The portions were small I got one sausage in my pasta. The carrot cake was almost laughable if I hadn't paid for it. The food was average. Pizza arrived cold Skip this place at least delevery read more

NEVER BUY FROM THIS PLACE!!!!!!! Took 1 hour and half to deliver a cold hell pizza and incomplete order. after 1 hour and 30 minutes waiting for 2 subs and 1 LG pizza they forgot the sub. No competence !!! awful service!!! read more

I've been on a veggie pizza kick recently, so I've been trying different locations around the Sudbury area. The Plum Tomato had 4/5 stars and I hadn't tried them before, so I figured I'd veggie give them a try for dinner. I ordered my large pizza for pickup online and was given an ETA of 20-25 minutes. When I arrived about 10 min early, the App said my pizza was still in the works. It's a casual place with plenty of booths, so I picked one and sat down to wait. After a few minutes, the young man behind the counter asked if he could help me. I told him I was waiting on a pizza and it turned out it was ready. I brought it home and tried a slice. Honestly, the pizza was super bland and I wasn't impressed with the crust. The top had good char, but the bottom needed more and the pizza sauce didn't taste like anything. Maybe their other pizzas are better? 3/5. I wouldn't order this pizza again. read more

See all

I had a Pizza and Salad dinner catered for an event at a local hotel. The food was DELISCIOUS and plentiful. Pizza and toppings perfect. The salad was robust with lots of extra vegetables. The driver was prompt and the pizza was still hot! Thank you so much! read more

Ordered delivery on a weeknight and took over 90 minutes when I live a mile away. Food was average at best and you didn't give me ANY of the sauces that came with the food. Thanks a lot! How does that even happen? This is not my first bad experience here, but it will be my last. read more

I love this place, their food is consistently great. Expect big pizzas and calzones and the wings are craveable too many flavors to list. . I had folks over and ordered a bunch of calzones and sides, got nothing but compliments. Been ordering for two years. Go to spot for sure. read more

love this place it's my go to will never stop coming here for as long as Im in MA. lady is also very welcoming and nice and she is so heartwarming and welcoming. read more

I like this place. Have ordered several times. My only complaint is I ordered cinna Stix with my order and didn't receive them. My small hlf chz/ hlf meatball and mushroom was great. Saving my salad for tomorrow. I'll be calling tomorrow for my cinnamon breadsticks. read more

The Plum Tomato - My order slip - Pizza Near Me - Marlborough, Massachusetts

The pizza had a thin crust which is what attracted us to go there. We were hoping for a NY style pizza and this was not it. The sauce lacked any flavor and the cheese was plain mozzarella. We put as much garlic and red pepper flake as possible but we couldn't make it taste any better. Also couldn't find a salt shaker anywhere. The Greek salad was good which is why I gave them two stars. Service was excellent. read more

Really good pizza and pasta. Been ordering delivery and takeout for awhile. I recently ordered from their site, and when I received the confirmation email at 5:15pm I realized it had ordered the wrong pizza. I called at 5:17pm to ask them to change it. They said, "the pizza is already in the oven, there is nothing we can do." So this is the last time I order from them, they lost a customer because they didn't want to waste a $15 pizza. I guess customer service isn't their forté. read more

Ordered online for pickup. Online ordering was easy to use. I like that they were descriptive for each menu items. There was plenty of parking when we got there as this restaurant is part of a plaza that shares parking. However, picking up was a bit inefficient. Had to wait in the regular line for a while just to pick up the online order. To be fair, they were busy (dinner time) or one could say they were understaffed (depending on how you look at it). There were only 2 staff at the front and one of them was multitasking with delivery orders and there were continuous streams of customers coming in. But we are on Yelp for the food. We got the steak quesadillas and an order of what they called "garbage fries". Steak quesadilla is (based on their menu) shaved steak with grilled onions and peppers and jack and cheddar cheeses piled in a soft tortilla shell, grilled and drizzled with Chipotle Aioli. I love it. It is what I like in a quesadilla but from an Italian-esque restaurant. The tortilla shell was well grilled with cheesy and meaty insides. Great for sharing. The garbage fries are waffle fries topped with bacon bits, jalapenos, black olives, red onion and melted jack and cheddar cheese and served with a side of Chipotle mayo. Very flavorful. I love the different elements of taste and bite...the crunchy goodness of bacon with the spice of jalapenos with carby fries all swimming in cheesy goodness. It is better to eat this fresh, as the cheese solidifies and heating it up is just not the same. Overall, a good experience. Those 2 orders easily fills 2 people at a decent price. I would come here for food again. read more

See all

The Plum Tomato is wonderful. One day. And mediocre the next. For the same pizza. I don't know if it's different chefs but it's super inconsistent. That said, they're the only decent game in town that delivers IMHO so there you go. I rounded to 4 because it's better than 3 but really 3.5 is where I'd land. read more

Ordered 2 sandwiches. Got home and there was 1 sandwich and 1 order of onion rings. Called to complain and they admittedly acknowledged their mistake. I asked for them to deliver my missing item and they said no, that I could drive back to get it. I said then I would be left with my sandwich and fries cold. I asked them to remake the order so I could have hot food. They agreed and I drove back. They handed me the missing item only. I told them it was unacceptable and they said it was the only solution. I told them to refund me and they gave me a slip of paper that said nothing about a refund and told me it was a refund. I'm waiting to see if the refund goes through. This is not the first time I've had issues with plum tomato and I won't be back again. read more

You know when you're drunk and have the drunk munchies? This was the absolute perfect pick! Pizza, calzones, wings, fried food...you can't go wrong! With my very drunk friend we ordered an xl order of boneless wings and a chicken bacon ranch calzone. Perfect food combo for a drunkin night! I used the Yelp 24 app. It said it would be delivered by 832. So about an hour for delivery in a Tuesday night..not too bad. It was 810 and my phone was ringing...the delivery was here! Nice and early! The wings were super tasty. We went with the teriyaki flavor. It was flavorful and satisfying. No sauce to dip though. Boo, I ordered a chicken, bacon ranch calzone. This calzone was huge! Perfect drunk food! It was super flavorful and stuffed with a tremendous amount of chicken, bacon and mozzarella cheese. It came with their homemade marinara sauce to dip. It was tasty! My only complaint about the calzone was that it was a little too doughy and it could have been cooked a little more. All in all the food was super flavorful, delivery was quick and the prices were reasonable. read more

See all

Purchased meatball and ricotta speciality pizza. Service provided was acceptable. However the pizza was a complete joke. Looked like a small pizza with ricotta drizzled on top which tasted watered down. Place was my go to place but last two pizzas were horrible. I don't mind paying for good pizza but for $20 you have to be kidding me. If they continue to put this type of product out of their establishment the business will not be around long. read more

The Plum Tomato - a slice of pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Marlborough, Massachusetts

I swear, there are at least ten different pizza shops in a five mile stretch of Boston Post Road (which is also US Route 20). None of the others are as well reviewed as The Plum Tomato and I see why. Firstly, instead of boring pizza, this is interesting pizza. My eye was drawn to one they called The Landsdowne. Onions, peppers and sweet sausage. Oh, my. It was prepared to order, so while I waited about ten minutes, my laptop and I used up their free wi-fi network (the password is their phone number). When I got the pizza back to the hotel room, it was still quite hot but I realized that I had neglected to grab a plate. My fault, totally. The pizza was delicious. Plenty of toppings, very flavorful. Five stars. read more

The Plum Tomato - The Plum Tomato in Marlborough - Pizza Near Me - Marlborough, Massachusetts

I love this place but very disappointed in my cheese steak sub. Basically you just get a 1/2 a roll with hardly any steak in it for 10.50 . Also the last time I got the chicken parm same! nothing in it. I understand prices are going up but this is ridiculous. read more

The Plum Tomato - Small cheese steak sub! - Pizza Near Me - Marlborough, Massachusetts

Pizza was very good, thinner type crust, good fresh toppings. The wings with hot Buffalo sauce were excellent, nice tingly spice level and the wings were plump and fresh. read more

I had the chicken pesto pizza; it's was excellent. I also had Caesar salad, which ok okay. They do a great job estimating the time for pickup. read more

I was a bit disappointed coming here for dinner. It's a typical pizza place that after walking in the storefront, I realized does a lot of delivery. It seemed like a solid place to have in your town to get some delivery from on a Friday night for dinner. We ordered the penne chicken Broccoli Alfredo dish and boneless buffalo wings. The Alfredo did not taste fresh,--it tasted like it sitting around for a long time and was heated to go on our dish. The boneless buffalo "wings" were one of my biggest pet peeves--chicken tenders dipped in hot sauce. They were extremely greasy. Every cut into them, oil came out. I hate wasting food, but we did throw most of them out. The woman behind the counter--she keeps them at a solid 2 stars given how nice she was. Maybe we ordered the wrong items and should have stuck to pizza. Pizza boxes seemed to be the most common item going out the door. The best part, prices were pretty cheap. read more

The Plum Tomato - Broccoli Fettucini Alfredo - Pizza Near Me - Marlborough, Massachusetts

See all

Food is excellent! Delivery is always late and cold! Budget 20-30 minutes on top of what they say for arrival time! read more

Have ordered from Plum Tomato in the past and the food has been decent, but just ordered two small pizzas ($40 total) and they were awful. Thin crust is one thing, but this crust was like overcooked/burnt cardboard. It tasted like what I would imagine a frozen grocery store pizza (have never had one) that had extra toppings added and then left in the oven for way too long would taste. I'm willing to pay for good take-out, but $40 for two small, flavorless, overcooked pizzas is inexcusable. read more

I've lived in Marlborough for four years and this place has been a favorite since day one. Food is great and the staff is friendly. Fresh ingredients...it's always appreciated when your dinner tastes like someone took the time to make it instead of just shoveling orders out the window. Everything is great, really. Pizza, calzones subs, fries, salads. Everything tastes great and there are so many different and delicious flavor combinations too. Just wanted to brag about my favorite spot. My favorite pizza in the area hands down. read more

I've ordered from here twice. First time was great! This time was the worst pizza I've ever seen. We ordered the Landsdowne pizza, which arrived looking like this (pic included). At first I thought it just got messed up during delivery, but it became clear it was very poorly made. The slices that looked okay were soggy and topped with huge chunks of sliced onion. The cheese and toppings slid right off when I picked up a slice because it was so wet. Gross, will never order again. read more

The Plum Tomato - The Landsdowne Pizza. Wet, soggy, with giant onion chunks. - Pizza Near Me - Marlborough, Massachusetts

I love this place! They are always friendly on the phone and in person! I've been going here for years and the food is ALWAYS great. I can't believe that anybody posts anything negative about the food....it's always fresh and tastes great!! read more

There is not enough words to describe how good the marguerita pizza was. Last time I had one decent was in NYC and I had no idea that this place 5 minutes away from our house would become my favorite Mozzarella's sticks were crispy and melting inside. We absolutely loved it read more

This review is as a workshop coordinator and delivery service only. I needed to order food for a large group order for a Saturday and Sunday workshop I was coordinating in the Framingham area. The group had dietary issues but Dave was absolutely awesome, easy to work with and friendly. The workshop was out of his coverage area and it was a large group order. He was willing to take the itemized orders, put names to the orders for ease of ownership (who ordered what item) and the delivery was on time both days. A blessing when I have a room of hungry people!! The food was fabulous. I have coordinated many conferences and it is hard to please everyone. Over 15 people were happy with their individual orders. I had the Gluten Free pizza and it was one of the best I've had in a while. The Greek salad with chicken was fresh, filling and delicious. I'm so happy I was able to work with Plum Tomato and would absolutely work with them again if I were in the area and coordinating a small workshop or even just finding a place to eat. They will be on my radar. Great food, service and super friendly accommodating staff. Loved my food and the experience. read more

I had the Best chicken parmesan I've ever had! The food was so good I didn't want to stop eating it even after I got full. Great portion size. Great ordering experience and quick delivery. I'd give them 10 stars! Joanne P read more

Great food . Will return but a little distance . If I head that way I will have a bite

New paint, new sign, new menu. A nice change. The basics are pretty standard fare. The cheesesteak is what you'd expect. The onion rings are thick and of the beer battered variety. If they're not frozen, the batter could use a little kick. Not sure what, but they need something. The real stars of this new menu are the grilled cheese sandwiches. I had the Smashed Meatball. It was hot, cheesy, and perfectly grilled on thick bread. Unique and delicious. A must try. Chips and pickle on the side make the perfect lunch. I won't be able to stay away from these. Service is friendly and they deliver. Love the new sign! Makes the outdated strip mall this place is in look less worn. read more

See all

We have gotten takeout several times. The pizza is fairly good. The subs & salads are really good. There biggest problem is that the wings, although big & flavorful have been way under cooked both times we got them. We had to put them in the oven for awhile to get them cooked. read more

Ordered a small steak and cheese, it comes with peppers and onions. Asked for provolone and mayo and toasted which it says on the slip. Obviously someone can't read instructions. Came with American cheese, no mayo and not toasted! read more

Always love the Plum, great food and trays. BUT this time, I was given a tray that was Half full and charged double. When I called to correct it, I could hear the cook (person in charge) saying "what does she want" in a frustrated voice. They did correct, I did have to go all the way back. Never an apology and no, the price was not fixed. The pizza was very thin compared to their terrific pizza in past. Disappointed for the first time.. They have been better then this.. had to go out and buy more food for event due to this. read more

ordered an Italian sub I am spoiled by New Jersey Mikes The young lady was fantastic left a 2 dollar tip for a ten dollar sub yikes lettuce was so wilted I was afraid to eat I asked no hots half was hots really tossed togeather. I side with the owners as their hands are tied I hate doing this being a business owner I promise to reorder next week And re post I will only re post if good read more

They have a really good chicken Caesar wrap! I have ordered takeout from here on several occasions. Food quality is consistent and service is great. Definitely recommend! read more

Ordered take out on a Sunday - online ordering through ChowNow was easy, but Groupon is not honored unless you order directly from the restaurant, so beware. Bummer. The Hawaiian pizza was good, although the dough was a bit "bready" for my liking. A 16" pie only had toppings on about 12.5" inches of pizza, so you're left with a lot of tasteless crust, which lacks the chewy/crispness of really good pizza dough. The hot wings were certainly spicy and very large, but perhaps too big as they were undercooked. There were 9 in a regular sized order, and 3 of them were inedible as they were too raw. The skin was soggy and pulled off when I bit the wing - perhaps due to steaming during take out. Might give it another try for a sandwich or pizza, but definitely won't order the wings again and won't likely be a regular here based on first experience. read more

Really great place with amazing variety. I've just discovered their grilled cheese sandwiches which are to die for. The pasta can be a little heavy and greasy but it's still good and their portions are very generous so you get multiple meals. Same with the calzones! Definitely recommend. Try the pesto or chipotle grilled cheese! read more

Pizza was middle of the road. Ordered delivery on a weekend and was delivered fast and hot.

Best pizza in town and it's not even close. 2 dollar slice deal for a giant slice. The owner is a great guy.

Siciliano pizza is tremendously amazing. Loaded with cheese and right amount of toppings. Salads always fresh and at least 2 meals. Quick and courteous staff. Prices are great for quality of food. read more