austin like HomeSlice, but this pizza is really, really good. I've gotten coupons in the mail that help sweeten the deal. Take-out is advised as this strip center location is tiny with limited uncomfortable seating ( a couple of bar tables and some picnic benches outside). read more